<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	xmlns:unherd="https://www.unherd.com"
	>

	<channel>
		<title>Cancel culture - UnHerd</title>
		<atom:link href="https://stage.unherd.com/tag/cancel-culture/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
		<link>https://stage.unherd.com/tag/cancel-culture/</link>
		<description>think again</description>
		<lastBuildDate>Tue, 14 Jul 2026 21:10:18 +0000</lastBuildDate>
		<language>en-US</language>
		<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
		<sy:updateFrequency>12</sy:updateFrequency>
		<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5</generator>

 
<site xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">241382538</site>				<item>
					<title>A cancellation novel’s lunar sequel</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/07/a-cancelation-novels-lunar-sequel/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/07/a-cancelation-novels-lunar-sequel/?edition=us#respond</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Image-7-7-26-at-12.13-PM.jpeg?w=541</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Books</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Paul Franz]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Blue-1000x1000-4.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Author Emmalea Russo peers into the mysteries of the occult in her latest novel. Credit: Michael Newton]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>Paul Franz has contributed criticism and poems to the <em>London Review of Books</em>, <em>New York Review of Books</em>, and other periodicals.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>plfrnz</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[Paul Franz has contributed criticism and poems to the <em>London Review of Books</em>, <em>New York Review of Books</em>, and other periodicals.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 07 Jul 2026 23:00:24 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 14 Jul 2026 21:10:18 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Another Earth]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Emmalea Russo]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Melancholia]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[safetyism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The Moon Papers]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1066327</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Emmalea Russo’s ‘The Moon Papers’ demands freedom to create]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The year 2011 saw the release of two movies — one, an auteurist masterpiece by Lars von Trier starring Kirsten Dunst and Charlotte Gainsbourg; the other a low-budget think-piece starring co-scriptwriter Brit Marling and William Mapother, then best known as Tom Cruise’s cousin — that shared a notably similar premise. </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Melancholia</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> and </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Another Earth </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">each portray the Earth as menaced by the approach of a rival planet. Von Trier’s film ends with the planet striking Earth, refuting the facile reassurances of scientific rationalist Kiefer Sutherland and vindicating his sister-in-law (Dunst), who knew there was nothing to do but accept or anxiously reject your own death and the deaths of everyone you love. The underrated </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Another Earth</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">, likewise death-haunted, ends more enigmatically. The new planet arrives, then hovers at a distance. Instead of obliterating ours, it reveals a duplicate world on which our lost possibilities — dead loved ones; the victims of our crimes — are wondrously preserved. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Reinforcing the sense of something in the water, or perhaps stars, at the time of their conception, both movies contain a notably similar scene. In each, the female lead (Dunst in </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Melancholia</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">, Marling in </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Another Earth</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">) presents herself as a nighttime sexual offering — open and waiting — to the impending planet. In each, the scene is gratuitous (in neither does cosmic penetration advance the plot), and as such essentially meaning-bearing. Both women are shown in an act of partly purgatorial, yet heroic, death-inviting-and-defying self-abandon.  </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">I do not know if the poet, astrologer, and 1990s cinema enthusiast Emmalea Russo had either movie in mind when composing her second novel, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">The Moon Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">, but it, too, is concerned with the arrival of a new celestial body. Granted, in Russo’s case, “Moon2” is artificial — an inflatable polyethylene contraption “one eighth as large” as the real moon and having “a strong analog vibe,” launched as an art project by the Mojave-based Collective for Constant Creation (“CCC”). Yet despite differences in tone, the three works share a mood — dispersed misgiving, sometimes accompanied by millenarian hopes — and also a specific interest in resonances between the celestial bodies and women’s sexual power. Each asks if these occult forces ought to be honored and even worshipped, or somehow tamed. For </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">The Moon Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">, this also means meditating on the dark powers of art.  </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Dylan-image.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>MAGA’s ‘Bad Bunny’ fumble</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Dylan Partner</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Against the background of the upcoming Moon2 launch, the novel’s main action unfolds in two settings: the Mojave Desert, where we follow Dean Konig, a disaffected member of the CCC; and rural Pennsylvania, home of Velour Bellmer, a 68-year-old pack rat and her daughter, Vesta Furio. Velour lives alone in a decaying mansion cluttered with antique furniture; Vesta, a painter, lives with her husband, Lars Arden, a gallerist three decades her senior, but is carrying on a cross-continental affair with Dean. Video calls grant the adulterous duo visual access to each other’s spaces: Vesta to the CCC compound, Dean to Vesta’s secret second painting studio, where she lets him watch her work. Meanwhile, a bat infestation in Velour’s attic draws local bat specialist Radko, who informs her she is hosting the “maternity colony” of an endangered species, which he cannot legally disturb. And so, in this ambiance of multiform gestation — natural and artificial, publicized and clandestine — the characters wait and Eros flickers. Radko and Velour feel attraction’s pull, despite their discrepant ages and his marriage to Chloe, a psychotherapist; Dean, unobserved by the husband, jacks off to Vesta’s video calls of herself fucking Lars. Lars, absorbed in his gallery work but sensing something is up, overrides his distaste for surveillance and plants a hidden camera in the potted cactus.    </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Most of these characters are returnees from Russo’s 2024 debut novel </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Vivienne</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">, to which </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">The Moon Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> is a kind of sequel. The Vivienne Volker of that novel was inspired by the historical Unica Zürn, lover of the surrealist puppet maker Hans Bellmer; at its center was a story about an artist’s cancelation. Vivienne, a textile artist in her 80s when the novel opens, had been slated to appear in a group show of “Forgotten Women Surrealist Artists,” until an online pressure campaign — wittily rendered in the novel’s opening pages by Russo, </span><a href="https://www.compactmag.com/article/purity-policing-is-poison-to-poetry/"><span style="font-weight: 400">herself the object</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> of a bizarre cancelation campaign in 2023 — results in her removal. The ostensible primary motive for the campaign is that of imposing “consequences” — for having allegedly incited another woman artist, her husband’s lover, to jump to her death decades earlier. But Volker’s accusers also wish to avoid the harms posed by the “violent nature of her work,” doll clothing whose innovations include cloth intestines and an embryo pinned to the stomach of a dress. Once the renegade gallerist Lars snatches up Vivienne’s work for a solo show, however, all turns out for the best — at least until one last act of mob vindictiveness. In the process, Lars gets acquainted with both Velour and the then 7-year-old Vesta. An epilogue shows Vesta at 18, rolling up to the desert compound of the CCC, newly married to Lars. </span><span style="font-weight: 400"> </span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“The CCC’s existence attests to a continuing need for art and religion, even in the most degraded circumstances.”</div>
<p><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Vivienne</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> distinguished itself with its pitch-perfect parody of 2020s art world safetyism, from the social media chatter that punctuates it like a tragic chorus to the embedded press release that declares “this is not an act of censorship. At the NAT Museum, we seek to foster artistic freedom in an atmosphere of safety. Wherever possible, we seek to reduce art-induced distress.” The novel’s deepest insight, however, that which lifted it above satire into vision, was to see in the acts of its dispersed internet chorus the most primal repudiation: essentially, a repudiation of nature, in its bloodiness and wildness, as embodied by Vivienne and her art. The primal “contamination” — to take up the theme of Russo’s essay on her own cancelation — was by the feminine principle. </span></p>
<p><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Vivienne</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> thus proposed an analogy between artistic and gestational creation, as revealed by the efforts of the internet mob to control both, a mission that the CCC takes up at the end of the book. </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Vivienne</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">’s closing pages depict a CCC project that sees comatose women used as gestation chambers for new births. “Our work transforms the often unnecessarily messy and risky process of creating new life,” a leaked memo reads: “By taking reproduction out of the hands of chance and into the luxury of our desert facility, the CCC fosters safety and equity, while de-emphasizing the role of capricious and often harmful nature.” The stage is thus set for </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">The Moon Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">, in which we see the CCC advertising a “fellowship” offering artists “VCs (voluntary comas) as vacations,” likewise for purposes of parturition. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Don’t let the CCC’s self-presentation as an arts “collective” fool you: it far more resembles Michel Houellebecq’s sterile ultramodern Europe than, say, the Big Sur hippie commune of his novel </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">The</span></i> <i><span style="font-weight: 400">Elementary Particles</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">. In an apt parody of modern NGOism, the CCC is both nominally non-hierarchical and — in a Philip K. Dickian touch — funded by the shadowy Voortelle Corporation, as well as by the government (thus yielding the running gag, spanning both novels, as to whether its members have “bosses”). Any conceptual resonance between the CCC’s artificial moon and </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Vivienne</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">’s detachable embryo, stapled to a dress and doubling as a purse, merely highlights the difference between these two modes of artistic creation. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">In a strange way, though, the CCC’s existence attests to a continuing need for art and religion, even in the most degraded circumstances. The spirit, it seems, must externalize itself. A collective devoted to the technological manipulation of the birthing process seems to yearn for some emblem of its reversal of nature. This is what “Moon2” provides. Both literally and figuratively a mockery, it symbolizes the aspiration to mastery by duplicating, usurping, and thereby seeking to tame the cosmic symbol of the feminine and mutable. This will to power is captured in a witty detail when Russo shows a member of an internal CCC chat reminding another member that their project aims to displace the terminology one would have previously taken for granted: “You’re forgetting that we rolled out the phrase Moon1.”</span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Knox.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The creepiness of Amanda Knox</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Valerie Stivers</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The dubious conceptual project of the CCC is not the only artwork considered in Russo’s novel, however. Toward the end, the prevailing opposition between openness to the natural and attempts to restrict it — a dynamic also played out in Radko and Velour’s negotiations over the bats in her attic — reveals a new axis. This centers on the gallerist Lars, perhaps the most sympathetic of the novel’s characters, who represents a cussedly populist spirit opposed to the petty and conformist pretensions of the art world. (He is for much of the book a lone voice calling bullshit on the CCC.) Lars has spent most of the book waiting, with increasing impatience, for Vesta’s new paintings so he can include them in his next show. He gets more than he bargained for — a series of intimate nudes, unmistakably of Dean Konig, produced without either Vesta’s lover’s awareness or her husband’s, blowing the lid off both their affair and the inner sanctum of the CCC.</span><b>  </b></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The strange permissions of art let Vesta turn a real affair — if her digital escapades count as one — into at once a genuine work of art and an act of infiltration, each of which paradoxically plays to the sympathies of her husband, and might thereby bring her closer to him. In its implied endorsement of Vesta’s acts, the novel thus ends up being a defense of a more traditional art — call it exploratory or Romantic — linked to Eros. Yet if Vesta’s paintings amount to “evidence” (as Lars can’t help but recognize) of their origins in illicit acts, they are not reducible to them. Both embodied and transcendent, such art is unsettling and ambiguous, far more so than the ponderous travesty of “Moon2.” The novel’s ultimate contrast is thus between art that is, so to speak, officially anti-authoritarian and art that opens itself to the dark forces of creation and love.</span><b> </b></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">In moving beyond </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Vivienne</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">’s cancelation plot, Russo seems, it must be said, to have decided against having much plot at all. With its chill vibe and reduced narrative drive, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">The Moon Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> feels at times like a set of thematic variations — a minor dependent satellite — upon its formidable precursor. Particularly toward the end, however, Russo’s second novel acquires a lunar intensity of its own. One awaits the next turn of the tide. </span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/07/a-cancelation-novels-lunar-sequel/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/07/a-cancelation-novels-lunar-sequel/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/07/a-cancelation-novels-lunar-sequel/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1066327</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The rewriting of campus history</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/05/the-rewriting-of-campus-history/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/05/the-rewriting-of-campus-history/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Snapins.ai_245819269_2001673213324095_1432747605763257073_n_1080-e1743017516721.webp?w=569</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Cancel culture</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kathleen Stock]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Blue-37.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[@antiterfsussex]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<div><strong>Kathleen Stock</strong> is contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</div>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>kathleen_stock1</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</div>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Fri, 01 May 2026 23:15:10 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 13 May 2026 10:45:37 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[culture war]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[High Court]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Kathleen Stock]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Transsexualism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[University of Sussex]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1058199</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[This week’s Sussex judgment ignores reality]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Back when I worked at Sussex University, I sat through a lot of meetings. To relieve the tedium, I used to note changing fashions in language; bureaucratic phrases arriving from other institutions and working their way mimetically through management brains. As I remember it, there was a lot of dizzying movement: many deep dives into data and much drilling into figures; endless circling back, driving forward, and cascading downwards. The contrast with our sedentary laptop lifestyle was marked.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Policy documents would arrive full of empty second-hand phrases, awkwardly strung together. For instance: “The curriculum shall not rely on or reinforce stereotypical assumptions about trans people, and any materials within relevant courses and modules will positively represent trans people and trans lives.” This was one of several overbearing clauses in Sussex’s “Trans and Nonbinary Equality Policy Statement”, launched with internal fanfare in 2018. The wording came from a template provided by </span><a href="https://www.advance-he.ac.uk/about-us" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">Advance HE</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">, an organization supposedly concerned with improving teaching standards in the higher education sector. It was robotically copied by several universities, </span><a href="https://x.com/MForstater/status/1908058430155219259?s=20" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">Sussex</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> among them.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Last year, the Office for Students issued a large fine to Sussex on the basis of introducing this policy, and cited my adverse experiences there as evidence of its chilling effect on academic freedom. Indeed, while I was working as a philosophy lecturer, attempting to broach thorny issues of sex and gender while avoiding disciplinary investigations from management, the mere sight of a link to this particular policy in an official email would cause significant clenching of my jaw. But this Wednesday, the passive-aggressive wording sidled back into my life, to enrich my dentist further. The High Court </span><a href="https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/the-university-of-sussex-v-the-office-for-students/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">ruled</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> that the fine had been unlawful, and the Office for Students had misapplied its own rules.  </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Central to the judgment was the finding that the trans policy did not in fact count as a “governing document” — meaning that the Office for Students was wrong to conclude it ever seriously breached their regulations. Yet on the ground at the time, the policy felt very much like a governing document. Indeed, it seemed positively Stalinesque in its effect. It combined with several other EDI policies and communications to inculcate a general feeling of menace: warnings about transphobia and hate speech; instructions about preferred pronouns and how exactly to apologize if you got them wrong; links to helplines for those affected by speech-based bigotry, and trans flags fluttering all over the shop. </span><span style="font-weight: 400"> </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">But according to this week’s ruling, “governing documents” in this context only ever means constitutional texts such as statutes and charters, not policies attempting to force change in cultural values or behavioral norms. And the judge also ruled that the OFS failed to consider other Sussex policies defending freedom of speech, supposedly more definitive of the institutional stance — though as I recall, these were squirreled away in remote corners of the website, given far less prominence in everyday life. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/04/russell-brand-spray-on-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/04/russell-brand-spray-on-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/GettyImages-2251981727.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/04/russell-brand-spray-on-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/04/russell-brand-spray-on-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Russell Brand: spray-on Christian</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/04/russell-brand-spray-on-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">There are other points in the ruling, less easy to paraphrase. Though the overall verdict is clear enough — the OFS messed up badly, misunderstood its own regulations, and also showed bias in its determination to make an example of Sussex — much of the text is taken up with the byzantine interaction of particular OFS regulations and Sussex documents, not easy for the non-specialist to decipher. Still, other matters are made transparently clear. As pertaining to the OFS’s academic freedom director, Arif Ahmed, for instance, the judge explicitly found that there was “no vitiating apparent bias in respect of Dr Ahmed’s personal role in the decision-making”, and that Sussex’s attempts to demonstrate otherwise had failed.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">But history is written by the victors, as they say; and yesterday the victorious Vice-Chancellor Sasha Roseneil was doing the media rounds, </span><a href="https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/free-speech-tsars-position-untenable-says-sussex-v-c" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">calling for Ahmed’s head</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> nonetheless. Originally a Cambridge philosopher of language, he is well-known within free speech circles for his refreshingly unadorned critiques of emotional safetyism within universities, including an </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-55246793#:~:text=The%20row%20at%20Cambridge%2C%20which,them%2C%22%20said%20Prof%20Anderson." target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">earlier successful fight</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> to see Cambridge remove a regulation requirement to be “respectful” towards opposing points of view. It would be completely in keeping with our times to see a confident plain speaker like him ousted by someone whose warm and fuzzy aim for her organization, </span><a href="https://www.sussex.ac.uk/broadcast/read/70636" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">as of yesterday</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">, is to “continue to focus on creating an open, inclusive and respectful campus culture”.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Though herself a sociologist, Roseneil also seemed in the mood to do a bit of historical reconstruction, waxing lyrical about the university’s “proud history of being the place where the most contentious issues of the day are aired”. During court proceedings earlier this year, Sussex’s barrister even went so far as to call the university a “bastion of free speech”. Reader, I laughed. Perhaps it was once so, and could be again; I have no idea, having relinquished my former connections. But it may not surprise you to learn that this is not my recollection of the place; and nor can it really be Roseneil’s. She arrived to run it in 2022, a year after I had left.</span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/britains-free-speech-paradox/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/britains-free-speech-paradox/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/GettyImages-2233888692-e1763737768137.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/britains-free-speech-paradox/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/britains-free-speech-paradox/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Britain&#039;s free speech paradox</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/britains-free-speech-paradox/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jonathan Sumption</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">I have described my Sussex experiences too often to rehearse them here again. By now, I am quite bored of remembering, so God knows how everyone else feels. But for an economical snapshot of what life was like back then, consider the tone and content of this </span><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20260429130622/https:/mailchi.mp/d93cf887c1cc/update25-7967765?e=de2a5292f0" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">“Dean’s update” email</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">, sent by my line manager to all staff in the arts and humanities in April 2021, including me, and preserved on the internet for posterity. In particular, attend to the lengthy sections on “Equality, Diversity, Inclusion” and “LGBTQ+ inclusion”, bearing in mind that this deathless managerial prose was composed years after my public </span><a href="https://x.com/Docstockk/status/1542965010493837321" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">complaints</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> about Stonewall’s overreach had first attracted local acts of animosity, and five months before the large scale protests against me started. And if you think this sounds like an “open” or even “respectful” environment in which to criticize the presence of males in women’s prisons or the medical transition of minors, I have an extremely scientific encyclopedia of gender identities to sell you.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">For those who are big fans of such things, I’m sure the High Court result will be triumphantly received as proof that stories about my tumultuous time at Sussex were always overdone. The judge stated in her ruling that she was not adjudicating on the substance of those events, about which the then-Vice-Chancellor expressed </span><a href="https://www.sussex.ac.uk/broadcast/read/56597" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">profound regret</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> at the time. Roseneil also stressed the separateness of the two matters in </span><a href="https://www.sussex.ac.uk/broadcast/read/70636" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">her own statement</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">. But in my experience, you can’t expect people who believe in magical gender essences to care much about finer details. In any case, whatever they are saying I’m not reading it, having blissfully given up monitoring my public image in the eyes of such people a long time ago.</span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;It is the moral crazes rippling periodically through universities that constitute the biggest threat to freedom of expression there.&#8221;</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">For related reasons, I am not clued up on exactly what this means for the sector as a whole; and nor do I really wish to remedy the deficit. But from the outside, it seems that one astonishing thing to have emerged from the ruling is that existing free speech statutes have literally nothing meaningful to say about the hundreds of politicized documents that have proliferated like weeds in British universities in the last decade, praising some forms of expression as desirable and proscribing others as suspicious or outright hateful; fueling a culture of student complaints, disciplinary investigations, and fear.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Perfectly rationally in the circumstances, thousands of academics are still self-censoring, having taken note of the finger-wagging policies appearing on the website, the sententious managerial sermons flowing into their inbox, the politicized commemorations and flags, the aggressivity of activist staff networks, and the extremely selective forms of “lived experience” highlighted by the institution as morally instructive. The High Court judgment is based on the Higher Education and Research Act (HERA), and implies it is not the regulator’s concern whether a university’s culture produces intimidating obstacles to freedom of expression like these, or avoids them. If this is true, it can only emphasize the total irrelevancy of HERA to freedom of expression in the modern context, and the urgent need for a different approach. The new Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act has yet to be enacted, and one can only hope it will do much better.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">For ultimately it is the moral crazes rippling periodically through universities that constitute the biggest threat to freedom of expression there, and the regulator needs to catch up. These are fueled partly by innate staff susceptibility, and partly by more hard-headed desires of managers to hop onto whatever bandwagon students are currently riding, hoping to benefit from larger application numbers and better </span><a href="https://www.thestudentsurvey.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">student scores</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">. They don’t tend to result in changes to foundational constitutions, but they do produce large numbers of suffocating bureaucratic tendrils, along with a lot of busywork: new policies and guidelines to keep people in line; marketing messages to tweak, and social media campaigns to launch; workshops for staff re-education, and fresh positions of power for true believer staff to occupy.  </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">In this stifling environment, better regulations would of course be welcome; but the country also needs to decide what universities are actually for. Are they just an expensive means of teaching middle-class kids to mouth certain attractive words and phrases, with which they can then drive forward progress, take deep dives into inequality, circle back to kindness, and drill down into the oppressive status quo? Or might they be better championed as places where such heartwarming, mind-numbing platitudes can be challenged and even mocked, without personal or professional cost? Having left the university sector behind me, I’ve now got full freedom to think for myself. It’s a glorious gift; one that all the clever, inquisitive, contrarian people still stuck in ivory towers and redbrick towerblocks can only dream of.</span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/05/the-rewriting-of-campus-history/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/05/the-rewriting-of-campus-history/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/05/the-rewriting-of-campus-history/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1058199</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>How the BBC betrayed Jenni Murray</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/03/how-the-bbc-betrayed-jenni-murray/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/03/how-the-bbc-betrayed-jenni-murray/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/GettyImages-835491860.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Feminism</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Julie Bindel]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Screenshot-2026-10-15-at-11.44.56.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Murray died this month at the age of 75. (Roberto Ricciuti/Getty Images)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Julie Bindel</strong> is an investigative journalist, author, and feminist campaigner. Her latest book is <em>Lesbians: Where are we now?</em> She also writes on <a href="https://juliebindel.substack.com/">Substack</a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>bindelj</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an investigative journalist, author, and feminist campaigner. Her latest book is <em>Lesbians: Where are we now?</em> She also writes on <a href="https://juliebindel.substack.com/">Substack</a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 23 Mar 2026 00:02:20 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 23 Mar 2026 00:02:20 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[BBC]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Feminism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Jenni Murray]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[radio 4]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[trans ideology]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Transsexualism]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1053424</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[My friend stood up to trans bullies]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>My friendship with Jenni Murray was cemented, believe it or not, at a lap dance club in Streatham. It was back in the early 2000s. I’d been a guest on <i>Woman’s Hour</i>, which Jenni had been presenting since 1987, a couple of weeks earlier. After the program, Jenni asked me to stick around for a chat. She wanted to talk to me about the sexual liberation of women, because she disagreed with some of my points of view on pornography, lap dancing, and prostitution.</p>
<p>While not keen on any of the above, Jenni was a classical liberal, and wondered whether, after decades of feminism, women could now be sexually liberated. She was thinking of writing a book on the theme. “After all,” she said, “there’s even a lap dance club solely for women these days.” She meant a place called Caesars, which was a dive on Streatham High Road that gave over one night a month to a women’s night: “Lap-Attack”.</p>
<p>We agreed to visit Lap-Attack together. It was horrific. The male performers appeared exploited and unhappy, while the female punters were mostly blind drunk and trying their best to pretend they were having fun. In the toilets, I encountered a group of lively black women in their twenties. One of them asked me, “Is that Jenni Murray out there? She’s my heroine”. I told Jenni, who was thrilled at the idea that a working-class woman in a lap-dance club would love what she was doing.</p>
<p>Jenni and I, both working-class feminists, remained friends for the rest of her life. She was a titan, presenting <i>Woman’s Hour </i>until she was 70. She would have done it longer, I believe, had she not been dogged by critics who believed her to be “transphobic”. Her beloved BBC let her down, leading to her resignation. Now that Jenni has died, aged 75, the corporation is giving her <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cpwj8e25ddgo" target="_blank" rel="noopener">the recognition</a> she deserved as a broadcaster — but I remember her bravery, too.</p>
<p>On 20 January 2017, years after our trip to Caesars, I was walking from the Tube to march against Donald Trump’s presidency when my phone rang. It was Jenni. My first thought was that she was at the demonstration and wanted to meet up. But what she actually wanted was my advice. We had spoken only a few weeks earlier, after her interview with the trans activist India Willoughby. During the interview, Jenni had faced a barrage of hostile sexism from this man who claims to be female. It goes without saying that Jenni had handled the conversation extremely professionally — but she was aghast at some of the things Willoughby had said.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/why-is-london-ignoring-its-grooming-gangs/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/why-is-london-ignoring-its-grooming-gangs/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/GettyImages-536194258.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/why-is-london-ignoring-its-grooming-gangs/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/why-is-london-ignoring-its-grooming-gangs/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why is London ignoring its grooming gangs?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/why-is-london-ignoring-its-grooming-gangs/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Julie Bindel</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>“What would have been your reaction,” Jenni asked Willoughby, “to being required to shave your legs when you lived as a man?” she asked.</p>
<p>“What a bizarre question, Jenni. Why would I shave my legs when I was living as a man?” replied Willoughby.</p>
<p>Jenni then asked how Willoughby — as a newcomer to such trials of “womanhood” — felt about women being held to a higher standard than men. Willoughby snapped. “I’m not really sure what your stance is on trans. But it seems quite hostile, quite honestly.”</p>
<p>Dealing with such a response was well within Jenni’s everyday repertoire. I had been a guest on <i>Woman’s Hour</i> many times, almost always with Jenni at the helm, and she had rigorously challenged some of my opinions, as her job required. And of course, if it was a debate-type format, she did the same to my opponent.</p>
<p>Jenni had called because she felt she needed to speak out about the misogyny of trans ideology. Years ago, Jenni had been infuriated by the Rev Peter Stone, who had undergone surgery, was now known as Carol, and seemed concerned about little other than clothing. This was a caricature of womanhood from a man who was ignorant of centuries of feminist struggle. Willoughby had induced similar fury in Jenni — so much so that she felt she had to act. She said that while she had always instinctively known that trans culture was bad for women, she had been worried about stirring the hornets’ nest. She told me that she had decided to write a big piece for <i>The Sunday Times Magazine</i>, in which she would set out her stall.</p>
<p>“How bad is it going to be if I do that?” she asked. I told her that she should be prepared for the worst. The mother of all hostility would be coming down on her. There would be calls for her cancellation. But despite the warnings I’d given her, Jenni didn’t waver.</p>
<p><a href="https://www.thetimes.com/uk/society/article/be-trans-be-proud-but-dont-call-yourself-a-real-woman-frtld7q5c?gaa_at=eafs&amp;gaa_n=AWEtsqfAGgYv4pF47jEa0XiHSTn4hTCqQSh55DHOz8gdvLBoW8kvog-Mpx_mmzJyYdY%3D&amp;gaa_ts=69bfc70d&amp;gaa_sig=k4KPzN1gUulOUk5sFIBVfkUs1ptbjApkVmUrLKFSVEnUXaVmY5J4VHXWFayXhzrOUdK0805-bTxc2oVvm_OSQg%3D%3D" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Her piece</a>, “Be trans, be proud – but don’t call yourself a ‘real woman’” was published in March 2017. In it, she made it clear that her concern was to hold on to women’s hard-won rights, and not anti-trans prejudice. She wrote:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px"><em>“I’m appalled at the repulsive misogyny evident in the response of trans activists who have accused Nimko Ali, a Somali and a courageous campaigner against female genital mutilation, of ‘practising white feminism’ or who have demanded the ‘no platforming’ (banning from speaking in public) of women, such as the lesbian feminist Julie Bindel, who have questioned the claims of trans women to be real women.”</em></p>
<p>As I feared, Jenni was subjected to endless abuse: not just scathing commentary in the press, but insults, calls for her sacking, and worse. She <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/09/11/jenni-murray-police-did-nothing-trans-activist-death-threat/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">later recalled</a> being issued “endless promises that I would be raped or murdered, leaving me genuinely worried for my safety. I had no assistance from the police — not that I asked for it, as I knew they would do nothing.”</p>
<p>What about the BBC, the institution to which Jenni had devoted decades? Rather than offer its unequivocal support, the corporation gave Jenni a warning, she said, and banned her from leading any <i>Woman’s Hour</i> discussion on the topic of transgenderism.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“Jenni would rail against a certain type of middle-class feminist who adopts whichever position they feel is going to give them the greatest social acceptability.” </div>
<p>Throughout, Jenni remained an exceptional journalist. Her long-time producer, Innes Bowen, worked with Jenni between 1998 and 2002 and describes Jenni as “incredibly impressive with her open-mindedness about issues, and her genuine desire to explore all sides of any debate.</p>
<p>“She didn’t want the same old issues being presented time and time again, and if that’s what the producers came up with, she would say: ‘Sorry, we can’t do that. This is not balanced, or it’s not fair.’ She only threw her toys out of her pram about twice a year. Mainly, she was protecting us from our own stupidity.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/the-prime-minister-women-needed/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/the-prime-minister-women-needed/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/GettyImages-1048109632-2.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/the-prime-minister-women-needed/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/the-prime-minister-women-needed/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The Prime Minister women needed</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/the-prime-minister-women-needed/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jenni Murray</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Jenni would rail against a certain type of middle-class feminist who adopts whichever position they feel is going to give them the greatest social acceptability. She was not one of those women herself.</p>
<p>“She was genuinely a national treasure,” Bowen says. “Many ex-BBC people believe that they are, but really, they fade into obscurity once they leave their role. For Jenni, the phone never stopped ringing. She was in demand. The country did love her.”</p>
<p>I realized quite how traumatic the Willoughby episode had been for Jenni in 2021, at FiLiA, a grassroots feminist conference. Jenni had been invited to speak on the main stage. When asked about what happened after she wrote the piece for <em>The Sunday Times</em>, she gave a response that left many of us in tears.</p>
<p>She had presented <em>Woman’s Hour</em> for 33 years, she said. “I’d never been perceived as someone who couldn’t be trusted. And suddenly, I had a manager coming into my office saying, ‘Oh, God, Jenni. Have you seen all the shouting on Twitter? I don’t think we can let you discuss this question anymore’.</p>
<p>“Three years later, I decided to quit. I can’t do what I love if I am not being trusted. But I made that excuse: ‘I’ve done it for 33 years, I’m coming up to my 70th birthday, I need to do something different.’ That was bullshit. I did not want to leave <i>Woman’s Hour</i>; I absolutely loved it. But I couldn’t stay in that atmosphere.”</p>
<p>It seems that little has changed. Just this week, the BBC <a href="https://substack.com/redirect/fd542152-226e-488c-b853-bf89147693f6?j=eyJ1IjoiMWljemU4In0.U4rr-py8jMETGkk4Mt4gotctflPx-MmNYVXH5BkPX8o" target="_blank" rel="noopener">rejected all initial complaints</a> about the decision by <i>Woman’s Hour</i> to interview Raewyn Connell, a man who says he’s a woman, about misogyny. <i>Woman’s Hour</i> barely lives up to its name these days.</p>
<p>In 2006, shortly after Jenni’s breast cancer diagnosis, I was asked by a newspaper how important a voice she was. My answer was that Jenni was irreplaceable. &#8220;I honestly think the show will die with her. She is an era — along with the program — and it can’t be reproduced.&#8221; It would appear I was right.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/03/how-the-bbc-betrayed-jenni-murray/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/03/how-the-bbc-betrayed-jenni-murray/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2026/03/how-the-bbc-betrayed-jenni-murray/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1053424</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Uncanceled at last</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/uncancelled-at-last/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/uncancelled-at-last/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Kate-Clancy-1.jpg?w=623</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>weekend essay</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kate Clanchy]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/kate-clanchy.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['I think this is the last stage of cancellation.' / Handout / Jamie Tomlinson]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Kate Clanchy </strong>is a poet, author, and teacher. <em>Some Kids I taught and What They Taught Me</em> <a href="https://swiftpress.com/book/some-kids-i-taught-and-what-they-taught-me/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">is available now from Swift Press.</a></p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>KateClanchy1</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is a poet, author, and teacher. <em>Some Kids I taught and What They Taught Me</em> <a href="https://swiftpress.com/book/some-kids-i-taught-and-what-they-taught-me/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">is available now from Swift Press.</a>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sat, 08 Nov 2025 00:03:18 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Sat, 08 Nov 2025 00:03:18 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Literature]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[peak woke]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Sensitivity readers]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1036361</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Four years on, are we any wiser?]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Cancellation is very much as you might imagine: a pit of utter despair. It does, though, have stages. And over the four years since I was canceled for being racist, classist and ableist — or at least that’s what the sensitivity readers of my memoir <em>Some Kids I Taught and What They Taught Me</em> thought — I think I may have passed through them all.</p>
<p>There is the time when you can hardly bear to go out, so heavy is the weight of shame that you cringe against walls and creep through the streets. Then you start to behave more normally but develop Post-Traumatic Embitterment Disorder (PTED). The affliction trails you everywhere, whining like an anxious dog. It pees in every corner and gets in your lap any time you have a drink. It barks at kind people trying to help you or licks their hands slavishly. You mustn’t feed it but you do. Sometimes fate hands it a bone. When two friends removed my name from the acknowledgments pages of their prize-winning books, my PTED howled until the neighbors woke up.</p>
<p>You have to get away from it. You have to get on. This year, I toughened up, got off the chair I had been cowering in for all these years, and painted my study yellow. The BBC reached out to interview me for a podcast. I didn’t wince; I am probably a good test case to talk about the culture wars. And then I was asked to take part on a panel, to do a couple of school workshops. I started to feel a little like my old self.</p>
<p>Along with the podcast, which was broadcast this week, I received an apology from my publishers, Pan Macmillan. I didn’t expect that, but I somehow found myself able to sit on my only faintly growling PTED and receive that apology calmly. I genuinely think Joanna Prior, the new CEO, is right to put what happened to me in the past. My grudges must somehow be put there too, or the PTED will dog me for life. What I needed, I have said, is a freer, saner discussion of the past.</p>
<p>So I’m starting again, here in <em>UnHerd</em> with another visit to my sensitivity readers. They seem to be rather fading from public consciousness. In 2021, they were a very hot topic and often all anyone asked me about the furore: writers genuinely feared a new board of censorship. Besides, the essay<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/how-sensitivity-readers-corrupted-literature/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> I wrote </a>back then felt like the last good thing I wrote before I went into darkness. That was the last time I made a lot of people laugh.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/how-sensitivity-readers-corrupted-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/how-sensitivity-readers-corrupted-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Kate-1-e1643385172784.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/how-sensitivity-readers-corrupted-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/how-sensitivity-readers-corrupted-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How sensitivity readers corrupt literature</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/how-sensitivity-readers-corrupted-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kate Clanchy</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Though perhaps even that was unfair of me, a little cheap. The sensitivity readers were poorly paid freelancers and also sitting ducks. They had been set up with Pan Macmillan to solve a problem for them. Having apologized for the “emotional anguish&#8221; caused by my book, Macmillan then considered recalling and pulping all the copies in bookshops and giving the proceeds to anti-racism charities. When this seemed too drastic, they settled instead on a new edition of the book, one with the “harm”, that word of 2021, removed. No one in the firm had read the book, though, so they recruited experts to find the harm: sensitivity readers who specialized in racism, ableism and the Middle Eastern diaspora.</p>
<p>It was a huge assignment because it was retrospective. The three readers had to justify the internet response: find something in the book to equal the many claims of eugenics, racism and ableism. They also had to demonstrate their own worth and the point of their new profession. They set off on their journey keenly enough with many scornful points on the first few pages of the manuscript. Then they found themselves in a book which was not only essentially liberal but also absolutely mined, sentence by sentence, anecdote by anecdote, with irony.</p>
<p>Of course, the results were comical. Hyperbole was the only place to go. All praise had to be “fetishizing”; all criticism “demonization”. To compare a small child climbing a tree to a koala had to be “explicit animalization of the other”. Harm had to be found somewhere so one reader decided it was “harmful” for me to call myself a “soft target” because “this state of being a “target” is a real issue that minorities face daily, and being used so flippantly by a white person can wash the importance of that”. Another decided it was “harmful” to say that Scottish children are better than London children at spelling “wh” sounds — <em>wh</em>ere, <em>wh</em>at — because of their accent. Even at the time the reasoning made me smile.</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">“The author states outright that… she is indeed comparing the two groups of pupils to assess who is ‘better’&#8230; Having it laid out in black and white that yes, your teachers do judge you, and yes, they find you lacking in comparison to others, can really hit people in the gut.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/TAW57K-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested Reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Now the cancel mob cries victim</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Lines such as those were, I thought (<em>pace</em> dear sensitivity readers), soft targets for me, fun for my essay. I believed the underlying ideas of the reads — that words could harm, that books must educate — were temporary notions that would pass and so worth attacking for those reasons.</p>
<p>Reading them now, though, I don’t find it all so funny. I am struck, rather, by the loneliness the reads express, the shadow of the pandemic over them all. Silence, in their view, is better than the wrong person joining the conversation. Stories should be confined to the therapy room, only spoken by one teller, never recounted, never adopted or adapted. Thoughts are types of mental illnesses — a savior complex, an identity crisis. No one can bear to read even the glimmer of a contrary argument. Malign prejudice is everywhere. Those are bleak as well as silly ideas, and yet how strongly they have stuck.</p>
<p>The readers, too, seem anxious to me now, rather than nasty. Or rather, nasty because they are anxious. They had been set an absurd task and were failing at it. The frustration shows in the way one reader becomes increasingly unmoored and incoherent as she progresses through the text, and abandons it halfway through.</p>
<p>Only a single reader made it all the way through the last chapter of my book. There he finds a series of infractions about the repeated use of the word “small” in relation to a Syrian child who has written a very grown-up sounding poem about war. Belittling stereotypes, he finds, “infantilizing” and “animalizing”. Granulation is so easy and shame so cheap. Why not read the poem, just once, and wonder? Besides, “small” is one of the glories of the English language, a word for “little” that we use for knobbly, close, personal things, a word infused with the tenderness we feel for pets and children but which can never be confused with lesser, or petty, a word that never carries scorn. Not to understand that — or to have put up barriers in the mind so you cannot hear it — seems so sad.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Only a single reader made it all the way through the last chapter of my book.&#8221;</div>
<p>I wonder whether that reader still has a job. It’s certainly hard to believe anyone still employs him to write sheets of comments like:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">&#8220;After initially stating that the radio debate spoke of compulsorary adoption, the end of the passage then, from the author’s voices, ponders whether compulsorary adoption is a tenable answer. (Thus I am merely flagging that this, abhorrent-to-some, mooted step is given potential credence by the author here)&#8221; (Sic)</p>
