<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	xmlns:unherd="https://www.unherd.com"
	>

	<channel>
		<title>Premium - UnHerd</title>
		<atom:link href="https://stage.unherd.com/tag/premium/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
		<link>https://stage.unherd.com/tag/premium/</link>
		<description>think again</description>
		<lastBuildDate>Wed, 21 May 2025 08:03:13 +0000</lastBuildDate>
		<language>en-US</language>
		<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
		<sy:updateFrequency>12</sy:updateFrequency>
		<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4</generator>

 
<site xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">241382538</site>				<item>
					<title>How Islamism infiltrated Downing Street</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/how-islamism-infiltrated-downing-street/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/how-islamism-infiltrated-downing-street/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Premium-article.jpg?w=622</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Investigation</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[David Rose]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/David-Rose-817-2.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>David Rose </strong>is <i>UnHerd</i>&#8216;s Investigations Editor.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>DavidRoseUK</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is <i>UnHerd</i>'s Investigations Editor.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 15 May 2025 23:03:51 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 21 May 2025 08:03:13 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Downing Street]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Islamism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Keir Starmer]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Labour Party]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=677143</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Sectarianism is affecting policymaking]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Ahmed was not always so cozy with Labour. During the Blair-Brown era, he was the spokesman for the Muslim Public Affairs Committee (MPAC), a lobbying organization driven by principles which include reviving the farid of Jihad and anti-Zionism. It also encouraged tactical voting against Labour MPs who didn’t share Muslim concerns. As Ahmed said at the time: “The Muslim vote is powerful. Thousands of Muslims are unhappy about the Government’s involvement in Iraq and lack of action in Palestine.” He advised that these voters should back candidates “likely to do the most for Muslims”.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">In its ventures, according to a report by an all-party group of MPs, MPAC would use extremist rhetoric and circulate radical material, including articles from neo-Nazi and Holocaust denial websites. </span><span style="font-weight: 400">It described Zionism as an “octopus that penetrates every western nation and pushes it to start World War Three upon Muslims” and used antisemitic smears in its attempt to unseat </span><span style="font-weight: 400">Lorna Fitzsimons, then MP for Rochdale. One of MPAC’s leaflets falsely claimed that she had done nothing for Palestinians because she was a “Jewish member of Labour Friends of Israel”. It also claimed it was Allah’s will that Muslims vote Liberal Democrat. MPAC was forced to issue a </span><a href="https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/race-row-apology-1065474" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">public apology</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> for the false claim about Fitzsimons, but</span> <span style="font-weight: 400">she was still ousted by a Lib Dem at the 2005 election. </span><span style="font-weight: 400">Though </span><span style="font-weight: 400">Ahmed was its spokesperson back in 2005, he told me, via his lawyers, he now regrets being involved with the group and abhors “any antisemitism”. He also stated that his sole motivation for joining the group was in relation to an anti-war campaign against those supporting the Iraq War.</span><span style="font-weight: 400"><br />
</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">MPAC was only one of </span><span style="font-weight: 400">several</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> organizations advancing Islamist agendas. Some worked via more delicate means. The Muslim Council of Britain (MCB), for instance, vehemently opposed UK support for Israel and the invasion of Iraq. It also </span><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20010309212038/http:/www.mcb.org.uk/news260101.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">boycotted</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> Holocaust Memorial Day, and in 2009, its deputy secretary-general Daud Abdullah signed a </span><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/mar/08/daud-abdullah-gaza-middle-east" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">declaration</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> supporting Hamas. Gordon Brown responded by banning all “engagement” with the MCB, a policy followed by subsequent Tory and Labour governments. Nonetheless, it is still the</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> largest Muslim organization in Britain, and it still wields influence. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Inevitably, other organizations were spawned. With the MCB denied access to Whitehall, another Islamist lobbying group, Muslim Engagement and Development (MEND) emerged in the 2010s. For a time, senior figures from both main parties attended its </span><a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2024/04/01/labour-cuts-ties-with-muslim-organisation-named-as-islamist/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">events</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">. But MEND’s star began to </span><a href="https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/mps-ditch-meeting-with-muslim-group-mend-over-islamist-claims-rgxqn0s05" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">fade</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> in 2017, after a young fanatic killed five people and injured 50 by driving a car into them outside Parliament, and one of its directors </span><a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4396832/Islamist-head-Muslim-pressure-group.html"><span style="font-weight: 400">claimed</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> this was “not terrorism”. In 2023, its chief executive Azhar Qayyum reaffirmed his support for the Palestinian people and their right to armed struggle after the October 7 attack and called for Israel to be “dismantled”. </span><span style="font-weight: 400"><br />
</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">When the Tory communities secretary Michael Gove told the Commons that MEND was to be </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-68564577" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">assessed</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> for extremism, Labour responded by announcing that it, too, would not </span><a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2024/04/01/labour-cuts-ties-with-muslim-organisation-named-as-islamist/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">engage</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> with MEND. But when one avenue is shut down, another opens. MEND is now part of a powerful coalition that today is increasingly applying pressure on the Labour government. The Muslim Vote (TMV), of which more later, includes several </span><span style="font-weight: 400">existing groups that openly supported the right to Palestinian armed struggle after the October 7 massacre, and which last year used its significant power to affect voting patterns. No wonder Labour is listening. </span></p>
<p style="text-align: center"><span style="font-weight: 400">*</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">But what do these groups want? Along with demanding a tougher line on Israel, the MCB and MEND have been making the same demand for many years: government acceptance of an official definition of Islamophobia, supposedly a unique form of prejudice. According to </span><a href="https://www.mend.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/MEND-Approaching-a-definition-of-Islamophobia-More-than-words-Executive-Summary.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">MEND</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">, this would “</span><span style="font-weight: 400">provide much-needed clarity in legislation</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> and policies that are intended to protect vulnerable minorities”.</span><span style="font-weight: 400"><br />
</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">B</span><span style="font-weight: 400">ut Khalid Mahmood, a Labour MP unseated by a TMV Islamist in 2024 — </span><span style="font-weight: 400">a man who had questioned whether women were raped on October 7</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> and </span><a href="https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/uk-election-palestine-candidate-ayoub-khan-unseats-labour-khalid-mahmood" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">dedicated his win</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> to the people of Gaza — </span><span style="font-weight: 400">believes there is a deeper motive. Islamists, he said, see a wide-ranging definition as “a way of extending their control over the young in schools and universities. If they start to blame every mishap on Islamophobia, it will induce a victim mentality, and isolate them from the mainstream — so making them more vulnerable to Islamist influence”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Under the Tories, the Islamists inched closer to success. A </span><a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/599c3d2febbd1a90cffdd8a9/t/5bfd1ea3352f531a6170ceee/1543315109493/Islamophobia+Defined.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">report</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> issued in 2018 by the All-Party Parliamentary Group on British Muslims, whose co-chair was the current health secretary Wes Streeting, stated that “Islamophobia is rooted in racism and is a type of racism that targets expressions of Muslimness or perceived Muslimness”. The former Tory attorney general Dominic Grieve wrote the foreword, saying Islamophobia was “undermining integration”.</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The APPG’s definition was attacked from both ends of the political spectrum. </span><span style="font-weight: 400">But some of those now close to Starmer welcomed it — including Muddassar Ahmed. In 2019, the Corbyn-led Labour Party endorsed the APPG definition, and this, </span><a href="https://x.com/MMuddassarAhmed/status/1108341875012968451" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">said Ahmed</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">, was a “momentous achievement </span><span style="font-weight: 400">driven by determined, visionary and indefatigable leadership</span><span style="font-weight: 400">”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">When, in 2024, Starmer attended Ahmed’s </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">iftar,</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400"> they also discussed how Islamophobia should be tackled and the Labour leader gave a speech in which he, too, pledged to deal with the “sickening rise in Islamophobia”. One guest felt sure that the evening marked a significant, political shift. Nafeez Ahmed </span><a href="https://x.com/NafeezAhmed/status/1774417536886391025" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">wrote</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> afterwards that Starmer’s speech revealed a new, more critical attitude to Israel and Islamophobia. Starmer had promised that a “Labour government will never turn a blind eye to that prejudice”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Muddassar Ahmed insists that he regrets being involved with MPAC and doesn’t share the Islamist views of some of those who were involved. He also wrote an article in 2015 in which he was critical of MPAC and accused it of being disagreeable and problematic. But he is now the head of an </span><span style="font-weight: 400">international network of Muslim leaders</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> called the Concordia Forum — and this network has controversial alliances. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">In 2020, for example, the Concordia Forum hosted a series of online interviews. One was with </span><span style="font-weight: 400">Nelson Mandela’s grandson Mandla, who has since been banned from entering Britain for supporting Hamas and spreading </span><a href="https://www.sajr.co.za/mandla-mandela-exposes-his-own-antisemitism/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">antisemitic</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> conspiracy theories. Another interview featured the Pakistani-American theologian Yasir Qadhi, who has </span><a href="https://canarymission.org/professor/Yasir_Qadhi" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">defended</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> the Holocaust denier David Irving and </span><a href="https://www.facebook.com/yasir.qadhi/posts/10154273537943300/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">claimed</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> that the American John Walker Lindh, who was captured after 9/11 fighting for the Taliban, was guilty of “youthful naivete, not treason”. Earlier this year, references to these talks vanished from the Concordia website, although they are still available on YouTube. And when I asked Ahmed’s lawyers, they told me neither he nor Concordia were aware of Mandela’s and Qadhi’s views, and did not </span><span style="font-weight: 400">“support or even tolerate any form of antisemitism or pro-terrorist sentiment”.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">But Muddassar Ahmed still has other controversial friends. Last year, he spent time in London with a man he called a “renowned American Muslim scholar”, the Islamist Omar Suleiman. Suleiman&#8217;s accomplishments “speak for themselves”, Ahmed gushed, praising his “leadership” and “heartfelt dedication”. He did not mention the fact that Suleiman has also called for a violent “third intifada” and </span><a href="https://www.jta.org/2019/05/20/ideas/imam-omar-suleiman-has-an-anti-semitic-past" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">cursed</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> Zionists as “enemies of God and humanity”. Speaking in January, Suleiman asked Allah to give “victory to our brothers and sisters in Gaza over these evil Zionists”. (Suleiman has said he is “not antisemitic”. Ahmed’s lawyers said his praise for Suleiman applied only “to his recognized work on interfaith dialogue and social engagement”.) Ahmed also has close ties to the repressive Islamist regime in Turkey led by Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Last month, he met some of its senior officials, and presented a “spirit of humanity award” to Erdogan’s deputy foreign minister Burhanettin Duran, praising his “principled leadership”. </span><span style="font-weight: 400"> </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">With Starmer now in Downing Street, Ahmed has found further opportunities to lobby Labour. On 17 February, 2025, as the grooming gangs scandal raged through the press, Ahmed unveiled a Concordia opinion </span><a href="https://www.prnewswire.co.uk/news-releases/poll-reveals--british-muslims-deeply-concerned-about-grooming-gangs-landmark-survey-completed-by-opinium-in-partnership-with-the-concordia-forum-explores-disinformation-and-hostility-towards-uks-muslims-302377243.html?tc=eml_cleartime" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">poll</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> that found most British Muslims thought grooming gang victims should be given more support and were “deeply concerned” about them. So far, so uncontroversial. But Ahmed went on to express sentiments that appear to have no basis in the poll’s data: “</span><span style="font-weight: 400">These findings reinforce the reality that misinformation about Muslims in Britain is rife and unjustified&#8230; The recent attacks conflating Muslim communities with grooming gangs is simply unfounded.” (His lawyers said he “stands by” this statement, and was voicing </span><span style="font-weight: 400">“</span><span style="font-weight: 400">caution against the harmful and inaccurate conflation of entire communities with the actions of a criminal minority”.)</span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;With Starmer now in Downing Street, Ahmed has found further opportunities to lobby Labour.&#8221;</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Launching the poll, Ahmed was flanked </span><span style="font-weight: 400">by disabilities minister, Stephen Timms, and the Labour MPs Naz Shah and Afzal Khan, both past recipients of Concordia Forum hospitality worth thousands of pounds. (The previous month, defying the official boycott, Timms had attended the MCB’s annual dinner, at which the Labour MP Abtisam Mohamed, who was later blocked from entering Israel, made a </span><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/newsroom/the-real-reason-israel-barred-labour-mp-abtisam-mohamed/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">speech</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">.) Ahmed also said the poll revealed that </span><span style="font-weight: 400">Muslims were “experiencing record levels of discrimination and hostility just for practicing their faith”. The Government, he urged, must do more to “engage British Muslims and ensure their voices are heard.”</span><span style="font-weight: 400"><br />