<p>Not because it is nonsense, or even because of the vibe shift, but because, since the advent of ChatGPT, no one writes like that. Which is both better and worse, because daft judgments may be combined with smooth, authoritative prose.</p>
<p>For example, last year, my student B, 25 and ridiculously gifted, sent his first novel off to a literary agent. A few weeks later, he received a surprisingly aggressive rejection letter accompanied by a reader’s report. His novel, the agent said angrily, represented women denigratingly. They all had low career aspirations and bad jobs. After so many years of supporting women in publishing, she wouldn’t be promoting that sort of stuff!</p>
<p>B was distraught. He felt, as he put it, that he was not just a bad writer but a bad person. He was also, justly, bewildered. His novel, set in a poor, post-industrial village, like the one he grew up in, did indeed center on women doing badly paid jobs. But they are not scorned: B’s delicate, ironical, deceptively flat prose opens up a whole landscape of their complex feelings. How can that element — the writing — have been missed? The reader had spent plenty of time on the book — that was evidenced by her lengthy summary. Then we tried putting the novel through ChatGPT and came up with exactly the same lengthy summary.</p>
<p>That was in 2024. AI had already learned to summarize, and the agent’s reader, very possibly a recent graduate, knew how to shame. Maybe by now the operations are combined. Who knows how many of the plethora of AI-powered test readers, which promise to “clean up your creative writing in minutes” and turn it into “a professional text”, have also absorbed sensitivity principles? I’m sure AI now could readily search a book and give certain phrases offense ratings. It would miss context and satire, but so did my sensitivity readers, every time.</p>
<p>Maybe, even now, texts are being morally improved and rewritten by one app and then read and rejected by another on even more delicate moral grounds without any human reading them at all. Maybe that’s what the British literary establishment will spend its last hours doing as their handsome Edwardian edifices burn to the ground and the episode of “Some Kids versus the Sensitivity Three” becomes a tiny footnote in the story of <em>The End of the Book</em>. Not reading but shaming. I wouldn’t be surprised. Except that I believe in B. He is a good writer. His images sing, his every observation and phrase is spry, jolting and surprising. AI will never recognize that, but humans will. B is also a poet, and I sometimes quote him Auden, lines from <em>In Memory of WB Yeats </em>(1939) which the poet, capricious in old age, later removed. They are about Time, which “worships language” and has no morals at all.</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">Time, that with this strange excuse,<br />
Pardons Kipling and his views,<br />
And will pardon Paul Claudel,<br />
Pardons him for writing well.</p>
<p>I can imagine only too easily what my sensitivity readers would have said about that.</p>
<p>I don’t know what Time will make of my writing yet. I’m not as confident as I am for B. I hope soon I’ll be able to inspire him with confidence in the wholehearted way I used to. Not yet, because I am too stiff and too lacking in confidence myself. I think this is the last stage of cancellation: it’s something like scar tissue, numbness with threads of pain.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/uncancelled-at-last/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/uncancelled-at-last/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/uncancelled-at-last/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1036361</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Now the cancel mob cries victim</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/TAW57K-1.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>cancel culture</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kathleen Stock]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Blue-37.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Monisha Rajesh has forgotten the first rule of victim club. Keith Morris/Hay Ffotos/Alamy]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<div><strong>Kathleen Stock</strong> is contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</div>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>kathleen_stock1</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</div>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Fri, 07 Nov 2025 00:03:27 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 18 Feb 2026 12:04:02 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Kate Clanchy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Victimhood]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1036237</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[They deserve little pity ]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>When Mary Beard tweeted out a <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/mary-beard-tweet-oxfam-aid-workers-sex-scandal-backlash-feminists-cambridge-priyamvada-gopal-latest-a8216306.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">picture</a> of herself weeping in 2018, her critics were pitiless. Even four years later, the travel writer Monisha Rajesh was still caustically <a href="https://x.com/monisha_rajesh/status/1655534568512929794" target="_blank" rel="noopener">tweeting</a> about the moment when “Mary Beard did her white tears”. According to a widely disseminated narrative, the Cambridge classics prof had already disgraced herself with an earlier, implicitly racist tweet, and was now “weaponizing” her anguish at the resulting criticism, in a manner inaccessible to black and brown women. Beard’s crying was framed as a deliberate action — as deliberate and as culpable as her subsequent act of posting the photo of it for the public to see.</p>
<p>Though white tears remain technically unavailable to Rajesh in virtue of her skin color, this week it became clear that she too is capable of crying in public. On an Instagram reel, she presented her own moist-eyed tribute act to Beard, and it went down about as well as the original. <a href="https://x.com/nice_cuppa/status/1986031175270539719/video/1" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Sobbing</a> volubly in a post which has since been made private, Rajesh bemoaned the news of a forthcoming BBC podcast in which she is to feature, and blamed bosses for exposing her to online abuse as a result. Entitled <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m002m0bm" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Anatomy of a Cancellation</em></a>, this six-part series for Radio 4 will apparently explore the stark claims of racism made by Rajesh and several others towards poet and teacher Kate Clanchy in 2021, as well as the supine apologies of Clanchy’s then-publisher in light of the subsequent media frenzy.</p>
<p>Both Rajesh’s tears and the relatively neutral tone of the BBC press release are a far cry from the heady days of 2021. Back then, the travel writer was <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/books/2021/aug/10/kate-clanchy-to-rewrite-memoir-after-criticism-of-racist-and-ableist-tropes" target="_blank" rel="noopener">apparently</a> comfortable enough with the Beeb to tell its reporter that Clanchy’s book — a high-minded tale about teaching immigrant school kids, which had won an Orwell Prize in 2020 — was “riddled with racist and ableist tropes” and “rooted in eugenics and phrenology”. She later wittily coined the <a href="https://x.com/KateClanchy1/status/1538475600792412161" target="_blank" rel="noopener">nickname</a> “KKKlanchy” for her target on Twitter.</p>
<p>Meanwhile, the BBC had yet to grasp that there might be a newsworthy witch hunt going on in the publishing industry. Instead it solemnly <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-58151144" target="_blank" rel="noopener">reported</a> that Clanchy had the temerity to describe two autistic children she personally knew as &#8220;jarring company&#8221; and “unselfconsciously odd&#8221; in her very own literary creation. Alongside the account of this supposedly heinous crime, there was a helpful link to a resource entitled “<a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/worklife/article/20210330-the-harmful-ableist-language-you-unknowingly-use" target="_blank" rel="noopener">The harmful ableist language you unknowingly use&#8221;</a>, explaining to any readers puzzled by the fuss that everyday expressions like “dumb”, “to turn a blind eye”, and “psychopathic” constituted “micro-assaults” against disabled people.</p>
<p>But we are in 2025 now, thank God, and we don’t have to turn a blind eye to all that dumb stuff anymore. Entirely appropriately, this week Clanchy received an <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckg19p6kej1o" target="_blank" rel="noopener">apology</a> from the new CEO of her ex-publisher Pan Macmillan for a “regrettable series of events” that was said to have caused “hurt” to her at the time. <em>The</em> <em>Times </em>also published a sympathetic <a href="https://www.thetimes.com/article/7681d5ec-3773-4b36-ab95-e4ab409d7899?shareToken=5117c5a20b67a2628630afd919d7f2c4" target="_blank" rel="noopener">piece</a>, documenting astonishingly callous treatment of the poet by those within the publishing industry, and describing how, at one point, she had contemplated suicide because of it. From a distance, it looks like Clanchy is now living the dream of every person ever canceled in public: not just bathing in the warm tears of her enemies, but also getting recognition for having suffered serious injustice from suitably authoritative-sounding institutions. After all — in the absence of information about the precise contents of the Last Judgment — the verdicts of mainstream media outlets still offer a passable shot at redemption.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/you-cant-cancel-poetry/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/you-cant-cancel-poetry/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Kate-1-e1643385172784.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/you-cant-cancel-poetry/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/you-cant-cancel-poetry/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>You can&#039;t cancel poetry</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/you-cant-cancel-poetry/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kate Clanchy </a></p></div></a></div>
<p>As I read the <em>Times</em> piece, I thought of a recent, highly pertinent <em>Economist</em> <a href="https://www.economist.com/britain/2025/10/29/the-idolatry-of-victimhood" target="_blank" rel="noopener">column</a>, which argued that the symbolic figure of the victim has become the “apex stakeholder” in modern society. The subject of this article was not victims in the straightforward sense of a person who has undergone a serious harm of some sort. Instead, it was about a much more exclusive set: people who have been <em>publicly recognized </em>as suffering serious harm. This is another matter entirely, as those affected by the grooming gang scandal demonstrates: ignored for years, now suddenly championed by nervous politicians. Such is the cultural capital of the victim in this socially approved sense, the <em>Economist</em> argued, the only way to stymie the political momentum of one of them is to find another victim whose interests are said to markedly differ. Or, as the piece says, it takes a victim to stop a victim.</p>
<p>Certainly, this looks true of the Clanchy saga, although I’m sure the woman at its epicenter wishes it was otherwise. Against the original claims about the terrible suffering of ethnic minorities and disabled people, said to be caused by Clanchy’s book and defensive reactions to its criticism, a competing set of claims was issued. These also mentioned online abuse, damage to mental health, and troubling suicidal ideation, but this time the proposed victim was Clanchy herself, along with any other creative artists cowed into fearful submission by marauding berserkers online. I’m not saying that it isn’t an awful experience to be the target of people like this — I know for a fact that it is — but still, it is striking that the only way to fight such obviously spurious charges is to emphasize how much their target has herself psychologically suffered in turn.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Rajesh has forgotten the first rule of victim club&#8221;</div>
<p>And now we have Rajesh’s attempt to get in on the act again, presenting herself as a rival object of pity with her tear-stained monologue. Unfortunately, though, like Beard before her, Rajesh has forgotten the first rule of victim club, which is that you cannot be seen to advertise your own suffering too obviously — for this would exhibit an unseemly agency, and sit awkwardly with the passivity built into the brand. The ancient meaning of “victim” was “sacrificial offering to the gods”, after all; and essentially, that’s the mood board. To count as a victim in the socially approved sense, you can only look big-eyed, dignified and long-suffering, like a dumb animal waiting for the knife, leaving it to others to invade the abattoir in protest on your behalf. As soon as you intervene to obtain recognition for your own plight, you risk slipping out of the category altogether; now seen as vaguely complicit in whatever first happened to you, or even as an active oppressor of the other, should your tone sound too excitable or harsh.</p>
<p>Yet for many, there remains a manic compulsion to plead your case to the wider world — even when you know that doing so is pointless, and even when nobody is accusing you of anything at all. At a deep level, it is probably due to what the German philosopher Odo Marquard has <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Defense-Accidental-Philiosophical-Studies-Odeon/dp/0195072529" target="_blank" rel="noopener">called</a> the “tribunalization of experience”: that nagging sense of personal guilt engendered by the modern godless predicament. Assuming that one can no longer pin ultimate causality on a higher being, a worrying question mark hovers perpetually over one’s own forays into deliberate action, along with an unconscious desire to be absolved in advance. There’s a corresponding urge to be formally designated by other people as spotless victim and not as red-handed oppressor. Or as Marquard <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Defense-Accidental-Philiosophical-Studies-Odeon/dp/0195072529" target="_blank" rel="noopener">wrote</a>, anticipating the massive trend for defensiveness on the internet: “For today, everything seems to need justification: &#8230; the way one’s hair grows, one’s mood, one’s life, education, bathing suits; only one thing—one wonders why—needs no justification, and that is the need to justify to one and all.”</p>
<p>In this light, the tearstained visual documents offered by Beard and Rajesh transcend racial divisions, and speak to a touchingly common human predicament: the wish, deep down, to appear more sinned against than sinning. Public apologies are easy; the hardest thing of all is admitting to your secret self you might have messed things up. It almost makes you feel sorry for people weeping all over the internet. Ultimately, the desire for perceived victimhood is a poisoned chalice. Far better to hark back to a more stoic age, and do your crying in the rain with the camera off.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/11/how-to-play-the-victim-card/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1036237</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>MAGA’s ‘Bad Bunny’ fumble</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Dylan-image.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>culture war</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Dylan Partner]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Bluemanv2.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>International</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[The rapper Bad Bunny has raised MAGA’s ire. Credit: Getty]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Dylan Partner</strong> is a writer living in New York City.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>narrenhut</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a writer living in New York City.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 06 Oct 2025 01:28:39 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 06 Oct 2025 01:28:39 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[bad bunny]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[bush administration]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[dixie chicks]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[john ashcroft]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[jon stewart]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[MAGA]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Progressivism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Super Bowl]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The left]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The right]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1031583</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Bush-style culture-policing is a gift to the Left]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Beginning a decade ago, Donald Trump shook the US political scene by challenging not just an elite policy consensus, but the often politely repressive style of the establishment. Where conventional Republicans and Democrats offered evangelical and progressive pieties, respectively, Trump’s MAGA movement delighted in rowdy rallies, vulgar jokes, and shattered taboos. In response, much of the Left doubled down on minute language policing, call-outs, and a general dourness — and paid the price for it at the ballot box in 2016 and 2024.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Now, as the Trumpians consolidate power, the MAGA-sphere is increasingly asserting cultural control; progressives, meanwhile, find themselves in a historically familiar position: that of the underdog. This resetting to an older pattern — the Right policing the culture, the Left in dissent — can be a gift to progressives. That is, provided they pick the right battles and wage them the correct way. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Consider the Right-wing reaction to the NFL’s announcement that Bad Bunny, a massively popular Puerto Rican rapper, will be headlining the 2026 Super Bowl halftime show. “They [NFL officials] suck, and we’ll win, and God will bless us,” declared Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem with characteristic nuance in a </span><a href="https://nypost.com/2025/10/04/us-news/nfl-officials-wont-be-able-to-sleep-at-night-after-picking-bad-bunny-for-super-bowl-halftime-show-dhs-chief-kristi-noem-says/"><span style="font-weight: 400">podcast interview</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">. The “X” (formerly Twitter) user known as the Redheaded Libertarian </span><a href="https://x.com/TRHLofficial/status/1972518877910495485"><span style="font-weight: 400">told her nearly 1 million followers</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> that “Bad Bunny is a demonic Marxist who was been [</span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">sic</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">] granted the largest stage with the greatest audience in the middle of a Christian revival.” The MAGA influencer Benny Johnson grumbled that the “NFL is self-destructing year after year.” The hard-Right pundit Jack Posobiec mused about staging an alternative halftime show headlined by the Christian rock band Creed.</span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/info-anarchy-comes-for-the-left/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/info-anarchy-comes-for-the-left/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/GettyImages-2213138249.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/info-anarchy-comes-for-the-left/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More From This Author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/info-anarchy-comes-for-the-left/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Info anarchy comes for the Left</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/info-anarchy-comes-for-the-left/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Dylan Partner</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Americans who came of age in the post-9/11 era will recognize a replay of</span><i><span style="font-weight: 400"> l’affaire</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> Dixie Chicks. That was when, amid a different surge of evangelical-tinged jingoism, the country band faced a ferocious backlash, fanned by George W. Bush himself, after one of their number criticized the Iraq War on a London stage. It was an unceremonious cancellation before we had a name for cancel culture, with radio stations nationwide blacklisting the chicks’ music. And it formed part of a broader pattern of early-Aughts conservative repression (remember Attorney General John Ashcroft covering up </span><a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cover-up-at-justice-department/"><span style="font-weight: 400">two nude statues at the Department of Justice</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">?). Such overreach was catnip to liberal comedians like Jon Stewart and fueled the dissent-is-patriotic Left that culminated in the Obama presidency.  </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The Trumpians, in their overreach, are creating similar openings for the Left: from revoking green cards for pro-Palestinian students to placing entire academic departments under federal ideological supervision in the name of combating anti-Semitism, the second Trump administration is seemingly going out of its way to alienate many of the young people, especially young men, who rallied to it in backlash to the censoriousness of the Left. But the Bad Bunny episode threatens to take the trend to a much broader public.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Bad Bunny, whose birth name is Benito Ocasio, is an ample target for MAGA pitchforks. He has raised vocal opposition against the Trump administration, and in particular its immigration policies, going so far as to exclude the United States altogether from his upcoming tour due to </span><a href="https://variety.com/2025/music/news/bad-bunny-didnt-include-us-in-tour-dates-fear-ice-raids-1236514269/"><span style="font-weight: 400">concerns about ICE raids</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">. Perhaps in retribution for these comments, Noem vowed that ICE would be “</span><a href="https://variety.com/2025/music/news/kristi-noem-ice-bad-bunny-super-bowl-halftime-show-1236540306/"><span style="font-weight: 400">all over</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">” his Super Bowl performance, which should only be attended by “law-abiding Americans who love this country.” (Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt </span><a href="https://thehill.com/blogs/in-the-know/5537460-white-house-bad-bunny-super-bowl-ice-raids/"><span style="font-weight: 400">walked back</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> this overeager vow in a later news conference, noting that there is “no tangible plan” for an ICE raid at the Super Bowl.)</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The ethnic and racial dimensions of the fracas are unmistakable. The </span><a href="https://x.com/CasualPolitics_/status/1973984877159608727"><span style="font-weight: 400">easy response</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> by </span><a href="https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2025-10-04/bad-bunny-super-bowl-halftime-show"><span style="font-weight: 400">many liberals</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> has been to note that the MAGA haters don’t understand that Bad Bunny is himself American, since Puerto Rico has been part of the United States since the time of the Spanish-American War. Fox News host Tomi Lahren, for example, </span><a href="https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/got-humiliated-tomi-lahren-roasted-140104981.html?guccounter=1&amp;guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&amp;guce_referrer_sig=AQAAACouA__DMgEV5ApkyqzoVsGSqY02HZWVDtDQvCSLNJX7KIo2ehJAaQQAeX4OSPg2za8n8ENpWuS4T-ma5SqfApm69x_gG9pJQtiyQwe20d4YR37z4wJeErEKoiJ_fRWSJsgoxd_RyMOvJa9yszGpl419nXUMhvAcQJMuNkXJy42i"><span style="font-weight: 400">said</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> that “he’s not an American artist.” </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">It’s tempting for liberals to smugly take note of such ignorance. But the Left’s Puerto-Rico-Is-America correctives fail to address the actual reasons why conservatives are fuming. For many, it’s the fact that Ocasio is vocally anti-Trump. For others, it’s that he performs in Spanish. And some others simply don’t see him as American at all, no matter what the geography books say. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Nativists in the United States have long faced a tough task of drawing the line between “real” and “fake” Americans, compared to nationalists in the rest of the West. Unlike many European countries that have only seen meaningful mass migration in the past few decades, immigration has fundamentally transformed the composition of the American ethnic stock for hundreds of years. The initial </span><a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/1919209"><span style="font-weight: 400">overwhelmingly English</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> population was eclipsed — one might even say “replaced” — by successive waves of migrants, first from Ireland and Germany during the 19th century, then by “Ellis Islanders”: Italians, Jews, and other Eastern Europeans who came around the turn of the 20th. This makes it difficult to ascertain what, exactly, an ethnically ideal America would look like.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">This is why the phrase “Heritage Americans” has </span><a href="https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2025/07/31/heritage-american-jd-vance-online-right-phrase-00481724"><span style="font-weight: 400">gained ground</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> among many on the online Right in recent months. Unsatisfied with merely drawing the line at the 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act, which abolished the decades-old ethnic quota system and allowed the migration of a vastly greater number of Asians and Africans (mass migration from Latin America was largely driven by other factors, such as the abolition of the Bracero system for importing cheap agricultural labor), they have reached back further in American history to define their in-group and out-group. Ellis Islanders aren’t real Americans, they contend — only those descended from colonial-era stock have a valid claim to American identity. </span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“Americans who came of age in the post-9/11 era will recognize a replay of l’affaire Dixie Chicks.”</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Someone like Bad Bunny, whether or not he identifies himself as American, falls outside of this and other definitions of “American” that have been raised in objection to the liberal notion of America as a “propositional nation” based on broadly defined civic commonalities. “America is not just an idea,” said JD Vance in </span><a href="https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2024/07/17/jd_vance_america_is_not_just_an_idea_it_is_a_nation.html"><span style="font-weight: 400">his speech</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> to the 2024 Republican National Convention. “It is a group of people with a shared history and a common future.” While Vance’s conception of American identity includes “welcoming newcomers,” more hard-line proponents of “Heritage America” make no such concessions to immigration and demographic change. Yet neither is particularly hospitable to a figure like Ocasio.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Ocasio’s strong Puerto Rican and Latino identities conflict with a certain understanding of our national “shared history and common future,” at least in the eyes of MAGA influencers, who see his presence on perhaps the most quintessentially American stage of them all, the Super Bowl field, as not just a partisan offense, but a betrayal of the national identity. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Some influential voices on the Left believe that this showdown could end up redounding to the advantage of Democrats and their more expansive conception of American identity. “The Democrats need to empower messengers that the establishment is scared of,” </span><span style="font-weight: 400">Molly Jong-Fast wrote in a </span><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/04/opinion/bad-bunny-super-bowl-democrats.html"><i><span style="font-weight: 400">New York Times </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">op-ed</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">, arguing that the party must take inspiration from Bad Bunny’s defiance of the Trump administration. “Democrats need to listen to the roar of the crowd.” </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Yet questions of identity, ethnicity, and belonging aren’t the most productive angle of attack here for the Left. Much more promising is focusing on the micromanagement of the country’s cultural life, which few Americans can tolerate in the long term, and many find contrary to their conception of freedom. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/save-us-from-the-crank-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/save-us-from-the-crank-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/GettyImages-1388455301.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/save-us-from-the-crank-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested article</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/save-us-from-the-crank-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Save us from the crank Right</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/save-us-from-the-crank-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Sohrab Ahmari</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">In the 2010s and 2020s, many Left-of-center institutions couldn’t grasp that they weren’t the underdogs. Progressive ideology is built around the defense of those perceived to be downtrodden, oppressed, and excluded from power — so their dominance of American culture created profound cognitive dissonance among the progressive cognoscenti. How could they have power if they were advocates of the powerless? How could they be cool if they were the establishment? How could they be rebels when the </span><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/may/04/cia-woke-recruitment-ad"><span style="font-weight: 400">CIA ran recruitment ads</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> in which an agency spy identified herself as “</span><span style="font-weight: 400">a cisgender millennial, who has been diagnosed with generalized anxiety disorder.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Deep down, many progressives continued to think of themselves as akin to the Dixie Chicks. But this self-conception wasn’t shared by many others, who saw them for what they were: hopelessly uncool and central to the “</span><a href="https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2021/11/the-cia-and-the-new-dialect-of-power/"><span style="font-weight: 400">new dialect of power</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">.” Jong-Fast and others believe the Trump administration’s harsh criticism of Bad Bunny will position his progressive politics as both popular and anti-establishment — or, to put it simply, cool. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Maybe. But it will take more than just a Trumpian crackdown for the Left to restock its currency of cool dissent. After all, Bad Bunny is still performing at the behest of a massive capitalist organization. Any musical act hosted by the NFL can’t be all that subversive. The Trump administration, from another perspective, can present itself as fighting another establishment — just one that happens to be temporarily excluded from the White House. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">A Left that wants to capitalize on the Trumpians’ Bush-like overreach will have to embrace a much more raucous style, learn to think and speak more freely within its own ranks, drop carefully workshopped rhetoric, and leave behind the dour managerial style that came to define it over the past decade. It will have to get </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">uncomfortable</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> once more with corporate America and the surveillance state, as its predecessors of an earlier age were. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Nearly a year into the second Trump administration, MAGA has fumbled the ball on culture. It remains to be seen if progressives are ready to drive it to the end zone. </span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/magas-bad-bunny-fumble/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1031583</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The Left&#039;s ugly free-speech fetish</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/the-lefts-ugly-free-speech-fetish/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/the-lefts-ugly-free-speech-fetish/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/GettyImages-1239585252-e1759691722859.jpg?w=648</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>free speech</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Sarah Ditum]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/sarah.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Gerardo Vieyra/NurPhoto /Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Sarah Ditum</strong> is a columnist, critic and feature writer.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>sarahditum</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a columnist, critic and feature writer.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 05 Oct 2025 23:01:02 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 06 Oct 2025 01:30:09 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Free Speech]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Literature]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1031539</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Consequence culture is making martyrs]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>What is politics? The American horror author, comic book writer and trans activist Gretchen Felker-Martin offered a shockingly bloodthirsty definition in a <a href="https://www.thefader.com/2022/04/29/gretchen-felcker-martin-manhunt-interview" target="_blank" rel="noopener">2022 interview</a> to promote his novel <em>Manhunt</em>: “Politics is who you love and who you’re willing to kill. That’s really it.” (Felker-Martin is male, identifying as a woman.) So there was no hypocrisy involved when, following the assassination of Charlie Kirk last month, Felker-Martin made <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/soupytoasterson.bsky.social/post/3lyk4wfhtgk2r" target="_blank" rel="noopener">two celebratory Bluesky posts</a>. “Thoughts and prayers you Nazi bitch,” read one. “Hope the bullet’s okay after touching Kirk,” read another.</p>
<p>It’s fair to say that Kirk was not over-mourned in the liberal enclave of Bluesky. Elsewhere, though, he was very rapidly attaining a kind of MAGA sainthood — aided by the fact that his killer appeared to be motivated by animosity to Kirk’s anti-trans views. Anyone demurring from the public performance of mourning risked becoming a target of Right-wing rage. Within hours, Felker-Martin received a call from the comics publisher DC, canceling the series Felker-Martin had been working on and terminating their relationship.</p>
<p>That made Felker-Martin one of the many Americans to have been fired or disciplined for being insufficiently respectful towards Kirk. High-profile examples include late-night host Jimmy Kimmel (whose show was temporarily pulled) and the columnist Karen Attiah (who was sacked by <em>The Washington Post</em>). More concerning are the rank-and-file Americans, from hospital workers to restaurant managers, who either lost their jobs or faced formal sanctions: over 145 by <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/26/us/kirk-critics-fired-free-speech.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The New York Times</em></a><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/26/us/kirk-critics-fired-free-speech.html">’ count</a> in late September, and presumably more since then.</p>
<p>In the words of historian Timothy Snyder, from his 2017 book <em>On Tyranny</em>, by canceling Felker-Martin, DC was <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/08/opinion/trump-power-surrender.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“obeying in advance”</a>: intuiting what the powerful wanted, and delivering it. Other writers were quick to identify this as a sinister tendency. “It’s an absolute shame that DC fired Gretchen Felker-Martin for exercising free speech,” <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/roxanegay.bsky.social/post/3lylccufivs2l" target="_blank" rel="noopener">wrote the feminist author Roxane Gay on Bluesky</a>. “Every writer here should be decrying this because we have to stand up for each other! This is ridiculous.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/did-too-much-hate-break-lena-dunham/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/did-too-much-hate-break-lena-dunham/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/lenadunham.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/did-too-much-hate-break-lena-dunham/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More From This Author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/did-too-much-hate-break-lena-dunham/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why women hate Lena Dunham</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/did-too-much-hate-break-lena-dunham/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Sarah Ditum </a></p></div></a></div>
<p>People losing their livelihoods for real or perceived political transgressions, however, is not a new phenomenon. It has been going on for over a decade — it’s just that, until very recently, the vast majority of the victims were identified with Right-wing politics, and so long as that was true, it didn’t strike those of Gay’s persuasion as an issue. In one egregious 2020 case, a worker for the San Diego Gas &amp; Electric company was <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/06/stop-firing-innocent/613615/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">fired for making a “white supremacist gesture”</a>: he had made the “okay” sign, unaware that it had recently been co-opted by the alt-Right. In another instance, a senior figure in the American Civil Liberties Union — which literally has one job: upholding the First Amendment — favored <a href="https://www.wsj.com/opinion/does-the-aclu-want-to-ban-my-book-11605475898" target="_blank" rel="noopener">banning</a> Abigail Shrier’s book <em>Irreversible Harm</em>, which describes the social contagion of trans identification among teenage girls.</p>
<p>But asked whether cancel culture existed in a <a href="https://www.motherjones.com/media/2021/03/roxane-gay-says-cancel-culture-does-not-exist/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">2021 interview</a>, Gay replied robustly: “No, it does not. Cancel culture is this boogeyman that people have come up with to explain away bad behavior… I like to think of it as consequence culture, where when you make a mistake — and we all do, by the way — there should be consequences.” (It would be snide, but not inaccurate, to point out that Felker-Martin’s sacking is also an instance of consequence culture.) Another cancel culture unbeliever was Karen Attiah, who <a href="https://x.com/KarenAttiah/status/1504842386173739033" target="_blank" rel="noopener">tweeted</a> in 2022 that “‘Cancel culture’ anxiety is not about free speech. It’s about status anxiety.” Concerns about free speech, in other words, were really just concerns about who got to speak — a failure of the once-powerful to accept their new place in the hierarchy. The possibility that the hierarchy might change again and leave the Left on the losing side never apparently occurred.</p>
<p>The intellectual collapse of the liberal Left allowed the Right to monopolize the cause of free speech, even if that position was rarely taken in good faith. One of Donald Trump’s first executive orders in this presidency was titled “Restoring Freedom of Speech and Ending Federal Censorship”; <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/11/us/politics/trump-wordplay.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">at the same time</a>, federal websites were being cleansed of oldspeak terms such as “antiracist”, “trauma” and “hate speech”. This government-directed linguistic purge is more disturbing by far than the “soft” repression of Left-wing cancel culture, but it violates the same principle.</p>
<p>While leftist fury held the ascendance, “civility” was treated as a dirty word. “Tone policing” was a grievous sin. The space between politics and violence was intentionally narrowed. Anyone who held the correct beliefs could engage in the most vicious forms of speech with no consequences whatsoever. Like, for example, Felker-Martin. For as long as he has enjoyed a public profile, he has been vivid and explicit about exactly who he thought should be killed and how. But so long as those enemies were Terfs and so anathema to the US mainstream, Felker-Martin faced zero reputational cost for doing so.</p>
<p>In a statement to <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/charlie-kirk-art-censorship/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Wired </em></a>magazine, DC’s editor in chief tried to present the firing as non-partisan, asserting that “the tone of Gretchen’s posts, not her personal views, was of concern for DC”. If that’s the case, I have to wonder whether DC had any awareness of Felker-Martin’s social media presence or literary output prior to Kirk’s death. Because, compared to much of Felker-Martin’s lurid and sexually inflected writing, “thoughts and prayers you Nazi bitch” is extremely mild stuff. Take this <a href="https://jessesingal.substack.com/p/id-like-gretchen-felker-martin-to" target="_blank" rel="noopener">2019 tweet</a> about the journalist Jesse Singal (a regular target of Felker-Martin’s), the tone of which apparently left DC unperturbed:</p>
<p>“Cis people, fix your hearts* or die.</p>
<p>*Bind Jesse Singal with strong rope and bring him to the quarry at the edge of town. Give him to us alive and unspoiled. Leave, and no matter the sounds you hear, do not look back.”</p>
<p>The motivation for this bizarre bondage scenario is that Singal has reported consistently and fairly on the failures of child gender medicine. That, according to Felker-Martin, amounts to “politely trying to incite genocide”, and this in turn justifies whatever sadistic fantasies Felker-Martin may have. It’s a rationale that invokes a pet idea of the Left’s called “stochastic terrorism”, which maintains that dehumanizing language is a form of violence in itself. Like “cancel culture”, though, “stochastic terrorism” was politicized beyond usefulness: instances in which the Left itself could be dehumanizing <a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-stochastic-terrorism-uses-disgust-to-incite-violence/?utm_source=mj-newsletters&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_campaign=daily-newsletter-09-27-2023" target="_blank" rel="noopener">never figured in the analysis</a>.</p>
<p>Usually, I would try to argue for a separation between an artist’s social media and their art. But in Felker-Martin’s case, it’s hard to make that distinction because his fiction is very much in the same genre of inventing justifications for violence, and then imagining that violence in pornographic detail. <em>Manhunt </em>is the story of two trans women surviving in the post-apocalyptic remains of society after a zombifying virus has ravaged anyone with sufficiently high testosterone: the protagonists are engaged in a constant hunt for DIY HRT in order to avoid succumbing themselves.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Anyone who held the correct beliefs could engage in the most vicious forms of speech with no consequences whatsoever.&#8221;</div>
<p>But while the rabid men are dangerous, the true antagonists are the members of a Terf militia, who are dedicated to rounding up and executing any surviving trans women. And it’s when describing the Terfs’ deaths that Felker-Martin is most obviously excited. Imminent violence against women goes hand-in-hand with arousal in<em> Manhunt</em>. When the two protagonists first encounter the militia and are preparing for a confrontation, Felker-Martin writes of one: &#8220;Her cock was hard, tenting the front of her stupid cargo shorts.&#8221;</p>
<p>In the moral schema of <em>Manhunt</em>, women deserve punishment for holding disobliging beliefs about trans women, even when those beliefs are an accurate reflection of what the trans women understand about themselves. The Terf militia leader inveighs against &#8220;Men who take sexual pleasure in stealing our bodies. In wearing our skin,&#8221; and this is presented as one of the many misdeeds for which she will ultimately pay with her humiliating death. But given one of the trans woman protagonists elsewhere recalls a teenage crush on a girl with &#8220;a body she’d wanted more to hollow out and crawl inside than fuck&#8221;, is the militia leader actually wrong?</p>
<p>In one especially unpleasant scene, Felker-Martin imagines the militia leader executing a defector from her ranks by disemboweling her and extracting her uterus, holding it up for the watching crowd with the words: &#8220;No life without a womb.&#8221; The purpose of this scene is to demonstrate the endless depravity of what, in the book, are referred to contemptuously as &#8220;menopausal white ladies&#8221; or &#8220;sneering middle-class white women&#8221;. It vindicates the trans characters’ decision to &#8220;kill them all and piss on their corpses&#8221;.</p>
<p>The ultimate &#8220;sneering middle-class white lady&#8221;, from Felker-Martin’s perspective, is J.K. Rowling, and <em>Manhunt </em>acquired a burst of notoriety from one specific scene in which Rowling’s death is narrated. Within the world of the book, Rowling attempted to ride out the infection &#8220;at her castle in Scotland with a bunch of her rich girlfriends&#8221;. The &#8220;girl-power retreat&#8221;, however, rapidly goes south: one of the friends has PCOS (meaning she has higher than usual testosterone), which leads to her contracting the virus and starting a rampage that leads to the castle burning, killing all inside, Rowling included.</p>
<p>In response to outrage at this, Felker-Martin presented himself as a <a href="https://archive.ph/u4ui1#selection-779.36-779.181" target="_blank" rel="noopener">victim of misrepresentation</a>. This is dishonest. The narrative takes pleasure in imagining Rowling’s death — the character who tells the story is &#8220;grinning evilly&#8221; — and the entire scenario is constructed as a Dante-esque punishment. Within <em>Manhunt</em>, Rowling is destroyed by her privilege, and by her apparently deluded belief in binary human sex. It is sadistic and disturbing, and almost none of the reviews noted this. <em>Manhunt </em>instead received supportive notices from <a href="https://www.npr.org/2022/03/14/1086399119/in-manhunt-a-virus-turns-anyone-with-enough-testosterone-into-a-feral-beast" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>NPR</em></a> (&#8220;brilliantly imagined&#8221;), <a href="https://www.vulture.com/article/best-books-2022.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>New York Magazine</em></a> (&#8220;full of… messy, beautiful humanity&#8221;) and <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/what-were-reading-this-summer-2022" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The New Yorker</em></a> (&#8220;tender&#8221;).</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/nigel-farages-cynical-pronatalism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/nigel-farages-cynical-pronatalism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/GettyImages-471927622.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/nigel-farages-cynical-pronatalism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More From This Author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/nigel-farages-cynical-pronatalism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Nigel Farage’s cynical pronatalism</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/nigel-farages-cynical-pronatalism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Sarah Ditum </a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The fact that Felker-Martin is obnoxious, misogynistic and crass doesn’t mean he deserved to lose his job over a bad tweet. But, realistically, he only had that job because this is the kind of person and the kind of art — obnoxious, misogynist and crass — that the liberal culture of the last five years chose to celebrate. <em>Manhunt</em> is not a good novel: it lurches from scene to scene with little explanation of how you got there, and the characters are so loosely drawn that they blur into each other. This is not even James Herbert, and yet it was lauded by critics as though it were George Eliot. Felker-Martin could only have achieved cultural prominence in a milieu that prized rightthink above artistic quality.</p>
<p>Liking <em>Manhunt </em>was a test of allegiance to the cause. The more violence you could stomach, the more you were overcoming your unconscious transphobia; and (for female readers) the more you could find pleasure in the degradation of women, the more you proved that you weren’t a part of the despicable “cisterhood” who apparently deserved this degradation. His pattern of sexualized harassment against individuals such as Singal was ignored because, as a trans woman, Felker-Martin could claim the perverse privilege of the most oppressed.</p>
<p>Not content with fictionally destroying female writers, Felker-Martin also sought to <a href="https://www.thefader.com/2022/04/29/gretchen-felcker-martin-manhunt-interview" target="_blank" rel="noopener">trash their reputations</a>. He was <a href="https://www.patreon.com/posts/63782522" target="_blank" rel="noopener">especially savage</a> about Sandra Newman’s novel <em>The Men</em>, which like <em>Manhunt </em>was published in 2022, and described a world in which every person with a Y chromosome — trans women included — had mysteriously disappeared. This “repellent premise”, according to Felker-Martin, was “fundamentally transmisogynistic” (even though it is not very different from Felker-Martin’s own book, albeit with fewer scenes of misogynistic butchery). That charge fed into a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/12/opinion/sandra-newman-men.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">broader denunciation</a> of Newman’s novel. <em>The Men </em>was bombed with one-star ratings on Goodreads even before it was out; an author who defended Newman’s novel was punished by having her own book removed from consideration for an LGBT literary prize.</p>
<p>I wonder whether this is what Roxane Gay would class as “consequence culture”. There was no call for solidarity with Newman like the one Gay would later make for Felker-Martin: no declaration that “every writer” should “stand up for each other”. Newman was deemed on the wrong side of history, and so she was allowed to sink. The recent rediscovery of free speech is difficult to swallow from people who have spent the last 10 years or so either airily downplaying the threat from their own, or actively making it worse.</p>
<p>Felker-Martin did not agree with Kirk about very much, but they did share an essentially martial vision of the world. Kirk saw himself as a soldier for God, while for Felker-Martin, <a href="https://www.thefader.com/2022/04/29/gretchen-felcker-martin-manhunt-interview" target="_blank" rel="noopener">every disagreement is a war</a>: “I have fuck-all time for a consensus.” This belief, that the only worthy way of life involves bloodletting, has been incubated on both sides of the American divide. Now, under Trump, the Right has the opportunity to crush its enemies, and it is doing so with relish, using techniques that the Left has refined. If this is how the Left rediscovers free speech as a universal principle, it’s been an expensive lesson, but a necessary one.</p>
<p>But a healthy culture needs other values too: it needs moral and aesthetic judgments that do not split along party lines. It needs to be able to say who is, and is not, a good person. It needs to be able to say what is, and is not, good art. Felker-Martin is the free-speech martyr that the Left of the last decade deserves: unpleasant, unsympathetic and almost impossible to defend.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/the-lefts-ugly-free-speech-fetish/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/the-lefts-ugly-free-speech-fetish/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/the-lefts-ugly-free-speech-fetish/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1031539</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>How Simone de Beauvoir got me cancelled</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/how-simone-de-beauvoir-got-me-cancelled/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/how-simone-de-beauvoir-got-me-cancelled/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/sione_de_beauvoir.jpg?w=623</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Gender wars</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Susan Pickard]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/blue__80__720.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[The pioneering feminist thinker is being erased. Credit: UnHerd]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>Susan Pickard is a professor of sociology at the University of Liverpool. She is serializing a version of her book on the Substack <a href="http://susanpickard.substack.com/">Beauvoirian Feminism</a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle></unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[Susan Pickard is a professor of sociology at the University of Liverpool. She is serializing a version of her book on the Substack <a href="http://susanpickard.substack.com/">Beauvoirian Feminism</a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Wed, 01 Oct 2025 22:59:50 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 02 Oct 2025 10:55:32 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Books]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Feminism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[gender theory]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Judith Butler]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Publishing]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Sexism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Simone de Beauvoir]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1031056</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Her work refutes trans ideology]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">In 2022, I signed a contract with an academic press for a book on Simone de Beauvoir, titled </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Beauvoirian Feminism</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. Two years later, I finished the book, which foregrounded the feminist thinker’s claim that biology is key to women’s experience. I’m a full professor of sociology at the University of Liverpool, and publication of finished academic works at my level is usually a matter of course. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">On </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">this</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> topic, however, things did not go smoothly. After the book was completed, due to the controversial nature of the material, the press sent it out to 26 readers for peer review. Most accepted the invitation — then backed out once they saw the manuscript. Only one delivered a report, criticizing my work for being “unfair” to gender theorist Judith Butler and “gratuitously unkind to trans people.” My insistence on embodiment — Beauvoir’s insistence — was treated as an embarrassing throwback. In 2025, the contract was terminated. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">I then sent the manuscript to several other presses, who also declined to take it forward. One respected university imprint rejected the book as “too controversial.” Another told me it did not publish books on “individual thinkers” — then six months later issued a book casting Beauvoir as a pro-trans icon. A third prestigious press told me my book “did not fit its list” — and went on to publish a title called </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Sex Is a Spectrum</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, inspired by Beauvoir.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The attempt to repurpose Beauvoir to shore up gender-identity orthodoxy represents an all-out attack on her thinking, and erases the actual contents of </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Second Sex</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, a foundational work of feminist theory, first published in 1949. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/is-this-the-end-of-genderism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/is-this-the-end-of-genderism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/GettyImages-2216250306.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/is-this-the-end-of-genderism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested article</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/is-this-the-end-of-genderism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Is this the end of genderism?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/is-this-the-end-of-genderism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Beauvoir is controversial today because she was the ultimate sex realist; she refused to separate body from identity, and believed that it was only through understanding women’s embodied reality that we could combat patriarchal cultural norms. Her essential position can be summed up simply: sex is the material ground of women’s lives, gender the cultural elaboration of that ground, and liberation comes not from denying the body, but by transforming the meaning imposed upon it.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">She began </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Second Sex</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> with research on biology, spending long hours in France’s National Library, sifting through centuries of the science on reproduction. Biology is not everything, she argued. It does not condemn us to lesser lives — but nor is it nothing: nature commandeers a woman’s body, from puberty onward, for the service of the species. These facts don’t make us unequal, but social structures and norms turn reproductive realities into inequality.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">In almost every species, Beauvoir emphasized, organisms are defined by the gametes they produce. Large gametes (ova) define the female, small gametes (sperm) the male. In humans, this is “a biological given, not a moment in human history.” We are born male or female, always in relation to each other — what Beauvoir, borrowing from Heidegger, called </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Mitsein </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">(“Being-with”). Such sex differences themselves are not hierarchical, but patriarchy makes them so.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“One is not born, but becomes, a woman,” she famously wrote in </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Second Sex</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. But this does not mean that gender floats free of sex. For Beauvoir, sex is the foundation; gender its cultural elaboration. A female body is defined by the norms of femininity of its time and place. These norms can change — and Beauvoir’s work aimed to push them toward liberation. Meanwhile, both biology and culture shape the body’s meaning, power, and visibility, qualities that change over a woman’s lifetime as she shifts through the various forms of girl or mother, or menopausal or old woman.</span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“What drops out of view is feminism’s starting point — that sex is the basis of women’s oppression.”</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Today, however, Beauvoir is mostly taught through the lens of foundational gender theorist Butler, who claimed to extend her work. But as I argue in my book, Butler actually ignored Bouvoir’s book, collapsing the notion of “becoming a woman” into performance, where repeated gestures conjure the illusion of sex. In Butler’s version, gender is the creator of sex. She makes no mention of puberty, childbirth, or aging.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Butler’s understanding of what a woman is has shaped two generations, and has had noxious consequences for women. If “sex” is only an idea, then puberty itself can be rejected; the category “girl” is something to exit, hormonally or surgically. This is framed as liberation, but in practice, it erases female experience: it turns puberty into a pathology, encourages girls to disidentify from their own bodies, and makes womanhood optional or disposable. What drops out of view is feminism’s starting point — that sex is the basis of women’s oppression. And crucially, the rejection of women’s bodies and of femininity today does not generate demands to transform those constraining norms, but instead points girls toward escape by “becoming boys” — as if freedom lay only on the other side of sex.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Beauvoir’s difference from Butler matters because without sex, feminism loses its compass. If we cannot name sex, how do we name sex-based oppression? </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">I have long felt the weight of trans orthodoxies in the classroom and the conference hall. When I teach that, for Beauvoir, the body is not a blank slate, students protest: “using ‘sex’ as a category rationalizes prejudice.” Later, their essays come in as cool hagiographies to Butler, scare quotes around the word “woman.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">In the past, I kept my feelings to myself, wary of complaint. At conferences, I heard how Beauvoir’s emphasis on freedom and authenticity meant that she would definitely support trans identities. When I reminded my fellow academics that Beauvoir explicitly said: “No woman can claim without bad faith to be situated beyond her sex,” they looked away in embarrassment, and muttered that Beauvoir was being “weaponized by TERFs in the service of transphobia.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">To deny the female body is to dissolve womanhood into the ether. That is why Beauvoir is awkward today. She insisted that women are animals — embodied, vulnerable, enduring — not cartoons, cyborgs, or avatars. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Nor, in reality, is the female body easily dismissed: it is a body that betrays us, bleeds, and contracts on its own schedule; it intrudes on our consciousness and ruins our plans. Beauvoir writes bluntly, even brutally, about menstruation, childbirth, and abortion. Some critics have called her misogynist. But nothing she said is false — if anything, she was understating the situation.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Erasing women’s biology and erasing Beauvoir go hand in hand. In syllabi, Beauvoir has become a footnote — and when she is taught, “becoming a woman” is misread as affirming gender identity, the opposite of her words.</span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/how-gender-self-id-is-being-abused/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/how-gender-self-id-is-being-abused/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Marcelin-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/how-gender-self-id-is-being-abused/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested article</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/how-gender-self-id-is-being-abused/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How gender self-ID is being abused</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/how-gender-self-id-is-being-abused/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Julie Bindel</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">I’ve felt this erasure before. As a child, visiting my mother’s Spanish family, I encountered a strident machismo: speaking about politics and having opinions, were for men, not women; I was told to join the women in the kitchen. And it has persisted in subtle ways throughout my career. As an undergraduate at Oxford, my tutor told me, frustratedly, “You are very polite,” unaccustomed to this feminine constraint in what had been, until two years earlier, an all-male college. It was a habit that stuck with me; I found myself overly cautious, and less willing to take the imaginative leaps needed for originality.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The sting of being told to disappear has never left me. That is what today’s distortion of Beauvoir feels like: an instruction to step aside, to be silent, while others rewrite reality.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Beauvoir’s discovery was that sex cannot be evaded. Even though as a young woman she rejected the category “woman” — she “thought like a man,” she said, holding her own in a male world — she eventually realized she had been one all along, defined by her body and by patriarchy’s myths. “If I want to define myself,” she wrote, “I first have to say, ‘I am a woman’; all other assertions will arise from this basic truth.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">That insistence is what makes her urgent now. A feminism that cannot speak of puberty, pregnancy, menopause, or frailty abandons women. Identity without the body is not liberation, but denial.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">When publishers canceled my book, they wanted me to cut my critique of Butler. I refused: this lay at the core of my endorsement of a Beauvoirian feminism. That refusal is why I write now — because freedom begins from naming the body we inhabit and at the same time refusing to let it dictate our destiny.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Beauvoir would not have recognized this denial as liberation. Her project was to remake the meaning of womanhood — to expand it, not abandon it. To challenge the myths and constraints that keep women from fulfilling our potential. That is why I call for a Beauvoirian feminism: a vision of woman as both flesh and freedom, subject and agent, irreducibly real.</span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/how-simone-de-beauvoir-got-me-cancelled/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/how-simone-de-beauvoir-got-me-cancelled/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/10/how-simone-de-beauvoir-got-me-cancelled/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1031056</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>A gender critic refuses to be canceled</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/john-boyne-refuses-to-be-cancelled/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/john-boyne-refuses-to-be-cancelled/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/boyne-e1758818013538.jpg?w=493</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Literature</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Julie Bindel]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Screenshot-2026-10-15-at-11.44.56.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['When I look back at that period around Polari, I've seen some bullying in my time in the literary world, but I've never seen it quite like that.' Photo: Leonardo Cendamo/Getty.]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Julie Bindel</strong> is an investigative journalist, author, and feminist campaigner. Her latest book is <em>Lesbians: Where are we now?</em> She also writes on <a href="https://juliebindel.substack.com/">Substack</a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>bindelj</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an investigative journalist, author, and feminist campaigner. Her latest book is <em>Lesbians: Where are we now?</em> She also writes on <a href="https://juliebindel.substack.com/">Substack</a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 25 Sep 2025 23:00:52 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 30 Sep 2025 16:25:14 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Gender]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[JK Rowling]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[john boyne]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[polari prize]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=1029995</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Britain’s literati betrayed John Boyne]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>The pen used to be mightier than the sword, but these days the Twitter mob is more powerful than both. Once upon a time, literary prizes were delightfully straightforward: a panel of luminaries would read a few books, argue over wine about narrative and vocabulary, and then write a check for their favorite story. The winner went home with a gong and a few hundred extra book sales in the bag.</p>
<p>But then the culture wars hit. And now our literary awards are no longer about merely recognizing artistic merit; they have become battlegrounds for ideological conformity. Well, in England they have.</p>
<p>That’s one of the reasons I traveled to Paris for the <em>Prix de Roman Fnac</em>. John Boyne was about to receive it for his latest novel, <em>Earth</em>. He is only the sixth non-French writer to win it since it was inaugurated in 2002, and the only non-French nominee among this year’s 250 books. But though celebrated in France, Boyne is <em>persona non grata</em> in England after an ugly spat over his inclusion on the longlist for the LGBTQ+ Polari Prize.</p>
<p>It all kicked off after a transwoman judge resigned from the Polari’s first novel panel when she discovered that Boyne, a gender-critical gay man, was up for a prize. Cue the storming out of another two judges and 10 authors, and a petition signed by more than 800 writers and publishing-industry workers calling on the Polari organizers to remove Boyne’s book from its long list. Despite the bullying, though, he stood firm.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/meet-irelands-gender-rebels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/meet-irelands-gender-rebels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Screenshot-2025-06-30-at-11.25.13.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/meet-irelands-gender-rebels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/meet-irelands-gender-rebels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Meet Ireland’s gender rebels</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/meet-irelands-gender-rebels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Julie Bindel</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>“The irony is,” he tells me, sipping a mint tea in a café outside Gare du Nord station, “I would have felt like an idiot, stepping down. I just thought, ‘you can all have your tantrums and scream and shout. But it’s really nothing to do with me.’ I had never heard of the Polari prize ’til I got on the list.”</p>
<p>His crime? To describe himself as a Terf. There is no greater sin among the LGBTQ+ community than for a gay man to be gender critical. And though the prize describes itself as inclusive, it was unable to withstand such contradictions, and the awards were entirely shelved this year.</p>
<p>Boyne laughs when I point it out. “I thought, ‘let them kick me off the longlist and see what happens then. But I am not doing their dirty work’.” At first, he urged those new writers who had asked to be removed from the list to re-enter the award. “It was obvious to me they were either misguided or had been bullied or intimidated into withdrawing,” he says. Then, as the matter dragged on unresolved, he suggested that if these writers returned, he would ask judges not to consider his book for the shortlist.</p>
<p>It all represented a new low in literary politics, with personal ideology taking priority over literary merit — “pure vitriol” from “grown-ups who work in an industry which should be defined by freedom of thought and freedom of expression,” as Boyne puts it. In France, though, things are different.</p>
<p>Full of verve, ready for the awards ceremony, he is keen to address the madness of recent years. “When it comes to a literary award, it should really just be about the best book. Nothing else should matter. Not who’s the most famous, who has the most acceptable, popular views on stuff. It should be just about the writing.”</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;It all represented a new low in literary politics, with personal ideology taking priority over literary merit.&#8221;</div>
<p>It’s never just about the writing, though, as Boyne discovered when his book <em>My Brother’s Name Is Jessica </em>was published. This was a novel told through the lens of the brother of a boy who believed he was a girl. “It’s where my troubles began,” he says.</p>
<p>“When I decided to write about a boy growing up wanting to be a girl, I decided to do it from his brother‘s point of view. He’s trying to understand it, and by the end of the book, he realizes that the person he’s always loved hasn&#8217;t changed in any way.”</p>
<p>But the abuse he got after <em>Jessica </em>was the worst he had ever received. “I was called a transphobic bigot for ‘misgendering’ Jessica!” he still seems baffled at the outrage. “What was I supposed to do? Call the book, ‘<em>My Sister’s name is Jessica</em>’? Which would mean absolutely nothing to people. The walls came crashing down on me after that. I was officially transphobic.”</p>
<p>From then on, Boyne was targeted whenever he spoke out in support of women, lesbians and gays, and, in particular, J.K. Rowling. She is an unspeakable in certain circles. And it was after he published an article in support of her earlier this year, proclaiming himself a Terf in the <em>Irish Independent</em>, that the gloves truly came off.</p>
<p>“What’s worse is that during the whole furor, not <em>one </em>person from Polari made contact with me,” he says. “Which is pretty disgusting and unprofessional to say the least.”</p>
<p>Things couldn’t be more different on the other side of the Channel. Boyne is greeted at his incredibly glamorous awards ceremony with rapturous applause from the literary crowd, not a cancellation. And he makes the most of the opportunity to contrast his experiences in the UK with France.</p>
<p>“We live in a time when culture is often denigrated,” he tells the room. “I learned this recently with a prize that I was nominated for in the UK, where the personal ideologies of the authors were considered much more important than the qualities of the books.” He then plays to the crowd: “It was a French writer, Voltaire, who pronounced this famous phrase, <em>I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend your right to say it.</em> Unfortunately,” he continues, “some today prefer: I disapprove of what you say, and I will not allow you to say it. But not here, not in France.”</p>
<p>Afterwards, as Boyne is besieged by cashmered crowd, I ask a few of those milling around whether they’ve heard about the transgender controversy. They either didn’t know what I was talking about, or couldn’t care less. “We are French, we believe in liberty, this nonsense has nothing to do with our values”, said one, with a gallic shrug. I asked another if Boyne’s views on the trans issue had influenced her view of his work. “I also don’t know whether he likes French cheese,” she replied, gnomically.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/stonewall-and-the-search-for-meaning/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/stonewall-and-the-search-for-meaning/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/GettyImages-1229701739-e1732212455224.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/stonewall-and-the-search-for-meaning/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/stonewall-and-the-search-for-meaning/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Stonewall and the search for meaning</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/stonewall-and-the-search-for-meaning/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Boyne is clearly relieved that these awards have been a sort of bookend to the cancellation. It shows that there is still hope for writers. “The <em>Prix du Roman</em> has reminded me of what’s most important: the books that I write, the support of readers around the world, and the friendship of those fellow novelists who believe in freedom of thought, freedom of expression, and the importance of literature.”</p>
<p>The worst thing about the whole episode, he says, was the tenor of the interventions by all those 800 people who signed the open letter against him. It’s impossible to be blasé about personal safety, he says. And it made him think very carefully about his response. “Forget about the gender issue for a moment, it comes down to whether or not you are capitulating to bullying,” he says. “I’ve seen some bullying in my time in the literary world, but I&#8217;ve never seen it quite like that.”</p>
<p>Boyne’s refusal to hide away, though, and the fact that he didn’t retire to lick his wounds following the onslaught against him has made a big difference. It has shown the British literary establishment in its very worst light. And, even under that spotlight, it has only doubled down.</p>
<p>Perfectly representing our cultural cringe, a trans activist tweeted about John a few days before the French award. “Appears you’re done getting awards. You’re an embarrassment to our country”, it read. Soon after he won the Fnac prize, Boyne retweeted it with a series of laughing emojis, adding, “That tweet aged well, dude. All of nine days.”</p>
<p>But it’s not only Boyne who’s laughing. France, too, is surely mocking our small-minded pretensions. As one of our great writers heads off to be courted by some of France’s finest literary critics, and as our literary world grows ever more timid, it’s hard not to feel a little embarrassed on Britain’s behalf.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/john-boyne-refuses-to-be-cancelled/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/john-boyne-refuses-to-be-cancelled/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/09/john-boyne-refuses-to-be-cancelled/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1029995</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The sadist assault on the ‘Coldplay couple’</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/the-sadist-assault-on-the-coldplay-couple/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/the-sadist-assault-on-the-coldplay-couple/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/Untitled-6-1-2.jpg?w=433</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>privacy</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Matthew Gasda]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Blue-52.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>International</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Wrong place, wrong time. Credit: YouTube]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>Matthew Gasda is a playwright, author, and columnist for <em>UnHerd</em>, based in New York City.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>FOMO_sacer</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[Matthew Gasda is a playwright, author, and columnist for <em>UnHerd</em>, based in New York City.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Fri, 18 Jul 2025 23:00:58 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Sun, 20 Jul 2025 01:43:35 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Big tech]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[CEOs]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Infidelity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Romance]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Surveillance]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=693821</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[We need a new ethic of privacy]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>I wish I didn’t know who Andy Byron and Kristin Cabot are. As you no doubt know by now, the Astronomer CEO and his firm’s HR chief were caught on the jumbotron at a Coldplay concert. He tried to sneak away, while she covered her face, but it was too late. Someone posted the footage online. A pile-up ensued. And their lives were turned upside down.</p>
<p>As I say, I wish I didn’t know who they are. And that’s because any of us might, for any particular reason, become Andy Byron or Kristin Cabot: flawed people in the wrong place at the wrong time. Anybody can make a bad-but-irrelevant-to-the-rest-of-us mistake on camera and face personal destruction. What such episodes reveal is a pathology in the social body, and the desperate need for a new ethic of privacy.</p>
<p>The “Coldplay-concert-couple” story is fundamentally irrelevant and effectively contentless, telling us nothing about the world, about ourselves; it isn’t particularly funny or tragic or profound. There is no pathos, no insight. True, the current culture on X and other social-media apps is perhaps less immediately destructive than it was during peak woke (circa 2017 to 2021). Still, the viral potential of these kinds of stories is a warning sign that our culture is obsessed with shame, surveillance, and control. An obsession with other people’s private lives is a sickness.</p>
<p>Leaking, doxing, spying on private citizens on Reddit, on private Facebook groups, on X, on Instagram, on TikTok — regardless of the moral quality of the subjects under consideration — hurts everyone. Because it makes everyone subject to this omnipresent, collectivized panopticon, and the more these images circulate, the more normal it becomes.</p>
<p>Group chats, dating apps, emails — or in Byron’s and Cabot’s case, simply being in public with no intention to be filmed — should not be subject to public judgment. This species of story is a distraction from serious issues, and runs cover for the genuinely powerful individuals and entities who materially impact our lives.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Test article</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Matthew Gasda</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Clearly, there is something in human nature that is primed to gossip, shame, and ridicule (thoughtlessly, automatically). But new technology allows us to give vent to these sordid tendencies in historically unprecedented ways. We should take seriously the moral warping effect that such stories, and our obsession with them, have on our souls.</p>
<p>The global village is like any village — scolding, punitive, consumed by hearsay, with nothing better to do. While turning someone into a meme might seem fun, it’s severely undignified, and discards the customs and safeguards of a liberal society in order to participate in a sadistic pile-on. So while the particular example at hand might not seem worth this much deliberation, that is my point.</p>
<p>There might be a story here about the hypocrisy of a CEO and an HR officer having an in-house affair that might get lesser-ranking employees fired. But what I see surfacing in the discursive arena is not intelligent critique of HR departments and their culture, but a glee at the immiseration of a random person.</p>
<p>If these trends continue — if algorithms continue to work the way they do, and I can’t imagine they won&#8217;t — then more and more victims will be dragged out of anonymity for mimetic sacrifice. And as a consequence, meaningful taboos about privacy, shame, and respect have disappeared, and everyone’s lives and behaviors have become fodder for comment and ridicule.</p>
<p>We sorely need new taboos — not against adultery or sexual immorality or interpersonal deception, because clearly we have plenty of those already. Rather, we need taboos against aggregating ourselves into idiotic, loathsome mobs, incapable of thinking about what the subjects of our ridicule and these digital stonings might suffer. A wiser perspective would admit that we all, at the wrong moment, are liars, fools, cheaters, charlatans, hypocrites. Let who has not sinned click the “like” or “repost” button.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“If our natural response to constant mutual surveillance is not disgust, then it should be.”</div>
<p>We all sin, and we might have received grace or mercy under the theocracies of older liberal and Enlightenment arrangements. Algorithmic justice and judgment, however, contains neither the virtues of theocratic society — you could at least avail yourself of religious law, with its exceptions and casuistry — nor of classically liberal society: there is no due process, no appeal mechanism. There’s no mediating structure in the global village. It is instinctive, animalistic, rash, cruel.</p>
<p>The force and direction of this collective online judgment should be turned against itself: We should punish not those caught in the panopticon, but the anonymous posters, Redditors, and the like; all who take joy in random acts of scorn. If we want to live in a tolerant, sane society, we should turn off our cameras, step away from mimetic digital village stonings, and reflect on our own haphazard and imperfect lives and selves.</p>
<p>This “should” will not come from above: there is no sign that tech companies will change their products to disincentivize this kind of behavior. Self-regulation, at scale, is, as of now, the only answer. The way we talk, write, act, and respond matters. Culture matters insofar as culture is a layer of software that at least partially governs how we use our phones. We sorely lack codes of conduct surrounding technology and our ability to record, dox, and harass each other.</p>
<p>If our natural response to constant mutual surveillance is not disgust, then it should be; phones come with cameras, but cameras linked to the global cortex are weapons. Using them to film strangers should not be normalized — telling people to put their phones away should. Piling on viral posts about random people who had no intention of going viral should not be normal, either. If Big Tech won’t take them down, then self-restraint is called for. Institutions can help uphold and reinforce these new norms by prohibiting phone usage in as many public spaces as possible.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/the-flattening-of-the-human-mind/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/the-flattening-of-the-human-mind/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-1393206444.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/the-flattening-of-the-human-mind/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/the-flattening-of-the-human-mind/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The flattening of the human mind</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/the-flattening-of-the-human-mind/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>There are secondary benefits, too: public spaces are also just better without everyone being on their phones; 50,000 people all filming the same concert, for instance, aside from having unintended consequences, is stupid and unaesthetic. Each of us doesn&#8217;t need to take our own badly framed photos of Gustav Klimt’s “The Kiss” when we visit Vienna. There are professional photos and postcards widely available. We could employ the faculty of memory, too.</p>
<p>Codes of conduct are what we might call counter-mimetics; they do have to be injected into social interaction and discourse, artificially at first, before they catch on. That’s what I’m proposing here. We might think something is amusing and worth commenting on or bad and worth scolding, and maybe, in isolation it is. But on the whole, we’re making life intolerable, anxious, and graceless.</p>
<p>It took several centuries for mounted knights to develop the code of conduct known as chivalry to regulate their unparalleled ability to kill or threaten anyone who didn’t have a horse, mail, and sword; let’s hope we can develop codes of conduct around our phones or whatever next-generation AI devices replace phones.</p>
<p>Privacy is a hard-won social good; give it back to others to protect your own.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/the-sadist-assault-on-the-coldplay-couple/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/the-sadist-assault-on-the-coldplay-couple/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/07/the-sadist-assault-on-the-coldplay-couple/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">693821</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Shiloh Hendrix’s racial boomerang</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/shiloh-hendrixs-racial-boomerang/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/shiloh-hendrixs-racial-boomerang/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-07-at-11.41.15.jpg?w=583</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Cancel Culture</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Zaid Jilani]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/imaged.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Shiloh Hendrix. Credit: Twitter]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Zaid Jilani</strong> is a journalist who has worked for UC Berkeley&#8217;s Greater Good Science Center, <em>The Intercept</em>, and the Center for American Progress.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>ZaidJilani</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a journalist who has worked for UC Berkeley's Greater Good Science Center, <em>The Intercept</em>, and the Center for American Progress.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 06 May 2025 23:00:26 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 07 May 2025 10:41:46 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Amy Cooper]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[antiracism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Black Lives Matter]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[christian cooper]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Karens]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Racism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[shiloh hendrix]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[viral video]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=675257</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The ugly, predictable backlash is here]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>In a country full of get-rich-quick schemes, the case of Shiloh Hendrix has got to be the most astounding.</p>
<p>In the past week, <a href="https://www.kttc.com/2025/05/01/rochester-police-actively-looking-into-viral-video-involving-reported-racial-slurs-rochester-park/" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.kttc.com/2025/05/01/rochester-police-actively-looking-into-viral-video-involving-reported-racial-slurs-rochester-park/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1746640552398000&amp;usg=AOvVaw3r3dYRt8lpgzda4zt4cCAe">a viral video</a> emerged of Hendrix’s verbal altercation about an African-American child at a Minnesota playground. Hendrix, holding her own infant, is in an argument with a man recording her — asking her why she referred to the black child using the N-word. She defends using the slur to the man and repeats it, arguing that she’s justified because the black child tried to take her child’s things.</p>
<p>The exact timeline of events is not clear. What’s beyond doubt is that she is enraged — and unapologetic about her use of the epithet. The episode thus marks a turning point in America’s video-and-race wars. Not just Hendrix, but her legions of online supporters have dug into their tribal trenches. It’s a reaction to the excesses of racial progressivism in recent years, though no less discomfiting for what it reveals: the evaporation of American liberal universalism.</p>
<p>We’ve all witnessed at least one iteration of this cycle over the past decade: someone, usually a white person, gets caught being racially offensive. Online outrage erupts, followed by some kind of real-world consequence for the offender: losing a job or even facing personal threats.</p>
<p>Hendrix has flipped the script. “My name is Shiloh, and I have been put into a very dire situation”, she begins her fundraising appeal. “I recently had a kid steal from my 18-month-old son’s diaper bag at a park. I called the kid out for what he was.” She then complains of online abuse and solicits financial support: “Anything will help! We cannot, and will not live in fear!”</p>
<p>The appeal became as viral as the initial video. As of this writing, she has raised more than $683,000. Provided she doesn’t have any extraordinary debt, this makes Hendrix <a href="https://www.investopedia.com/average-american-net-worth-by-income-bracket-11678401" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.investopedia.com/average-american-net-worth-by-income-bracket-11678401&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1746640552398000&amp;usg=AOvVaw31vnMfkmA-RXbHguX_ep0U">many times richer than the median American</a>. Thus we have the first case, maybe in American history, of a woman quickly getting rich as a result of publicly using the N-word.</p>
<p>To Hendrix’s defenders, that’s a blinkered explanation. They aren’t celebrating a racist tirade or trying to turn an ugly moment into a stranger’s good fortune. Rather, they believe they’re turning the tables on years of Left-wing social repression that destroyed people for even minor social transgressions. They have a point.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/GettyImages-885800092.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How cancel culture lost its power</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Geoff Shullenberger </a></p></div></a></div>
<p>During the “racial reckoning”, proportionality was discarded. If someone committed the sin of racism, their life was forfeited. They didn’t deserve a job, friendships, or a moment of peace. They had to be un-personed. This included even those who were merely <em>misperceived</em> as racists, such as the University of Southern California professor <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2020/09/08/professor-suspended-saying-chinese-word-sounds-english-slur">suspended</a> for using a Mandarin filler word which <em>sounds </em>like the N-word (but which has nothing to do with it).</p>
<p>I remember how, in 2020, <em>The</em> <em>New York Times</em> turned a brief verbal altercation in Central Park between a black birdwatcher named Christian Cooper and a white dog walker named Amy Cooper (no relation) into a national referendum about racial tensions in the United States.</p>
<p>Christian wanted Amy to make sure her dog was leashed — unleashed canines being a pet peeve of his. Amy refused to do so, and this resulted in a war of words between the two. Eventually, Christian tried to get Amy’s dog to come to him with some treats, resulting in Amy calling the police on him. Speaking to the emergency dispatcher, a clearly distressed Amy made sure to mention that Christian is black.</p>
<p>All of this was recorded by Christian, who uploaded the video and made it go viral. The nation’s news networks and newspapers all jumped on it, tsk-tsking that this was what America had come to: Central Park Karen calling down a police assassination on an African-American man who had inconvenienced her.</p>
<p>Amy ended up going into hiding after losing her job and receiving a mountain of online hate. As far as I can tell, <a href="https://www.newsweek.com/i-was-branded-central-park-karen-i-still-live-hiding-1839483" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.newsweek.com/i-was-branded-central-park-karen-i-still-live-hiding-1839483&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1746640552398000&amp;usg=AOvVaw2ivNpA-31p6P4xU6covaVm">she still lives in hiding today</a>. Christian, by contrast, became a national celebrity. A couple of years ago, he even <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/671722/better-living-through-birding-by-christian-cooper/" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/671722/better-living-through-birding-by-christian-cooper/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1746640552398000&amp;usg=AOvVaw1UCpEAgeoU7pcmYy7rTH_w">wrote a bestselling memoir</a>, published by Random House. For much of the progressive Left, this was a perfectly reasonable set of outcomes. A “racist” white lady was shunned into oblivion; her “victim” was rewarded by a karmic load of riches and fame.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“When you have such a simple story guiding your morality — you can expect a simple response. Maybe a brutally simple one.”</div>
<p>But over time, the nuances of the story became more apparent (<a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-real-story-of-the-central-park-karen/id1570872415?i=1000530855326" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-real-story-of-the-central-park-karen/id1570872415?i%3D1000530855326&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1746640552398000&amp;usg=AOvVaw2aILxieRhnuMEyMZtMHFd9">not least thanks to a podcast feature produced by the African-American journal Kmele Foster</a>). Amy had suffered sexual assault in the past and was clearly triggered by the interaction with Christian, who, it turns out, had a bit of a reputation for accosting people. Was Amy right to cite Christian’s race in the phone call with the police? Maybe not.</p>
<p>But it was also the kind of thing she thought she could say in that moment that would get him to back off. Remember, in 2020, much of liberal America believed that police were systematically murdering black men. If two liberal New Yorkers ran into each other in Central Park, chances were that they shared some variation of that belief. If her assault trauma was triggered, then, she would say <em>anything</em> to get away from the man drawing her dog away from her.</p>
<p>Yet the era of Left-wing racialism didn’t allow for these nuances. It told a simple story of racist white people persecuting minorities. And when you have such a simple story guiding your morality — you can expect a simple response. Maybe a brutally simple one.</p>
<p>All of this cut strongly against how I thought about these issues growing up in a diverse corner of Georgia in the Nineties. My social circle was white and black, Indian and Latino, and it was common to see arguments over race and culture spill over from private to public. People got into heated disputes, then made up the following day; sometimes, they just agreed to disagree. We were making our own way towards a more tolerant world without having every moment judged in a digital Thunderdome.</p>
<p>The viral video ended all that. And what is happening with Hendrix is a sort of middle finger to what came before. It’s a dialectical boomerang, slamming back to the hand that cast it — or the face that forgot it.</p>
<p>Hendrix is telling the world that she won’t be broken. In that sense, you can understand why so many conservatives and white people have been rushing to her side. I agree with her defenders that she shouldn’t be subjected to social death. People screw up, and calling a child a racial slur is a big screw-up, even if he did take something that wasn’t his. But people should also be mature and figure out ways to work through screw-ups without inciting a mob to bludgeon the offender into social oblivion.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/how-the-identity-cult-captured-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/how-the-identity-cult-captured-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/GettyImages-1246602827-1-scaled-2.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/how-the-identity-cult-captured-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/how-the-identity-cult-captured-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How the identity cult captured America</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/how-the-identity-cult-captured-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Martin Gurri</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>That said, Hendrix’s boosters have also learned the wrong lesson from the years of progressive racialism. Many of her backers have <a href="https://x.com/wayotworld/status/1918683723958026318" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://x.com/wayotworld/status/1918683723958026318&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1746640552398000&amp;usg=AOvVaw0X8ZlTMoVJLtiCNZ2grO3M">compared her case to that of Karmelo Anthony</a>, a black teen who allegedly stabbed a white teen to death in Texas. Anthony’s family has <a href="https://www.givesendgo.com/HelpKarmelo" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.givesendgo.com/HelpKarmelo&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1746640552398000&amp;usg=AOvVaw3f6CwKitnpMwnyYKw-O7-K">raised more than half a million dollars</a> not just for legal fees, but to support themselves. If Anthony’s family can raise money, why can’t Hendrix’s?</p>
<p>The problem is that both Hendrix and Anthony have been turned into avatars of racial grievance. We have to support “our side” — meaning, white people or black people — even if they happened to be in the wrong in the given case. The co-founder of GiveSendGo, which hosts both fundraisers, <a href="https://x.com/jacobawells/status/1918506236347031698" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://x.com/jacobawells/status/1918506236347031698&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1746640552398000&amp;usg=AOvVaw3in_Fvc6h11ZT7_cnAhhN8">had to disable comments on both of them</a> owing to the deluge of racist remarks.</p>
<p>While these currents in American society are marginal for now, we shouldn’t underestimate the anti-American ideology pulsing through them. Contrary to the narratives told by the critical-theory Left and the race-fixated weird Right, America isn’t a country founded for the purpose of defending one race, religion, or creed. It’s not a country based on blood or soil.</p>
<p>Encouraging people to bestow loyalty based on skin or ancestry never ends well in this country, or any other. Both Shiloh Hendrix and Karmelo Anthony are Americans first and foremost, and they should be judged based on their adherence to the law and norms that we all have to abide by.</p>
<p>We should demand the best behavior from anyone, black or white. We should extend grace and mercy, regardless of race, when people fail to meet the standard. What we <em>shouldn’t</em> do is start celebrating and rewarding bad behavior out of some sense of racial revenge. That way lies national perdition.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/shiloh-hendrixs-racial-boomerang/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/shiloh-hendrixs-racial-boomerang/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/shiloh-hendrixs-racial-boomerang/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">675257</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Will Kneecap sell out?</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/will-kneecap-sell-out/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/will-kneecap-sell-out/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-1813802644-e1746122590455.jpg?w=664</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Music</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Darren McGarvey]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/loki.gif?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Will Kneecap sell out? Sacha Lecca/Rolling Stone/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Darren McGarvey</strong> is a Scottish hip hop artist and social commentator. In 2018, his book <i>Poverty Safari</i> won the Orwell Prize and his new book <a href="https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/111/1117584/the-social-distance-between-us/9781529104080.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Social Distance Between Us</em> </a>(Ebury Press) is out on 16th June.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>lokiscottishrap</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a Scottish hip hop artist and social commentator. In 2018, his book <i>Poverty Safari</i> won the Orwell Prize and his new book <a href="https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/111/1117584/the-social-distance-between-us/9781529104080.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Social Distance Between Us</em> </a>(Ebury Press) is out on 16th June.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 01 May 2025 23:02:34 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 02 May 2025 08:13:25 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Israel-Hamas]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Kneecap]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Rap]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=673920</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[True rebels never become stars]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>One week, Kneecap were booked for Glastonbury. The next, they’re being <a href="https://www.thetimes.com/culture/music/article/counterterror-police-to-investigate-kneecaps-hamas-chants-zrgd97fkw" target="_blank" rel="noopener">investigated</a> by counterterrorism police. Given the West Belfast trio’s outspoken views on the Middle East, an issue that only continues to inflame public passions, it’s perhaps most surprising that a reckoning took so long to arrive.</p>
<p>Yet if the demands for accountability are only growing shriller, Kneecap’s story is nothing new. Once an artist moves from cult status into the mainstream, all while continuing to challenge accepted narratives, a reaction is sure to follow. Amid the apologies and the caveats, then, Kneecap now faces the same question as any radical artist on the precipice of stardom. Do you soften your edges for access, or hold your ground, and risk the establishment&#8217;s wrath?</p>
<p>In many ways, Kneecap’s difficulties feel specific to our cultural moment. The band has been accused of glorifying violence, of supporting Hamas and Hezbollah. These are charges they’ve denied. Either way, it comes as no surprise to me that this pro-Palestine, anti-government trio are in a bind. As a professional working in various capacities as a writer and performer, I can tell you right now that using your platform to either criticize Israel, or express solidarity with innocent Palestinians, comes with risks.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/kneecap-are-the-future-of-northern-ireland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/kneecap-are-the-future-of-northern-ireland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/GettyImages-2160263387-e1725381029478.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/kneecap-are-the-future-of-northern-ireland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/kneecap-are-the-future-of-northern-ireland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Kneecap are the future of Northern Ireland</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/kneecap-are-the-future-of-northern-ireland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Darran Anderson</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>I’ve been reported to the police for taking part in fundraisers for medics in the Gaza Strip. I’ve been accosted by a chief executive, and delegates at a conference, for using a keynote speech to urge a politically neutral organization to join calls for a ceasefire. Scheduled appearances were mysteriously canceled, and organizers have had to bulk up security in case protesters turn up.</p>
<p>The tensions Kneecap speak to arise not just from the strength of feeling around the war between Israel and Hamas, but the strong sense many of us have that our political class collaborates with major media players to stifle debate. It creates a culture whereby any criticism to the prevailing narrative — that anything Israel does is morally justified — becomes futile and where raising your voice against the systematic brutalization of innocent civilians in the Gaza Strip starts to feel dangerous.</p>
<p>In this context, then, Kneecap become a case study in how thought and speech are regimented — and, in the generalities anyway, it’s nothing new. Transgressive artists have long been made examples of and punished for their politics. Sinead O’Connor’s career was derailed after she tore up a photo of the Pope on <em>Saturday Night Live</em>, in protest of the Catholic Church’s abuse cover-ups. She was right, but she was ruined. The Dixie Chicks were boycotted, threatened and driven off country radio after criticizing the Iraq War. NWA had the FBI on their backs.</p>
<p>And so the list goes on. In every case, craven politicians join a growing media chorus of condemnation, rendering the acts in question too toxic to book. It’s the same story with Kneecap, with the very journalists who defend edgy comedians like Jimmy Carr and Ricky Gervais — and their right to say incredibly offensive things we all know are part of an act — now expecting us to believe Kneecap are some kind of quasi-paramilitary group.</p>
<p>Beyond the media outrage, meanwhile, Kneecap’s predicament ironically speaks to the band’s success and their clear desire to cross into the mainstream. That’s why we’ve seen statements issued and apologies offered — public relations maneuvers aimed at minimizing the commercial impact of negative coverage. Though the group certainly wish to retain their radical credentials, it’s also clear they’ve been pushed into a far more defensive position than they’re comfortable with, or indeed than their fans are used to.</p>