</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Astonishingly, the </span><span style="font-weight: 400">very next day, Ahmed’s voice was heard in the state dining room at No 10. At a “round table” meeting between Muslim leaders and Starmer, Ahmed was </span><a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/number10gov/54335066307" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">pictured</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> sitting two places to the PM’s left. The meeting, wrote another of the Muslim leaders present, marked </span><span style="font-weight: 400">a “</span><a href="https://solutionsnotsides.co.uk/node/392" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">reset</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">” that would see the Government build “stronger partnerships” with Muslims. </span></p>
<figure id="attachment_677532" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-677532" style="width: 1920px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img fetchpriority="high" decoding="async" class="wp-image-677532 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg" alt="" width="1920" height="1080" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg 1920w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=300,169 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=768,432 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=1024,576 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=1536,864 1536w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=267,150 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=253,142 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=250,141 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=660,371 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/54335066307.jpg?resize=480,270 480w" sizes="(max-width: 1920px) 100vw, 1920px" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-677532" class="wp-caption-text">Starmer was pictured speaking to Ahmed, right and facing away from the camera, at a reception in Number 10. Photo: Number 10, via Flickr.</figcaption></figure>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Reset it was, for 10 days later the deputy prime minister and communities secretary Angela Rayner announced she was setting up a five-person “working group” to “provide the Government with a working definition of anti-Muslim hatred/Islamophobia”. Its chair would be the liberal Tory Grieve, veteran of the 2018 APPG report. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The backgrounds of its other members were rather different. One, Asha Affi, stood as an east London council election candidate in 2010 for George Galloway’s far-Left, Islamist-friendly Respect Party, whose policies included rejection of Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state. (Asked about this and other radical Respect policies, she told me she had not supported them.) </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Another member, Akeela Ahmed, is a longstanding associate of Muddassar and the wife of Nafeez, with whom she attended Muddassar’s pre-election </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">iftar. </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400">In February, Akeela </span><a href="https://x.com/BBCr4today/status/1894297161292288410" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">urged</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> Starmer to end the boycott of the MCB</span><span style="font-weight: 400">, despite the fact it remains highly controversial: its deputy chief until January had visited and venerated the Hamas leadership in Gaza, while its new secretary-general </span><a href="https://muslimmatters.org/2022/02/03/did-the-prophet-wear-glasses-raising-children-resilient-muslims/https:/muslimmatters.org/2022/02/03/did-the-prophet-wear-glasses-raising-children-resilient-muslims/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">says</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> Muslim parents should teach their children to identify “primarily” as Muslims</span><span style="font-weight: 400">. (Akeela told me she knew nothing of Muddassar’s work with MPAC, nor his friendships with Islamists, and had a long record of interfaith dialogue.)</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Akeela’s husband, Nafeez, has lobbied, with the help of Muddassar, for journalists to be forced to undergo training on how to cover Islam and Muslims. This lobbying came i</span><span style="font-weight: 400">n 2012, when Lord Justice Leveson was conducting an inquiry on the ethics of the press. Muddassar Ahmed’s PR firm, Unitas Communications, submitted a </span><a href="https://www.discoverleveson.com/evidence/Submission_by_Dr_Nafeez_Ahmed_on_behalf_of_Unitas_Communications/8052/media" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">document</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400">, drafted by Nafeez, to Leveson’s inquiry. It said there should be a statutory press regulator with powers to enforce “mandatory training” to journalists on how to cover Islam and Muslims, to levy “meaningful sanctions or penalties” and ensure more Muslims got media jobs. (Nafeez told me he thought the document was “an important contribution” that would make sure “</span><span style="font-weight: 400">the media does not engage in promoting inaccurate racist reporting against Muslims as a group”. Muddassar Ahmed’s lawyers said he still supported the document’s central demand, for “a more robust regulatory system capable of holding the British media to account for instances of inaccurate, racist anti-Muslim reporting practices” without “compromising the fundamental right of freedom of speech”.)</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">A third group member is the cross-bench peer Shaista Gohir, who has also previously expressed highly controversial opinions on the Middle East before the October 7 attacks. One of her tweets read: “The only reply to a murderer is resistance. #Free Palestine.” Another proclaimed: “The US are not much of a superpower when they are ruled by another country – Israel.” Others suggested Israel deliberately targeted Gaza’s children, that Israel’s power was so great that US elections were pointless, and that Hamas bore no responsibility for triggering Israeli airstrikes by firing rockets. Those who claimed it did should “go over and live one day of Palestinian life”. </span><span style="font-weight: 400"> </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Though her tweets date from 2014, and she insists that she is not antisemitic and opposes antisemitism, more recently, her son Faris, who is also her parliamentary assistant, has claimed that Israel fabricated evidence of the October 7 atrocities. In one instance, he posted a photo of dried blood caking the floor of a home where civilians were murdered, commenting: “Because they were caught with pink fake blood they’ve now done the opposite and got black paint or some shit,” following this with a laughing face emoji. (He told me: “I strongly condemn all forms of prejudice and discrimination, including antisemitism.”)</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Meanwhile, Shaista previously downplayed the role of Muslims in the grooming gangs scandal. In 2013, she authored a </span><a href="https://www.mwnuk.co.uk/go_files/resources/UnheardVoices.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">report</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> that deplored claims the gangs were a “Pakistani, Asian or even a Muslim problem”. This meant “right-wing populist groups have used this issue to fuel racism and Islamophobia, ignoring evidence… that the majority of offenders are White.” </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Her study focused on victims of Asian heritage, and found most of those who preyed on them were from their own communities. However, she reassured readers she was “not suggesting that sexual exploitation is more of a problem in Asian and/or Muslim communities”. Her work was echoed in a </span><a href="https://www.mend.org.uk/debunking-the-racist-muslim-grooming-gangs-narrative/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">report</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> from MEND in February, which said the claim that grooming gangs were predominantly Muslim was a “myth” that reflected an “Islamophobic narrative”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Lost in all this, meanwhile, is </span><span style="font-weight: 400">the view shared by many Muslims that there is no need for an Islamophobia definition at all. According to </span><span style="font-weight: 400">Mahmood, whatever comes out of Rayner’s group will harm, not help, British Muslims by “deepening their isolation and encouraging a victim mentality”.</span></p>
<figure id="attachment_677525" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-677525" style="width: 1920px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-677525 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg" alt="" width="1920" height="1168" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg 1920w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=300,183 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=768,467 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=1024,623 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=1536,934 1536w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=267,162 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=253,154 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=250,152 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=660,402 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Screenshot-2025-05-15-at-18.14.56-660x402.remini-enhanced.jpg?resize=480,292 480w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1920px) 100vw, 1920px" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-677525" class="wp-caption-text">Baroness Gohir, second left, pictured with Carla Denyer, co-leader of the Green Party, at the launch of Muslim Heritage Month at the House of Lords in March 2025. Photo by Alishia Abodunde/Getty Images.</figcaption></figure>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Today, though, with Labour under existential threat from Reform on one side, it is hemorrhaging votes and seats to candidates backed by Islamists on the other. It therefore finds itself under significant pressure to appease that lobby. Much of this is being applied via MPAC’s spiritual successor, TMV. Much as Ahmed did in 2005, last year TMV mobilized the now far larger Muslim electorate in the General Election. After months of vigorous campaigning, the group issued an appeal to all Muslims on the eve of the poll, asking them to vote for candidates it backed.</span><span style="font-weight: 400"><br />
</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">The results were spectacular. In the 21 constituencies where Muslims make up more than 30% of the electorate, Labour’s vote share </span><a href="https://hyphenonline.com/2024/07/06/the-impact-of-muslim-voters-at-the-2024-election-was-even-bigger-than-you-think-apsana-begum-shabana-mahmood-birmingham-perry-barr-blackburn-leicester-dewsbury-uk-election/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">fell</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> by an average 29 percentage points. The safe seats held by Wes Streeting, Shabana Mahmood and other ministers became marginals. Prominent MPs such as shadow cabinet member Jonathan Ashworth were turfed out, and TMV helped the ex-Labour renegade Jeremy Corbyn return to Parliament. One of the TMV coalition’s leading members is MEND — the organization with which Labour had severed its links. MEND had now had its revenge.</span><span style="font-weight: 400"><br />
</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Khalid Mahmood, whose 15,000 majority was wiped out in Birmingham Perry Barr, tells me that in its anxiety to staunch the loss of votes, Labour has failed to exercise due diligence. “People have got through to the leadership without any vetting,” he says. “I&#8217;m shocked by some of the stuff they’ve been involved in, and yet they&#8217;re going to be determining important areas of policy, especially on Islamophobia. How does a government minister appoint people with these connections?”  </span><span style="font-weight: 400"><br />
</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">According to Mahmood, the challenge from Muslim radicals also explains why Starmer has </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cx2vmdgdddyo" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">refused</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> to hold a national inquiry into the Pakistani-heritage grooming gangs. Islamists, he points out, often claim that the attention paid to the gangs’ ethnicity is itself driven by Islamophobia: “They like to say that overall there are more white abusers, but real, horrendous crimes have been committed by Pakistanis and Bengalis. There have been key gangs in these communities, and this has got to be dealt with.” Thus Labour’s “trepidation” over TMV may increase the future risk to vulnerable girls.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Back in 2012, when Starmer was director of public prosecutions, there seemed to be no such trepidation: Starmer </span><a href="https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/we-failed-grooming-victims-law-chief-keir-starmer-admits-9dwd9brflvm" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">said</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> there was </span><span style="font-weight: 400">“clearly an</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> </span><span style="font-weight: 400">issue of ethnicity that has to be understood and addressed”. </span><span style="font-weight: 400">But in April, his safeguarding minister Jess Phillips </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9w82y9z2vxo" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">made clear</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> there would be no national inquiry into grooming gangs. It is worth noting that in 2024, a TMV challenger slashed her majority from more than 10,000 to just 769</span><span style="font-weight: 400">.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Meanwhile, the lobbying continues, with familiar faces cropping up at the new organizations replacing those which have been barred from Westminster. In March, Akeela Ahmed — one of the five members of Angela Rayner’s Islamophobia “working group” — launched a new British Muslim Network (BMN) which </span><a href="http://bmn.org.uk/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">promises</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> to ensure that “British Muslim perspectives and experiences can engage with and shape policy”, and its supporters include the ex-Tory peer Sayeeda Warsi, who has often appeared at MEND events and </span><a href="https://www.thejc.com/news/features/the-puzzle-of-baroness-warsis-links-with-islamist-group-jyaj88mx" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">reportedly</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> once advised it on a “makeover”.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">What might those perspectives be? They seem unlikely to be amenable to free speech. Akeela’s BMN co-chair is the Leeds imam Qari Asim, who met King Charles at </span><a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/ephraim-mirvis-charles-muslim-jewish-buckingham-palace-b2696272.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">Buckingham Palace</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> in February after signing “reconciliation accords” with Jews. Asim was an adviser to Michael Gove until he was </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leeds-61771695" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">sacked</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> after an argument over free speech and blasphemy involving the screening of a film about Mohammed’s daughter, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400">The Lady of Heaven. </span></i></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">This is not the only question mark on his record. Asim also has ties with Pakistani imams who revere Mumtaz Qadri, who was </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-35684452" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400">executed</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400"> in 2016 for assassinating the Punjab governor Salman Taseer. Taseer had spoken out against the use of the death penalty for blasphemy — thus incurring the wrath of hardliners. </span> <span style="font-weight: 400">Asim has visited Qadri’s supporters in Pakistan and hosted others at public events in England praising them as “incredible”, “remarkable” and “insightful”. (Akeela Ahmed told me she did not know of Asim’s links with Qadri’s supporters, and does not share their views. Asim, for his part, said he is opposed to blasphemy laws, does not share the imams’ views of Qadri, and regards Taseer’s murder as a “repugnant crime”.)</span></p>