<p>For example, while the band has emphasized that it stands in solidarity with Palestinian civilians, and oppose Israel’s bombardment and occupation, they do not support militant Islamist organizations. Yet, such distinctions rarely matter once the wheels of the media outrage machine begin turning. The point is not to understand or debate Kneecap’s actual views, but to frame them as toxic enough that venues, festivals and collaborators all feel pressured to abandon them.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/labours-ruthless-raid-on-the-sick/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/labours-ruthless-raid-on-the-sick/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/GettyImages-2058358205.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/labours-ruthless-raid-on-the-sick/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/labours-ruthless-raid-on-the-sick/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Labour&#039;s ruthless raid on the sick</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/labours-ruthless-raid-on-the-sick/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Darren McGarvey</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>And though I loathe the confected outrage of many a blowhard on this issue, the wicked dilemma Kneecap now faces is arguably one of their own making. They’ve sold themselves as countercultural and gained a loyal global following as a result. This boxes them into a specific set of responses — none of them free of risk. By being seen to back down, even slightly, in the face of a concerted political and media effort to paint them as terrorist sympathizers, they risk alienating their core support, thus weakening the very leverage they have in the music industry. Alternatively, doubling down will effectively mean being blacklisted from major festivals and media outlets for the foreseeable future, even if they do at least retain their integrity and links to the fanbase.</p>
<p>Despite the calm collectedness the band and their manager are keen to paint, then, there’ll now be panic behind the scenes. And no wonder: life-changing opportunities are now on the line. Of course, for the group’s hardcore fanbase, the answer is simple: fight the power. But it’s never quite as simple as “stand your ground” versus “sell out”.</p>
<p>As creatives, we hope to have our cakes and eat them too. We want the visibility, the critical acclaim, and the big performance fees. But we also want to be seen as unwavering in our principles, and unscrupulous in pursuit of artistic integrity. Once a radical act begins to gain traction beyond pub open-mics — when a wider audience starts paying attention — everything changes. The decisions get heavier. The risks get real. And that visibility, often romanticized from the outside, can be extremely stressful. A lot of radical artists don’t plan for this moment. It comes as a shock. They’re propelled into a space they never expected to inhabit, and they arrive carrying principles that don’t always map neatly onto the pressures and expectations that follow.</p>
<p>Suddenly, the stakes aren’t just ideological. As Kneecap is doubtless now discovering, livelihoods are involved: your own, your partner’s, your kids’. You’ve got a label to deal with. You’ve got tour managers, stage crew, new fans, and media people around you, many of whom have very different values and priorities. The freedom to just steamroll your way through, to say “to hell with it all”— that becomes much harder to exercise when other people depend on your success to pay their bills. And despite their rebellious aesthetics, bands like Kneecap are professionals with aspirations of their own, not least a desire to be financially secure.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;We want the visibility, the critical acclaim, and the big performance fees. But we also want to be seen as unwavering in our principles.&#8221;</div>
<p>And, especially for a group from West Belfast, when someone from your community finally breaks through, there’s often a silent burden to carry: represent us, but don’t get it wrong or you’ll have hell to pay. Kneecap didn’t ask to be role models or political lightning rods. They came up from a place where art, humor, trauma, and resistance blur together. West Belfast isn’t a backdrop: it’s the very soil they grew out of. Their use of the Irish language isn’t decorative, it’s an act of cultural reclamation, an assertion of identity in a postcolonial context that still cuts deep. Their solidarity with Palestine comes from that same instinct: to back those being brutalized by a far more powerful force.</p>
<p>Ultimately, then, Kneecap will have to decide what matters more: global recognition in a fickle, spineless industry, or holding true to their principles. If you want to be mainstream, you have to make sacrifices, and few acts can have it both ways. Even Eminem went pop eventually. Unrelenting scrutiny comes with any public platform. Kneecap exercises their freedom of speech to say what they believe, but there are always consequences to raising your head above the parapet. Other people will exercise theirs to condemn, marginalize and punish. That’s the way free speech works.</p>
<p>Artists won’t always get it right, and when they do fuck up, it’s appropriate that they should acknowledge their mistakes. Integrity comes not just from staying true to our beliefs, but also from admitting when we’ve crossed a line. We’ve all said and done stupid and offensive things. In the end, though, that’s not the issue. The issue is that, as a result of expressing views about Israel regarded as controversial — but which are in fact entirely mainstream — Kneecap now has every editor in the country instructing hacks to trawl through every lyric, every interview and every act of public flatulence, looking for proof these guys are something they aren’t.</p>
<p>Who knows what Kneecap will do next. I don’t envy their plight. But I do know this: the system rewards outrage only when it can be commodified. It tolerates rebellion as long as it’s aesthetic. The moment your politics cut too close to the bone, you’ll find out just how tolerant the liberal cultural sphere really is, and who your friends really are.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/will-kneecap-sell-out/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/will-kneecap-sell-out/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/will-kneecap-sell-out/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">673920</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Amanda Knox creeps me out</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Knox.jpg?w=529</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>American Original</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Valerie Stivers]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Blue-76.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[If you think she did it, "Free" is a very provocative title for her new memoir. Credit: Getty]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>Valerie Stivers is a senior editor of <em>UnHerd</em> US.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>valerie_reads</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[Valerie Stivers is a senior editor of <em>UnHerd</em> US.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 30 Mar 2025 23:00:57 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 31 Mar 2025 12:53:55 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[amanda knox]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Crime]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Feminism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Italy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Memoir]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Murder]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Prison]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Tabloids]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=666011</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[I could see why she raised suspicion]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Amanda Knox starts off her new memoir, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Free: My Search for Meaning</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">, with a barbed anecdote: her mother told her once when she was a child that she would have “an extraordinary life”. And she has, though not in the way that any mother would wish for. As most people at least semi-remember, Knox is the American exchange student in Perugia, Italy, who, along with her Italian boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito, was convicted of the brutal 2007 murder of her roommate, Meredith Kercher; a second man, a migrant from Côte d’Ivoire named Rudy Guede, was also convicted in a separate trial. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The bizarre details of the crime — Kercher was raped, stabbed multiple times, then covered tenderly with a duvet — and the Italian prosecution’s proposal, on no physical evidence, of a Satanic sex ritual orchestrated by Knox, created an international media firestorm that has flared up again with each new legal development. Knox was freed on appeal in 2011 and has been exonerated by Italy’s highest court. But the legal wrangling continues (she has sued to have additional minor convictions overturned), and she remains an object of bizarrely intense public fascination. Her new memoir (she also wrote one shortly after her release) is well-written, persuasive, and genuinely insightful. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">It’s also occasionally tone-deaf in a way that seems to expose the reasons the story gripped us so in the first place.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Knox, who was 20 in 2007, has steadfastly maintained her innocence ever since her brief, obscure time in Italian police custody directly after the murder, when she made a series of damaging and incoherent statements that were used against her as a confession. She has always maintained the plausible and evidence-supported theory that Rudy Guede acted alone, and that the Italian police took advantage of her youth and naivety to juice up a salacious case. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Today, she is 37, married, and a mother of two, and lives once again in her hometown of Seattle. She has become a writer, hosts a successful podcast with her husband, the author Christopher Robinson, and is an activist for criminal-justice reform and media ethics. If she was once dangerously naive about her predicament, she is no longer. She explains that her first book, written shortly after her release, was “the story of what Rudy Guede had done to Meredith, and of what the Italian justice system had done to me. It was the story of what happened to me, and it left little room for anything I actually did.” </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Free</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> is a corrective whose dual mission is to tell her personal story and to defend her right to tell it.  </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/why-the-world-fell-for-romantasy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/why-the-world-fell-for-romantasy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/cutting-shapes.webp?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/why-the-world-fell-for-romantasy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/why-the-world-fell-for-romantasy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How the world fell for ‘romantasy’</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/why-the-world-fell-for-romantasy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Valerie Stivers</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">White, female, American college students from solidly middle-class families </span>haven’t <span style="font-weight: 400">contributed much to prison literature to date. But the combination of Knox’s intelligence and unique situation is a genuine addition to the genre. As she tells it, she arrived in prison so innocent that “it took me a while to realize that the room I was kept in was in fact a cell, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">my cell…</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">” As the days and months passed and the gears of justice turned (very slowly, provincial-Italian-style), she had the experiences we would expect: she was scared, alone, isolated, and mistreated by the guards and other inmates (who disliked her as the privileged and famous one). </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">But she also had experiences we don’t expect: when she was allowed out to exercise in a small courtyard, she jogged, did jumping jacks, skipped, and </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">sang</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> at the top of her lungs, anything to feel free. When she was scared and lonely, she would call up a vision of herself as the happy, innocent, tough little girl she once was, and then she would talk to her younger self about their current troubles. Her raw youth pours off the page.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">She was aware, even at the time, that much “invisible luxury” set her apart from her fellow prisoners. She had family to support her and visitors at every visiting hour. She didn’t suffer from the combination of trauma, mental health, and addiction that is common among female prisoners. Nonetheless, she <em>was</em> a prisoner, and accepting the situation as it was, especially after her conviction and sentencing to 26 years, helped her survive. The story of a young girl’s slow, painful grasp of the human essentials is powerful: we always have agency; there are things we possess that can’t be taken away; we must accept the life we actually have, and not pine for the one we wish for. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/what-prisons-teach-us-about-democracy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/what-prisons-teach-us-about-democracy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/GettyImages-53460365.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/what-prisons-teach-us-about-democracy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/what-prisons-teach-us-about-democracy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>What prisons teach us about democracy</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/what-prisons-teach-us-about-democracy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Ian Birrell</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">After four years of incarceration, Knox was freed on appeal and returned to America, only to discover herself in a different kind of prison. She was traumatized from her ordeal, had panic attacks, and found it difficult to reconnect with family and friends. She was — and is — notorious, a public figure and media sensation, a frequent target of hatred and death threats. For defending her innocence, asserting the value of her own story, or even just being OK, she is perceived as denying the awfulness of what happened to Meredith Kercher. The tabloids, especially in England and Italy, continue to distort her every action into something sinister. “Amanda Knox Wears Bizarre Yellow Outfit as She Marries Poet Boyfriend”, ran a <em>Daily Mail</em> headline from 2020. Once again, she faces the challenge of accepting the life she has, trying to make sense of her experience and to make something good out of something terrible. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The middle section of the book explores the social and cultural factors at play in her case, skillfully woven into the events of her life post-release. She was, she theorizes, the first cancellation of the social-media era and the first person to be subject to the kind of prolonged public shaming that has now become commonplace. She was also a victim of prurience, and the virgin-slut narrative, and the time-honored tradition of pitting women against each other. Cultural factors came into play: the Italian investigators couldn’t comprehend her behavior in the days following the murder, and created a narrative of her guilt as a result. The case became not about the facts, but about her character. </span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“She was, she theorizes, the first cancellation of the social-media era.&#8221;</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">I was moved by the book, and went to see Knox in discussion with British journalist Jon Ronson at the Powerhouse Arena in Brooklyn on Wednesday night without lingering doubts about her innocence. I understood why the people who still believe she is guilty, not least the Kercher family’s lawyer, find her ongoing notoriety to be ghoulish. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">If you think she did it, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Free</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> is </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">very</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> provocative name for a book. And that “extraordinary” from the opening anecdote has a third valence: Knox has had a more extraordinary life than most people because she has benefited, and not just spiritually, from her hardship. She writes books about it; she befriends other famous people (Monica Lewinsky became a pal); she just executive-produced <em>Blue Moon</em>, a Hulu series about the ordeal set in Perugia, expected to debut this year. But I’d been convinced that these perceptions were not her fault, and that she had no moral obligation to cater to them. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">And yet a strange thing happened: the longer she talked, the more it seemed possible that this small, cute, physically unimposing, nerdy-chic Seattle mom in platform boots </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">could have done it</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">. To be clear, I don’t believe she really did it. More important, there has never been any evidence that she did. But there is <em>something</em> about </span><span style="font-weight: 400">her</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> affect and demeanor that gives off the eerie vibe that if any totally unlikely young woman could secretly be a crazed killer, it’s this one. The more she laughed and said how absurd it was, the more I could see why the police were suspicious. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">She mentioned some photographs in a particular situation made her look like &#8220;a flippant psycho&#8221;, cackling at the ridiculousness to a crowd of fans, but </span><span style="font-weight: 400">t</span><span style="font-weight: 400">hat was exactly what she looked like in that moment. She argued that such perceptions are the awful legacy of suspicion, media-distortion, and our dirty minds. Perhaps greater self-knowledge would come in realizing that it is a mysterious quality of </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">hers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">, unfortunate to be sure, that was visible to Italian investigators, and has been visible in photography since the early days of the case. I suspect it’s the real cause of our unstoppable slippery fascination with her.  </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/how-safe-is-the-letby-verdict/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/how-safe-is-the-letby-verdict/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Screenshot-2025-03-10-at-11.15.44.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/how-safe-is-the-letby-verdict/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/how-safe-is-the-letby-verdict/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How safe is the Letby verdict?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/how-safe-is-the-letby-verdict/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> David Rose and Cleuci de Oliveira </a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">And there are reasons for it. Knox doesn’t quite know how to treat other people. Her co-defendant Raffaele Sollecito, for example, has only a minor role in </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Free, </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">mainly as a person whose life was, unlike hers, permanently derailed by the wrongful accusations. He’s still single, Knox writes. He’s a pariah in Italy, and he’s never been able to get steady work. Someone brought him up at the event, and she retold an anecdote from the book about how sad he was during their meeting in Italy in 2022, when a passer-by mistook her baby for his. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">I thought Sollecito would have been unlikely to feel good about himself if he were sitting in the audience. Knox’s right to tell her story suddenly seemed more complicated than it had in the memoir. If you’ve come through an awful catastrophe, with multiple victims including yourself, and your ultimate success highlights your fellow survivor’s failure, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">do</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> you really have every right in the world to promote it far and wide? There are some situations — many, actually — where we can’t say whatever we want, and this in order to protect the feelings of other people. Or we can, but we’ve chosen ourselves over them, and it’s going to look bad.  </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">There’s also Giuliano Mignini, the prosecutor of Knox’s case, with whom she strikes up an unlikely relationship in the book’s third section. The narrative slows down a bit here, as Knox enters into an endless wrangle with what she wants from the man — which somewhat contradicts her claim to have found peace. Mignini is willing to engage with her and offer her his friendship, but he won’t say he was wrong about her case. Her final epiphany comes from accepting that there is greater value in just forgiving him. It’s true, and it sounds good (and makes her sound good), but she also mocks him in the book and did so again during the event for being more invested in the relationship than she is. At the event, she tacitly agreed with Ronson, her interviewer, that Mignini is a narcissist. Again, I wondered how he would have felt if he were sitting there, and again I doubted Knox for promoting her own virtue at someone else’s expense.  </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">One of the many themes of the case has been Knox’s ordinariness. She fascinates us, supposedly, because what happened to her could happen to anyone. But </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">Free</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> proves in many ways — both its insight and intelligence, and also its odd failures and lack of self-awareness — that she’s never been ordinary.  </span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/amanda-knox-creeps-us-out/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">666011</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The return of Gamergate</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-return-of-gamergate/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-return-of-gamergate/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/GettyImages-1469467115.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>vibe shift</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Ryan Zickgraf]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/1_245945.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['There are no clear conditions for victory in the culture wars.' Leon Neal / Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>Ryan Zickgraf is a columnist for <em>UnHerd</em>, based in Pennsylvania.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>ryan_zickgraf</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[Ryan Zickgraf is a columnist for <em>UnHerd</em>, based in Pennsylvania.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Wed, 05 Mar 2025 23:00:42 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 06 Mar 2025 12:21:00 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Gamergate]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Games industry]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Video games]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=658959</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Culture warriors are killing their own]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>There’s a memorable line from <em>The Dark Knight</em> that sums up the curious trajectory of Czech video game developer Daniel Vávra: “You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.”</p>
<p>Gamergate, an idiosyncratic consumer revolt of angry gamers against the video game industry and journalists that erupted in 2014, initially made Vávra and his Prague-based Warhorse Games folk heroes for not embracing DEI in their development of a game called <em>Kingdom Come: Deliverance</em>. But in the wake of Trump and Elon Musk’s political triumph, Vávra has been branded insufficiently anti-woke. Gamergate keeps waging new battles against every phantom of woke cultural depiction, no matter how minor, illustrating the sisyphean nature of the online culture wars — it’s a virtual game no one can ever truly win.</p>
<p>Vávra is not your typical blue-haired social justice warrior. The barrel-chested, bearded Czech looks like a character in his own medieval European action game and once <a href="https://www.eurogamer.net/jailed-arma-3-devs-send-letter-from-prison-as-czech-protests-escalate" target="_blank" rel="noopener">led a street protest</a> outside the Greek embassy in Prague to protest colleagues’ arrest. Yet, a decade ago, he became a pariah among many of the press and his peers. They hated that Vávra was sympathetic to Gamergate. In 2015, progressive activists accused Warhorse Games of racism for not including people of color from a game set in rural 15th-century Bohemia, which Vávra defended as part of a commitment to historical accuracy. The controversy prompted him to speak out against the wokeification of the games industry. “The future of our biz is at stake, and ‘progressive’ media are destroying it with their hateful narrative,” he said.</p>
<p>The keyboard jockeys of Gamergate applauded Vávra’s stance but the fallout of the controversy was ugly: Warhorse got hate mail from progressives, and news outlets such as <em>Vice</em> <a href="https://www.vice.com/en/article/kingdom-come-deliverance-waypoint-radio/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">refused</a> to cover Kingdom Come. Vávra likened the backlash to living in the USSR. “I had the ‘privilege’ of growing up in a totalitarian communist regime,” he told a games journalist in 2015, “so I have first-hand experience with censorship and… going to prison for your opinion or shitty propaganda on TV, in literature and even music.”</p>
<p>Explaining how reception to a video game gets compared to life in the last days of Soviet communism isn’t easy. What sparked it all was a laughably low-stakes morass involving the ex-boyfriend of a game developer who posted an angry rant about their relationship online. Each side of Gamergate insisted they had the moral high ground, with one claiming they were defending “ethics in videogame journalism” and the other side saying they were righteously fighting “misogynists lashing out at women in gaming”. More broadly, Gamergate was a kind of clash of online civilizations. In her 2017 book <em>Kill All Normies</em>, Angela Nagle described the dynamic as “hysterical liberal call-out culture produced a breeding ground for an online backlash of irreverent mockery and anti-PC”.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Explaining how reception to a video game gets compared to life in the last days of Soviet communism isn’t easy.&#8221;</div>
<p>In other words, they were two sides of the same coin: shrieking online bubbles — one self-righteous and woke and the other conservative and/or trollish that worked out of the same terrible playbook: bad faith character assassination, public shaming, or getting someone fired. I say that from <a href="https://medium.com/@ryansmithwriter/a-weird-insider-culture-d1c3cc644c29">personal experience</a>; keyboard warriors and even some of my colleagues tried to get me fired from my role writing about video games for <em>The Onion</em> because I was inaccurately perceived as a Gamergate foot soldier.</p>
<p>Gamergate might sound arcane now, but it was the perfect moral panic for the peak Twitter era, a funhouse mirror version of the scapegoating of video games of the Eighties and Nineties. Blaming games for society’s ills used to be a bipartisan effort: Hillary Clinton, Donald Trump, and Joe Biden have all tried to restrict them (Biden even once called game developers <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/joe-biden-on-video-games-2020-1" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“little creeps”</a> who make games that teach people how to kill). But instead of being blamed for inspiring school shooters, Gamergate became a useful liberal talking point among Democrats. They cited video games&#8217; power to allegedly groom young white males and turn them into bitter incels and extreme Right-wingers.</p>
<p>For most of Gamergate’s lifespan, the movement looked like a lost cause. It became a reliable punching bag for the mainstream media, part of the founding myth of the alt-Right, which begat Q-Anon, which begat Trump’s presidency; indeed, Trump has even been called the <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/act-four/wp/2015/12/07/donald-trump-is-the-gamergate-of-republican-politics/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“Gamergate” of Republican</a> politicians. For instance, <em>Vox</em> <a href="https://www.vox.com/culture/2020/1/20/20808875/gamergate-lessons-cultural-impact-changes-harassment-laws" target="_blank" rel="noopener">argued </a>that Gamergate was “a watershed moment and learning experience for many future Trump supporters”. For his part, Steve Bannon admits that he viewed Gamergate as an opportunity for recruiting what he labelled “rootless white males” into a standing Right-wing army online. &#8220;You can activate that army,” he told Joshua Green, the author of <em>Devil’s Bargain</em>. “They come in through Gamergate or whatever and then get turned onto politics and Trump.</p>
<p>Yet Gamergate had the opposite effect as intended: games got more identitarian — not less — since 2014. As Gamergate’s online forces fumed, new games increasingly incorporated more racially diverse characters and LGBTQ storylines. In <em>Dragon Age: Veilguard</em>, you can get a call-out for misgendering a non-binary character — an eye-roll-inducing HR lecture in a fantasy game about dragons.</p>
<p>But perhaps not for long. As others have noted, there’s been a noticeable vibe shift against progressive political correctness. Game journalists and activists failed miserably in their attempt at a reverse Gamergate — <a href="https://www.compactmag.com/article/game-not-over-for-gamergate/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a boycott</a> of <em>Hogwarts Legacy</em> due to J.K. Rowling’s “transphobia”. Now, the media says that <a href="https://www.newsweek.com/jk-rowling-transgender-women-harry-potter-tv-show-hbo-warner-bros-1991239" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Rowling</a> may have just won the culture war.</p>
<p>Complaints about Assassin&#8217;s Creed: Shadows’ usage of a black samurai hero in a game about historical Japan led to the game being delayed three months until early 2025 to “better incorporate player feedback”. Wired is calling the controversy <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/assassins-creed-shadows-dei-gamergate/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">&#8220;Gamergate 2.0</a><a href="https://www.wired.com/story/assassins-creed-shadows-dei-gamergate/">&#8220;</a>, but what they don&#8217;t mention is that Japanese gamers have been the most vocal and got over 100,000 signatures for a petition to cancel the game, saying it’s “a serious insult to Japanese culture and history, and may also be linked to Asian racism”. In this case, the politics of &#8220;cultural appropriation&#8221; butted up against the &#8220;underrepresentation” of black characters and won.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/americas-post-apocalyptic-cities/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/americas-post-apocalyptic-cities/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/GettyImages-1280430435.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/americas-post-apocalyptic-cities/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/americas-post-apocalyptic-cities/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>America&#039;s post-apocalyptic cities</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/americas-post-apocalyptic-cities/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Ryan Zickgraf</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Then came Trump’s re-election in November, which signalled the ultimate triumph of the <a href="https://www.newstatesman.com/international-politics/2024/12/dawn-anti-woke-era" target="_blank" rel="noopener">anti-woke </a>regime, with outspoken <a href="https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1768131451680129254?lang=en" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Gamergater Elon Musk</a> suddenly wielding incredible power. Some game developers have even started to pitch themselves as <a href="https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/video-game-publishers-are-starting-to-use-anti-dei-as-a-marketing-meme" target="_blank" rel="noopener">anti-DEI</a>, while liberals&#8217; attempts to invoke Gamergate as a rallying cry are falling on deaf ears. Lin Manuel Miranda recently released a DEI-inspired concept album based on of <em>The Warriors</em>, the 1979 cult movie about New York gangs, but this time with all-female protagonists and an incel villain that Miranda says was <a href="https://www.billboard.com/music/music-news/lin-manuel-miranda-warriors-album-eisa-davis-interview-1235803494/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">inspired by Gamergate</a>. If you haven’t heard of the album, it’s probably because it’s hopelessly corny, an embarrassing relic from the Obama years that <a href="https://www.officialcharts.com/albums/lin-manuel-mirandaeisa-davis-warriors/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">deservedly died </a>on the Billboard charts.</p>
<p>Likewise, <em>Dragon Age: Veilguard</em> earned half the expected sales, and <em>Concord</em>, a target of Gamergate for its gender-fluid characters and awkward pronouns, got shut down by Sony after only two weeks due to a historically dismal performance.</p>
<p>No wonder there’s been a distinct tone of triumph amongst the extremely online denizens of “Kotaku In Action” — a subreddit that’s been the unofficial home to Gamergate for a decade. Some of the group’s 157,000 members have gone as far as to declare a victory in their decade-long battle against “Social Justice Warriors”. “Ten fucking years after the thing, we were proven to be right even though anyone not dishonest or mentally disabled knew we were right,” one poster proclaimed recently in a thread titled <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/KotakuInAction/comments/1iitgrm/gamergate_won/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Gamergate Won</a>. “Now that we&#8217;ve won, can games start being good again?”</p>
<p>However, there are no clear conditions for victory in the culture wars and little interest in calling for a truce. So, the crusade keeps expanding to absurd lengths until it begins to resemble the thing that progressives accused it of being — a Right-wing reactionary political force. “Gamergate went from [being] about games journalism to a wider culture war to what it is now — a last attempt to stop globalists from taking full authoritarian control of the West,” went a recent Gamergate Reddit post.</p>
<p>What does it mean to Reddit post your way to a populist Right-wing crusade against “globalists?” Not much, so it’s much easier to keep targeting video games for wokeness, no matter how petty the offense. Just ask Warhorse Games.</p>
<p>Vávra is being canceled once again, but this time, ironically, it’s by Gamergate. The just-released sequel to <em>Kingdom Come</em> includes an optional same-sex romance option and an added element of racial diversity because the game is set in the Czech city of Kuttenberg, which, like other cities in the Holy Roman Empire, was a hub of trade and cultural exchange. Vávra and Warhorse insisted that they were going once again for historical accuracy, such as the inclusion of a <a href="https://archaeology-travel.com/germany/medieval-jewish-heritage-in-germany/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Jewish quarter</a>. Still, Gamergaters accused them of “going woke” and began boycotting the game and spamming Metacritic with bad <a href="https://x.com/DanielVavra/status/1887264653199171753" target="_blank" rel="noopener">reviews like</a>: “<em>Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2</em> is a gay woke historically inaccurate DEI game.”</p>
<p>Now, Vávra is speaking out against his former comrades-in-arms: “[It] turns out that we are once again in the middle of a rather bizarre culture war, this time from the opposite side than usual.”. His colleague, Tobias Stolz-Zwilling, stated that Warhorse would rather not be connected to any political battle. &#8220;It seems like someone is always trying to brand us somehow, and we are just trying to make a cool video game,&#8221; he said.</p>
<p>Either way, Vávra may have the last laugh. <em>Kingdom Come: Deliverance II</em> has been a critical darling and sold over 2 million copies in its first two weeks. The growing sentiment in “Kotaku In Action” is that the Gamergate boycott of the game may have been an overreach. As one commentator noted, “It&#8217;s lame when anyone of any political or cultural stripe engages in a witch hunt or a purity test, especially when it isn&#8217;t even sincere.”</p>
<p>Who just wants to play some video games instead?</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-return-of-gamergate/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-return-of-gamergate/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-return-of-gamergate/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">658959</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Morrissey is the villain we need</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/morrissey-is-the-villain-we-need/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/morrissey-is-the-villain-we-need/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/GettyImages-566849073.jpg?w=508</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Weekend culture</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Lias Saoudi]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/blueddd-300x300-1.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['For this tender Mancunian gob-shite is always there for us when we need him most.' Brian Rasic/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Lias Saoudi </strong>is the frontman of Fat White Family and the Moonlandingz, and the co-author of <a href="https://www.waterstones.com/book/ten-thousand-apologies/adelle-stripe/lias-saoudi/9781474617857" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Ten Thousand Apologies: Fat White Family and the Miracle of Failure</em></a></p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>FatWhiteFamily</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is the frontman of Fat White Family and the Moonlandingz, and the co-author of <a href="https://www.waterstones.com/book/ten-thousand-apologies/adelle-stripe/lias-saoudi/9781474617857" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Ten Thousand Apologies: Fat White Family and the Miracle of Failure</em></a>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sat, 15 Feb 2025 00:05:42 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Sat, 15 Feb 2025 00:05:42 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Morrissey]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The Smiths]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=656418</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[He's trapped in his own creation]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>It’s been 20 years since I first set eyes on a Smiths LP. The LP in question — <em>Meat is Murder</em> — was released 40 years ago this week. I loved that cover. It made me ponder an alternative universe, one where the US army solely recruited vegans to go and fight Vietnam. The mid-Eighties seemed as far away to me in the mid-2000s as they do to me now, like they’re following me around. That might just be my sense of time warping with age, or maybe it’s because, in so many ways, the cultural clocks had stopped turning by the end of the Eighties.</p>
<p>The triumph of neoliberal ideology — obliterating any hope for the proletarian Bohemia espoused by Morrissey and co. — left in its wake a world of obligatory positivity, of mandatory self-promotion, of endless canned laughter. By the time I was old and depressed enough to want to listen to the band, their stature had only grown. With no one around quite able to fill their boots, they’d become even more of a lifeline to those in search of personality in a world on the bore.</p>
<p>In 2005, I moved from student accommodation into a houseshare in Archway, North London. In halls, there were enough of you to avoid one another. It’s only once six of you shack up in the same building that you find your people. I realized pretty quickly that a guy named Gregg was my people. Picture a Smiths obsessive starting his second year at uni in your head, and there he is: thick-rimmed specs, cardigan, delicate yet cumbersome, literate, pale, ultra-sensitive, achingly mystified by sex and wandering around Sainsbury’s on a sullen Tuesday afternoon defacing the avocados in the name of Palestinian justice. He played the band constantly. They didn’t make sense to me at first. Morrissey’s voice felt monochromatic, overwrought, lacking in subtlety. It was too much, this incessant melodramatic moan. They didn’t make sense to me until I needed them to. Until the mud and murk of animal desire had reduced me to a kind of whimpering paste.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/small-dick-energy-gave-us-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/small-dick-energy-gave-us-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/sde.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/small-dick-energy-gave-us-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/small-dick-energy-gave-us-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How small dick energy gave us Trump</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/small-dick-energy-gave-us-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Lias Saoudi</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>My friendship with Gregg took a turn for the worse when I became aware of my superior value in the sexual marketplace. When both of us were total no-hopers, we couldn’t have been closer. Then I met Millie. I lost interest in Gregg. I had cocaine to snort and parties to attend with my beautiful new hipster girlfriend. I used to think about Gregg downstairs in his Smiths dungeon, while Millie and I canoodled in the room above his head. He used to roll his TV up close enough to his bed so that he could watch it with headphones attached. This way he could enjoy fully sound-tracked porn without the rest of the house clocking on. I used to think of him down there, plugged into that box, while Millie and I plugged into one another. I knew his suffering: it had up until moments ago been my own. Still, somehow, I found his pain added to my pleasure.</p>
<p>Then Millie left me for another boy. I’d grown lazy, entitled, bored — a lifelong pattern asserting itself for the first time. My mentality was a long way from catching up with my biology, to paraphrase Mozza on <em>Meat is Murder</em>. The boredom was supplanted by raging, bitter desire once I knew I’d been replaced. I was suddenly beneath where Gregg had been. Gregg’s world looked idyllic from the fresh hell of jealousy I’d stumbled into. I wanted no more part in this sordid, bloodthirsty competition. In that moment, I wished I could obliterate sex from the world. What was left of my innocence was gone. At moments such as these only The Smiths suffice. Somehow only Morrissey seems to understand.</p>
<p>I was asked during an interview last year what I made of his politics, clearly a reference to recent provocations. I didn’t care about his politics, I responded. I don’t go to pop stars for politics, I go to them with heartbreak, and no one has done more for the broken-hearted than Morrissey. In retrospect, though, that response seems insufficient. For it’s only by dint of Morrissey’s political sensitivities that he was able to relieve so much heartache in the first place. Splicing the wit of Oscar Wilde with droll proletarian kitchen sink drama, the long-term loners and unemployables of his songs are suddenly able to seal themselves off from their lack of prospects in aristocratic futility: <em>No, I never had a job because I never wanted one</em>. Through humor and wordplay, disenchantment is made regal: <em>Shoplifters of the world, unite and take over</em>…</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;I don’t go to pop stars for politics, I go to them with heartbreak, and no one has done more for the broken-hearted than Morrissey.&#8221;</div>
<p>The Smiths nailed that dread, so familiar to youth, at submitting yourself to this gray machine which longs to turn you into itself. I think for a lot of young men getting into The Smiths is like being given permission to finally feel too much — <em>Why do you sleep alone tonight? Because tonight is just like any other night</em>. It’s not just pathetic to stew in your woundedness. It’s also human. It’s also hard proof you’re actually here. That’s nothing to be ashamed of. Quite the contrary: your ineptitude might well be something to celebrate, might well be a form of insurrection.</p>
<p>The sensitivity required to concoct such a body of work and at so young an age is breathtaking. That obvious sensitivity also renders it difficult to work out the level of seriousness with which to take Morrissey’s constant thumb-in-eye public aggravations. He’s too intelligent not to know what he’s doing. Claiming Richard Madeley married his own mother, calling for the head of Elton John, suggesting Jamie Oliver eat his own kids — you’d have to have a heart of stone to read this stuff and not laugh. His vegan fundamentalism sometimes leads him into more complex waters, however. In particular, his endorsement of For Britain — a party alluded to even by Farage as “Nazi”.</p>
<p>It&#8217;s weird that the anti-establishment post-punk icon of Irish immigrant stock should move to LA forever, then become obsessed with how many Muslims there are in Bradford. Is he genuinely so concerned for the welfare of animals that he’ll lay down with dogs? It is possible. Or has he just become a bit of a curmudgeon? Nostalgia was always a key element with The Smiths, from the album covers of old film stars to the elaborate croon to the high romantic lyrical stylings. Is this unchecked nostalgia turning into regression perhaps? What kind of England is he advocating for anyway? Suet puddings? Vicars on bicycles? Whistling bobbies on the beat?</p>
<p>I think it was Shaun Ryder who once summed up his acerbic inclinations best: “it’s just Morrissey being Morrissey.” Morrissey is the ultimate fan. He always has been. Having written literature on James Dean, and set up the unofficial New York Dolls fan club before fame, to this day he can still be found penning elegant <a href="https://www.morrisseycentral.com/messagesfrommorrissey/let-us-now-praise-famous-men">tributes</a> to his favorite artists. Everyone begins as a fan. Everyone in art supplicates themselves before other art, before going on to make it themselves. In a sense, artists are just psychotically dedicated fans.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/05/morrissey-will-never-be-cancelled/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/05/morrissey-will-never-be-cancelled/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/gettyimages-1207374574-594x594-1-e1651233413647.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/05/morrissey-will-never-be-cancelled/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/05/morrissey-will-never-be-cancelled/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Morrissey will never be cancelled</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/05/morrissey-will-never-be-cancelled/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Douglas Copeland</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The ultimate goal is a kind of closed-circuit fandom. A self-replenishing, self-sustaining vortex of adulation, with you at the core. Ideally, you become a fan of yourself. A ritualized, masochistic enslavement to one’s idols — if you have what it takes, you might eventually be able to convert into a ritualized, masochistic enslavement to one’s own image. Morrissey strayed beyond this singularity some time ago. He’s started looking at Oscar Wilde’s fall from grace, thinking: “I want me some of that action.” Like all great egotists (see “Ye” for the mentally ill variety), only crucifixion will suffice when it comes to bringing the curtain down. Martyrdom or bust. It’s not enough that we love him, he wants all of our feelings, he wants our loathing too. Spare a thought for what it must be like to live like that. We can simply switch Morrissey off when we’re sick of him. He can never leave his creation.</p>
<p>Morrissey could go as far as calling for the removal of all Muslims and peoples of Muslim descent from the British Isles — he could go as far as to single out the polluting effects of me and the rest of the Algerian diaspora specifically — I would still have love for him. That last bit might actually <em>increase</em> my love for him — I’ve been trying to suss out how to get my dad deported for years. I dare say within our sanitized media landscape having someone around that’s willing to “play the villain” is far from a bad thing.</p>
<p>No, he’d have to inflict serious personal wounds for me to turn my back on him; he’d have to run my own mother down in his car then lie about it. For this tender Mancunian gob-shite is always there for us when we need him most. When the storm clouds of betrayal, self-hate and prolapsed pride begin brewing, he’s there waiting for us, the exact <em>bon mot</em> to hand. People forget that in a hurry it seems. That they can help themselves to the tonic of Mozza as and when it suits them, then calmly place him back on the shelf until the next time we think we <em>know</em> it’s over.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/morrissey-is-the-villain-we-need/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/morrissey-is-the-villain-we-need/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/morrissey-is-the-villain-we-need/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">656418</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The Left won’t let go of woke</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/the-left-wont-let-go-of-woke/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/the-left-wont-let-go-of-woke/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Chibber-2.jpg?w=477</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>identity politics</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Catherine Liu]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/2_720.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>International</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[For many on the Left, the year 2020 never ended. Credit: Getty]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>Catherine Liu is professor of film and media studies at the University of California, Irvine, and the author of <em>Virtue Hoarders: The Case Against the Professional Managerial Class</em>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>bureaucatliu</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[Catherine Liu is professor of film and media studies at the University of California, Irvine, and the author of <em>Virtue Hoarders: The Case Against the Professional Managerial Class</em>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 04 Feb 2025 00:01:34 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 04 Feb 2025 00:01:34 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Anti-Woke]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ethnic studies]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Identity politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Jacobin]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Socialism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The left]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[vivek chibber]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[woke]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=653741</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[So much for the ‘vibe shift’]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p style="font-weight: 400">“Wokeness” is receding, according to the mainstream conventional wisdom. Having peaked in the plague-and-reckoning year 2020, the story goes, Left identity politics and the disciplinary practices that usually go with them have been on a downward trajectory ever since. The election of 2024 decisively affirmed the decline of woke: how could progressives continue to use terms like “Latinx” when half of Latino men pulled for Donald Trump’s GOP at the ballot box?</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">But the woke Left apparently hasn’t received the memo. Witness the social-media mobbing of Vivek Chibber, a professor of sociology at New York University and the editor of the socialist journal <em>Catalyst</em>, after he dared to historically analyze wokeness as an illiberal, authoritarian tendency.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">Chibber made his comments last week on a <em>Jacobin </em>magazine podcast titled <a href="https://x.com/jacobin_av/status/1884612286536413688?s=46" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://x.com/jacobin_av/status/1884612286536413688?s%3D46&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1738685906296000&amp;usg=AOvVaw2pHMNqsacSb7jjN6vkx-7Z">Confronting Capitalism: The End of Wokeness</a>. It triggered a firestorm of angry “X” comments that ranged from mischaracterizing him as a Right-wing goon to outright obscenity. Ajay Singh Chaudhary, the director of the Brooklyn Institute for Social Research, dismissed Chibber’s critique of wokeness as “tripe” and a <a href="https://x.com/materialist_jew/status/1885028320909078625" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://x.com/materialist_jew/status/1885028320909078625&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1738685906296000&amp;usg=AOvVaw27FtLgo_8Xu9ey3OeuqYli">“carbon copy” of the Right’s</a>.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">Laleh Khalili, a Mideast scholar at the University of Exeter, <a href="https://x.com/LalehKhalili/status/1884897151680905632" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://x.com/LalehKhalili/status/1884897151680905632&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1738685906296000&amp;usg=AOvVaw1yb4g1BSdQEOBRP4oZ3xlS">denounced Chibber</a> as a “brownshirt waving a red flag.” William Clare Roberts, an assistant professor of politics at McGill University, suggested that Chibber is “no different” from liberal writers like Matt Yglesias or Jonathan Chait: “I am weary of having to treat him like he’s a serious thinker on the socialist left, much less a Marxist”. Many other commenters didn’t even bother with full sentences. Instead, they simply called Chibber a “pedophile” and the like.</p>
<p>So much for the vibe shift. But what did Chibber actually say that so incensed the professional Left? Perhaps it was because he dared to point out that wokeness is not popular. Or perhaps it was his definition of wokeness that rankled its acolytes: Chibber defined wokeness as a professional-class movement for social justice that excludes socialism from its political project and that is highly intolerant to boot.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“Thanks to identity politics, militancy and activism became institutionalized within the academy.”</div>