<figure id="attachment_677197" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-677197" style="width: 1024px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-677197 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg" alt="" width="1024" height="640" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg?resize=300,188 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg?resize=768,480 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg?resize=267,167 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg?resize=253,158 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg?resize=250,156 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg?resize=660,413 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg?resize=480,300 480w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2198334881.jpg?resize=800,500 800w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-677197" class="wp-caption-text">King Charles met Qari Asim in February 2025. Photo by Andrew Matthews – WPA Pool/Getty Images.</figcaption></figure>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">Today, though, the Islamist lobby is in a far stronger position than when Brown excommunicated the Muslim Council of Britain. Exercising its religious muscle, TMV has toppled Labour MPs, is the biggest electoral threat to survivors such as Jess Phillips, and has scored significant wins in the recent council elections, including in Lancashire where there were </span>victories <span style="font-weight: 400">for Maheen Kamran, who wants to prevent “free mixing” between men and women, and Azhar Ali, the Rochdale by-election candidate dropped by Labour last year for antisemitism.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">So while </span><span style="font-weight: 400">many moderate Muslims reject Islamism, TMV can call on a growing voting bloc to drown out those moderate voices. And even though</span><span style="font-weight: 400"> individuals such as Muddassar Ahmed reject these radical organizations, they nonetheless owe their access to the corridors of power to the sectarian vote marshalled by TMV, putting them in hoc to the actions of a group with radical connections.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400">And they are convinced their day is coming. On the day after the 2024 General Election, TMV boasted: “This is just the beginning, not the end. This has always been a five-election campaign&#8230; To all the naysayers who said the Muslim community can never unite, can never coordinate — tonight you had your answer. We take one step towards The Almighty, and then His help comes raining down.” </span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/how-islamism-infiltrated-downing-street/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/how-islamism-infiltrated-downing-street/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/how-islamism-infiltrated-downing-street/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">677143</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>US Trade Chief: Brexit liberated the UK</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/us-trade-chief-brexit-liberated-the-uk/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/us-trade-chief-brexit-liberated-the-uk/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/GettyImages-2214076203.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Interview</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Sohrab Ahmari]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/2204036.jpeg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['Brexit made it possible for the UK to do this.' Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty.]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Sohrab Ahmari</strong> is the US editor of <em>UnHerd</em>. His next book, on <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Triumph-Normal-Societies-Return-Common/dp/0063446936/"><em>The Triumph of Normal</em></a>, is forthcoming from HarperCollins.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>SohrabAhmari</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is the US editor of <em>UnHerd</em>. His next book, on <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Triumph-Normal-Societies-Return-Common/dp/0063446936/"><em>The Triumph of Normal</em></a>, is forthcoming from HarperCollins.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 08 May 2025 23:03:56 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 09 May 2025 09:04:32 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Brexit]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[European Union]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Keir Starmer]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Trade]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK-US trade deal]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=675756</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Negotiations with Brussels will be much harder]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer is in a good mood. “This is a job that goes up and down, but I’m on an up today”, he tells <em>UnHerd</em> in his first major interview with a European outlet, conducted just ahead of the news conference in which the US-UK trade deal was announced. And he leaves no doubt about how the long-sought arrangement came about: “Brexit liberates Britain to work with us in meaningful ways”.</p>
<p>Note well, though: it’s a trade agreement, not a free-trade deal. The difference means a lot to Greer, a lawyer who served as a senior aide to Robert Lighthizer, President Trump’s trade envoy during his first term and a ferocious critic of neoliberal globalization. Having assumed his former boss’s job in the second term, Greer also channels his worldview.</p>
<p>“When people talk about a free-trade deal,” he tells me, “the objective is: ‘Let’s just liberalize as much as we can, as quickly as we can, and we’ll just see where the chips fall economically. And let’s be as expansive as possible in the things that we’re covering.’ And as you know, my view is different.” To Greer, trade is only worthwhile if it’s “reciprocal, fair, balanced, and contributes to the economic security of the United States”.</p>
<p>The new UK-US deal — an “agreement in principle”, he insists, not the final document — reflects this narrower account of trade. “We are being somewhat picky about areas where we want to increase trade or maintain trade.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/jd-vance-my-message-to-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/jd-vance-my-message-to-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/GettyImages-2161880203.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/jd-vance-my-message-to-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/jd-vance-my-message-to-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>JD Vance: My message to Europe</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/jd-vance-my-message-to-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Sohrab Ahmari</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>For starters, “we are essentially maintaining our tariffs as a general matter”, says Greer. That is, the Trump administration’s 10% levy will remain in place as a sort of default. However, “there are areas where the United Kingdom [has] had higher tariffs and barriers to our products, where they will bring those down. On our side, we will find appropriate accommodation, consistent with US economic and national security interests, on things like autos and steel, while protecting our own industries.”</p>
<p>But is there any pathway for Britain to escape the 10% tariff altogether? “The main thing for Britain”, he says, “is they have an opportunity to go into the economic-security fold of the United States”, particularly with respect to sectors that Washington otherwise considers security-sensitive, such as automotives, pharmaceuticals, and semiconductors.</p>
<p>“Obviously,” he adds, “the British want to be able to take care of other sectors in their economy, etc. And there is a discussion to be had on that. But the nature of our national emergency” — persistently high, across-the-board trade deficits — “means that we need to be able to keep that 10%, and we expect that average tariff rates will remain high.”</p>
<p>Still, the agreement — the holy grail of UK politics for nearly a decade — was only made possible by Britain’s decision to leave the European Union. “Brexit made it possible for the UK to do this,” Greer tells me. “Especially with respect to tariff levels. The UK now controls its own tariff levels and can make its own decisions about what it wants to protect and what it doesn’t.”</p>
<p>Likewise, on non-tariff barriers such as regulatory hassles, “the UK now has sovereignty over these matters.” Here, one sticking point — the bane of US, UK, and European negotiators for at least the past two decades — has to do with Europe’s more stringent standards on agricultural products, particularly animal protein. Were “chlorinated chickens” a difficulty during Greer’s discussions with his counterparts?</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;The agreement — the holy grail of UK politics for nearly a decade — was only made possible by Britain’s decision to leave the European Union.&#8221;</div>
<p>“They certainly came up,” he says, “because that’s where we suffer so many barriers to the UK market”. Avoiding directly answering the poultry question, Greer says Washington anticipates “an expanded quota for American beef”, “a reduced on duty on that quota for beef”, and “a reduced tariff for American ethanol”. As for agricultural sanitary questions, “with any country you have to comply with their import rules, but we’re very happy to have that conversation with them”.</p>
<p>The haggling around these and other issues wasn’t easy. “I work directly with Varun Chandra,” a special adviser to Prime Minister Keir Starmer, “and Johnny Reynolds”, Britain’s secretary of state for business and trade. “These folks were professional, dedicated, and very tough negotiators, but at the same time very committed” to the special alliance.</p>