<p style="font-weight: 400">A pile-up on X when a Leftist like Chibber criticizes wokeness is politically significant, because it demonstrates that for much of the Left, there is no difference between the neoliberal micromanagement of diversity in the ranks of the professional class, on one hand, and the struggle to empower the American working class relative to capital, on the other. Progressives in states like California have successfully transformed the language of human resources, while neglecting problems like skyrocketing housing costs and working-class wage stagnation.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">If Democrats had been successful on both the language and the wage fronts, there might be less explosive hostility to the party’s politics of hypocrisy. November’s massive shift to the GOP in the Golden State and similar blue areas reflected a silent protest against one-party rule: it is the combination of Democratic identity politics and liberal compliance with the demands of the party’s wealthiest donors that has bred resentment and nihilism among downscale Americans.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">Unable and unwilling to contemplate the limits of wokeness in building mass politics, identitarian Leftists have taken out their rage against Chibber. In Chinese, there is a saying that reflects the tyrant’s wisdom when controlling a crowd: “kill a chicken to scare the monkey”. You do a symbolic murder of a critic of woke dogma in order to silence anyone else with doubts in their mind about the priorities of Left politics. The X mob can live off the pleasure of group psychology, following an imaginary woke leader by mobbing an enemy online. It is a disgusting spectacle and bodes ill for the evolution of Left liberalism.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">It is critical to attack the authoritarianism at the heart of contemporary liberal politics from the Left: if the Left fails to sound its own alarm about the professional-class takeover of identity and diversity, then the Right will continue to draw upon the rage that animates working-class, non-college-educated people of all races, genders, and sexualities. They have seen liberalism deliver nothing but empty promises of inclusion when they hunger for an actual change in the political field itself. Trump sees the hypocrisy of woke elites and acts as a vehicle for catharsis.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">If anything, Chibber didn’t go far enough in his critique. At a key point in the podcast, he dared to ask a question most of us don’t pose any longer: why couldn’t ethnic and gender studies be integrated into existing departments of history, sociology, English, American Studies, and the like when they first emerged in the 1960s? Why did they have to be carved out as separate disciplines? Chibber argued that this owed to “grassroots” demand for separate identity-based departments.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">But this is mistaken, and any serious Left critique of the rise of identity studies — a key vector of what came to be known as woke ideas — must reckon with the granular history. In fact, the establishment of the first-ever ethnic studies departments, at the University of California, Berkeley, and San Francisco State University, was engineered by a lifetime FBI informant named Richard Aoki.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">This is notable, because the upshot of Aoki’s work, and that of the wider movement he helped incept, was to defuse campus radicalism and turn would-be revolutionaries into credentialed race professionals of the kind who would soon become familiar to anyone who has faced the business end of a university diversity office or corporate HR department.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/in-defence-of-wokeness/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/in-defence-of-wokeness/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/GettyImages-1218190450-copy-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/in-defence-of-wokeness/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/in-defence-of-wokeness/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>In defence of wokeness</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/in-defence-of-wokeness/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tomiwa Owolade</a></p></div></a></div>
<p style="font-weight: 400">In his 2012 book, <em><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/07/books/review/subversives-by-seth-rosenfeld.html" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/07/books/review/subversives-by-seth-rosenfeld.html&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1738685906296000&amp;usg=AOvVaw1RQ5DSlDlJXiyhw-fbfcJA">Subversives: The FBI’s War on Student Radicals and Ronald Reagan’s Rise to Power</a></em>, the <a href="https://revealnews.org/article/new-fbi-files-show-wide-range-of-black-panther-informants-activities/" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://revealnews.org/article/new-fbi-files-show-wide-range-of-black-panther-informants-activities/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1738685906296000&amp;usg=AOvVaw1hkS-AY9Zu7m_egisUaYyf">journalist Seth Rosenfeld</a> used the Freedom of Information Act to extract documents from the FBI about its activities against California militant groups during the Sixties and early Seventies. In the course of his research, he discovered that Aoki, the first Asian member of the Black Panther Party, was recruited by the FBI when he was in the Army during the Fifties to inform on student radicals. Aoki, as it happens, also midwifed the Asian American Studies section of Berkeley’s ethnic-studies department, the first of its kind in the United States.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">This origin story sheds a cold light on identity- and grievance-based disciplines, which were designed to emphasize “visibility” and “representation” over critically analyzing and attacking capitalism itself. Other American universities would soon follow Berkeley’s path and create ethnic-studies departments to signal their commitment to progressive causes.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">Thanks to identity politics, militancy and activism became institutionalized within the academy and, later, the corporation and the security apparatus. Is it possible that Aoki abandoned his early commitment to anti-Communism and had a genuine conversion to the sort of identity politics he would espouse as a chief promoter of ethnic studies? Certainly. And I am not suggesting that identity politics was solely a product of the American security establishment; life is much too complex and contingent to permit such single-cause explanations. Still, there is no denying that university-based ethnic studies came to supply a new <a href="https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2021/11/the-cia-and-the-new-dialect-of-power/" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2021/11/the-cia-and-the-new-dialect-of-power/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1738685906296000&amp;usg=AOvVaw1UZrNSpFHqQb9yJIqOiDp3">“dialect of power”</a>: a way for the likes of the FBI or Goldman Sachs to deflect questions about their decisions by showcasing the “diversity” of the people who make those decisions.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400">The point is that those of us on the Left need <em>more</em> discussion of the origins of identity politics, the role it has played in creating nominally progressive liberal institutions, and its complicity with defanging actual radicalism. Chibber’s intervention in this debate wasn’t inflammatory. It was conversational, accessible, and reasonable. Chibber’s work is the answer to the millions of Americans who crave a critique of Democratic identity politics but have only found it on the Right. The viciousness of his critics only vindicates his arguments.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/the-left-wont-let-go-of-woke/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/the-left-wont-let-go-of-woke/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/the-left-wont-let-go-of-woke/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">653741</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Will our universities ever recover from Covid?</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/will-our-universities-ever-recover-from-covid/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/will-our-universities-ever-recover-from-covid/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/GettyImages-1267392423.jpg?w=504</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>five years on</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Jennie Bristow]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Jennie-Bristow-mum.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Covid ruined lives. Ben Hasty/MediaNews Group/Reading Eagle via Getty Images.]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Dr Jennie Bristow</strong> is a sociologist of generations and author of <em>Stop Mugging Grandma</em></p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle></unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a sociologist of generations and author of <em>Stop Mugging Grandma</em>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 16 Jan 2025 00:01:17 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 16 Jan 2025 00:01:17 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Covid]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[lockdowns]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Universities]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=649762</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The cult of safetyism is still rampant]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>From job losses to course closures, British universities are in meltdown — as panicked institutions are desperately shedding their crumbling 20th century identities. Yet if academics, subjects and even physical buildings all look set to go, with administrators scrambling to be “fit for purpose” in a new world of metrics and edutainment, the sector seems strangely unwilling to reflect on why the collapse has come.</p>
<p>There are plenty of candidates here. Tuition fees and burgeoning student numbers are two obvious examples, together encouraging universities to compete for an unsustainable market of teenage “customers”. More recent changes haven’t helped either, particularly a national insurance hike set to <a href="https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/universities-hit-employer-national-insurance-hike-confirmed" target="_blank">cost</a> higher education some £372 million. In the end though, these challenges only became existential after one single event: Covid. Amid all the hand-wringing over the sector’s current crisis, its failure to rise to the challenge of the pandemic has provoked curiously little attention.</p>
<p>During the first lockdown, universities, like schools, were legally required to treat students as germs on legs. They were <a href="https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9030/#:~:text=In%20March%202020%20university%20and,campuses%20for%20the%20autumn%20term." target="_blank">first</a> closed down, then subjected to a range of bizarre “social distancing” requirements that made large in-person lectures impossible. But as the months went on, and government guidance promoted the importance of face-to-face teaching, many institutions dragged their feet. Having been forced to push through strategies of emergency remote teaching, it seemed safer and easier to stick with it. That’s despite having exhorted a new intake of freshers to move to campus so they could take up (read: pay for) a “student experience” that effectively meant being locked up in their rooms.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-real-chaos-of-the-new-normal/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-real-chaos-of-the-new-normal/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/hdweouhfqohg-e1698764219932.jpeg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-real-chaos-of-the-new-normal/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-real-chaos-of-the-new-normal/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The real chaos of the &#039;new normal&#039;</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-real-chaos-of-the-new-normal/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jennie Bristow</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>From a hard-nosed business perspective, the desperation to retain students as fee-paying bodies, even while providing an experience that was neither educational nor social, was the logical outcome of a policy approach that sees students primarily as units of funding. It was also, ironically, the outcome of an attitude to university governance that has long prioritized safety and satisfaction over robust education and academic freedom.</p>
<p>Universities have spent so long pandering to the idea that their role is to give the student-consumer “what they want” — higher grades for less effort; the gamification of learning in place of reading books; safe spaces in which they can be shielded from uncomfortable ideas — that they couldn’t compute why bedroom learning was not, in fact, any kind of education at all.</p>
<p>This was not what students wanted. Remember the scenes from the University of Manchester, with angry teenagers <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/education/2020/nov/05/security-fence-manchester-university-student-flats" target="_blank">tearing down</a> the steel “cages” built around their accommodation? Or what about the angry scenes of kids <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-55130415" target="_blank">trapped</a> at a party when the fire alarm went off? The door was faulty, but the safety messages reissued by the university emphasized that “illegal” large gatherings were putting students’ health and safety at risk. Nor, of course, was Manchester the only university to turn its campus into a student-funded quarantine camp, even if others showed slightly more flexibility. For my part, I largely taught in person outside of formal lockdowns. The masks, visors and distancing made it very weird, but at least I got to know students by their eyebrows.</p>
<p>For over a year, at any rate, the central purpose of higher education was subsumed beneath a veil of hysterical safetyism, eagerly fueled by the main academics’ union. The University and College Union (UCU) set its face against on-campus teaching, warning that asking students back would <a href="https://www.ucu.org.uk/article/10964/Universities-must-not-become-the-care-homes-of-a-Covid-second-wave" target="_blank">turn them</a> into the “care homes of the second wave”. No less telling, it also <a href="https://www.ucu.org.uk/media/11295/Archived-Critical-worker-status-in-HE-in-England-guidance/pdf/ucu_covid19_critical-workers_he_eng_jan21.pdf" target="_blank">briefed</a> its members about the dangers of arguing that “staff are required to work on campus and/or deliver face-to-face teaching or services”. When your own union claims your job is inessential, you might not be surprised if a wave of redundancies follows — especially when the same union decides that the biggest threat to academics’ health is freedom of speech.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;The central purpose of higher education was subsumed beneath a veil of hysterical safetyism&#8221;</div>
<p>How else to explain the attacks against anyone who questioned the wisdom of lockdowns, with many academics finding themselves subject to vicious smear campaigns from <a href="https://afcomm.org.uk/2023/11/17/covid-scientist-sunetra-gupta-talks-to-us-about-campaign-to-smear-her/" target="_blank">colleagues</a> and <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/newsroom/jay-bhattacharya-the-legal-case-against-anthony-fauci/" target="_blank">government officials</a> alike? In this time of dangerous uncertainty, when societies were dealing with literal matters of life and death, there was an urgent need for academic collaboration and debate. Instead, debate was stifled, with similar attitudes soon spreading to other corners of the academy. In October 2021, to give one example, philosophy professor Kathleen Stock left her post at the University of Sussex following an intimidation campaign by students and academics opposed to her gender-critical views. Far from supporting their colleague, the local UCU branch <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/nov/03/kathleen-stock-says-she-quit-university-post-over-medieval-ostracism" target="_blank">called</a> for a university-wide investigation into “transphobia”.</p>
<p>Nor was this mania to die down with Covid. The UCU has continued to <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0025t43/politics-live-09122024" target="_blank">dismiss</a> concerns about academic freedom as a “sideshow” invented by the Right, while also <a href="https://educationhub.blog.gov.uk/2024/07/26/free-speech-act-what-you-need-to-know/" target="_blank">opposing</a> the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act, with the union suggesting “there is no real evidence” of a free speech crisis on campus. Tell that to the hundreds of academics who <a href="https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSc9GcINYCmoeyuiOLPNmmfJ_cUYNfbbf_m09xMCl7S2RQYASA/viewform" target="_blank">signed</a> an open letter imploring the Government to implement the remaining provisions of the Act, something even Keir Starmer now seems <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cyv43p1z15eo" target="_blank">willing</a> to accept.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/lockdown-loneliness-is-here-to-stay/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/lockdown-loneliness-is-here-to-stay/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/GettyImages-1212894222-e1617297459663.jpeg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/lockdown-loneliness-is-here-to-stay/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/lockdown-loneliness-is-here-to-stay/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Lockdown loneliness is here to stay</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/04/lockdown-loneliness-is-here-to-stay/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jennie Bristow</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Not, of course, that this is a purely British problem. Across the world, higher education’s failure to prioritize academic inquiry during Covid has been a huge blow to its legitimacy. Yet in the UK, where the public has long <a href="https://bristoluniversitypress.co.uk/generational-encounters-with-higher-education" target="_blank">raised</a> concerns about the status and value of degrees in our massified, financialized system, people are now questioning the worth of university altogether. This not only speaks to how lightly we hold our cultural heritage: it is a terrible shame for the kids. Students and parents continue to be <a href="https://www.kcl.ac.uk/news/graduates-overwhelmingly-positive-about-universities-but-public-favour-more-vocational-options-study-finds" target="_blank">broadly positive</a> about higher education, despite its problems. But when the sector is tearing itself apart, why should the public come to the rescue?</p>
<p>A year ago, Professor Shitij Kapur, vice chancellor of King’s College London, <a href="https://www.kcl.ac.uk/news/uk-universities-trapped-in-triangle-of-sadness-kings-vice-chancellor-says" target="_blank">argued</a> that UK universities are trapped in a “triangle of sadness” between “aspiring students who feel burdened with debt and uncertain prospects, a stretched government that has allowed tuition fees to fall far behind inflation, and beleaguered university staff who feel caught in the middle”. To escape this mess, we need an unflinching discussion of a single basic question: what are universities for? To come to an answer, meanwhile, we need people committed to the intellectual and educational purpose of higher education and prepared to acknowledge previous mistakes. Otherwise, we’ll be left with the policy fudge we have right now, a consultant-led <a href="https://www.pwc.co.uk/government-public-sector/education/documents/higher-education-financial-sustainability-report.pdf" target="_blank">drive</a> to achieve institutional “sustainability” by cutting back the things that give universities their heart: subjects, academics, and students who are there to broaden their minds.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/will-our-universities-ever-recover-from-covid/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/will-our-universities-ever-recover-from-covid/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/01/will-our-universities-ever-recover-from-covid/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">649762</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>It&#8217;s time to flee your utopia</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/its-time-to-flee-your-utopia/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/its-time-to-flee-your-utopia/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/GettyImages-1228646180.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>malicious algorithms</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Alex O'Connor]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Blue-thumbnail-2.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Could he change your mind? Matthew Hatcher/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Alex O&#8217;Connor </strong>is the host of the “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/@cosmicskeptic" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Within Reason</a>” YouTube show and podcast.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>CosmicSkeptic</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is the host of the “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/@cosmicskeptic" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Within Reason</a>” YouTube show and podcast.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Wed, 28 Aug 2024 23:02:24 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 29 Aug 2024 15:36:43 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture Wars]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ideology]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=617708</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Social media kills political understanding]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>I was recently at a party when someone I hadn’t seen in a while said, “I found out that two of my cousins are actually Trump supporters. Like, <em>actual</em> Trump supporters. Seriously. Like they actually support Trump. I couldn’t believe it.”</p>
<p>I couldn’t believe it. It’s one thing to talk with disdain about your political opponents, but how striking that she genuinely <em>couldn’t fathom </em>that Trump supporters are real, or at least that any would find themselves in distant relation with her. This political species making up about a half of the American electorate (not to mention his international admirers), it is at best <em>irrational </em>to impute such an unlikelihood to this kind of discovery. But given our desperate need (in the service of everybody <em>calming down a bit</em>) for proactive efforts at understanding each other a little better, the development of this sentiment may well be a kind of vice.</p>
<p>Forget for a moment any moralising about charity in politics and think strategically. Perhaps your only concern is, understandably, keeping <em>him </em>out of office. Fine. But to defeat something, you must understand it. And treating this quite plausible political threat as a kind of strange alien which does not so much befriend as contaminate our loved ones, and which can have no other explanation than as a manifestation of our most base intolerance and bigotry, probably isn’t quite “steel-manning” the opposition.</p>
<p>Political hatred is nothing new, of course, and there will always be more and less antagonistic periods in the US’s continual development (remember that the vice president used to be whoever came second in the election, an entertaining policy to imagine active in the last few presidential cycles), but something does seem decidedly more <em>openly </em>nasty about modern US politics; gone are the days of clandestine bitterness — now even the <em>pretence </em>of propriety has been dropped in favour of common name-calling.</p>
<p>There are probably two reasons for this. The first is that Trump is a genuine anomaly. He swears. He insults. He asks Theo Von what cocaine is like. He attempts to prevent democratic elections. <em>He is a convicted felon</em>. Worse still, he appears to bring out the worst in otherwise generally professional politicians. (The recent dick joke made by the spotlessly charismatic 44th president at the DNC can hardly be <em>blamed </em>on Trump, but it is difficult to imagine him doing the same at the expense of John McCain or Mitt Romney.)</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/the-speech-kamala-owes-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/the-speech-kamala-owes-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/GettyImages-504725250-e1723822462221.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/the-speech-kamala-owes-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/the-speech-kamala-owes-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The speech Kamala owes America</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/the-speech-kamala-owes-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Lee Siegel</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Why has such child’s play become so politically mainstream? The answer perhaps lies in the second reason: social media. Politicians are the nervous hostages of voters, who at present are the nervous hostages of malicious algorithms designed to cultivate self-assurance and righteousness with artistic precision.</p>
<p>We often hear that social media is something of a “new public square” where ideas are efficiently trialled and debated, while providing a decidedly meritocratic possibility for basically anybody’s response to appear right underneath a tweet by the President himself. But I see it as a sort of no-man’s land. Step into it, and your life immediately gets worse. You may blow something up. You may blow yourself up. You may find another country’s government is suddenly attacking you.</p>
<p>Really, though, social media is best described as a utopian paradise. I mean in the etymological sense: utopia from <em>ou topos</em>, “no place”. Paradise from <em>paradeiso</em><em>s</em>, “enclosed park”. A place that is not real, and at the same time a walled garden. Less a public square, whose contents are contingent and out of your control, and more a private estate designed from the ground up to keep out anything which may disillusion you of the space.</p>
<p>Ingeniously, the conviction is encouraged that we are its architects, furnishing the plot with autonomous follows and subscriptions, and with an array of painless mechanisms for muting or blocking the vexatious topics and people. But anyone paying attention knows that we are instead helpless addicts to an algorithmic generation beyond our comprehension. It is not your stated preferences but the unconscious microseconds of difference between how long you spend here or there which determine what kind of material you are fed (remember it is called a <em>feed</em>).</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;We are helpless addicts to an algorithmic generation beyond our comprehension.&#8221;</div>
<p>In 2012, a story began circulating about an enraged father storming into a Target outside of Minneapolis, demanding to see the manager. His daughter, still in high school, had received coupons from the company advertising cribs and maternity clothes, which he believed was inappropriate. Days later, that same father apologised to that same manager, having found out that his daughter was due in August.</p>
<p>Statistician Andrew Pole, reported the <em>New York Times</em>, had created a “pregnancy-prediction model” which analysed the purchasing habits of Target’s female customers, assigning a probability based on correlative spending decisions. The daughter’s behaviours were picked up by the system, and thus is explained how Target figured out that a girl was pregnant before her own father did.</p>
<p>This story is perhaps dubious, but the fact that it is so believable proves that we already know how recommended content is really produced. We have all heard stories of people who swear that they only needed to mention dog food in audial range of their (sometimes inactive) computer for it to begin advertising pet food to them. True or not, the paranoia it invokes proves at least one thing: many of us are fearful that we <em>do not even know when and how we are being monitored</em>.</p>
<p>And not monitored by some despotic government (though why not that too!), but by <em>advertisers</em>, who want not to quell political dissent but to simply curate content, figuring out what you will buy, and watch, and read, and selling it to you for the low cost of your zombified attention.</p>
<p>Not you and me, though. Because we know all of this, and we are enterprising in our efforts to defy it. We follow people <em>intentionally </em>whom we disagree with. We engage in conversations and debates online. Our feeds are an impressive and virtuous balance of Left and Right.</p>
<p>Do not fall for this trap: it is smarter than you think. It is smarter than you. Remember that disagreements can be enjoyable, and entertaining or winnable disputes are allowed in your garden. After all, what is more rewarding than “interacting” with the “other side” by publicly exposing their ignorance and stupidity?</p>
<p>When was the last time you had your mind significantly changed as a result of such an interaction? The unfortunate reality is that the extent to which you enjoy disagreeing with someone (including revelling in righteous anger, and being congratulated for it) on social media is inversely proportional to the seriousness of the threat they pose to your worldview. This is why online arguments gravitate around either smarminess in flawless victory, or dull rage at how unthinkable a position is, and tragically evade the productive space in-between.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/the-mythical-masculinity-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/the-mythical-masculinity-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/GettyImages-2147828945.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/the-mythical-masculinity-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/the-mythical-masculinity-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The mythical masculinity of Donald Trump</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/the-mythical-masculinity-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Frederick Kaufman</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The thing about a town square is that you don’t get to choose who’s there. You don’t get to amplify voices based on your interests. You certainly don’t get the murky town council doing this for you without you even realising based on a painstaking surveillance project.</p>
<p>Whatever it is, we spend a lot of time there. And in comprehensively regulating what kind of people we politically interact with, social media at the same time dictates our very understanding of the terms of the debate.</p>
<p>I believe a significant number of political arguments are at base about language. Disputed definitions are often the <em>foundation </em>of political disagreement. But our vocabulary can only ever be a result of how those we are surrounded by use and understand terms, and if people spend enough time separated by selective algorithms during the evolution of our political semantics, linguistic speciation will inevitably ensue. Our words begin drifting from their original referents, and we end up developing a different vocabulary from our opponents <em>without realising it</em>.</p>
<p>Thus the time wasted feuding over labels that simply represent different concepts depending on who speaks them: “democratic”, “woke”, “racist”, “woman”. Bafflement arises as a result of encountering contradictory concepts, so when our definitions begin to vary, confronting a person who negates our view of the world is not just upsetting, but <em>confusing</em>. It is as though we have been met with a contradiction. The empathetic friend who is not a feminist. The rational neighbour who is not a capitalist. <em>The cousin I love who is a Trump supporter</em>.</p>
<p>Yes, social media is a utopian paradise. It should be avoided at all costs.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/its-time-to-flee-your-utopia/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/its-time-to-flee-your-utopia/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/its-time-to-flee-your-utopia/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">617708</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>How cancel culture lost its power</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/GettyImages-885800092.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>mob justice</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Geoff Shullenberger]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/4.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Milo has changed his tune. (Michael Masters/Getty)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><span class="css-901oao css-16my406 r-1qd0xha r-ad9z0x r-bcqeeo r-qvutc0"><strong>Geoff Shullenberger</strong> is managing editor of <em><a href="https://www.compactmag.com/">Compact</a></em>.</span></p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>g_shullenberger</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is managing editor of <em><a href="https://www.compactmag.com/">Compact</a></em>.</span>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 18 Jul 2024 23:01:24 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 19 Jul 2024 08:06:13 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Doxing]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Social media]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=610710</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The Right should be wary of norm enforcement]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>On July 16, three days after the assassination attempt on Donald Trump, the founder of the Right-wing X account “Libs of Tiktok” announced she was dedicating “ALL OF LIBS OF TIKTOK’S RESOURCES” toward “EXPOSING the Radical Left fantasizing about killing President Trump”.  At issue were social media posts in the aftermath of the shooting in which people said things like “shame he missed” and “a little to the right next time”. Because of her efforts, Raichik boasted, “TEN DERANGED LEFTISTS have already been FIRED from their jobs.” Those targeted included a realtor, a physical therapist, several nurses and schoolteachers, and a Home Depot cashier.</p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">This scorched-earth campaign has met with a mixed reception. Some have <a href="https://x.com/bdomenech/status/1813627929638961444" target="_blank" rel="noopener">made</a> the obvious point that getting random people fired for intemperate posts is what Raichik’s Right-wing milieu has long denounced as “cancel culture”; others were celebratory. Perhaps the most remarkable reversal came from the provocateur Milo Yiannopolous, once an advocate of what he called “cultural libertarianism”, who </span><a href="https://x.com/Nero/status/1813444830309331147" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">declared</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> on X: “</span><span style="font-weight: 400;">Shaming, shunning and public humiliation are necessary to maintain a well-ordered and pious society… </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">Cancel culture is good. It is bad that good people don’t do it.”  </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">This declaration may seem at odds with Milo’s &#8220;dangerous faggot&#8221; antics of the past, but it’s a fair summary of certain long-standing conservative assumptions: that there must be shared norms for society to continue to function, and these norms should be enforced through social stigma. The Right-wing embrace of free-speech absolutism over the past decade or so was always in tension with these assumptions.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The question is not whether such a pivot is hypocritical — which frankly is true of all but a handful of participants in these debates — but whether the mechanisms of cancel culture, as we currently understand it, may serve these conservative ends.      </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Right-wing supporters of tactics such as Raichik’s don’t seem to agree on what is meant to be achieved by them. While some admit they are mainly interested in revenge, others have <a href="https://spectator.org/in-defense-of-cancel-culture/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">claimed</a> a détente could be achieved in the culture war through “mutually assured destruction”. The thinking seems to be that if Leftists fear that culture will come for their own, they will think twice about deploying such tactics against the Right. We might think of this as a pursuit of classically liberal ends — the protection of viewpoint diversity and free speech — by illiberal means. For others, conversely, the objective seems to be to forge a new cultural consensus in which Left-wing views are suppressed through stigma. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Regardless, the assumption appears to be that the Left’s pursuit of cancellation has been effective at enforcing its norms, ergo the Right should follow suit — whether to achieve equilibrium or total cultural dominance. But there remains a question: has cancel culture really been a boon to Left-wing dominance? </span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;The assumption appears to be that the Left’s pursuit of cancellation has been effective at enforcing its norms, ergo the Right should follow suit.&#8221;</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">There have been other cancel cultures, of course, but this one has risen from the media environment forged by digital technology roughly a decade and a half ago. Consider the paradigmatic 2013 ordeal of Justine Sacco, a PR executive with 170 Twitter followers who posted the following joke while en route to visit family in South Africa: “Going to Africa. Hope I don’t get AIDS. Just kidding. I’m white!” Unfortunately for her, this clumsy attempt at wit came to the attention of</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> reporter Sam Biddle, who amplified it on the site </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Valleywag</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. The rest is history: Sacco became, for a moment, the main character on Twitter and beyond, lost her job, received death threats, and so on. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">This incident illustrates several features specific to the 21st-century cancel culture phenomenon. First, while a media outlet played a role, the key factor was the activation of the online swarm. It follows from this that the impetus for Sacco’s dismissal and reputational destruction did not proceed from any explicit rules of behaviour but from the spontaneous consensus of an emergent mob. Although this conviction reflected the view, often associated with the Left, that racism is a particularly condemnable offence, participation wasn’t limited to one political group. None other than Donald Trump joined in, declaring “Justine is fired!” and promising to donate to Aid for Africa. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Another essential feature was what has been called context collapse. In a pre-social media age, someone like Sacco might have been fired from her job for telling a joke that offended a supervisor — but the power to do this was limited to a particular institutional context. Alternatively, she might have lost a friend for making an off-colour joke at a bar. In both cases, the consequences would have been limited to particular settings. Under the reign of cancel culture, they can amount to a near total reputational destruction, cascading across all realms of individuals&#8217; lives while according them an unwanted public profile.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">In the early social-media era, it wasn’t clear that the media dynamics that enabled the rise of cancel culture — those that combined context collapse with rapid mob activation — had any clear ideological valence. Take the case of <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/feb/21/internet-shaming-lindsey-stone-jon-ronson" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Lindsey Stone</a>, who faced similar consequences to Sacco after posting a photo on Facebook in which she made an obscene gesture at Arlington National Cemetery. The norms Stone violated, needless to say, weren’t exactly those of the Left. Making a racist-seeming joke could lay waste to your reputation, but so could making an unpatriotic-seeming one. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Even if we fast-forward a few years into the Trump era, when cancel culture had become more obviously Left-coded, Left-wingers weren’t immune from its effects. In 2017, the academic George Ciccariello-Maher was forced to resign by a conservative mob outraged by a tweet he later — like Sacco — excused as a joke: “All I want for Christmas is a white genocide.” To be sure, it might have taken a far milder anti-black tweet from an academic to produce a similar impact — but fall Ciccariello-Maher did. </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">There is also the fact that plenty of progressives have fallen victim to purity-obsessed denizens of their own ideological camp. See Ciccariello-Maher’s </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">second</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> cancellation: a post with a youthful-looking girlfriend incensed Leftists about the “problematic age gap”. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-ghost-who-haunts-the-maga-revolt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-ghost-who-haunts-the-maga-revolt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/updated-maga.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-ghost-who-haunts-the-maga-revolt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-ghost-who-haunts-the-maga-revolt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The ghost who haunts the MAGA revolt</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-ghost-who-haunts-the-maga-revolt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Geoff Shullenberger</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The rise of cancel culture, all of this suggests, was not some strategic Left-wing scheme to achieve ideological hegemony, but the chaotic emergence of social dynamics in a new media landscape. The norms enforced in the early cases just discussed — disapproval of racist jokes and disrespect for fallen soldiers — predated this development. Social media had incited the violation of these norms as a means of accumulating the currency of attention, but also created chaotic new mechanisms for policing such violations by exposing them to a broader public that could be easily galvanised into a virtual mob. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">But far from stifling norm-violating speech in a totalitarian manner, the rise of the digital panopticon induced new incentives for engaging in it — as the career of Milo Yiannopolous illustrates. The fact that mob actions, whatever individual scalps they were able to claim, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">failed</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> to enforce Left-wing consensus in such a manner as to prevent, say, Trump’s election, explains why overt top-down censorship by digital platforms became so common after 2016. Although in some cases these actions enforced the same values asserted by cancel mobs, such actions took us out of the realm of horizontal norm enforcement <b>—</b> the realm in which cancel culture operates<b> —</b> and into that of indirect state tyranny.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">If cancel culture were ever effective at enforcing a given set of norms, there is reason to think this efficacy has been on the wane. We have also seen a disaggregation and re-fragmentation into new platforms, meaning that becoming the main character of the entire internet for a day, as Sacco did, is now nearly impossible, and so is enforcing the same set of norms across the digital public sphere. Aided by this development, many ostensibly cancelled figures have reemerged unscathed and often very successful. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">As we hurtle toward a second Trump term, the future of public discourse will look less like a reversal of Left-wing hegemony into Right-wing hegemony, than an even more chaotic and incoherent version of the fractured present. The dissolution of shared norms into competing normative and digital spheres will proceed apace alongside the continued erosion of localised institutional procedures in the face of viral media. Whatever such a society might look like, it won’t be well-ordered or pious. </span><span style="font-family: georgia, palatino, serif;"><br />
</span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-cancel-culture-lost-its-power/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">610710</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Eminem has lost his superpower</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/eminem-has-lost-his-superpower/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/eminem-has-lost-his-superpower/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/fuwehfguowefg.jpg?w=620</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Culture</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Sarah Ditum]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/sarah.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Slim Shady is dead. Long live Slim Shady. (Houdini)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Sarah Ditum</strong> is a columnist, critic and feature writer.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>sarahditum</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a columnist, critic and feature writer.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 06 Jun 2024 23:01:55 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 07 Jun 2024 06:10:43 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[America]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[none]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=604620</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[In 'Houdini', his jabs at outrage feel like feints]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Slim Shady is dead. Back in April, the rapper Eminem teased his new album — called <em>The Death of Slim Shady (Coup de Grace) </em>— with a trailer for a fake true-crime documentary about his peroxide-headed, foul-mouthed, sociopathic alter-ego’s murder. A couple of weeks later, the <em>Detroit Free Press </em>(Eminem’s hometown paper) ran an obituary for the fictional character. And now we’ve got the new single, “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=22tVWwmTie8&amp;ab_channel=EminemVEVO" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Houdini</a>”, with a video where Eminem plays himself and Slim battling for control of his career.</p>
<p>In other words, killing Slim Shady looks a lot like bringing him back. But Eminem (real name Marshall Mathers) has never been able to retire Slim for very long, however conflicted he’s sometimes seemed to be about his own creation. It’s Slim who made him famous, and Slim who made him hated; it’s Slim who defines the paper-thin line between performer and performance, and Slim whose rage and nihilism gave voice to the underbelly of America.</p>
<p>Before Slim, he was in danger of being nobody: Eminem’s first hit, after an underwhelming apprenticeship in underground rap, was “My Name Is”, in which he introduced himself as Slim Shady with a riot of outrageous rhymes. In just the first verse, he riffs about self-harm, suicide, assaulting Pamela Anderson and taking three different kinds of drugs, before rounding things out with some light blasphemy: “I don’t give a fuck, God sent me to piss the world off.”</p>
<p>That last line was altered in the radio edit to leave Christianity out of it: “I don’t give a damn, Dre sent me to tick the world off.” (Dre is his producer, Dr Dre.) It’s a mark of how conservative American culture was at the turn of the century, but it’s also a good illustration of Eminem’s talent for compounding the offence and being incredibly funny at the same time: in the process of bowdlerising himself, he promotes his producer to the level of a deity.</p>
<p>True to his word, he did indeed piss the world off. Labi Siffre, the British musician whose track “I Got the…” provided “My Name Is” with its beat, initially refused to licence the sample because he was so disgusted by the homophobia and misogyny of the lyrics. “Dissing the victims of bigotry — women as bitches, homosexuals as faggots — is lazy writing. Diss the bigots not their victims,” <a href="https://newhumanist.org.uk/articles/2915/qa-labi-siffre" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Siffre told <em>New Humanist</em> in 2012</a>. He only gave the OK after being supplied with a clean version that he assumed (wrongly) would be the only one released.</p>
<p>Before most people even knew what trolling was, Eminem had elevated it to an art. As far as he was concerned, he only became offensive because people were so determined to be offended. Asked about his relentless gay jokes in a 2017 interview, he explained: “when I started getting flack for it, I thought, <em>Alright, you people think I’m homophobic? Watch this</em> [&#8230;] I was trying to push the buttons of people who were calling me something that I wasn’t.”</p>
<p>Pop music is always at war with good taste, whatever that happens to be. In the late Nineties, artists and labels were still dusting themselves off from the efforts of the Parents Music Resource Center (headed by Tipper Gore) to impose censorship on music. Being shocking was a cause in its own right, and Slim Shady was its ideal avatar. Eminem didn’t care about niceties like “punching down”. Like a rap version of the stand-up Jerry Sadowitz, he was an equal-opportunities hate criminal.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/10/how-eminem-became-a-role-model/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/10/how-eminem-became-a-role-model/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/2GettyImages-85231071-scaled-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/10/how-eminem-became-a-role-model/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/10/how-eminem-became-a-role-model/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How Eminem became a role model</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/10/how-eminem-became-a-role-model/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Dorian Lynskey</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>For a while, he was a one-man moral panic. “What is the artistic value here?” wailed a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2001/01/29/opinion/in-america-a-musical-betrayal.html?searchResultPosition=21" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>New York Times </em></a><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2001/01/29/opinion/in-america-a-musical-betrayal.html?searchResultPosition=21">column</a> that called Eminem “both inane and obscene”. The problem with this line of criticism was that Eminem was, clearly, a wildly talented MC as well as whatever else you wanted to call him, delivering high-speed wordplay and intricate rhymes that never failed to hit their target. Writer Bob Herbert went on to accuse rap as a genre of having “thoroughly broken faith with the surpassingly great, centuries-long tradition of black music in America”.</p>
<p>This was hysterically pompous, even if you didn’t like Eminem (and for the record, I do), not least because it set up a white guy as the exemplar of “black music”. Before Eminem, white rap meant the embarrassing novelty of Vanilla Ice, or the Beastie Boys — more credible by the Nineties, but fundamentally a bunch of nice Jewish boys. Eminem joked gleefully about his race (“I am the worst thing since Elvis Presley/ To do black music so selfishly/ And use it to get myself wealthy,” he said on 2002’s “Without Me”), but he paid his dues on the gangsta rap scene.</p>
<p>And he really did belong to the streets: the Detroit from which he emerged was a world of trailer parks, opioid abuse and dead-end jobs, dramatised in his great semi-autobiographical movie <em>Eight Mile</em>. Under the gross-out wit, he represented a class that had a lot to be angry about. Slim Shady wasn’t just an individual: he was a whole demographic, as he laid out on “The Real Slim Shady” in 2000. “And there’s a million of us just like me/ Who cuss like me, who just don’t give a fuck like me/ Who dress like me, walk, talk and act like me.” If gangsta rap led to alarmism about the character of black youth, Eminem carried the alarming threat that the white kids might be just as bad.</p>
<p>Shady was the American id before Trump came along to do that job (although Eminem is on the record as an avowed anti-Trumpist): “I’m like a head trip to listen to ’cause I&#8217;m only givin’ you/ Things you joke about with your friends inside your livin’ room.” The most objectionable thing about the character, by this light, was that he wasn’t a hypocrite.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Shady was the American id before Trump came along to do that job.&#8221;</div>
<p>Didn’t everybody (well, every man) get mad and fantasise about revenge, the same way Eminem fantasised about killing his wife Kim on record? (The couple divorced in 2001, and later married and divorced again.) It didn’t mean he was going to <em>do </em>anything. This was catharsis, not premeditation. But there’s a fine line between identification and incitement. The criticism of violent art has always been that it doesn’t merely expose brutish impulses, but that it encourages them.</p>
<p>However much Eminem had always mocked the idea of being seen as a role model, there were people who now aspired to be like him. People like the character Stan in the eponymous song from 2000, whose name eventually became a synonym for an obsessive, stalkerish fan. Every successful artist or product or political position has its own stan culture now.</p>
<p>“Stan” is structured as a series of letters from Stan to Eminem, who he addressed as “Slim”. These start innocent albeit overinvolved, but escalate to a putative tape recording dictated by Stan as he drives his car off a bridge with his pregnant girlfriend tied up in the boot (a reference to Eminem’s femicidal fantasy on the track “Kim”). In the last verse, Eminem raps in a low-key way that tells you he’s not playing Shady here. His response to Stan is supportive and concerned — “I just don’t want you to do some crazy shit” — before at the last gasp he realises he’s already heard about Stan’s “crazy shit” on the news.</p>