<p>Negotiations with Brussels are likely to prove even hairier. When I ask Greer which other trade conversations are advancing productively, he mentions India, Japan, South Korea, Switzerland, Israel, Jordan, and the Philippines — but not the European Union. “It’s a variety of economies,” he notes. “The UK is the sixth largest economy in the world, India is one of the largest economies in the world; but also some smaller economies where it’s also important to make sure that American influence is felt and present.”</p>
<p>As for Brussels, “they have expressed an interest in negotiating”. The problem is that “they have philosophical, legal, and cultural aversion to what we’re doing. It can be very challenging. But I have a very friendly relationship with my counterpart there. And I believe that they are strongly interested in a deal. And we’re open to a way forward on that, too. But it’s not as advanced as [with] other economies.”</p>
<p>But if the deepest goal of the tariff regime is to contain China’s rise, and decouple the American economy from the Middle Kingdom’s, shouldn’t Washington take it easier on the Europeans, not least so they’re more likely to collaborate with the United States on issues like Taiwan? Greer disagrees.</p>
<p>“I would just frame that differently,” he says. “I know that that’s a very Washington thing to say. I know people say, ‘Oh, we’re just aligning everyone against China’. Fundamentally, this is less about tagging one certain foreign country or another. We have this problem of a giant trade deficit. Which has led … our manufacturing base being diminished, having a lack of working-class jobs, etc.”</p>
<p>Fundamentally, it is the erosion of America’s industrial base and working-class security that are Team Trump’s prime objectives. “Obviously, China is a big aspect of that”, he grants. “But we have other countries that send a lot of stuff, too, where they have a lot of over-capacity. So, when we’re looking at agreements, which are essentially modifications of our regime, we’re asking: Are they helping us address our emergency?”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/tariffs-will-awaken-the-american-dream/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/tariffs-will-awaken-the-american-dream/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/GettyImages-1463832.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/tariffs-will-awaken-the-american-dream/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/tariffs-will-awaken-the-american-dream/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Tariffs will awaken the American Dream</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/04/tariffs-will-awaken-the-american-dream/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Edward Luttwak</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The new accord with Britain meets these criteria: “We have this deal with the UK, where they’re clearly giving us more market access, and other national-security-related measures, we can find a good accommodation that will ensure that we have protected supply chains. Those are the kinds of outcomes we’re looking for. We’re not trying to create two blocs.”</p>
<p>As one of the chief architects of the “Liberation Day” tariffs, Greer has maintained a relatively low profile, even in the United States. Yet it isn’t Donald Trump who pores over detailed trade tables and the minutiae of agricultural standards — it is Greer. Has the stock-market reaction to his policy vision made him at least a little queasy?</p>
<p>Not really. “There are a lot of indicators to the economy”, he replies. “So, of course, we watch these indicators to see what effect [our policies are having]. We find that the markets sometimes are good indicators. Sometimes they overreact, sometimes they underreact.”</p>
<p>Short-term alarm or optimism on Wall Street isn&#8217;t the best guide, he insists. “Right now, you have all the so-called smart people saying, ‘Well, we’re not seeing the effects of the new trade policies on the numbers yet — but we will!’ But it goes both ways. The first couple of weeks, they went, ‘Oh, well, look at the markets — this means everything’s bad.’ And then we got a really good jobs report. The GDP number was a little funky, but not quite as bad as some people thought it was going to be.”</p>
<p>Bottom line: “We are in the middle of a process, and taking any one data point and projecting a policy over the next months or years, it’s a dangerous thing to do. We watch it, we have to assess the indicators, but they can fluctuate based on imperfect information.” The Trump administration, in other words, believes that the US economy has enough juice to weather the epochal transition they have put in motion. And individual trade deals like the one with Britain can reassure market actors along the way.</p>
<p>No wonder Greer’s having an “up” day.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/us-trade-chief-brexit-liberated-the-uk/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/us-trade-chief-brexit-liberated-the-uk/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/05/us-trade-chief-brexit-liberated-the-uk/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">675756</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Steve Bannon is ready for war</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/steve-bannon-is-ready-for-war/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/steve-bannon-is-ready-for-war/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/GettyImages-2036301243.jpg?w=526</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Interview</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[James Billot]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/James-Bilot-Blue.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['I’m not a politician.' Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>James Billot is UnHerd&#8217;s <strong>Newsroom editor.</strong></p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>james_billot</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 18 Feb 2025 00:03:52 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 18 Feb 2025 13:11:26 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[China]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Elon Musk]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Populism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Silicon Valley]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Steve Bannon]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Tech bros]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[visas]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=656826</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[He talks Musk, China and a third Trump term]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>“Musk is a parasitic illegal immigrant. He wants to impose his freak experiments and play-act as God without any respect for the country’s history, values, or traditions.” Steve Bannon doesn&#8217;t hold back when I meet him in the basement of his Washington townhouse.</p>
<p>The <a href="https://www.thecut.com/2017/09/why-steve-bannon-wears-so-many-shirts.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">triple-shirted</a> architect of old-school Trumpian populism, briefly a White House advisor during Donald Trump&#8217;s first term, has emerged as the counterpole to Elon Musk, whose ultra-libertarian agenda has come to dominate the President&#8217;s second term. To Bannon, the billionaire X owner is more forceful and, perhaps, more dangerous than any figure on the Left. &#8220;Musk is the one with power at the moment,&#8221; he says. &#8220;The Democrats are nowhere to be seen.&#8221;</p>
<p>Less than a month into the Trump presidency, Musk has established himself as a core fixture in the White House. He holds news conferences in the Oval Office with his four-year-old; hosts foreign leaders in meetings that strikingly resemble head-of-state bilaterals; enjoys access to virtually every federal department; and, most importantly, has the ear of the President.</p>
<p>Bannon, meanwhile, must settle for a microphone. The 71-year-old’s <i>War Room</i> podcast beams out to hundreds of thousands of MAGA ultras six days a week — despite being purged from platforms including Spotify. In his studio, stacks of old <i>Financial Times</i> papers, archival documents and recording equipment are strewn across the table, overlooked by countless religious icons and memorabilia. “We have not yet begun to FIGHT,” reads one sign on his mantelpiece, beside a wooden crucifix labelled “full armor of God”. Top of his agenda: a third Trump term.</p>