<p>This is great storytelling. It’s also a tiny bit cake-and-eat-it: in this song, Eminem gets to play out Slim Shady-style violence and position himself as the author (rather than the character) in opposition to it. But it’s also incredibly sharp about the kind of fame an artist like Eminem had to navigate in the voracious celebrity culture of the noughties. Shady was a device that let him play out the most grotesque parts of his personality; but to at least some of his fans, Shady <em>was </em>Eminem.</p>
<p>And because Shady-as-Eminem rapped about things that happened to Eminem-as-Marshall, the boundary was always fragile. Both Kim and Eminem’s mother sued him over his lyrics, with Kim alleging the infliction of emotional distress and his mother alleging defamation; he settled out of court with both of them.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Test article</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2026/11/test-article/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Sarah Ditum</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Kim has never alleged that Eminem was violent to her in real life, but violence against women is endemic in hip-hop, including among Eminem’s collaborators. In 2015, Dr Dre — by then an executive with Apple — issued an apology “to all the women I’ve hurt” over allegations of abuse and assault against women. Where does that leave Eminem and the Slim Shady character who traded barbs with Dre about smacking bitches? The vibe had shifted away from the anarchism of the Noughties. People were starting to ask things like: <a href="https://eu.usatoday.com/story/life/music/2014/11/25/eminem-shady-xv-misogyny-violence/19444645/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“Why are Eminem&#8217;s violent lyrics still OK?”</a></p>
<p>Nearly 10 years later, it feels pop culture has reached the end of its censorious swing. The industrial centres of wokescolding — <em>Gawker</em>, <em>Vice</em>, pre-Elon Twitter — have all been kneecapped. Performers are tired of feeling stifled. In a recent interview, <a href="https://theface.com/music/charli-xcx-interview-new-album-xcx6-vol-4-issue-18" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Charli XCX</a> — a pop star who definitely does not come across as Right-coded, and is thoroughly embraced by queer culture — expressed nostalgia for “the Paris Hilton days. Everybody is so worried about everything right now, how they’re perceived, if this art they’ve created is going to offend anyone.”</p>
<p>The conceit of “Houdini” is that Shady’s back because he’s needed, but if anything, the Shady comeback is slightly too late. “If I think that shit, I’ma say that shit/ Cancel me what?” Eminem raps. But this isn’t 2016 or 2020. Cancellation feels like a much more remote threat, if it ever was a threat for someone with Eminem’s fan base and stature. As strong as the track is, the jabs at outrage feel like feints this time. <span style="font-weight: 400;">Nicki Minaj has already done stronger stuff about Megan thee Stallion being shot; David Chappelle was joking about R Kelly’s abuses 20 years ago. It’s harder for Shady to shock the breath out of listeners the way he used to. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">But however tired the Shady character becomes, he can’t die. That’s partly because the forces that made him still exist: the angry, alienated boys he appealed to in the noughties have grown into angry, alienated men. At 52, you could say Eminem is too old for this kind of crass rebellion. But the average capitol rioter was middle aged. The soup throwers of Extinction Rebellion are mostly grey haired. Rage doesn’t appear to have an age limit. And the white underclass of America that Eminem came from abides, neglected equally by Republicans and Democrats more attracted to culture wars than economics. As ever, Eminem is only giving the discourse what it’s asked for. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">There’s another reason Shady will probably always be with us, though. When Eminem first put on the character, it was a mask that allowed him to cover up his vulnerabilities: under the aggression and gore, he’s also been the bullied kid, the opioid addict (now recovered), the father striving to make a living for his daughter’s sake. But the character made him famous, and fame, in John Updike’s phrase, is the mask that eats the face. “I’ve created a monster/ ’Cause nobody wants to see Marshall no more, they want Shady, I’m chopped liver/ Well, if you want Shady, this is what I’ll give ya,” he announced on “Without Me” in 2002. There’s menace in that line, but a kind of tragedy too: you can’t destroy your double without destroying yourself.</span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/eminem-has-lost-his-superpower/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/eminem-has-lost-his-superpower/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/eminem-has-lost-his-superpower/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">604620</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>America&#8217;s most embarrassing man</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/americas-most-embarrassing-man/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/americas-most-embarrassing-man/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/GettyImages-905021290.jpg?w=489</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Weekend culture</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kat Rosenfield]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Thumbnail-Example-1-2.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[A fabulist and a fool. Earl Gibson III/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Kat Rosenfield </strong>is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>katrosenfield</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sat, 11 May 2024 23:05:26 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Sun, 12 May 2024 03:32:42 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Jussie Smollett]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=498293</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Jussie Smollett isn't charismatic, he's just cringe]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Spring, the season of rebirth, is as good a moment as any to review the second lives of the formerly cancelled. Some are faring better than others: Louis C.K., for one, is fully back in business, albeit after taking a multi-million dollar financial hit for his masturbatory scandal circa 2017. Roseanne Barr, who lost her TV series over a racist (and allegedly Ambien-induced) tweet is now a moderately successful podcaster, as well as a cast member on a new, &#8220;anti-woke&#8221; <a href="https://www.newsweek.com/adam-carolla-premiers-new-anti-woke-show-roseanne-barr-megyn-kelly-1898158">animated series</a> from <em>The Daily Wire</em>. Shane Gillis, fired from <em>Saturday Night Live</em> over offensive comments, was welcomed back to the stage as host this year, a sure sign that all was forgiven.</p>
<p>These are the success stories, the comebacks, the triumphs over adversity. But then, in a category all his own, there&#8217;s Jussie Smollett.</p>
<p>Smollett was initially moderately famous as a TV actor on the Fox network show <em>Empire</em>, where he&#8217;d been a regular cast member for five seasons from 2014. But then, in 2019, he shot to global infamy as the perpetrator of a hoax hate crime — one that has remained vivid in our collective memory not just because of its sensationally improbable narrative, but because Smollett refuses to let us forget.</p>
<p>It was a brutally cold night in Chicago, in January, when two white men allegedly assaulted Smollett after recognising him on the street at 2am. In the actor&#8217;s telling, they beat him, threw a noose around his neck, poured bleach over his head, and screamed, &#8220;This is MAGA country!&#8221;, before fleeing into the night.</p>
<p>It later emerged that Smollett had staged the attack with the specific intent of having it captured by a nearby security camera and creating a storm with it on social media (the tragic cherry on top of this whole sordid affair: the camera was pointed in the wrong direction). But at the time, the combination of a hate-crime narrative plus a MAGA hat-wearing villain stroked every confirmation bias that progressive pundits and politicians had.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;He is no mere transgressor, nor a mere grifter; he&#8217;s a fabulist.&#8221;</div>
<p>There was an outpouring of support, including from then-senators Kamala Harris and Cory Booker. And the narrative, at least in Left-leaning spaces, settled somewhere in the vicinity of “this just goes to show what life is like for a gay black man in Donald Trump’s America”; which, once the truth emerged that Smollett’s attackers were in fact a pair of Nigerian brothers whom he’d hired to attack him, was swiftly retooled by Smollett’s supporters into a “nevertheless, my original point still stands” argument about how the fact they were fooled was surely proof of rampant racism in its own right.</p>
<p>Many careers and reputations fell to pieces in those heady final years of the Trump administration, when cancel culture was at its peak. But Smollett’s downfall is unique by comparison. He doesn’t quite fit the mould of the Hollywood bad-boy type whose delinquent or attention-seeking behaviour has resulted in criminal charges. He is no mere transgressor, nor a mere grifter; he&#8217;s a fabulist, which places him at a unique crossroads in the American cultural imagination. For those shameless enough to really commit to the bit, being an audacious liar can command a certain grudging respect. Consider P.T. Barnum, Frank Abagnale, even Donald Trump — each of them an icon in his own right, and all of them utterly full of shit.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/why-ozempic-is-cheating/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/why-ozempic-is-cheating/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-483485664-scaled.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/why-ozempic-is-cheating/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/why-ozempic-is-cheating/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why Ozempic is cheating</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/why-ozempic-is-cheating/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kat Rosenfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Could Smollett have made himself into one of these, doubling down on his fabricated tale of victimhood with the same brazenness with which Trump continues to hammer the &#8220;stolen election&#8221; narrative? In this paradigm, the sheer ludicrousness of the story would even have been a selling point, and at least some people seem to have been ready to buy in: when Smollett was convicted on five counts of felony disorderly conduct, Black Lives Matter released a statement referring to the entire trial as &#8220;a white supremacist charade&#8221;, writing: &#8220;We can never believe police… over Jussie Smollett, a Black man who has been courageously present, visible, and vocal in the struggle for Black freedom.&#8221;</p>
<p>But this coping strategy was not adopted by the majority, for whom the entire thing was, if not forgotten, then very intentionally not discussed. Far from elevating Smollett to folk hero status a la Barnum or Trump, his initial supporters rapidly dispersed. Tweets were quietly deleted, and follow-up statements given grudgingly if at all. Smollett disappeared from the cast of <em>Empire</em>, and the show was cancelled the following season.</p>
<p>At the time of Smollett&#8217;s conviction — nearly two years after the story first broke — Wilfred Reilly <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/how-jussie-smolletts-hoax-unravelled/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">wrote</a> in <em>UnHerd</em> that the case revealed &#8220;an uncomfortable truth about race in America: that the constant exaggeration, or even invention, of incidents of bias by activists and media members is probably a bigger problem than the residual violent racism that still exists&#8221;.</p>
<p>Today, this seems truer than ever, in that the primary emotion aroused by Smollett among his former supporters is profound embarrassment. It also may explain why Smollett seems to have little hope of ever working again — if he even wants to, which is also an open question. For the past five years, the actor&#8217;s bandwidth has been largely consumed by the doomed project of sticking to his story, to insist on the ending he planned (and paid) for instead of the one he got. He continues to deny any wrongdoing and apparently intends to appeal his conviction all the way to the Supreme Court. These efforts may be understandable in a sunk-cost sort of way, but they are also having the opposite of their intended effect: the more he struggles to free himself from the mire of his infamy, the deeper he sinks, and the less sympathetic he becomes. Donald Trump, he is not.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/why-did-we-forgive-oj-simpson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/why-did-we-forgive-oj-simpson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/GettyImages-83095954-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/why-did-we-forgive-oj-simpson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/why-did-we-forgive-oj-simpson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why did we forgive OJ Simpson?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/why-did-we-forgive-oj-simpson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kat Rosenfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>In a parallel-universe, Smollett might have come clean, apologised, and paid restitution as soon as it became clear that his story was bullshit — and after a few dutiful weeks of mockery, we would all moved on to the next thing. In this alternative reality, Smollett is still working; <em>Empire</em> might even be still running. Despite that F. Scott Fitzgerald quote about there being no second acts in American lives, the reality of American culture is that we love a good comeback, even, or maybe even especially, after the most humiliating public misstep.</p>
<p>But you have to take your lumps, first, in a way that Smollett has categorically refused to do. His original, much-criticised plea deal eventually fell apart precisely because it included no admission of guilt. His conviction at trial, too, could have been avoided if he&#8217;d just owned up to the fabrication. Indeed, however embarrassing the hoax was, it has long since been eclipsed by the cringe-worthy spectacle of Smollett still insisting it happened.</p>
<p>All of this is to Smollett&#8217;s detriment — if for no other reason than that it&#8217;s to the embarrassment of powerful people whose support he would need most if he wanted to come back. This is what sets the actor apart from someone like Roseanne Barr or Louis C.K., but also someone like Barnum or Trump: in allowing himself to be made foolish, he made fools of his allies, too, duping them into the role of supporting actors in an offensive farce. If he&#8217;d been more charismatic, maybe he could have gotten away with this — or if he&#8217;d been more apologetic, perhaps he could have been forgiven. But his actual path, the third way, is the worst of both worlds: Smollett diligently continues to spin his wild tale of victimhood, playing the role of the brazen showman… but to an empty house.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/americas-most-embarrassing-man/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/americas-most-embarrassing-man/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/americas-most-embarrassing-man/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">498293</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>America&#8217;s censors have committed their Guernica</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/americas-censors-have-committed-their-guernica/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/americas-censors-have-committed-their-guernica/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/GettyImages-57597400-e1711628248590.jpg?w=606</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Censored</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kat Rosenfield]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Thumbnail-Example-1-2.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[(Chris Hondros/Getty Images)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Kat Rosenfield </strong>is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>katrosenfield</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Fri, 29 Mar 2024 00:02:31 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 29 Mar 2024 00:02:31 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Censorship]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Israel]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Media]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=494532</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The culture war was won years ago]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>America’s cultural mood calls to mind a bunch of people tentatively peering out from their hiding places in the aftermath of a torrential hailstorm. Is it over? Can we come out now? Are we still cancelling each other to death, or has the vibe finally shifted?</p>
<p>In recent months, people who lost their jobs amid this or that spasm of ideological intolerance have <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/02/tom-cotton-new-york-times/677546/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">begun to reappear</a> in places where they would have been previously blackballed, telling stories that sound like modern-day versions of <em>The Crucible</em>, except much stupider. The memoir of #MeToo hero <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/how-metoo-became-too-cringe-for-america/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Christine Blasey Ford</a> was released last week to surprisingly little fanfare, while a <em>NYMag</em> exposé of womanising podcaster <a href="https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/andrew-huberman-podcast-stanford-joe-rogan.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Andrew Huberman</a> — which only a few years ago might have resulted in the boycotting and deplatforming of the man in question — made barely a dent in the discourse. Brands that went all in on social justice are now quietly — and in some cases, desperately — distancing themselves from the excesses of the era. Even the painfully hip young progressives who run Biden’s social-media channels have stopped using inane terms like Latinx, and resumed posting like normal people, or close enough.</p>
<p>And yet, there is also a sense that we cannot pull back from the edge, particularly in the rarefied spaces where high culture is made. Consider this month’s imbroglio at the literary journal <em>Guernica</em>, which lost virtually all its volunteer staff in a wave of mass resignations following the publication of an essay by writer and translator Joanna Chen. Titled &#8220;From the Edges of a Broken World&#8221;, it described Chen&#8217;s complicated and conflicted relationship with her adopted country of Israel — to which she immigrated at the age of 16 after the death of her brother — in the wake of the October 7 attacks that left 1,400 people dead, and the retaliatory bombing by Israel which augmented that number by tens of thousands more. Within days of the essay&#8217;s publication, <em>Guernica</em>&#8216;s co-publisher and nearly a dozen editors <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/12/arts/guernica-magazine-staff-quits-israel.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">announced</a> that they were resigning in objection, accusing Chen of trying to &#8220;soften the violence of colonialism and genocide&#8221;. The magazine unpublished the essay with apologies, although apologies for <em>what</em> remains unclear; a &#8220;more fulsome explanation&#8221; for the retraction was promised but has yet to appear, and the magazine&#8217;s <a href="https://www.guernicamag.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">website</a> has not been updated in weeks.</p>
<p>It&#8217;s hard to understand how someone could read Chen&#8217;s words and see a woman who is &#8220;speaking for power&#8221;, and blind to the plight of the Palestinians, let alone defending genocide. &#8220;There is a limit to which the human soul can stomach atrocities and keep going,&#8221; she writes, in a paragraph that mentions both the October 7 slaughter by Hamas terrorists and the ongoing massacre in Gaza. The essay, which has since been <a href="https://washingtonmonthly.com/2024/03/18/from-the-edges-of-a-broken-world/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">republished</a> by <em>Washington Monthly</em>, is interspersed with lines of poetry by Palestinian writers, people Chen knows personally from having translated their work, and also describes her ongoing work as a volunteer driving Palestinian children to Israeli hospitals. But of course, most of the essay&#8217;s fiercest critics didn&#8217;t read it, at least not comprehensively — and of course, not reading it was exactly what they wanted everyone else to do. That&#8217;s the thing about censors: they don&#8217;t really care what you&#8217;re saying. They just want to stop you from saying it.</p>
<p>In truth, the most interesting thing about <em>Guernica</em>&#8216;s collapse is how familiar its contours seem. The substance of the controversy changes, but its shape remains the same. There was the cherry-picking of one allegedly offensive line — in this case, Chen grimacing as a friend tried to comfort her children by describing the sounds of rocket fire as &#8220;good booms&#8221; — which was then repeated ad nauseam, like a magic password that allowed critics to condemn the essay while bypassing any actual engagement with its content. A <a href="https://twitter.com/nkulw/status/1767918142930788571" target="_blank" rel="noopener">search</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/LailaAlarian/status/1768244142709023198" target="_blank" rel="noopener">for the</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/mariskreizman/status/1767919997710430255" target="_blank" rel="noopener">phrase</a> &#8220;good booms&#8221; on X is an illuminating, if depressing, reminder that what you cannot bring yourself to read charitably you will also inevitably struggle to comprehend — and that even the most literate among us are not above pretending, for the sake of tribal signalling, to have the intellectual capacity of a turnip.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“The most interesting thing about Guernica&#8217;s collapse is how familiar its contours seem.&#8221;</div>
<p>But of course, this was just step one; eventually, and particularly if a backlash has begun to brew, the censors will pivot to a litany of secondary indictments: a lack of oversight by the editor (&#8220;A rigorous editorial process might have produced something worth reading!&#8221;), an error in the publication process (&#8220;Only one editor saw it!&#8221;), the quality of the censored work (&#8220;It&#8217;s not even good!&#8221;).</p>
<p>For those of us who come to these debates based on a sincere and principled commitment to free expression, this rhetorical barrage is disorienting; it&#8217;s like being invited to a scrimmage only to find your opponent repeatedly picking up the goalposts and carrying them all over the field, jeering at you over their shoulders for wanting to play in the first place. It would be almost hilariously bewildering, if it weren&#8217;t so damned bleak. The journal editors who are supposed to be the custodians of the literature that allows us to know ourselves, our world, and each other — people who spend their lives bewailing the dangers of book bans from the Right — become a pack of sneering authoritarian bullies when confronted by work that dares to empathise with anyone but their chosen side. The artists who are supposed to be our truth-tellers, our rule-breakers, whine that a story wasn&#8217;t subject to <em>proper editorial process,</em> like a snotty bureaucrat sending you to the back of the line because you didn&#8217;t properly fill out Section 320A of Form 981 at the DMV.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/how-metoo-became-too-cringe-for-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/how-metoo-became-too-cringe-for-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/GettyImages-1041745222.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/how-metoo-became-too-cringe-for-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/how-metoo-became-too-cringe-for-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How MeToo became too cringe for America</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/how-metoo-became-too-cringe-for-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kat Rosenfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>It doesn&#8217;t matter if the story was good; it doesn&#8217;t even matter what the story was about. Anyone who cares about art, and especially the ones who care about it enough to make it, knows this for the cringing, callow conformity it is. It is — or at least, it <em>should</em> be — utterly beneath us.</p>
<p>A common criticism of Israel is that, in its treatment of the Palestinians, the country has become the thing it once hated. This seems too facile to adequately describe the complexities of a conflict thousands of years old, in which all parties involved have suffered, and struggled, and spilled the blood of others as surely as others have spilled their own. But it could perhaps describe the current state of the arts in America, in this moment of absolute hegemony by the Left in every place where culture is produced — and in which the flag of the progressive cause can be found <a href="https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/biden-hosts-pride-month-celebration-at-white-house-voices-lgbtq-support" target="_blank" rel="noopener">literally</a><a href="https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/biden-hosts-pride-month-celebration-at-white-house-voices-lgbtq-support" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> flying</a> over everything from corporate headquarters to the White House.</p>
<p>We call this a &#8220;culture war&#8221;, but in truth, it feels like that war has been over for some time, and that the <em>Guernica</em> controversy is just the latest flex by a regime that has been in power for over a decade. Consider how long we&#8217;ve lived in thrall to the shrieking, puritan mode of cultural critique first advanced on the <a href="https://www.vice.com/en/article/mvnkpv/brief-look-back-at-your-fave-is-problematic" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Your Fave Is Problematic</a> Tumblr. Consider how long we&#8217;ve been policing books and films for &#8220;harmful tropes&#8221;, or obsessing about the racial makeup of the Oscar nominees. Consider that it was 2017 when progressive folk hero Roxane Gay effectively torpedoed HBO&#8217;s <em>Confederate</em>, an alternate-history drama led by Game of Thrones showrunners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss, by <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/25/opinion/hbo-confederate-slavery-civil-war.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">calling</a> it &#8220;slavery fanfiction&#8221; in the pages of the <em>New York Times</em>.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/is-black-trauma-porn-over/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/is-black-trauma-porn-over/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Screenshot-2024-03-05-at-17.50.1.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/is-black-trauma-porn-over/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/is-black-trauma-porn-over/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Is black trauma porn over?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/is-black-trauma-porn-over/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kat Rosenfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>I often think about <em>Confederate</em>. Who knows: maybe the concept was, if not slavery fanfiction, too flawed to pull off. Maybe it would have been in truly bad taste. But maybe it would have been interesting, or provocative, or even great — and we&#8217;ll never know.</p>
<p>This, too, is the thing about censorship: at its worst, it isn&#8217;t just about one book, one film, one painting going up in flames. At its worst, it yanks the paintbrush from the artist&#8217;s hand before he&#8217;s painted a single stroke, all for fear of what he might create. It&#8217;s why, even now, it still seems so strange and terrible to me that so many of these avid censors are often artists themselves. The one-time counterculturalists who overthrew the scolds of the Moral Majority, ascending into power through the sheer audacity of their art, their stories, their songs — how long did it take before these same people started using their newfound influence to silence the voices of the artists <em>they</em> didn&#8217;t like? A year? Five years? Was it always going to be thus?</p>
<p>Maybe. What matters, I think, is that we are fully living on the other side of that moment, and have been for a while. The spasms of the past few years, whatever you want to call them — wokeness, cancel culture, something else — were not a power struggle, but the aftermath of one: the part where the winner shows his strength and supremacy by stamping his boot on the faces of the losers, not forever, but certainly until everyone knows exactly who&#8217;s in charge.</p>
<p>Seen this way, what happened at <em>Guernica</em> is simply what has been happening. Not a revolt from below, but a reminder from above of who holds the power, the influence, and the censor&#8217;s pen in their hot little hands. That <em>Guernica</em> has published nothing since the meltdown over Chen&#8217;s essay seems less like accidental fallout, and more like things going exactly as planned.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/americas-censors-have-committed-their-guernica/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/americas-censors-have-committed-their-guernica/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/03/americas-censors-have-committed-their-guernica/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">494532</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>In defence of grumpy old men</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/in-defence-of-grumpy-old-men/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/in-defence-of-grumpy-old-men/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-590718112-e1707328050717.jpg?w=566</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Publishing wars</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kat Rosenfield]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Thumbnail-Example-1-2.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Otto Penzler, centre. (Jimi Celeste/Patrick McMullan via Getty Images)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Kat Rosenfield </strong>is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>katrosenfield</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 08 Feb 2024 00:01:36 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 08 Feb 2024 00:01:36 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[#MeToo]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Euro 2024]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Identity politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Joe Biden]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Publishing]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=498415</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The publishing world needs cantankerous codgers]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>In every culture, in every era, you will find the archetype of the cantankerous old man. He&#8217;s ubiquitous in cinema — the aged, scowling hero of <em>Gran Torino</em>; the feuding codgers of <em>Grumpy Old Men</em>; the dementia-stricken patriarch of <em>The Father</em> — but no less so in real life, where you can find him parked in an easy chair on the shady side of the porch, yelling at the neighbourhood kids to get off his lawn. He can be a comic figure or a tragic one, an object of respect or ridicule, but you ignore him at your peril. The next American president, after all, will be a cantankerous old man. We just have to decide if we want the one with the spray tan and the multiple felony indictments, or the one who recently confused the current French president <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2024/02/06/biden-confuses-emmanuel-macron-francois-mitterrand/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">with the one who died in 1996</a>.</p>
<p>Some old men lose their edge as they age, while others develop a sharper one. Otto Penzler, the white-haired proprietor of the storied Mysterious Bookshop in New York City, would seem to be the latter. Now 81, Penzler is a polarising figure within the mystery writing community, the kind of person whose name elicits either a grin or a wince. In addition to building from scratch the biggest mystery bookshop in the world, he has edited dozens of mystery novels and anthologies and overseen multiple publishing imprints. At the height of his power, a good word from Penzler could make a writer&#8217;s career.</p>
<p>But his good words, his critics note, were reserved largely for white, male, heterosexual writers — and Penzler has a reputation for being less than reverent about the sacred cows of his more progressive peers. In 1991, he publicly criticised the women&#8217;s mystery writer&#8217;s group Sisters in Crime in an interview with the <a href="https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1991-12-08-9104200811-story.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Chicago Tribune</em></a>: &#8220;It’s a negative, flawed concept. It’s an organization that espouses non-sexism but is sexist.&#8221; In 2005, he <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20050428231710/http:/www.thebookstandard.com/bookstandard/news/author/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1000901810" target="_blank" rel="noopener">described</a> cosy mysteries as &#8220;not serious literature&#8221;, adding: &#8220;Men take [writing] more seriously as art.&#8221; More recently, he excoriated the Mystery Writers of America after the organisation, under pressure, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/28/nyregion/linda-fairstein-central-park-5.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">rescinded</a> its plans to honour mystery novelist and former prosecutor Linda Fairstein with a &#8220;Grand Master&#8221; award for literary achievement. (This was part of a broader campaign to cancel Fairstein over her role in prosecuting the Central Park Five, spurred by a Netflix series that portrayed her as the case&#8217;s chief villain; a defamation <a href="https://nypost.com/2023/09/20/netflix-ordered-to-face-defamation-lawsuit-by-central-park-five-prosecutor/">lawsuit</a> brought by Fairstein against the series&#8217; creators is currently making its way through the courts.)</p>
<p>Among those who dislike him, these incidents are seen as damning evidence in favour of Penzler&#8217;s defenestration. A recent X <a href="https://twitter.com/JamesDFHannah/status/1753160471304138764" target="_blank" rel="noopener">thread</a>, prompted by his upcoming appearance at a mystery event called Bouchercon, bemoans his continued influence despite what the author describes as his &#8220;terrible opinions and inexcusable behavior&#8221; — although the behaviour in question, as I discovered in the course of reporting this piece, is more a matter of rumour than record. For those who remember the MeToo-era debacle of the Shitty Media Men list, it&#8217;s character assassination via whisper network: people will tell you that there are <em>stories</em>, but plead ignorance when asked to relate one. Penzler&#8217;s status as a Bad Man is entirely vibes-based. A snub here, a brusque comment there. Once, perhaps, there was a confrontation with a female critic who had panned a book written by one of Penzler&#8217;s friends, after she showed up uninvited to a party at his bookstore.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-martyring-of-scott-adams/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-martyring-of-scott-adams/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/SCOTT-ADAMS-.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-martyring-of-scott-adams/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-martyring-of-scott-adams/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The martyring of Scott Adams</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-martyring-of-scott-adams/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kat Rosenfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Penzler told me he doesn&#8217;t remember this incident, but admits that it&#8217;s in the realm of possibility. &#8220;Did I possibly call her a bitch, yes. Because she was,&#8221; he says, mildly — and if a comment like this makes you leap up in outrage, you are almost certainly not a person who would enjoy Penzler&#8217;s company. He&#8217;s friendly but blunt, impatient with foolishness, and — as he is the first to note — his personality doesn&#8217;t always play well in a world where people increasingly expect a soft touch.</p>
<p>When I first stumbled across that X thread, it initially struck me as no different from a hundred other minor publishing squabbles: the tiniest of tempests in the teensiest of teapots. But look through the lens of the zeitgeist, and there&#8217;s something intriguing here: an evolving and increasingly fraught relationship between the archetypal codger and a culture that no longer reveres him. We used to extend some grace to society&#8217;s granddads, acknowledging the possibility that a person old enough to have watched the moon landing live on TV might reasonably, if not wisely, see things differently from the strident 25-year-olds among us. But that grace has been replaced by a conviction that such opinions aren&#8217;t just embarrassing in an &#8220;old man yells at cloud&#8221; sort of way, but intolerable, harmful, toxic — and that a person who holds them needs to either get with the times, or be ostracised from polite society.</p>
<p>Mystery writing, like the rest of publishing, has undergone a reckoning in recent years — and what the diversity activists want is nothing less than a metaphorical asteroid hit, an extinction-level event that clears out the pale-male-stale old guard, and ushers in a colourful new world order. There&#8217;s just one problem: metaphorical asteroids, unlike their physical analogue, don&#8217;t actually kill the dinosaurs. And while it&#8217;s one thing to campaign for the ouster of dead white men from their various places of honour in the sciences, or the arts, or atop the lists of history&#8217;s greatest works of literature, it&#8217;s quite another to be confronted with <em>live</em> white men — men who&#8217;ve worked hard all their lives to get where they are, who do not agree that they have outlived both their relevance and respectability, and who are not about to slink off into obscurity just because the passage of time and the sensibilities of a new generation have rendered both their identities and opinions unpopular.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/why-must-we-demonise-the-male-gaze/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/why-must-we-demonise-the-male-gaze/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/GettyImages-652062315-1-1-e1692810721502.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/why-must-we-demonise-the-male-gaze/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/why-must-we-demonise-the-male-gaze/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Forgive my male gaze</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/why-must-we-demonise-the-male-gaze/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Howard Jacobson</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>This all-encompassing presentism, in which every person must be judged by his worse offences against the pieties of the Current Thing, has found an even easier target than our oldest living citizens: those who are recently dead. It’s a phenomenon that makes for some interesting reads in the newspaper&#8217;s obituary section. &#8220;Herman Cain, a former Republican presidential candidate and supporter of President Donald Trump who pointedly refused to wear a mask during the coronavirus pandemic, has died after contracting COVID-19,&#8221; <a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKCN24V2OH/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">reported</a> Reuters in 2020, while a <em>New York Times</em> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/08/us/politics/james-watt-dead.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">obituary</a> for former Interior Secretary James Watt informs readers that he &#8220;insulted Black people, women, Jews and disabled people&#8221;, before it describes his life or contribution to politics. As the writer Oliver Traldi <a href="https://x.com/olivertraldi/status/1752028835422630115?s=46&amp;t=69AV9qA7xHjecqhrTp9K2Q" target="_blank" rel="noopener">quipped</a>, &#8220;before you read about this man&#8217;s life, let&#8217;s precisely calibrate your sense of to what extent he was on the right side of history as conceived by readers of this absolute rag in the current year&#8221;.</p>
<p>Meanwhile, some progressives have taken it as an article of faith that we cannot wait anymore for these living relics to exit the world&#8217;s stage; we have to just push them out of the way. This sentiment was palpable in the MeTooings of people like Garrison Keillor, Al Franken, Leon Wieseltier, and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/22/opinion/langella-netflix-metoo.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Frank Langella</a>, as well as the ouster of older white men from positions of influence in <a href="https://airmail.news/issues/2024-1-20/i-have-a-history-of-getting-in-trouble-by-speaking-my-mind" target="_blank" rel="noopener">media</a>, the <a href="https://hyperallergic.com/576369/gary-garrels-resigns-sfmoma/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">arts</a>, and more during the Covid-era Awokening. Even if you didn&#8217;t necessarily think these guys had done much — or anything — wrong, there was a sense that perhaps they should just go away on principle, for the sake of the cause. Hadn&#8217;t they been in power long enough? Wasn&#8217;t it time for them to step aside, and give someone else a turn?</p>
<p>On this front, Otto Penzler makes for an interesting case study: in 2021, he was fired from the Best American Mystery anthology series he&#8217;d edited since 1997, and replaced by editor Steph Cha, a young Korean-American novelist with whom he had butted heads over the MWA&#8217;s treatment of Linda Fairstein. In most situations like this, the outgoing editor is expected to go quietly, perhaps releasing an unctuous statement about the importance of making way for a new, more diverse generation of writers. Penzler, on the other hand, immediately launched a competing anthology that sold so well it currently stands at #13 in its category on Amazon. &#8220;We buried them,&#8221; Penzler says — a statement which, though difficult to truly quantify, seems roughly accurate: the 2021 edition of The Best American Mystery and Suspense, the first in 24 years not edited by him, is ranked #1312.</p>
<p>You come at the curmudgeon, you best not miss.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/has-fuccboi-killed-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/has-fuccboi-killed-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/29780316395014-1-scaled-1.jpg?w=199" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/has-fuccboi-killed-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/has-fuccboi-killed-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Has Fuccboi killed literature?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/has-fuccboi-killed-literature/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Ann Manov</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Of course in a previous, and perhaps less ridiculous, era, this disagreement — Penzler&#8217;s opinion of cosy mysteries and the mystery community&#8217;s opinion of Penzler — would be chalked up to a matter of taste. There was a time when it was possible to merely dislike someone, for whatever reason, without claiming that your personal animus was actually rooted in a bigger, braver struggle against oppression and isms and phobias. There was also a time when inviting a man to speak at a conference in his chosen field was understood as a narrow acknowledgment of that man&#8217;s achievements and expertise, rather than an endorsement by the organisers of his every opinion. Perhaps most important, there was a time when reasonable people would have agreed that if you are still citing the less-than-articulate comment someone made to a newspaper 33 years ago as a top 10 reason to destroy his reputation, you are engaged not in the advancement of social justice but a bizarre personal vendetta.</p>
<p>But in this moment, in which every personal beef is blown up into a proxy war for the ideological soul of the nation — or, in this case, the mystery writing community — the grumpy old men among us are seen less as human beings than reactionary avatars, a blight on progress. The result is a remarkably aesthetic-driven notion of what the proper distribution of power would look like, as with Joe Biden&#8217;s 2022 <a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/us/retiring-us-justice-breyer-appear-with-biden-white-house-2022-01-27/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">vow</a> to consider only black female candidates as replacements for retiring Supreme Court justice Stephen Breyer, or the FAA&#8217;s strange <a href="https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/the-faas-hiring-scandal-a-quick-overview" target="_blank" rel="noopener">attempt</a> to stack the deck in favour of everyone <em>except</em> older white men in its hiring processes. But it also explains the furore surrounding someone like Penzler — who, despite his alleged disdain for women, has published, collaborated with, and championed scores of them over the years. This isn&#8217;t about the man himself, but what he represents: the bad old days, and bad old ways, which publishing&#8217;s self-appointed new guard have found dismayingly difficult to uproot. To get him booted from the Bouchercon stage would signal a shift in the power dynamic. It would mean that the asteroid had hit at last.</p>
<p>To fail to do this, on the other hand, would signal that the identitarian spasm in publishing — and whatever little power and credibility it once conveyed — is already on the wane. For the vibes, they are a-shiftin&#8217; — but the grumpy old man endures.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/in-defence-of-grumpy-old-men/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/in-defence-of-grumpy-old-men/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/in-defence-of-grumpy-old-men/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">489613</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>David Mamet on Hollywood, Hamas and Donald Trump</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/david-mamet-on-hollywood-hamas-and-donald-trump/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/david-mamet-on-hollywood-hamas-and-donald-trump/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/GettyImages-615382114-1-e1705665486851.jpg?w=648</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Flo Read]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Flo-Website.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['Hollywood is dead.' Ernesto Ruscio/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>is UnHerd&#8217;s <strong>Senior Producer and Presenter </strong>for UnHerd TV.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle></unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[for UnHerd TV.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 22 Jan 2024 00:00:34 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 22 Jan 2024 00:00:34 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[America]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Broadway]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hamas]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hollywood]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Israel]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=496773</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Hollywood is dead — and so is the American Left]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><strong>Pulitzer Prize-winning writer and director David Mamet has, in his own words, gone from a Hollywood veteran to “the hermit of Santa Monica”. Celebrated for his plays <em>American Buffalo</em>, <em>Glengarry Glen Ross</em>, and <em>Speed-the-Plow</em>, Mamet has dedicated his formidable energy to the culture war raging in La La Land. </strong></p>
<p><strong>To mark the release of his memoir, <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Everywhere-Oink-Embittered-Dyspeptic-Hollywood/dp/1668026317" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Everywhere an Oink Oink</em></a>, Florence Read spoke to Mamet about the death of storytelling, antisemitism in America and his zeal for Donald Trump. Here is a selection of his comments.</strong></p>
<div><div style="left: 0; width: 100%; height: 0; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.25%;"><iframe src="//cdn.iframe.ly/api/iframe?url=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2FAPre9AQ4Jo8&amp;key=357d953055da7177194e1a84a2d8a5a3&amp;playerjs=1" style="border: 0; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;" allowfullscreen scrolling="no" allow="encrypted-media; accelerometer; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; autoplay"></iframe></div></div>
&nbsp;
<p><strong>ON THEATRE:</strong></p>
<p>In addition to having a Director, they have a Managing Director, and the Director is now called the Artistic Director. What was he before, if it wasn&#8217;t artistic? [&#8230;] The theatre is not only dead, it stinks. [&#8230;] It&#8217;s “culture”, right? Nobody likes culture. It&#8217;s nonsense. Now we have political commissars who say, in addition to the Artistic Director, in addition to the Managing Director, we have to have a Director of Diversity, who&#8217;s on top of everything. And we&#8217;re all going to pay attention to this person who tells us, you don&#8217;t have enough black women in the play, or you don&#8217;t have enough trans people. Whether you&#8217;re black, or trans, or gay, you have the right to hear a story. If somebody&#8217;s not telling you a story, then that theatre stinks.</p>
<p><strong>ON AUDIENCES:</strong></p>
<p>Broadway had a huge audience that was largely middle class and Jewish. And they were people who worked and lived in the city. So the only plays that were put on were those that reflected their experience. They only endorsed the plays that reflected their experience. But all those people have moved away. There is no more audience in New York. So who comes? People from out of town. So the two things that they can see are either trash or filth. They can see pageants. I don&#8217;t want to go to Disneyland to see a thoughtful roller coaster. Right? I want to go to Disneyland for a thrill. So New York is now Disneyland. I don&#8217;t want to see a play which is thought provoking. What the hell do I care? I want to have either a thrill or a dog-treat. And the dog-treat is diversity. Please, tell me I&#8217;m not a racist. I&#8217;m not a transphobe. These people are shaking the audience down.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/12/the-self-delusion-of-secular-jews/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/12/the-self-delusion-of-secular-jews/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/GettyImages-630615052-1-e1701870501912.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/12/the-self-delusion-of-secular-jews/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/12/the-self-delusion-of-secular-jews/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The self-delusion of secular Jews</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/12/the-self-delusion-of-secular-jews/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> David Mamet</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><strong>ON CRITICS:</strong></p>
<p>Critics have always been a bunch of brainless whores.</p>
<p>The national press is completely co-opted — it&#8217;s Pravda. It&#8217;s absolutely Pravda. No one&#8217;s going to put on a play that&#8217;s not going to be approved by the press. And the press is there to approve the play. Right? What they&#8217;re doing is the equivalent of the Stalinist plays “Me and My Tractor”. One doesn&#8217;t have to worry about criticism, because nobody is going to put on a play which is not going to get a good review. And so what happens is the people on the Left enjoy having differences about minor points of doctrine. Because that makes them feel that they&#8217;re intellectually independent.</p>
<p><strong>ON POLITICS:</strong></p>
<p>In America, there&#8217;s no such thing as an independent voter. An independent voter is a liberal speech defect.</p>
<p>Western culture is completely bifurcated. What&#8217;s happening now is that the conservative side has said, “wait a second, what&#8217;s wrong with the Judeo-Christian ethic? What&#8217;s wrong with the laws? What&#8217;s wrong with judging people?” Martin Luther King said he had a dream that people would be judged by the content of their character rather than the colour of their skin. It was his dream and that dream came true to the largest extent. And then the wokists came in and said “no, we must judge people by the colour of their skin”. And the conservatives said, “you know what, I&#8217;d rather vote with Dr King”. The conservatives are done with the Left. We&#8217;re not looking for anything from the Left because there&#8217;s nothing there.</p>
<p><strong>ON CANCEL CULTURE:</strong></p>
<p>It&#8217;s called fascism. It&#8217;s my way or the highway. And cowardice is contagious, because we&#8217;re herd creatures. [&#8230;] So if everyone is saying “Jesus Christ, x, y, or z might limit my ability to get ahead, I&#8217;m gonna hold my tongue”, we start limiting the things we can say. And then because we don&#8217;t want to feel like hypocrites, we start limiting the things we think.</p>
<p>Relationships are broken off in Hollywood, people lose your number. Your manager, your agent, they just go away. That&#8217;s unfortunate. Hollywood is dead.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/will-hollywood-strike-back-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/will-hollywood-strike-back-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/GettyImages-78020524-1-e1696002491309.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/will-hollywood-strike-back-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/will-hollywood-strike-back-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Will Hollywood strike back?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/will-hollywood-strike-back-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> David Mamet</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><strong>ON HOLLYWOOD:</strong></p>
<p>It&#8217;s a phoney-baloney business. The movies have always been about putting images up on a bedsheet and selling popcorn. Right? The whole idea that there&#8217;s any sagacity in the movies is nonsense. There were a few magnificent works of art made in a hundred years, a whole bunch of really good movies and a lot of crap.</p>
<p><strong>ON FILM SCHOOL:</strong></p>
<p>Film school is warehousing. You learn nothing in film school. The only thing it fits you to do is to be an executive. Which is to say somebody who doesn&#8217;t know anything, hoping rather than to make a good movie to get the job that some other executive has. Because that&#8217;s what bureaucrats do.</p>
<p><strong>ON ISRAEL:</strong></p>
<p>If Hamas had not been voted in, Gaza would be the richest city in the world. It would be Singapore. What are the Jews doing to Gaza? Nothing. They said, take it. PS, they said, if you need medical help come across the border. PS, if you guys are gay, go to Tel Aviv, we&#8217;ll welcome you. We aren’t going to kill you, we’re glad to have your business. Gaza is at the end of the Mediterranean, and it&#8217;s right off the Suez Canal. It&#8217;s the most valuable real estate in the world. And they want to kill the Jews. It doesn&#8217;t make sense. The Jews are, and have always been, so happy to say: “For God&#8217;s sake, let&#8217;s be partners.” [&#8230;] The most diverse country in the world is Israel. And they want to kill it. Because it works. The answer is “from the river to the sea”. You all have to die.</p>
<p><strong>ON JUDAISM IN AMERICA:</strong></p>
<p>We were second-class citizens. We always existed at the mercy of the country. [&#8230;] So our answer was always to work harder. [&#8230;] We had to figure out a way to do the thing that nobody wanted to do, because that was the only thing that was left. A good example is family law. And a good example is the movies. Jews have always been outsiders. What always happens, going back to the fall of Jerusalem, is that when things get tough, people turn on the Jews. It&#8217;s the equivalent of kicking the cat or screaming at the secretary.</p>
<p>I don&#8217;t see the Jewish culture anymore. People got into the habit of going to the temple the same way they went to the dentist. [&#8230;] Go to an evangelical church, or go to a black Baptist church. Those people are praying to God ecstatically and with their whole hearts. So when you go back to these assimilated Jewish synagogues, it&#8217;s like taking a bath with your socks on and no water. They’ve got so effing woke. We don&#8217;t need some rabbi to tell us to be kind to black people.</p>
<p><strong>ON DONALD TRUMP:</strong></p>
<p>Trump was the best president since Abraham Lincoln. [&#8230;] He brought peace to the Middle East. He closed the border. He made us an energy exporter. He had the best rating among African Americans of any president ever. And the country was at peace and prosperous in the world. All of a sudden, he gets kicked out. And the world is a mess. But because the liberals cannot defend their position, all they can do is indict Trump. He&#8217;s not generating anger. He&#8217;s talking to reason.</p>
<p>He’s got a big mouth, so do I. The question is, who do you like in a fair fight with your back to the wall? Who would you rather have: Joe Biden, who&#8217;s a senile old bag-man, or Donald Trump, who’s a scrapper and loves his country.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-naked-persecution-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-naked-persecution-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/GettyImages-1479830181-1-1-e1680674765252-copy.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-naked-persecution-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-naked-persecution-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The naked persecution of Donald Trump</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-naked-persecution-of-donald-trump/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> David Mamet</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><strong>ON FREE SPEECH:</strong></p>
<p>I don&#8217;t think any speech should be banned. [&#8230;] And it&#8217;s my right to make up my mind about what you say. [&#8230;] The question is, who gets to say what counts as hate speech? That&#8217;s where the power is. [&#8230;] The most terrible thing in the world was the idea that there were certain crimes which are hate crimes. The question is not what did the person do, but what do we think about their motives in regard to certain societal norms which we have today. There&#8217;s no such thing as a love crime. All crimes are hate crimes, right?</p>
<p>If you gave me all the fame and power, it’s still poison, it’s tainted. In return for what? In return for my conscience, in return for my soul, in return for whatever it has pleased God to give me as a gift for making up stories. I say thank you. I&#8217;ll play these.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/david-mamet-on-hollywood-hamas-and-donald-trump/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/david-mamet-on-hollywood-hamas-and-donald-trump/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/david-mamet-on-hollywood-hamas-and-donald-trump/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">488719</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>We are all Mean Girls now</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/we-are-all-mean-girls-now/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/we-are-all-mean-girls-now/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/MV5BMGE2MDE0M2ItNWMzZi00YjAzLTljOWQtMDFmYjM1YTVlMWFmXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMjMzMDI4MjQ@._V1_.jpg?w=622</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kat Rosenfield]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Thumbnail-Example-1-2.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Regina George has finally won. (Mean Girls/IMDB)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Kat Rosenfield </strong>is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>katrosenfield</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Wed, 17 Jan 2024 00:01:46 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 17 Jan 2024 00:01:46 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Feminism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Victimhood]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Willy Wonka]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=496461</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Millennials understand the appeal of being a bully]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>In 1995, a girl named Emily Brown raised her hand during our pre-high school anti-bullying presentation. &#8220;Excuse me,&#8221; she said, smiling serenely at the guest speaker: &#8220;I think you should know, it&#8217;s just not like that in our class. We don&#8217;t bully people, and we don&#8217;t have cliques! People just have their own groups of friends, and I mean, it&#8217;s not like we can be friends with everyone.&#8221;</p>
<p>I have no idea what the presenter said in response. I was too busy having a flashback to a moment from gym class earlier that week: I&#8217;d been running laps around the soccer field when a gaggle of girls suddenly came up from behind and surrounded me, like a pride of lions circling a gazelle. One of them, the ringleader, took up a position just over my right shoulder. &#8220;Roses are red, violets are black, Rosenfield&#8217;s chest is as flat as her back,&#8221; she hissed — then drove an elbow into my ribs and laughed uproariously as I stumbled and faceplanted into the grass.</p>
<p>The girl who did this was, of course, Emily Brown.</p>
<p>The bully-in-denial is a recurring phenomenon in the work of Rosalind Wiseman, author of the 2002 parenting book <em>Queen Bees and Wannabes</em>. In her presentations on cliques and bullying, Wiseman would invariably be challenged by one girl who insisted that her services were not needed — and this, Wiseman explained, was your queen bee. &#8220;Without exception, three things will be true about this girl,&#8221; she wrote. &#8220;First, she&#8217;ll always be one of the meanest, most exclusive girls in the room; second, she honestly believes what she&#8217;s saying; and third, her parents will be in total denial about how mean she is and completely back her up.&#8221;</p>
<p><em>Queen Bees and Wannabes</em> was an insightful analysis of the brutal dynamics of what Wiseman calls &#8220;Girl World&#8221;, a land of ferocious intrasexual competition and social aggression. It was also the source material for the 2004 film <em>Mean Girls</em>, in which Tina Fey transformed Wiseman&#8217;s first-person research and parenting advice into a scathing satire of American teen social life in the Y2K era. The film entered the canon not only thanks to its comedy and quotability, but its familiarity to a millennial audience who had lived the dynamics Wiseman had documented, and still bore the scars of their own recent journeys through Girl World. I was 22 by the time the movie came out, but when the villainous Regina George stood up at her school&#8217;s anti-bullying assembly and said, &#8220;Can I just say that we don&#8217;t have a clique problem at this school? And some of us shouldn&#8217;t have to take this workshop, because some of us are just victims in this situation,&#8221; I cackled in recognition: <em>Oh my god, it&#8217;s Emily Brown</em>.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/how-the-nineties-are-haunting-millennials/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/how-the-nineties-are-haunting-millennials/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/the-crown-season-6-coming-to-netflix-november-december-2023.webp?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/how-the-nineties-are-haunting-millennials/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/how-the-nineties-are-haunting-millennials/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How the Nineties are haunting millennials</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/how-the-nineties-are-haunting-millennials/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kat Rosenfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>If <em>Mean Girls</em> was a hit in 2004 because it captured the darkly funny truth about how savage and Machiavellian the socially ambitious teenage girl can be, the new musical reboot of the movie hints at our increasingly uneasy relationship with that truth. Just as Disney has lately tried to complicate its fairytale villainesses by <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/05/villains-have-never-had-it-so-good/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">giving them sympathetic origin stories</a>, <em>Mean Girls</em> 2024 traffics in facile YASS-KWEEN-ing feminism that gives meanness an implicit pass. Here, Regina George is a victim of sexism rather than a powerful social terrorist in her own right. After all, the movie asks, would anyone have a problem with her horrible, grasping behaviour if she were a man?</p>
<p>In the original <em>Mean Girls</em> — as in Wiseman&#8217;s book, and as in life — Regina George&#8217;s weaselly claim to be one of the “victims in this situation” is exposed for the howler it is when Tina Fey&#8217;s character asks: &#8220;How many of you have ever felt personally victimised by Regina George?&#8221; (Every hand in the room goes up.) Not so in the 2024 version, where Regina&#8217;s denial goes unchallenged. Much like the velour sweatsuits sported by the original Plastics, the inclination of <em>Mean Girls</em> to hold young women accountable for their cruelty seems to have gone out of style, and even Wiseman&#8217;s original research is no longer received as the universally relatable truth it once was. The cruel and cunning young woman who wields gossip as a weapon isn&#8217;t just something you see in the movies; she&#8217;s a human constant that transcends social construct, a raceless, classless, timeless phenomenon. The truth is, anyone can be a mean girl — but this truth does not jive easily with a contemporary, highly identitarian discourse in which villainy is seen as the sole purview of the privileged. In one recent<em> New York Times</em> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/12/style/mean-girls-rosalind-wiseman.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">article</a>, a competing researcher dismisses Wiseman&#8217;s entire concept of the mean girl as racist, rooted in privilege, “a product of middle- to upper-class white girls”.</p>
<p>Personally, if I were the betting type, I&#8217;d wager my life savings that this researcher is one of Wiseman&#8217;s bullies-in-denial. But anyway: one can certainly see how for those who buy into this mode of cultural critique, <em>Mean Girls</em> becomes not just irrelevant but inscrutable. The oppressed-oppressor model sees no difference between the queen bee who rules with an iron fist, the sycophantic handmaidens who enable her reign, or the naive newbie who fears the queen bee&#8217;s meanness right up until the moment she exceeds it herself; they&#8217;re all cis, straight, able-bodied white women, so who cares?</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-tragedy-of-becoming-a-woman/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-tragedy-of-becoming-a-woman/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/GettyImages-1224709686-2-scaled-e1676311578620.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-tragedy-of-becoming-a-woman/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-tragedy-of-becoming-a-woman/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The tragedy of becoming a woman</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-tragedy-of-becoming-a-woman/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Sarah Ditum</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Perhaps for this reason, the new <em>Mean Girls</em> makes a cursory effort to be more <em>en vogue</em> and intersectional: the character of Janis, who masterminds the movie&#8217;s central plot to take down Regina George, is not only updated in this version with multiple marginalisations, but also given the film&#8217;s first, last, and best words, including a sorry-not-sorry showstopper of a solo that outright celebrates her scheming. This might be the biggest change from the original <em>Mean Girls</em>, which was strong on insight while sparing its audience the insult of heavy-handed moralising. The message now, and it&#8217;s not exactly subtle, is that it&#8217;s fine, even heroic, to manipulate the people around you and destroy someone&#8217;s life if you feel she&#8217;s mistreated you… just as long as you&#8217;re a gold medallist victim in the oppression Olympics.</p>
<p>Advertised as “not your mother&#8217;s <em>Mean Girls”</em>, the film is, in this way, utterly in keeping with the mores of the present moment — if not in the Girl World ruled by teenagers, then among the adult millennial women who now reproduce its contours in their personal and professional lives. Wiseman herself has now pivoted in her work to addressing the phenomenon of the grown-up mean girl; even in ostensibly feminist spaces, it&#8217;s not unusual to witness the utter social destruction of one woman by another, with the aggression deemed permissible just as long as it&#8217;s aimed at an acceptable target by an acceptable perpetrator.</p>
<p>The young adult literary world in which I began my career is no exception, as I found out first-hand seven years ago, when a fellow author began spreading a laughably false but incredibly damaging rumour about me through my personal and professional circles. When I publicly asked that she stop, I was informed that because I was white and she was not, pointing out her misbehaviour was bullying <em>her</em>. A queen bee looks different in 2024 from how she did 20 years ago, but the perks of accruing that level of social capital remain the same, including the freedom to designate certain people as losers and then mistreat them accordingly — all while blithely claiming that there&#8217;s nothing toxic about any of this at all.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/barbie-is-fight-club-for-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/barbie-is-fight-club-for-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/MV5BZTA1ZTBmYjQtYjRhOS00NWVlLWI2YWItYTE3YmQyOTYyYTAyXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMTUzMTg2ODkz._V1_-scaled-e1689766495961.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/barbie-is-fight-club-for-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/barbie-is-fight-club-for-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Barbie is Fight Club for women</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/barbie-is-fight-club-for-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kat Rosenfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>In this sense, the new <em>Mean Girls</em> both is and isn&#8217;t “your mother&#8217;s”. It&#8217;s not quite the same story, but it is the same idea — one that has evolved (I won’t say matured) alongside its core audience to give them what they want, over and over again. In 2004, the movie offered an unflinching and relatable portrayal of how girls acquire power by hurting each other on purpose. But when the tactics that allowed one to rule in Girl World are useful today to adult women who want to accrue real-world power, can we really indict them? The original <em>Mean Girls, </em>written in the age before social media, made it not just acceptable but socially lucrative to fight like a girl, but had the temerity to note that girl-on-girl social aggression is ultimately damaging to women as a class. The new movie takes a different view: it&#8217;s <em>good</em> to be the queen.</p>
<p>Part of the problem is that the new <em>Mean Girls</em> is a derivative of a musical that was a derivative of a film that was a derivative of a non-fiction parenting book, a copy of a copy of a copy that has lost its original sharpness; it has, to quote one reviewer, “mythologised the culture of gossip and backstabbing for a new generation”. In the public imagination, the queen bee has gone from an observable phenomenon to an archetype to a mythological figure. Soon, she&#8217;ll pass into legend; soon, people will forget she was ever real at all.</p>
<p>Mean girls? Pffft, that&#8217;s just an outdated stereotype, that&#8217;s white women&#8217;s nonsense, that&#8217;s not a thing that exists. In fact, can I just say: we don&#8217;t have a clique problem, and some of us shouldn&#8217;t have to take this workshop, because some of us are just victims in this situation.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/we-are-all-mean-girls-now/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/we-are-all-mean-girls-now/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/we-are-all-mean-girls-now/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">488549</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The rage behind Transgender Map</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-rage-behind-transgender-map/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-rage-behind-transgender-map/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/GettyImages-1515208979-1-e1700508411566.jpg?w=705</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Transgender</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Jesse Singal]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/singal.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[A Pride parade in London (Mark Kerrison/In Pictures via Getty Images)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Jesse Singal </strong>is the author of <em><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Quick-Fix-Psychology-Cant-Social/dp/0374239800" target="_blank" rel="noopener">The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can&#8217;t Cure Our Social Ills </a></em>and cohost of <a href="https://blockedandreported.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Blocked and Reported.</a> His Substack is <a href="https://jessesingal.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Singal-Minded</a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>jessesingal</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is the author of <em><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Quick-Fix-Psychology-Cant-Social/dp/0374239800" target="_blank" rel="noopener">The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Our Social Ills </a></em>and cohost of <a href="https://blockedandreported.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Blocked and Reported.</a> His Substack is <a href="https://jessesingal.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Singal-Minded</a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 21 Nov 2023 00:02:00 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 05 Aug 2024 08:53:48 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[autogynephilia]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Gender ideology]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Journalism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Media]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[none]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Transgender]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=491110</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[An activist media ecosystem enabled Andrea James]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Andrea James used to be a respectable, mainstream figure within the trans rights movement. A transgender woman herself, she was (and is) a film producer who carved out an important niche in the very early days of the internet: one of her sites <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/19990515000000*/https:/tsroadmap.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">dates back to 1999</a>. Her mission back then was uncontroversial, by today’s standards. She provided “a valuable resource for trans women and men navigating social, legal, and medical transition in the late 1990s and early 2000s” according to a veteran of trans activism, who knows James personally.</p>
<p>By the time I became aware of her, in 2014, she had become notorious in circles where sex research and journalism overlap. What appears to have curdled her is the work of Ray Blanchard, the sex researcher who proposed the theory of autogynephilia, which posits that some trans women are motivated to transition by sexual arousal at the thought of being a woman. It is seen by some trans people as offensive because, in their view, it pathologises and/or sexualises their identity. An apparently <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/askAGP/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">smaller group</a> of individuals, most famously <a href="https://www.annelawrence.com/autogynephilia_&amp;_MtF_typology.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Anne Lawrence</a>, believe it accurately describes their own experiences.</p>
<p>Back in the Noughties, Blanchard and the psychology professor J. Michael Bailey — who popularised Blanchard’s ideas in his 2003 book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Man-Would-Queen-Gender-Bending-Transsexualism/dp/0309084180" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Man Who Would Be Queen</em></a> — became the subjects of a smear campaign that, whatever one thinks of the theory, became abusive. Andrea James was one of the worst offenders. Her behaviour has been <a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2008-06871-004" target="_blank" rel="noopener">well-documented</a> by the medical historian and bioethicist Alice Dreger, who in a <a href="https://alicedreger.com/in_fear/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">2006 blog post</a> observed that “Ms. James was notable for the way she decided to go after Bailey’s children to extract revenge. She posted on the internet photographs of Bailey’s daughter and labeled her a ‘cock-starved exhibitionist.’”</p>
<p>After she published her blog post, Dreger described in an update how James sent a series of hostile emails, including one referring to her five-year-old son as a &#8216;precious womb turd&#8217;: &#8220;She also came to my departmental office (I was not there) and then emailed me, subject line &#8216;Mommy Knows Best,&#8217; saying, &#8216;Sorry I missed you the other day. Your colleagues seem quite affable, and not as fearful as you. […] Bad move, Mommy. […] We’ll chat in person soon&#8217;.&#8221;</p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">These incidents are described in more detail in Dreger’s book </span><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Galileos-Middle-Finger-Heretics-Activists/dp/0143108115" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Galileo’s Middle Finger</span></i></a><span style="font-weight: 400;">, published in 2015, by which point James’s influence appears to have waned. I began reporting on youth gender medicine around that time, and I didn&#8217;t get any sense that other prominent transactivists, or LGBT groups, took James seriously. Her name didn’t come up as someone you should talk to, if you wanted to better understand these issues. So why, a few years ago, did she experience a partial reversal in her fortunes?</span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/GettyImages-1245528886-1-e1681805956225.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The media is spreading bad trans science</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jesse Singal</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>It all started in 2018, when <em>The Atlantic </em><a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/07/when-a-child-says-shes-trans/561749" target="_blank" rel="noopener">published a cover story</a> about the debate over youth gender transition — written by me. The story included quotes from a number of people, including teens, who explained how profoundly transitioning had benefited them. However, it also included quotes from detransitioners, and dug into some of the controversy over youth transition. James was outraged that I would shine a light on the subject’s nuances, trade-offs and difficult questions. From some trans activists&#8217; points of view, it is settled science that youth gender medicine works — indeed, saves lives. To suggest otherwise is heresy.</p>
<p>Because of that view, plenty of people criticised the article, some harshly. But James’s response was something else. She was so outraged that she launched a Kickstarter called <a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/andreajames/the-transphobia-project" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“The Transphobia Project”</a>. It went live about a year after the publication of my article — which, in the FAQ section, she called “one of the most disgraceful moments in American journalism this century”, and credited with motivating her entire endeavour. As for the endeavour itself, she described it as “an interactive data visualization of the platforms and people creating biased content about gender identity and expression”. James explained how it would work: &#8220;Any time someone publishes media on these topics, a score called a t-index is generated for that work. That t-index also gets applied to the creator, any co-authors or editors, the platform where it appeared, and the organizations that support that platform. … Those with a high t-index become more prominent on the chart.&#8221;</p>
<p>And yet, nowhere on her Kickstarter does James clarify how her system would determine someone&#8217;s transphobia. Indeed, “appearing on the chart does not necessarily mean a person or organisation is transphobic.” In fact, if you look past the various buzzwords, it’s very hard to figure out what, exactly, the then-proposed project would <em>do</em>, other than show how various writers and editors are connected v<span style="font-weight: 400;">ia the publications they work for </span>(hardly a state secret). Yet despite the vagueness of The Transphobia Project’s actual, well, <em>project</em>, James enthuses on her fundraising appeal that it “will help us identify and expose bias, and maybe even get a few people fired along the way!”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/download-11-1-scaled.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why I stopped being a good girl</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Hadley Freeman</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>When The Transphobia Project’s Kickstarter launched, Donald Trump was still president, and liberal institutions were understandably preoccupied with his frequently ugly attempts to get journalists harassed and fired. James’s project didn’t hide the fact that it had similar goals, but, perhaps because James was going to target morally <em>bad</em> journalists for harassment and firing, rather than morally <em>good</em> ones, a cohort of progressives decided to hold her up as a champion in the noble fight against transphobia.</p>
<p>Kickstarter, for example, highlighted The Transphobia Project on its &#8220;featured projects&#8221; page, and <a href="https://medium.com/kickstarter/this-is-what-transphobia-in-the-media-looks-like-3b9da535322e" target="_blank" rel="noopener">published an article</a> about it in the official <em>Kickstarter</em> Magazine <span style="font-weight: 400;">by Rebecca Hiscott</span>. In <em>Axios</em>, the respected tech writer Ina Fried published an article headlined, <a href="https://www.axios.com/2019/06/17/transphobia-project-andrea-james-data-analytics" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“Exclusive: Using data to track transphobia in media”</a>. It was effectively a press release. The website <em><a href="https://www.journalism.co.uk/news/transphobia-project-aims-to-encourage-newsrooms-to-work-with-trans-communities-for-better-coverage/s2/a753238/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Journalism.co.uk</a></em> published a similarly hagiographic writeup by Daniel Green, which was subsequently promoted by<a href="https://www.niemanlab.org/reading/transphobia-project-uses-data-visualisation-to-zoom-in-on-outlets-that-spread-biased-transgender-content/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> Harvard’s Nieman Lab</a>, one of the most important media-criticism institutions in the country.</p>
<p>None of the articles mentioned that the woman they were championing had once publicly called her enemy’s young daughter a “cock-starved exhibitionist”. None reached out to me for comment, despite James noting that my article had inspired the whole project (though Green, to be fair, posted part of my response at the bottom of his article after I complained). Nor did they interrogate James’s self-professed credentials. <span style="font-weight: 400;">(I contacted all the authors — as well as Mike Allen, cofounder of <em>Axios — </em>to ask why they had failed to dig up James’s history of intimidating behaviour, and whether they planned any followup. I didn’t hear back from any, save for a brief note from a Journalism.co.uk editor who didn’t respond to my queries except to note that they wouldn’t be writing about James further.)</span></p>
<p>A close read of James’s proposal, combined with knowledge of her background, raised serious questions about whether she had the experience or technical chops necessary to pull off The Transphobia Project. And yet various outlets produced prime examples of a growing genre of journalism, geared not at establishing the truth, but at showing you’re on the right side of a raging controversy.</p>
<p>Probably partly because of this coverage, James’s fundraising was successful: 252 backers provided her with $23,302, more than ten times her $2,000 goal. The estimated delivery date, still visible on her Kickstarter, was July 2019. More than four years on, the Transphobia Project still doesn’t exist, and there is no sign James will deliver on her nebulous promises.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/the-fictional-world-of-trans-activism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/the-fictional-world-of-trans-activism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/2GettyImages-1325609608-scaled-e1647889456206.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/the-fictional-world-of-trans-activism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/the-fictional-world-of-trans-activism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The fictional world of trans activism</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/03/the-fictional-world-of-trans-activism/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>But even if The Transphobia Project remains unrealised, James has been busy. In the past four years, she has vastly expanded and updated her website, Transgender Map. And what she has added is not more data analysis of transphobic networks, but rather shockingly detailed webpages on what appears to be every enemy she has accumulated in recent years — an ever-growing list.<span style="font-weight: 400;"> These pages include personal information not only about them, but also about family members who are almost always wholly uninvolved in the fight over sex and gender.</span></p>
<p>The page dedicated to one editor at a mainstream site — who doesn&#8217;t appear to ever have written anything about transgender issues, but has edited pieces James dislikes — not only lists their spouse’s name but is, in fact, one of the spouse&#8217;s top Google results. The journalist Helen Lewis, a friend of mine, said that her page initially included photos from her first wedding, which James took from Flickr. When Lewis made the page private, James noted the change. Indeed, she seems to keep a very close eye on how her victims respond to their pages. Many of the entries also include caricatures that James has commissioned, likely at considerable cost, given the sheer number of them. In one of the creepiest cases I found, James commissioned a cartoon of not only my podcast co-host, Katie Herzog, but also her wife, who is unconnected to any of this. UnHerd also has its own page, listing many of its contributors and editors.</p>
<p>Many of the people featured have been deeply disturbed by it. “Does anyone know who runs the TransgenderMap website?” <a href="https://twitter.com/detransaqua/status/1695445429347913919" target="_blank" rel="noopener">asked Prisha S</a>, a detransitioner, on Twitter. “There are web pages about detransitioners with personal info and hate. The page about me is the longest. Whoever runs it seems to hate me a lot. It&#8217;s freaky, honestly. Can anything be done?”</p>
<p>Being featured didn’t really bother me initially. But I did become concerned when I received an upset email from my brother asking why the site was showing up near the top of <em>his</em> search results. It transpires James had compiled the most detailed biography of me that exists on the internet, the vast majority of which had nothing to do with my output on youth gender transition. <span style="font-weight: 400;">Bringing my family into her perceived conflict with me crossed what felt like a line that would be obvious to most people. </span>The page included the full names of my mother, my father, both my brothers, and everything she could find about all of our work histories. She even included the date my mother died. While accuracy isn’t James’s strong suit — at one point my page stated I am half-Hindu — it felt like an intimidation tactic: <em>Look how much I know about you</em>.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/01/journalism-is-being-eaten-alive-by-opinion/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/01/journalism-is-being-eaten-alive-by-opinion/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Screen-Shot-2020-01-28-at-4.23.39-PM-1.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/01/journalism-is-being-eaten-alive-by-opinion/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/01/journalism-is-being-eaten-alive-by-opinion/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Journalism is being eaten alive by opinion</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/01/journalism-is-being-eaten-alive-by-opinion/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jesse Singal</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Recall that one of James’s goals of the Transphobia Project was “get[ting] a few people fired along the way”. The updated version of Transgender Map seems to be operating with very similar motives: the pages seem designed to trigger negative personal and professional repercussions.</p>
<p>“The first time my 11-year-old daughter googled me, this was the first thing that came up,” said <a href="https://lisaselindavis.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Lisa Selin Davis</a>, a friend of mine who has also written at length about gender identity and youth transition. “It includes the names of my children and two family members… It&#8217;s designed to silence and humiliate us. I can handle it, but it&#8217;s a little heartbreaking to me that my kid had to see this instead of anything else about me.”</p>
<p>Another one of James’s victims is Paul Garcia-Ryan. He is a therapist who trained at a leading gender-affirming clinic in New York City. He is concerned about the quality of care that gender dysphoric youth receive and is seeking to improve it. He recently spoke at the first conference held by the <a href="https://segm.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine</a> (SEGM), a group with similar aims, in New York. (I was in attendance as well.) This alone was enough to rouse James’s ire, and soon Garcia-Ryan discovered his newly published page, which falsely describes him as an “anti-transgender activist” and explicitly instructs any minors who find themselves in his care to break off their therapy with him.</p>
<p>“Efforts to damage the reputations of clinicians creates a chilling effect amongst medical and mental health professionals, deterring them from speaking up, even when their concerns are grounded in legitimate scientific, medical, and ethical considerations,” Garcia-Ryan said in an email. “Clinicians hold an enormous responsibility and thoughtful work with gender dysphoria requires professionals to be courageous and stand firm in their clinical integrity.”</p>
<p>James has targeted a number of other responsible and careful clinicians in the field of youth gender medicine. She has also created a page for <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gordon_Guyatt" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Gordon Guyatt</a>, a legend within the field of medical research. He is one of the founders of evidence-based medicine, a (genuinely) lifesaving movement to improve the quality of medical research. Because Guyatt spoke at SEGM, he’s now a transphobe, according to the unerring moral judgment of Andrea James. He is tarred as an “anti-transgender activist” — ironic, given that <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">when I asked him</a> about the claim that questioning the evidence for transgender medicine is itself transphobic, he replied: “You’re doing harm to transgender people if you <em>don’t</em> question the evidence.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/06/the-doctors-profiting-from-trans-surgery/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/06/the-doctors-profiting-from-trans-surgery/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/gettyimages-1354913010-594x594-1-e1653994147647.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/06/the-doctors-profiting-from-trans-surgery/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/06/the-doctors-profiting-from-trans-surgery/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The doctors profiting from trans surgery</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/06/the-doctors-profiting-from-trans-surgery/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Miquel Missé</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>But James’s website is more about rage than reason. Really, all it takes to land oneself on it is to have said something publicly that she disagrees with, or to have associated, in any way, with <em>any</em> institution or <em>any</em> person she dislikes. For example, she has a page dedicated to a European academic — a far-Left trans man who couldn’t be more in favour of trans people’s dignity and right to medically transition — simply because he has published some (rather excellent) work criticising certain mainstream strains of trans activism, <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/06/the-doctors-profiting-from-trans-surgery/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">including on this website</a>. This is someone who has dedicated years of his life to radical trans activism, and now his second-highest search result in Incognito mode on Google Chrome is a webpage that suggests he is enabling transphobia.</p>
<p>Garcia-Ryan’s page ranks highly if you search his name, too. That’s the whole point: to scare people off talking about this issue. I’m telling you a tiny fraction of the stories I’ve heard from individuals targeted by James, many of whom don’t want to come forward. In short, very little has changed since Alice Dreger <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3170124/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">published</a> her first long expose of the Michael Bailey affair back in 2008: “Almost universally those who wrote to me [about their run-ins with James] — including sex researchers — asked that I not ever quote them or mention them by name,” she wrote. “They feared being attacked by James, as Bailey and others had been.”</p>
<p>For that reason, and because of my own involvement, I have been deeply conflicted about writing this piece. But it’s a perfect 2023 story, in a way. It epitomises an approach to social justice and to journalism that is so anti-intellectual, and unforgiving that it’s impossible to imagine it making the world a better place. But perhaps most disturbing is that there’s no accountability. No one can control whether they’re included on James’s site. There’s no one to appeal to other than James herself, and she has proved herself time and time again to be unreasonable. (I emailed James about this piece. She sent a brief response, which didn’t address any of my points, and has not commented further.)</p>
<p>But our information ecosystem doesn’t reward reasonableness — it rewards reaction and outrage. And particularly when the subject is social justice, media outlets are all too eager to abdicate their basic responsibilities as guardians of the truth.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-rage-behind-transgender-map/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-rage-behind-transgender-map/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/the-rage-behind-transgender-map/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">481815</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Twilight has made monsters of us</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-twilight-made-monsters-of-us/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-twilight-made-monsters-of-us/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Taylor-Lautner-Says-Competitiveness-Among-Twilight-Fans-Had-Impact-on-Robert-Pattinson-Friendship-020323-1-b7e7c88d72654e5ca863cef6080be2a1-e1700070481659.jpeg?w=753</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kat Rosenfield]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Thumbnail-Example-1-2.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Team Edward! (Breaking Dawn: Part 2/IMDB)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Kat Rosenfield </strong>is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>katrosenfield</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast. Her latest novel is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/You-Must-Remember-This-Novel/dp/0063207397/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>You Must Remember This</em></a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 16 Nov 2023 00:00:13 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 16 Nov 2023 10:10:46 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Consumer culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[fandom]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Fans]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Identity politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Tribalism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Twilight]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=491104</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The nation was a tinderbox and vampires were the match]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Fifteen years ago, in a world rattled by economic turmoil and facing impending recession, one of the most influential phenomena of our time emerged — an issue that would dominate the discourse, capture the intellect, and shape the political destinies of an entire generation. I am talking, of course, about the question: Team Edward or Team Jacob?</p>
<p>November 2008 marked the theatrical release of <em>Twilight</em>, the first film adaptation of the romance novels that centred on a love triangle between a vampire, a werewolf, and a teenage girl. By this point, they had already become a transformative force in the book world — but this was only the beginning.</p>
<p>Within a year, you couldn&#8217;t swing a cat without hitting something <em>Twilight</em>-themed. There was a <em>Twilight</em>-themed makeup palette, and Immortal <em>Twilight</em> perfume to dab on your pulse points. You could drink your coffee from a Team Edward mug in the morning, roll up to the Burger King drive-thru in Edward Cullen&#8217;s Volvo C30, order a <em>Twilight</em>-themed kids&#8217; meal for lunch, then go home and curl up in the arms of your Edward <a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.etsy.com%2Flisting%2F37339934%2Ftwilight-edward-cullen-robert-pattison%3Fshow_sold_out_detail%3D1&amp;psig=AOvVaw3avWSuUrskoQO74eTIE0pS&amp;ust=1700089689851000&amp;source=images&amp;cd=vfe&amp;ved=0CBMQjhxqFwoTCMj_rerNxIIDFQAAAAAdAAAAABAE" target="_blank" rel="noopener">body pillow</a> beneath your precise replica of <a href="https://www.instyle.com/celebrity/hottest-twilight-beauty-and-fashion-items-right-now?slide=73c00e74-1464-44de-b954-6f656c18b981#73c00e74-1464-44de-b954-6f656c18b981" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Bella&#8217;s purple duvet</a>. The franchise&#8217;s rabid fanbase was a market force unto itself: brand something as a <em>Twilight</em> tie-in, and they&#8217;d snap it up.</p>
<p>These fans weren&#8217;t just a reliable income stream, though: they were a powerful, even political, faction that was not to be trifled with. I was a reporter on the Young Hollywood beat for MTV News at the height of the <em>Twilight</em> craze, and so great was their cultural power that an editorial edict instructed we refrain from calling them &#8220;Twihards&#8221;, because they didn&#8217;t like it.</p>
<p>At first, <em>Twilight</em>&#8216;s cultural influence was chalked up to its popularity among adolescent girls. Edward and Bella&#8217;s romance was a love story, but also an obvious abstinence parable, making it a perfect vehicle for teens to explore the burgeoning passions for which they otherwise had no words. This, at least, was not surprising: every generation has something that both captures the imagination and inspires the lust of a young female audience. I was too old to be swept up in the Edward Cullen craze, but just the right age to spend long hours earnestly debating with my friends which of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles would make the best boyfriend. (Raphael, obviously.)</p>
<p>But the way <em>Twilight</em> captured the broader discourse was more unusual, which had as much to do with timing as with the story itself. <em>Twilight</em> dropped directly into the midst of a digital revolution that catapulted fandom from niche communities to a global, quasi-political force. The iPhone, Goodreads and Tumblr all debuted in 2007; when <em>Twilight</em> the movie was released a year later, it was the spark in an armoury already filled with 10 different types of ammunition.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-not-to-have-sex/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-not-to-have-sex/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/hths-still-04-65423fb9979a0.jpeg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-not-to-have-sex/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-not-to-have-sex/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How not to have sex</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-not-to-have-sex/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kat Rosenfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The resulting explosion wasn&#8217;t just in consumption: fans were curating mood boards, making memes, writing their own fanfics, and engaging in direct conversations with creators courtesy of social media. Stephenie Meyer might have written <em>Twilight</em>, the book, but the ever-expanding universe in which it existed? That belonged to the fans — who increasingly felt a sense of entitlement, control, even ownership over the stories, the characters, and the culture they loved.</p>
<p>For this, we may credit <em>Twilight</em>&#8216;s ageing fanbase, who rather than discarding fandom in favour of more grownup concerns ended up simply carrying it with them into the adult world. For teenage girls, the Edward vs Jacob debate offered a way to explore romantic relationships — who you liked and what you wanted — within the safe framework of fiction. But for adult women, <em>Twilight</em> was more than an excuse to be horny on main; it was a framework for discussing <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2012/11/at-its-core-the-twilight-saga-is-a-story-about/265328/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">literally anything</a>, from race to religion, to romantic mores, to decolonisation. Was Bella a <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/nov/16/twilight-not-feminist-sado-masochism" target="_blank" rel="noopener">victim</a> of Stockholm Syndrome, or a feminist icon who persisted in chasing what she wanted at all costs? Was Jacob cruelly and undeservedly <a href="https://ohnotheydidnt.livejournal.com/48491628.html?page=5" target="_blank" rel="noopener">friend-zoned</a>, or was he a total incel? Was <em>Twilight</em> racist because the vampires were pale — or should it be celebrated for representing Native American characters? Then there was the question of the age gap between Edward and Bella: you say <em>immortal teenage dreamboat</em>; I say <em>creepy 108-year-old man</em>.</p>
<p>All this was happening against the backdrop of a collapse in the distinction between teen and adult content in publishing and entertainment: 2008 was the era of Peak YA. As many not-so-young adults suddenly discovered a passion for content aimed at teenagers, bookstores were overwhelmed by &#8220;chosen one&#8221; stories, in which a heroine who doesn&#8217;t know how beautiful she is has to fight the forces of evil — while caught in a love triangle between two equally strapping suitors. For decades, this type of content had been written off as frivolous, a passing fancy; now, its power could not be denied. <em>Twilight</em> was perhaps the first property to make clear that, in the digital age, young women&#8217;s passions are not to be taken lightly.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/09/the-twilight-of-the-disney-princess/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/09/the-twilight-of-the-disney-princess/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/10324092284_e0a84fd0b6_o.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/09/the-twilight-of-the-disney-princess/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/09/the-twilight-of-the-disney-princess/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The twilight of the Disney princess</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/09/the-twilight-of-the-disney-princess/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Mary Harrington</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><em>Twilight</em> itself has now faded from view, but its influence lives on; it taught us to see absolutely everything as a question of <em>teams</em>. It wasn&#8217;t just the Edward-or-Jacob debate, which would always be a sort of friendly rivalry owing to its predetermined resolution (you could make a good enough case for Jacob, but Bella was never going to end up with him). It was the <em>Twilight</em> fandom itself, and what it became for its adherents. Loving <em>Twilight</em> was a cause, a chance to be part of something bigger than yourself — as was <a href="https://screenrant.com/twilight-movies-bad-hate-criticisms-reputation-explained-reasons/#:~:text=The%20reasons%20why%20the%20Twilight,of%20plot%20to%20be%20annoying." target="_blank" rel="noopener">hating</a> <em>Twilight</em>, if that was your thing, for <a href="https://feministing.com/2015/10/14/the-gender-swapped-twilight-proves-how-sexist-the-original-is/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">whatever</a> <a href="https://ew.com/gallery/10-reasons-you-hate-twilight/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">evils</a> you felt it represented.</p>
<p>And by the time the final film in the series was released — one week after Barack Obama&#8217;s successful re-election to the presidency — American culture at large was beginning to look a lot like American politics: a highly polarised world of in-groups and out-groups, where the rivalries weren&#8217;t so friendly anymore. At the same time, a new mode of cultural critique had arrived in the form of Your Fave Is Problematic, a witch-hunting Tumblr that indicted celebrities and content creators (and by extension, their fans) for various sins against social justice. The whole thing was a guilt-by-association machine. If an admired creator was called out for some -ism or -phobia, you had two choices: denounce the sin and renounce your fandom, or be tarred as complicit.</p>
<p>In this moment, the cult of fandom and the culture of consumption fully collided to create something monstrous — but also, something deeply compelling. If art and politics were inextricable — as both Tumblr users and mainstream culture critics now <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/118958/liberals-are-killing-art-insisting-its-always-political" target="_blank" rel="noopener">reliably assured us they were</a> — then so was fandom and activism. Fandom <em>mattered</em>. Fans <em>mattered</em>. And whatever you were into, it was more than mere interest; it was your identity. In this world, what you like is who you are.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/tribalism-has-come-to-the-west-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/tribalism-has-come-to-the-west-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/usdude.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/tribalism-has-come-to-the-west-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/tribalism-has-come-to-the-west-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Tribalism has come to the West</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/tribalism-has-come-to-the-west-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Ayaan Hirsi Ali</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>And in a world where fandom had become political, it was only a matter of time before politics became fandom: tribal, facile, and tailor made for our current moment. As a mode of engagement, fandom neither rewards nor leaves room for nuance; the whole point is that it&#8217;s obvious which team you should be on, which makes it the ideal medium for a political culture that thrives on simple sloganeering, Instagram-sized infographics, and 60-second TikTok explainer videos. Fandom is what fuels the blonde college student in a keffiyeh, rolling her eyes as she <a href="https://twitter.com/canarymission/status/1723777686110167105" target="_blank" rel="noopener">explains</a> that once Israel has ceased to exist, the Jews who lived there can simply return to wherever they came from — like Yemen, or Ethiopia. It fuels, too, the pro-Israel activist who thrusts a camera in her face, knowing she&#8217;ll beclown herself.</p>