<figure id="attachment_657047" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-657047" style="width: 1800px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-657047 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg" alt="" width="1800" height="1200" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg 1800w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=300,200 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=768,512 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=1024,683 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=1536,1024 1536w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=566,376 566w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=267,178 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=253,169 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=250,167 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=660,440 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SB.jpg?resize=480,320 480w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1800px) 100vw, 1800px" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-657047" class="wp-caption-text">Inside the War Room studio.</figcaption></figure>
<p>We met last Thursday, just days after Bannon pleaded guilty to skimming money from donations intended to privately fund the border wall, charges he nonetheless dismisses as “politically motivated” and “lawfare in the extreme”. But on that day he is in an ebullient mood: just before our meeting, the Senate confirmed Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as Secretary of Health and Human Services. “This is a historic day,” Bannon reflects. “If you weld together the MAHA movement with MAGA and add in Hispanics, African-American men, and conservative Right-wing Asians, we have a 1932 coalition” — a reference to FDR’s sweeping first victory. He takes a long pause. “And yes, we have the tech bros too.”</p>
<p>Since promising, and failing, to <a href="https://www.vanityfair.com/news/story/steve-bannon-vows-to-oust-elon-musk-from-donald-trump-inner-circle?srsltid=AfmBOopupJsK3n_Svddpn7GxjoWr6J0BQO5zu6Ht4eAVH9NgwMX7XE0c" target="_blank" rel="noopener">run Musk out</a> of the White House by Inauguration Day, Bannon’s view of the world’s richest man and his fellow “tech bros” hasn’t softened. He claims that he was willing to give Musk and his DOGE team the benefit of the doubt — “I have to give the devil his due” — for taking on the administrative state. But so far, he says, it has yielded disappointing results, as evidenced by the House panel’s <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/house-gop-panel-approves-budget-blueprint-steep-tax-spending-cuts-rcna192002" target="_blank" rel="noopener">budget blueprint</a>: “DOGE is sitting there with the budget, but where the fuck are the DOGE cuts? We are 30 days away from approving a budget for the entire year with $2 trillion already baked in, and not one penny of anything that DOGE found. It’s ludicrous.”</p>
<p>Musk’s DOGE team has instead elected to focus on several <i>bêtes noire</i><em>s</em> of the Right: the US Agency for International Development, the Department of Education, and DEI programs across the government. At the Department of Education alone, DOGE claims to have made nearly <a href="https://x.com/DOGE/status/1889113011282907434" target="_blank" rel="noopener">$900 million</a> in cuts, but as yet — and despite Trump’s <a href="https://www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/doge-department-of-defense-budget-cuts-prepares-0f7073fa" target="_blank" rel="noopener">permission</a> — it has not made a move on the Pentagon, which failed its <a href="https://www.cfo.com/news/pentagon-fails-7th-audit-in-a-row-michael-mccord-cfo-dod-pentagon/733313/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">seventh audit</a> in a row last year.</p>
<p>“I notice there is a hesitancy to cross the Potomac and go to the Pentagon,” Bannon says. “I would like to see $100 billion taken off the $900 billion budget right now, which is really a trillion.” Bannon goes on to describe DOGE’s efforts as “performative”, but for now, he is not ready to dispense with Musk. “It’s pretty evident the President&#8217;s using him as an armor-piercing shell that’s delivering blunt force trauma against the administrative state.”</p>
<p>This is a curious posture. On the one hand, Musk is, according to Bannon, an “agent of Chinese influence”, a problem “not just to the MAGA movement, but a problem to the country”. On the other, Bannon can countenance granting Musk access to the private data of nearly all government employees. Were Musk truly a threat to America’s national security, why would Bannon not be calling for his removal? “President Trump says Musk doesn’t do anything that he’s not on top of. I take him at his word.”</p>
<p>That feels like a lot of trust to place in one man, but to Bannon Trump is a “providential” figure. In his mind, Trump is facing something much harder than anything FDR dealt with and as a result, he should only be compared to the two other “top-tier” presidents: Washington and Lincoln. If there is an FDR comparison to be made, Bannon thinks, it’s that Trump should get a third term. He’s “exploring” options for this, he tells me.</p>
<p>Bannon knows that what he is proposing is unconstitutional, but if it further ingratiates him with the President, he’ll do it. “I don&#8217;t have right now a tremendous amount of support on this legally,” he says, “but remember, I faced longer odds on many other topics in my life.” It is also what happens when you turn a president into a god: politics becomes a holy war, creating a permission structure for a “by any means” approach to governance. On what basis would he even make the argument? “I&#8217;m working on making sure they have a correct interpretation of the Constitution,” he says. “I believe that President Trump&#8217;s eligible for one more term because I think it says consecutive.” It doesn’t. As the 22nd Amendment clearly states: &#8220;No person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice.&#8221; Trump has been elected twice.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“I believe that President Trump&#8217;s eligible for one more term&#8221;</div>
<p>Legality aside, does the country really need another octogenarian president? “You give me a guy at 78 years old that’s coming in and working 18, 20 hours a day and dropping bombs like he’s dropping every day,” Bannon says. “Every day for me is Christmas morning, so why would we want to stop it?”</p>
<p>These “bombs” include turning Canada into America’s 51st state — it would grant the United States greater access to the Arctic — and acquiring the Panama Canal (a “great geostrategic move”). He also commends Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth’s efforts to bring an end to the conflict in Ukraine (“it’s historic”). But when it comes to Trump’s plan to “clean out” Gaza and turn it into the riviera of the Middle East, the two men don’t seem entirely aligned. There is “bigger thinking on there that, quite frankly, I don’t understand&#8221;, Bannon tells me. “He’s thinking out loud, right? He’s outside the box on so many things, we just have to trust President Trump.”</p>
<p>Once again, we just have to trust him.</p>
<p>On the question of Europe, however, Bannon is in line with the administration. A day after Vice President J.D. Vance <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ceve3wl21x1o">browbeat</a> his European counterparts over free speech and mass migration, Bannon struck a similar note. “The message was clear: Europe is no longer going to be treated like a protectorate,” he says. “To me the Atlanticists are quite frankly the most racist people in the world because they only think about white people in Western Europe and the United States. They don&#8217;t have any other broad perspective.”</p>
<p>There is, though, a danger in pulling too hard on this thread. Leaders like Emmanuel Macron have been calling for strategic autonomy for some time, <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/apr/10/emmanuel-macron-sparks-anger-europe-vassal-us-china-clash" target="_blank" rel="noopener">warning</a> the continent to not “be a vassal” in a US-China stand-off. Is Bannon not concerned that the US may be pushing Europe into Beijing’s arms? “I am worried about that,” he says, “but the Chinese have already infiltrated Europe. The British elite are totally bought and paid for.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/peter-thiel-on-the-dangers-of-progress-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/peter-thiel-on-the-dangers-of-progress-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/2-7-e1671102377388.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/peter-thiel-on-the-dangers-of-progress-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/peter-thiel-on-the-dangers-of-progress-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Peter Thiel on the dangers of progress</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/12/peter-thiel-on-the-dangers-of-progress-2/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Mary Harrington</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Singling out the new British ambassador to the US, Peter Mandelson, Bannon warms to his theme: &#8220;From our mother country that we have a special relationship with, I can&#8217;t think of a worse individual to be sent over here that hates MAGA and that&#8217;s trashed Trump.&#8221; He adds: &#8220;They send him to Fox to grovel and say that he didn&#8217;t mean what he said before, but it won&#8217;t wash. Plus he&#8217;s on the payroll of the CCP.&#8221;</p>