<p>It&#8217;s not just the tribalism but the blazing certainty — that there&#8217;s a right side, and that identifying it is both uncomplicated and fun. For people coming of age on social media, <em>Twilight</em> offered the first inkling of how good being part of a mob could feel. How wonderful to just pick a side and root for it: fiercely, loyally, unconditionally and absolutely. And once you had done this with sparkly vampires, it was surprisingly easy to do it with everything else.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-twilight-made-monsters-of-us/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-twilight-made-monsters-of-us/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/how-twilight-made-monsters-of-us/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">481805</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Free speech is still worth fighting for</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/free-speech-is-still-worth-fighting-for/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/free-speech-is-still-worth-fighting-for/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/GettyImages-1465133957-scaled-e1699553655950.jpg?w=552</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Jonathan Sumption]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/JS.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Since when was free speech a bogeyman? (Guy Smallman/Getty Images)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Jonathan Sumption</strong> is a former Justice of the Supreme Court, and a medieval historian.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle></unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a former Justice of the Supreme Court, and a medieval historian.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Fri, 10 Nov 2023 00:00:46 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 10 Nov 2023 00:00:46 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Academia]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Campus wars]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Censorship]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[decolonisation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Democracy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Enlightenment]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Free Speech]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Freedom of expression]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[JS Mill]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Liberalism]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=490619</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[No one is entitled to intellectual safety]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Freedom of expression is probably the most widely acknowledged human right in the world. Lip service is paid to it even in totalitarian states. Freedom of expression is not worth much in Russia or North Korea, but their constitutions guarantee it in very similar terms as the United Nations. And yet, it is today under greater threat than any other human right. This is happening even, perhaps especially, in liberal democracies. How are we to explain this paradox?</p>
<p>Our approach to the whole issue of free speech is still largely moulded by attitudes born in the Enlightenment, when the main enemy of freedom of expression was the state and certain quasi-state institutions, such as the established churches. But in modern liberal democracies, the real enemy of free speech is not the state but the pressure of opinion from our fellow citizens. This is not a new insight, but it is a frequently forgotten one. Most of our issues were recognised by the great Victorian apostle of free speech John Stuart Mill, a thinker whose uncanny ability to anticipate the dilemmas of our own age can still take us by surprise. Mill foresaw that in a democratic age, such as was just dawning in Victorian Britain, a culture of conformity would be a greater threat to freedom of expression than any action of the state. Society, he wrote, is capable of practising “a social tyranny more formidable than many kinds of political oppression, since, though not usually upheld by such extreme penalties, it leaves fewer means of escape, penetrating much more deeply into the details of life and enslaving the soul itself”.</p>
<p>Tolerance does not come naturally to human beings. For most of human history, what people believed about the natural world, about government and society and about the moral codes of humanity was laid down by authority, usually by people claiming to speak in the name of God. Pluralism and diversity of opinion have only been accepted as desirable for the last three or four centuries. They are essentially the legacy of the Scientific Revolution of the 17th century and the European Enlightenment of the 18th. These movements rejected mere authority as a source of truth, in favour of observation, reasoning and rational discourse. But like all cultural phenomena, theirs was a fragile construct. In recent years, we have reverted to the older, more authoritarian model which prevailed before the 17th century, although God no longer has much to do with it.</p>
<p>A large part of the explanation has been the decline of individualism. Mill’s outlook on life was profoundly individualist. He once declared that if all mankind were of one opinion and only one person of the contrary opinion, there could be no justification for silencing him. But today individualism is widely rejected as a social value. It is regarded as selfish, uncaring and antisocial. This attitude has undermined the case for freedom of expression; it reflects a view of society as a single great organism which must have a single collective notion of what is true and good. Free speech is seen as a tool of oppression.</p>
<p>It is true that in a world of free speech, the most powerful voices will belong to people influential enough to have a public platform. This is so even in an age when speech has been democratised by social media. However, in a world of free speech, what the powerful say will be open to challenge. The alternative is a world in which public discourse is dominated by a different and more sinister form of power — the power of those with loud enough voices and sharp enough elbows to drown out others. That power will not be open to challenge. The idea of a community with a common outlook on the world sounds more inviting than a community divided by ideological or economic conflict. However, as long as human beings retain their individuality, their intellectual curiosity and their scepticism, a common outlook cannot be achieved without systematic coercion — which is what we are witnessing today.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/when-fear-leads-to-tyranny/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/when-fear-leads-to-tyranny/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/GettyImages-1057768854-e1636042694680-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/when-fear-leads-to-tyranny/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/when-fear-leads-to-tyranny/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>When fear leads to tyranny</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/when-fear-leads-to-tyranny/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jonathan Sumption</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>John Stuart Mill anticipated many things, but he did not anticipate the internet. Social media can conjure up instant online lynch mobs. They make a powerful amplifier available to the most intolerant strands of opinion. The algorithms which determine what material is placed under people’s noses expose them only to sentiments which they already agree with, thus intensifying their opinions and eliminating not only dissent but even nuance and moderation. Mill assumed that the pressure to conform would come from self-righteous majorities. But social media has conferred immense power on self-righteous minorities, often quite small minorities.</p>
<p>The most remarkable illustration of this is the vicious campaign currently being conducted to silence those who believe that gender is based on an immutable biological fact. Polling evidence suggests that the overwhelming majority of people believe that gender is determined at birth and cannot be altered by medical or surgical intervention, let alone by simple choice. That view is consistent with the current scientific orthodoxy, which regards gender as binary. Yet pressure from a noisy minority has created a situation in which the public expression of the prevailing and probably correct view about gender can lead to dismissal from employment, the cancellation of speaking engagements and publication contracts, and an avalanche of public shaming and abuse.</p>
<p>John Stuart Mill taught that the only purpose for which power might properly be exercised against individuals against their will was to prevent harm to others. But what we are presently witnessing is a subtle redefinition of the whole concept of harm to include the harm said to be caused by having to endure contradiction. The argument is that words wound, especially when they relate to another person’s identity or status; a university or a workplace where a person is exposed to disagreement must therefore be regarded, in the standard catchphrase, as “unsafe”.</p>
<p>The difference between violence and words is obvious. Violence is coercive. Words, even if offensive, are not coercive except in those cases where they are calculated to provoke violence. Yet in North America, Britain and much of the Anglosphere, this notion of harm has captured institutions. <a href="https://www.thefire.org/research-learn/scholars-under-fire-attempts-sanction-scholars-2000-2022" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Recent research</a> in the United States suggests that 29% of university professors have been pressured by university authorities into avoiding controversial subjects; 16% have either been disciplined or threatened with discipline for their words, their teaching or their academic research, while another 7% say that they have been investigated. Those working on any subject involving ethnic or religious sensitivities are particularly vulnerable. More than 80% of students report that they self-censor their work for fear of stepping out of line.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/the-love-life-of-js-mill/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/the-love-life-of-js-mill/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/GettyImages-463894637-scaled-e1683214476276.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/the-love-life-of-js-mill/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/the-love-life-of-js-mill/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The love life of JS Mill</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/the-love-life-of-js-mill/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Pratinav Anil</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Underlying much of this debate is a fundamental challenge to the objective notion of harm. When interest groups object to someone’s opinion, harm is whatever they perceive as harm. It depends on “lived experience”, as the phrase goes, particularly when the offended group is an ethnic, religious or sexual minority. The desire to accommodate minorities who feel themselves oppressed is understandable. It assists social inclusion. But carried to its logical extreme it gives them a right of veto, an entitlement to silence opinions. And it <em>is</em> being carried to its logical extreme. In many countries, including Britain, hate speech is in some circumstances a criminal offence or an aggravating factor when accompanied by some other criminal conduct. The British police and prosecution authorities have agreed upon a definition of their own devising, according to which a hate crime means any action which is <em>perceived by the victim or any other person</em> to be motivated by hostility or prejudice. In other words, they have adopted a subjective definition dependent on the feelings of the victim rather than an objective assessment of the words used.</p>
<p>All of these problems have been intensified by a powerful generational divide. A mass of anecdotal evidence suggests that venues, publishers, and other media who shun controversial views are often pushed into it by their junior staff. This rage of a younger generation against their own societies is not wholly irrational. Liberal democracy has always depended on economic good fortune. The turn in the economic fortunes of Western democracies has persuaded a whole generation that they will be the first cohort for many decades who will be worse off than their parents. The postwar generation seems to them to have lived on the fat of the land, deferring intractable issues like climate change, capricious patterns of inequality and poisonous race relations for their children and grandchildren to deal with.</p>
<p>The perceived power of vested interests and the inertia of democratic decision-making have combined to persuade much of the younger generation that debate is worthless and direct action the only answer. The European and American sense of moral and intellectual superiority provokes attempts by a younger generation to discredit their legacy. Hence the impact of the Black Lives Matter movement (even in societies such as Britain where the police do not routinely murder people of colour), the demands for “decolonisation” of school and university syllabuses, and so on. The influential French philosopher Michel Foucault argued that what people regard as objective truth or independent opinion is really no more than the product of entrenched power structures. Debate is pointless in such a world; to get anywhere, you have to break the power structures. I do not imagine that the young enemies of free speech have read Foucault’s opaque prose. But many of them act on the same principle. An angry and frustrated generation is unlikely to accept the conventions of rational discourse or the messy compromises of democratic politics as readily as their parents did. Indeed, successive surveys by the Washington-based <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2021/12/07/global-public-opinion-in-an-era-of-democratic-anxiety/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Pew Research Institute</a> suggest that support for democracy is declining among the young in much of the West, especially in Britain and America.</p>
<p>These developments have fundamentally changed the argument about freedom of expression. The issue now pits different groups of citizens and different generations against each other. The people who scream abuse at their adversaries from the roadside or from their social media accounts would claim to be exercising their own rights of free expression. The impact of their anger is indirect. They create an oppressive climate in which other people are silenced and may lose their careers, their livelihoods and their reputation, or else may simply be forced to keep away from controversial subjects. The screamers do not themselves bring about these consequences. They simply influence the mood in a way which causes other people, such as editors, publishers, universities and employers, to persecute dissenters, because in a world of heightened intellectual tensions they prefer to keep their heads down. An editor is under no obligation to give space to people of controversial views. A publisher is under no obligation to publish them. A university cannot be made to employ them. So, when the freedom of expression of one group is used to silence others, how is the state to mediate?</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-oxford-kids-are-alright/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-oxford-kids-are-alright/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/kathleen-stock--e1743017349747.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-oxford-kids-are-alright/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-oxford-kids-are-alright/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The Oxford kids are alright</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-oxford-kids-are-alright/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The law has generally been on the side of free speech. In the United Kingdom, to be criminal, words have to be inflammatory and intended to — or known to be likely to — stir up hatred against vulnerable categories of people. For good measure, there is a broad exemption for the protection of free speech which in principle permits discussion, criticism or expressions of antipathy, dislike, ridicule, insult or abuse. The British police have recorded as “hate incidents” gender-critical tweets, tweets critical of the police, accidental damage done by schoolchildren to a copy of the Koran, even speeches by ministers proposing restrictions on immigration. But when these cases have come before the courts, they have usually been thrown out. In one case where the police took action against a gender-critical tweeter, the judge remarked that their conduct offended against a “cardinal democratic principle”. “In this country”, he added, “we have never had a Cheka, a Gestapo or a Stasi. We have never lived in an Orwellian society.”</p>
<p>But there are limits to what law can achieve. The government and the courts are impotent to protect people against the worst threats to free speech: the howling trollers of the internet, the addictive outrage of the street protesters, or the oppressive self-censorship of publishers, journalists and academics. These things can only be addressed by a profound cultural change, which it is beyond the power of law to bring about. Changing this culture depends on you, on me, on every one of us. The only reason that activists try to disrupt and suppress unwelcome opinions is that experience shows that it works. Venues do not book controversial speakers. Publishers do not publish controversial books. Prominent commentators do not step out of line or, if they do, they are bullied into issuing cringing apologies.</p>
<p>None of us has to behave like this. All of us can contribute to the solution by being willing to make it clear where we stand, not just on free speech itself, but on the subjects which have become taboo. I return to the ideas of John Stuart Mill. He recognised that what was needed was the courage of individuals to defy the mob. In language which might have been directed at our present problems, he wrote that “precisely because the tyranny of opinion is such as to make eccentricity a reproach, it is desirable in order to break through that tyranny that people should be eccentric”. By eccentricity, he meant diversity of opinion. “That so few now dare to be eccentric”, he wrote, “marks the chief danger of the time”.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-death-of-historical-truth/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-death-of-historical-truth/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/GettyImages-1219014569-e1677671848781.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-death-of-historical-truth/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-death-of-historical-truth/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The death of historical truth</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/03/the-death-of-historical-truth/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jonathan Sumption</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>If, for example, we believe that gender is not an optional status but a biological fact, we can say so, instead of being shamed into silence. If we reject concepts dear to particular ethnic or religious groups, we should say so and refuse to back down or apologise when they take offence. We have to discuss the unmentionable, challenge the unchallengeable. I am not recommending rudeness or abuse, but there is a larger place for reasoned objection than we realise.</p>
<p>The greatest challenge will be self-censorship by venues, publishers, the media, and academic institutions. They will say, perhaps only to themselves or in the privacy of their editorial boards or faculty meetings, why should we expose ourselves? Why should we quarrel with our young and idealistic junior staff or students who do not wish to sully their hands with this or that book, film, or lecture? Why should we court the unpleasantness involved in speaking up? The answer to that was given by Mill in his inaugural address at the University of St. Andrews, after he had been elected as its Rector in 1867. “Let not any one pacify his conscience by the delusion that he can do no harm if he takes no part, and forms no opinion,” he said; “bad men need nothing more to compass their ends, than that good men should look on and do nothing”.</p>
<p>Free speech is not a luxury. Ever since the 17th century, the civilisation of mankind has been based on the notion that there is such a thing as an objective truth, independent of human will. It may be only partly knowable, and more or less difficult to identify, but it exists somewhere out there whether we like it or not. We have built our intellectual world by objective study of the available material, by logical reasoning and by willingness to engage with dissenting opinion. These are not just social constructs. They are universal principles, which are necessary if we are to discuss controversial issues in the same language. They have made possible the phenomenal economic prosperity and intellectual achievement of the last four centuries.</p>
<p>The basic principles of rational discourse on which all this depended are now under challenge. Reason is rejected as arrogant. Feeling and emotion are upheld as suitable substitutes. Freedom is treated as domineering, enlightenment as offensive to the unenlightened. Current campaigns to suppress certain opinions and eliminate debate are an attempt to create a new conformity, a situation in which people will not dare to contradict, for fear of provoking their outrage and abuse. These things are symptoms of the closing of the human mind and the narrowing of our intellectual world. Something in our civilisation has died.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/05/the-law-wont-protect-freedom-of-speech/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/05/the-law-wont-protect-freedom-of-speech/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/GettyImages-52029976-e1626707001807.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/05/the-law-wont-protect-freedom-of-speech/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/05/the-law-wont-protect-freedom-of-speech/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The law can&#039;t end the culture wars</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/05/the-law-wont-protect-freedom-of-speech/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Adam King</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>No one can be entitled to intellectual safety. That is because statements of fact or opinion are necessarily provisional. They reflect the current state of knowledge and experience. Once upon a time, the authorised consensus was that the sun moved round the Earth and that blood did not circulate round the body. These propositions were refuted only because current orthodoxy was challenged by people once thought to be dangerous heretics and disturbers of the peace. Historically, most societies have abhorred democracy, rejected religious and political tolerance, and regarded the whole idea of racial or gender equality as ridiculous. These ideas, which were thought to reflect obvious moral truths, died out in most countries in the face of rational argument. Knowledge advances by testing conflicting arguments, not by suppressing them. Understanding increases by exposure to uncomfortable truths.</p>
<p>For those of us who live in democracies, our collective life depends on the resolution of issues between citizens by marshalling objectively verifiable facts. It depends on ordered debate about their implication under common rules which exclude coercion and falsehood. It depends on a culture in which the outcome of our processes of collective decision-making is accepted even by those who disagree with it. That is what is at stake in the current debate about free speech. The alternative is a narrow-minded, intolerant and authoritarian society in which the fear of giving offence or challenging existing shibboleths eliminates the most creative and original products of the human spirit.</p>
<p>Ultimately, we have to accept the implications of human creativity. Some of what people say will be wrong. Some of it will be hurtful. Some of it may even be harmful. But there are greater values at stake. We cannot have truth without accommodating error and tolerating the challenge to received ideas. We cannot live together in society without allowing people to say things that other people regard as foolish, hurtful or untrue. It is the price that we pay for allowing human civilisation to advance and flourish. It is worth fighting for.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><em>This is an edited version of a speech delivered last weekend at the Christchurch Town Hall, for the New Zealand Free Speech Union.</em></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/free-speech-is-still-worth-fighting-for/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/free-speech-is-still-worth-fighting-for/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/free-speech-is-still-worth-fighting-for/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">481497</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Does Billy Bragg have a woman problem?</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/does-billy-bragg-have-a-woman-problem/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/does-billy-bragg-have-a-woman-problem/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/GettyImages-491304628.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Julie Bindel]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Screenshot-2026-10-15-at-11.44.56.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[(Christopher Furlong/Getty)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Julie Bindel</strong> is an investigative journalist, author, and feminist campaigner. Her latest book is <em>Lesbians: Where are we now?</em> She also writes on <a href="https://juliebindel.substack.com/">Substack</a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>bindelj</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an investigative journalist, author, and feminist campaigner. Her latest book is <em>Lesbians: Where are we now?</em> She also writes on <a href="https://juliebindel.substack.com/">Substack</a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 02 Oct 2023 23:01:39 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 02 Oct 2023 23:01:39 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Billy Bragg]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Feminism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Gender ideology]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Louise Distras]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Misogyny]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[music industry]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Roisin Murphy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Trans activism]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=486866</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The musician's attack on Louise Distras reeks of misogyny]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Louise Distras was once a darling of the anti-establishment Left. An underground punk singer whose <a href="https://louisedistras.bandcamp.com/album/dreams-from-the-factory-floor-2" target="_blank" rel="noopener">hits include</a> &#8220;Dreams From the Factory Floor&#8221;, this working-class woman is unafraid to speak her mind. Five years ago, she was being invited onstage by Billy Bragg, the folk singer and progressive activist — but since then, a lot has changed. Recently, Bragg has publicly and repeatedly condemned Distras, because she had done what she has always done: speak out against misogyny. This time, though, she was criticising the backlash against women who refuse to recite the “trans women <em>are</em> women” mantra.</p>
<p>Distras has been expressing concern about gender ideology in private since late 2021, but the first time she went public with her opinions was in May of this year. “I’m a woman, and a woman is an adult human female,” she said in an <a href="https://twitter.com/LouiseDistras/status/1653436388577091584" target="_blank" rel="noopener">interview</a> with <em>Louder than War</em>, a music website. “I’m a woman that’s experienced domestic abuse.” She later made comments, on <a href="https://twitter.com/LouiseDistras/status/1655521680616218624?t=kA1O7EB6N1iEM-v_DYe3ig&amp;s=19" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Twitter</a>, about how women are silenced for questioning gender ideology: “No amount of rainbows and &#8216;kindness&#8217; can hide the authoritarianism and misogyny and homophobia that&#8217;s on display here, especially in the arts.”</p>
<p>Born in Wakefield in 1987, Distras ran away from home in her teens and, she told me, “stayed with a lot of dangerous people who took advantage of me”. She turned to song writing as a form of escape. Her bravery is remarkable. But as soon as her straightforward resistance to gender ideology became known, she was met with horrendous abuse. Distras has been called every name under the sun, including anti-trans, Nazi, scum, prostitute, grifter, child serial killer, and witch. She soon realised that she had been “marked for life” as a “disgusting terf” — that no redemption would ever be possible. She was told she deserves to be chucked out of the music industry. Her booking agency has said that her attitude towards transwomen could “have detrimental effects on [her] musical career”. Radio stations have stopped playing her songs and venues cancelled her gigs. “If I go back to the industry as it stands,” she says, “if someone had the balls to book me for a gig, I would likely be physically attacked. It&#8217;s not safe.”</p>
<p>Having been rejected by the majority of her contacts in the music industry, Distras decided she might as well use her voice to speak out. Alongside five other women, her testimony featured in <a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-12541309/Now-ordinary-women-like-CANCELLED-trans-lobby-came-celebrities-like-JK-Rowling-wasnt-say-frontline-gender-debate-war.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">the <em>Daily Mail</em></a> about the experience of being ostracised for daring to question gender ideology. One of the first derogatory reactions was from Bragg. “What??”, he tweeted, linking to the feature, which included a photograph of Distras — who usually wears black and leather on stage — wearing a formal dress. “Louise Distras hates trans people so much that she’s willing to dress in a style acceptable to <em>Daily Mail</em> readers in order to have a go at them. What does this have to do with feminism Louise? Or punk rock?”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/the-murder-trial-that-broke-me/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/the-murder-trial-that-broke-me/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Nikki.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/the-murder-trial-that-broke-me/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/the-murder-trial-that-broke-me/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The murder trial that broke me</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/the-murder-trial-that-broke-me/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Julie Bindel</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Bragg fancies himself a bit of a trans ally. And prides himself on being an all-round anti-sexist bloke. In 2014, he posed with a sign, “I pledge never to commit, condone, or remain silent about men’s violence against women in all its forms,” as part of the <a href="https://www.whiteribbon.org.uk/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">White Ribbon</a> campaign.</p>
<p>Back in the early days of her career, Bragg championed Distras as one of a “new breed” of singers, tweeting in 2013 that her song <em>Love Me The Way I Am</em> should be our next Eurovision entry. Another of her songs, <em>The Hand You Hold</em>, is about how what women say and do should matter more than how we look, and she tells me that “Billy for some reason loved that song and that&#8217;s why he invited me to go play on his stage” — which she did that year, at Glastonbury, and again in 2017. “So for him to now take a pop at me and start criticising what I look like instead of actually listening to what I have to say means he is the biggest hypocrite.”</p>
<p>But it is not only men who have gone after Distras. In a recent interview with <em>Kerrang!,</em> Phoebe Lunny of the Lambrini Girls <a href="https://www.thelineofbestfit.com/news/lambrini-girls-hit-back-at-terfs-have-fun-on-the-wrong-side-of-history" target="_blank" rel="noopener">reacted</a> to Distras speaking out against trans ideology and the silencing of women: &#8220;I will scrap any Terf, any day, in person, with my fists.&#8221; In a tweet, Distras pointed to the hypocrisy of claiming to be progressive while &#8220;inciting violence against women”. She also condemned <em>Kerrang!</em> for publishing the remarks, saying she is “ashamed my face was printed on its pages. Vile!&#8221;</p>
<div class="ad-insert-events"></div>
<p>Spoken word poet Amelia Vandergast also responded angrily to Distras’s public statements about being cancelled by trans activists. In a <a href="https://www.anrfactory.com/wipe-away-the-terf-tears-freedom-of-expression-was-never-permission-to-perpetuate-hate-in-the-music-industry/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">feature</a> entitled, “Wipe away the terf tears: freedom of expression was never permission to perpetuate hate in the music industry”, published in <em>A&amp;R Factory</em> website, she wrote:</p>
<p>“In the recent <em>Daily Mail</em> article, which attempted to portray women as the victims of their transphobic hate, Louise Distras bemoaned the journalists, radio stations, and her booking agency who rightly refuse to have anything to do with her for the self-piteous bile spewed across her social media platforms (anyone got a tiny little violin I can borrow?)”</p>
<p>For Distras, the hypocrisy within the so-called radical music scene is appalling. While the misogyny of trans activists is ignored, women are viciously attacked for daring to defend their sex-based rights. She is one of a growing list of female artists criticising cancel culture — a phenomenon of which <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KBOfye7F6vM" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Bragg denies</a> the existence.</p>
<p>But Bragg has form. He has dismissed feminist concerns about self-identification and argued that, owing to our <a href="https://x.com/billybragg/status/1663869132499038210?s=20" target="_blank" rel="noopener">incompatible “hardware”</a>, lesbians are biologically ill-equipped for sex with other women and should therefore understand the plight of men claiming to be female. When Maya Forstater was harassed by trans activists in the street, <a href="https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1702725991754277235.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Bragg</a> suggested that she could not possibly have been scared or upset, because she appeared to be smiling. This is a classic <a href="https://www.stylist.co.uk/people/chelsea-handler-women-smile-hillary-clinton-sexism-sexual-harassment-street-crime-video/29626" target="_blank" rel="noopener">sexist trope</a>. Too often, women are told by men to &#8220;Give us a smile&#8221; when we complain about being sexually harassed by them, and yet women are informed we must have enjoyed the harassment if we attempt to laugh it off.</p>
<p>“I think he&#8217;s a misogynist,” Distras says, of Bragg. “I think it&#8217;s just plain to see for everybody and the way he is — the way that so many men are in the music industry.” She talks about how uncomfortable she has felt with him, describing him as “creepy”. “He&#8217;s everything he says he&#8217;s not. His words and his actions just don&#8217;t match up for me… The way he goes after women over the trans issue has made it really clear to me that he&#8217;s just a misogynist, and that he just doesn&#8217;t care about women”. She says what many feminists have said of many men in recent years: “The trans thing is just an excuse for him to bully women with impunity and do it publicly and get applauded for it.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Doc-20-Feb-2022-10.19.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why I stopped being a good girl</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Hadley Freeman</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Bragg also showed no sympathy for <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/thepost/why-the-bbc-had-to-memory-hole-roisin-murphy/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Róisín Murphy</a>, another female singer-songwriter who has faced the wrath of trans activists. After a private Facebook conversation in which she criticised the policy of giving children puberty blockers was leaked, she was <a href="https://twitter.com/billybragg/status/1698027688739348849" target="_blank" rel="noopener">admonished</a> by Bragg for holding the wrong opinion. “Them&#8217;s the breaks,” Bragg tweeted when it was suggested that Murphy was being punished by having BBC coverage and concerts cancelled. “Think before you post is my advice, especially on issues that are contentious.” This is cowardice.</p>
<p>Distras strongly feels that the music industry used to be about “freedom of expression and freedom of speech”, but is currently in thrall to gender ideology and “totally monotheistic”. “There’s an urgent need to build a new one, with a proper counterculture that isn&#8217;t dominated by misogynists like Billy Bragg, where women have actually got a proper say,” she says, telling me she has had numerous messages from female musicians who are too scared to speak out — especially after seeing what happened to Murphy. “It&#8217;s well established that violence towards women is a massive problem in the music industry,” says Distras, “and here they are inciting more violence, and the rest of the music industry just applauds them for it and tells them they are stunning and brave.”</p>
<p>“We need more musicians to come forward courageously and without apology. There&#8217;s been so much support for me, and there will be for the other women. And the more of us that stand up, the more these men like Billy Bragg will not be so dominant.”</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/does-billy-bragg-have-a-woman-problem/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/does-billy-bragg-have-a-woman-problem/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/does-billy-bragg-have-a-woman-problem/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">481700</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Can paedophilia ever be a thought experiment?</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/can-paedophilia-ever-be-a-thought-experiment/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/can-paedophilia-ever-be-a-thought-experiment/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/GettyImages-1435811378-e1695318175638.jpg?w=629</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kathleen Stock]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Blue-37.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['Novels can do it much better.' (Screen Archives/Getty Images)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<div><strong>Kathleen Stock</strong> is contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</div>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>kathleen_stock1</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</div>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 21 Sep 2023 23:03:04 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 22 Sep 2023 10:02:18 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Academia]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cancel culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Don't miss]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Paedophilia]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Philosophy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Universities]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=486135</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Philosophy professors are no longer safe]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p style="margin: 0cm;"><span style="color: black;">Imagine that a philosophy professor is invited onto a podcast. The hosts ask him to describe a thought experiment he finds interesting or provoking. He decides to pick a scenario in which an adult male has sex with a “willing” 12-year-old girl, before saying that the man in his example would not necessarily be at fault. It would, he says, depend on whatever accompanying harm was caused to the child, but there are some situations in which the sexual activity would be harmless. Would the professor’s proffering of such a thought experiment be morally wrong?</span></p>
<p>It seems a lot of people think so — for of course this particular case isn’t just hypothetical. In January last year, Professor Stephen Kershnar was invited on to the podcast <a href="https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/episodes/Sexual-Taboos--Stephen-Kershnar-e1dlqgp" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Brain In A Vat</a> to discuss the topic of “Sexual Taboos”. After his choice of thought experiment was excerpted and tweeted out by <a href="https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1488675032985268228.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Libs of TikTok</a>, things escalated quickly. Conservative <a href="https://dailycaller.com/2022/02/02/suny-fredonia-stephen-kershnar-pedophilia-libs-tiktok/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">websites</a> pounced. A student at Kershnar’s university, SUNY Fredonia, <a href="https://www.change.org/p/suny-fredonia-fire-professor-stephen-kershnar" target="_blank" rel="noopener">started a petition</a> demanding he be fired. The university president directed police to search Kershnar’s computer, took him out of teaching on the grounds of student protection, and put him under investigation. Though he kept his paycheck, he has since been barred from teaching. According to the<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/13/nyregion/suny-fredonia-professor-lawsuit.html?unlocked_article_code=Nicknof1cbKaOKAacl4jwXUWeYAXHdBhOSTgMpnjrzkAVZNeTrU-NT-ifiS3Bg2QvWntG7H8bKnDHcYLRi374lU_xdZGJW5I81UsyrUuKDl9ebBnbWsrd3rsXd8BF8l9pNVHgAE0sJu5mWaeD0NCp3DqKtLy7EI6-53QJcgF1eIBn8dil_LUQkrwTxcoTDKFn2s4-2y4jCQ5znSaXiOkQJVzB1nh3imYCMAHj4wlPJHMA6QLXYJ0FygV7eMWDApfpH4p-pVTGkm0orfBEcuQp5hx_7UuKP9EMuFhwNCakCXiyhmCsYqeuf-enWrCLHnxRZ--p_S0n7kcHeLK5qc4q3GmYsI4qWxMRlg&amp;smid=url-share"> <em>New York Times</em></a> this week, he is now suing his employer.</p>
<p>In truth, Kershnar hardly offered a thought experiment at all. Compared with the most elaborate of philosophers’ constructions — see Judith Jarvis Thomson’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Defense_of_Abortion#:~:text=Thomson%20argues%20that%20one%20can,to%20life%20but%20merely%20deprives" target="_blank" rel="noopener">baroque image</a>, offered in defence of abortion, of waking up to find yourself non-consensually hooked up to an unconscious violinist, physically dependent on your circulatory system to recover from a poisoning — it was barely more than a sketch. But failure to meet the normal standards of thought experiments is not what people objected to here.</p>
<p>One typical insinuation of Kershnar’s critics seemed to be that, by offering such an argument, he must have been indulging in a case of special pleading. The assumption was that, by his choice of example, and, indeed, by <a href="https://philpapers.org/rec/KERPAA-7" target="_blank" rel="noopener">the book he wrote</a> beforehand partly defending the same sort of  conclusions, he inadvertently betrayed his own paedophilic sexual predilections, thereby removing any claim to intellectual authority. (He strongly denies this.)</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/should-women-learn-to-love-pain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/should-women-learn-to-love-pain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/GettyImages-1640113655-1-1-e1694102280960.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/should-women-learn-to-love-pain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author </span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/should-women-learn-to-love-pain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Should women learn to love pain?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/should-women-learn-to-love-pain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock </a></p></div></a></div>
<p>But other explanations are also available, embedded within the peculiar culture of academic philosophy. There is, for instance, an established tradition within applied ethics of coming up with counterintuitive conclusions. After all, there’s no fun or kudos in saying the same thing as everyone else. One approach is to demonstrate to readers that, given ethical principles or values to which they are already committed, surprising and perhaps even shocking consequences seem to follow. Some dispassionate types just find this sort of thing cool and edgy, independent of the emotional impact generated for others. Kershnar himself seems to be a big fan of the tactic. His published work includes moral defences of torture, slavery, violent sexual fantasies, anti-immigration policies, faking orgasms, only dating Asians, and <a href="https://philpapers.org/rec/KERDWA" target="_blank" rel="noopener">discounting women’s applications</a> for jobs in philosophy departments.</p>
<p>Occasionally in philosophy, some famous ethicist or other <a href="https://schwitzsplinters.blogspot.com/2023/09/does-it-matter-if-ethicists-walk-walk.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">is criticised</a> for failing to live up to his own favoured principles in private life. In this particular case, you rather hope Kershnar doesn’t try too hard. Looking at the evidence available, though, it seems mostly likely that he’s just a professional contrarian. In the legal case against his university, his lawyers quote a student as saying of the professor “it was almost impossible to tell what he actually believed and what he didn’t”. I forced myself to read one of his background articles about paedophilia, and found the relentless tone-deaf logic-chopping almost unbearable in the context of the prurient subject matter. Still, for all I know, the interest is entirely academic. Philosophers are, after all, quite strange.</p>
<p>As the not-particularly-popular saying goes: “one person’s <em>modus ponens</em> is another’s <em>modus tollens</em>”. That is: when faced with an apparently intolerable conclusion stemming from an apparently sound argument, you can either accept the conclusion, or work harder to find out what was wrong with your premises in the first place. Some thinkers fight much harder than Kershnar to reject the disturbing conclusions that seem to follow from relatively unexceptionable premises. Oxford philosopher <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derek_Parfit" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Derek Parfit</a>, for instance, devoted an enormous amount of energy trying to avoid what he called “The Repugnant Conclusion” in population ethics. This says, roughly, that the existence of a very large population with very low average happiness per person is preferable to that of a small population with very high average happiness. In the end though, by his own admission, Parfit<a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/ARCHIVES/WIN2009/entries/repugnant-conclusion/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> couldn’t dislodge it</a> — thereby handing a gold-plated excuse to leaders of large countries with failing economies to increase the birth-rate.</p>
<div class="ad-insert-events"></div>
<p>Others just go with the rational flow, coming to fully endorse value judgements that nearly everyone else rejects. For instance, as is well-known, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1999/09/11/a-professor-who-argues-for-infanticide/cce7dc81-3775-4ef6-bfea-74cd795fc43f/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Peter Singer</a> holds that in certain circumstances, killing disabled babies would be preferable to killing animals. <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/10.1086/677021.pdf?casa_token=pEjjeu8x4ioAAAAA:2ODpEAU9Zb3DXYB_HgeKi_xYkuzg8PZI5KSbyP7eU7aO9fylXolam-tnNTZglY8dTmd-XPgHgeC38dV7XoOQqMyAqp_mqnxHvc01zX6GP-Gwh-AreBM" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Elizabeth Barnes thinks</a> there would be “nothing intrinsically wrong” with “a mechanism that allows non-disabled people to become disabled if they wish”. <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7656150/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Julian Savulescu</a> and others argue that there are “equity-based reasons” to use drugs to keep “non-binary adults” in a permanent pre-pubertal state, so that the development of secondary sex characteristics is permanently prevented. Whatever the ultimate success or failure of these arguments, there is probably not a single grotesque behaviour in history that couldn’t be justified by some philosopher somewhere, playing around with a highly unlikely-but-still-possible scenario in which the behaviour is present, but where “harm” is magically subtracted and “consent” or “benefit” added.</p>
<p>The most basic use of a thought experiment in ethics presents us with a particular hypothetical case and asks us what our “pre-theoretical intuitions” tell us about it — which might sound pleasingly technical to the uninitiated, but could just as well be reframed as asking what feelings you are now getting in your water. Confronted with this scenario, it asks: do you feel such-and-such would be right / wrong / good / bad / fair / unfair? Whatever you say in response to the imaginary version, it’s assumed you would also say the same towards the equivalent real one.</p>
<p>Then, depending on the case, something more complex might be attempted: for instance, an analogy might be made with some other more mundane and everyday case, to suggest your intuitions should be the same there too. This is effectively what Thomson’s violinist experiment does. If your intuitions tell you that it would not be wrong to detach yourself from an unwanted violinist in the circumstances she outlines, even if this resulted in the violinist’s death, then — since the situations are supposed to be relevantly similar — you ultimately should conclude the same in the case of an unwanted foetus. (Thomson has a further explanation of what the common factor allegedly is.)</p>
<p>Yet if I were suddenly plunged, for real, into a situation involving an unconscious violinist being plumbed into my or someone else’s circulatory system, I’d be in a very different sort of world from this one — quite possibly, a world directed by David Cronenberg. Who knows what other weird stuff would be going on there? And who knows how I’d react to it, if so? The question arises of why I should take my responses to this crazy tale to be indicative of anything at all.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/centrist-dads-wont-save-britain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/centrist-dads-wont-save-britain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/GettyImages-1155260347-e1694714807122.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/centrist-dads-wont-save-britain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author </span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/centrist-dads-wont-save-britain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The Centrist Dads won&#039;t save Britain</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/centrist-dads-wont-save-britain/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock </a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Kershnar’s thought experiment is different because it describes a scenario that nearly everyone would intuitively reject as wrong. Still, when you look at his published background reasoning about the supposed permissibility of hypothetical instances of “adult-child sex”, it also involves appealing to intuitions about totally anachronistic scenarios. For instance, he discusses a situation where there exist children who are “precocious and fully grasp the different dimensions of sex like some precocious children can grasp the different dimensions of music and mathematics” (and moreover where, presumably. we could somehow reliably test for this understanding). The relevance to the actual world, where children are not actually precocious in this way and sex is nothing relevantly like mathematics or music, is totally obscure.</p>
<p>In any case, real-life events — unlike thought experiments — aren’t just stripped-down stories, pruned of distracting ephemera to get to the bits the philosopher really wants you to notice. They come thicketed with endless detail to be noticed even years afterwards. And with moral reactions, it’s the details that matter. Not just details about who did what to whom; but also why, and how much did it hurt, and who did it help, and what did all parties think was going on, and what exculpatory factors existed beforehand, and what happened afterwards; and how did all these factors interact in this particular case? Novels can do this stuff much better. <em>Lolita</em> can tell you what is wrong with paedophilia much more powerfully than any dry fictional construct from a bloodless academic.</p>
<p>None of this is to suggest that Kershnar should have been punished as he was. Distasteful as his general approach is, arguing for the permissibility of doing something is not the same thing as doing that thing yourself. In a society that values freedom of thought, we have to fight hard to maintain this distinction, or else the whole enterprise of arguing about ethics collapses completely. Still, perhaps ironically, what happened to Kershnar’s podcast once the internet got hold of a small part of it tells us something instructive about the problem with ethical thought experiments in general. A snapshot was taken of a multifaceted situation; any relevant or complicating context or background was removed; and it was flung like red meat towards readers for a satisfyingly outraged moral reaction. If we want to understand complex real-world ethical issues, we should probably try to avoid this sort of thing.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/can-paedophilia-ever-be-a-thought-experiment/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/can-paedophilia-ever-be-a-thought-experiment/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/09/can-paedophilia-ever-be-a-thought-experiment/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">481452</post-id>				</item>
						</channel>
</rss>