<p>On domestic policy, meanwhile, Bannon offers a more subtle critique of Trump’s plan to extend the provisions in his signature Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which reduced tax rates for corporations and individuals. &#8220;I don’t think this should be renewed at all,&#8221; he says. &#8220;I’m mad about that.&#8221; He even expresses disappointment at the rate of deportations, which, despite all the noise, is moving at a similar rate as the Obama era. &#8220;We have to deport the 10 million illegal aliens who are here. Right now, we can’t even get the criminals out of jail.&#8221;</p>
<p>This is, in Bannon’s mind, not Trump’s fault, but the Deep State’s — the same Deep State that stole the 2020 presidential election, incarcerated him for four months, and is now working to undo the Trump agenda. It’s a convenient foil. Blame the Deep State if something goes wrong and claim victory if Musk does his job. For this reason, Bannon is happy for the president to &#8220;wrangle&#8221; the tech bros. &#8220;The enemy of the enemy is my friend,&#8221; he says. &#8220;This country is being destroyed by the Praetorian guard of the administrative state… Elon is helping expose this.&#8221;</p>
<p>Though neither would care to admit it, there is a certain symmetry between Bannon and Musk. Bannon joined Trump in the final stretch of his 2016 campaign, and then took on a high position once he entered office, while Musk did much the same in 2024. Both men had their turn on the cover of <em>TIME</em> magazine, a moment that precipitated Bannon’s downfall from Trumpian grace shortly after.</p>
<p>&#8220;Sloppy Steve&#8221;, as he became known, likes to talk. He was ousted from the White House for being one of the primary sources in Michael Wolff’s book <i>Fire and Fury</i>, and was repeatedly accused of leaking while in office. This habit made him even more of a nuisance once he was out, with a recent <i>New York Times</i> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/10/magazine/charlie-kirk-american-right.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">story</a> noting that the administration was getting &#8220;hammered by Right-wing media&#8221; almost immediately after.</p>
<p>All of which is to say that Bannon can cause problems if he wants to. And in making an enemy out of Musk, what may appear like a squabble between two egotistical men could spill out into open warfare. Because at the heart of this conflict is a battle over the philosophical direction of the Trump presidency and, by extension, the country. That Vance even felt the need to <a href="https://x.com/JDVance/status/1889640434793910659" target="_blank" rel="noopener">address</a> this &#8220;civil war&#8221; between the &#8220;populists and techies&#8221; — which he said was overstated — nonetheless shows that the tension in this coalition is not immaterial.</p>
<p>Despite Bannon claiming to be in regular contact with the White House, is Musk’s presence there a sign that the techno–libertarians are winning? &#8220;Absolutely not. Look at who he has put in: Neil Ferguson at the FTC, Gail Slater on antitrust, and <a href="https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/trump-taps-mike-davis-ally-to-advise-on-judicial-selection" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Mike Davis</a> on the White House counsel,&#8221; he responds. &#8220;Trump is sending a signal to tech bros, saying, ‘You don’t own me,’ and he’s also saying, ‘I’m not buying your techno-libertarian stuff.&#8217; That was a huge fuck you to the broligarchs.&#8221;</p>
<p>The populists, then, are securing enough appointments to keep Bannon happy for now. But Trump has also <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/elon-musk-is-a-danger-to-trumpism/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">gutted</a> the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/elon-musk-is-a-danger-to-trumpism/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">crippled</a> the National Labor Relations board — hardly pro-worker moves. There is also the looming budget, which may include cuts to Medicaid, a federal health insurance program for over-65s. After we spoke, the War Room host fired out another warning shot at Musk on his <a href="https://newrepublic.com/post/191557/steve-bannon-warns-republicans-cut-medicaid" target="_blank" rel="noopener">podcast</a>. &#8220;There are a lot of MAGAs on Medicaid,&#8221; he said. &#8220;I’m telling you, if you don’t think so, you are dead wrong… Just can’t take a meat axe to it, although I would love to.&#8221;</p>
<p>“You’re not going to win every fight,” Bannon says. “You’ve got to pick the fight you want to win.” So what happens if he loses one of those fights? He draws three red lines: China, AI, and visas. The last of these already caused a major rift in the MAGA movement shortly after Christmas — before Trump even took office — with Elon Musk <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_EFqfHKkaE" target="_blank" rel="noopener">threatening</a> to go to “war” with other parts of the MAGA coalition, not least Bannon, over-expanding the guest-worker programs beloved of Silicon Valley. It resulted in the now former DOGE executive Vivek Ramaswamy going into “witness protection” — a scalp claimed by Bannon and the MAGA base. “It shows that Trump doesn’t believe in any of this techno-libertarian stuff.”</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“You’re not going to win every fight. You’ve got to pick the fight you want to win.”</div>
<p>China is a different story. Bannon describes himself as a “super hawk”, and he calls for a “hemispheric defense” against Beijing, which stretches from Greenland all the way down to Javier Milei’s Argentina. Together, this vast landmass would be a bulwark against communist influence, with tariffs protecting North America as a “premium market”. For this reason, Ukraine must sign a peace deal with Russia so that the unholy alliance of Putin and Xi does not strengthen any further.</p>
<p>For Bannon, though, the AI threat is greater still. At last week’s Paris conference, Vance promised a “pro-worker growth path for AI”, but the <em>War Room</em> host is convinced this will simply empower the Chinese state, as well as oligarchs in the US. “We have let the wealthiest people in America soar to the commanding heights of the algorithmic age with no controls,” he says. “They have created an apartheid state. You don&#8217;t have to hire any blacks or Hispanics in this country. Or even American citizens.”</p>
<p>Bannon worries that the rise of AI will not only take blue-collar jobs but entry-level jobs at a technical and administrative level too. “We can’t let these techno-vandals randomly hop from one core institution to another, spray-painting garbage graffiti with no intention of ever cleaning it up.” Were Musk to make further encroachments on his red lines, Bannon promises that he would “pound” him every day on the podcast.</p>
<p>Would Musk even care? Despite all of Bannon’s attacks, Musk has limited his response to a <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2025/02/06/elon-musk-steve-bannon-feud-013395" target="_blank" rel="noopener">single tweet</a>, describing the War Room host as “a great talker, but not a great doer”. Nevertheless, Bannon assures me that he has “pretty good political connections” on Capitol Hill and in the White House. He also claims that his recent Manhattan court case inspired new Attorney General Pam Bondi to file a <a href="https://www.newsweek.com/bondi-ny-immigration-lawsuit-letitia-james-hochul-2030311" target="_blank" rel="noopener">lawsuit</a> against New York over immigration, which feels like a stretch. “This is not a brag, it’s just a fact,” he says.</p>
<p>Still, Bannon must surely resent that he is no longer inside a movement that he helped to create. Instead, the tech bros, who had their “Damascene moment at 11pm on November 5”, are now in charge. With the Democrats in disarray, it leaves open the question of who will take ownership of the movement after 2028. “The bench is deep,” says Bannon, without naming names. He stresses, though, that future leaders from both political parties won’t be politicians, citing Stephen A. Smith, a sports TV presenter, as a contender for the Democratic Party. “Democrats will defer to MAGA-type, Trumpian personalities,” he says. “Smith has an ability to communicate to the American people.”</p>
<p>“New leaders are going to emerge,” he assures me. “Remember Sherman was considered a nut case. Grant was a drunk. Lincoln was a failed congressman.” Does that list include ex-convict podcasters? “No, no, no, that’s ridiculous — I’m not a politician.” Nor is Stephen A. Smith — and nor, once, was Donald Trump.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/steve-bannon-is-ready-for-war/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/steve-bannon-is-ready-for-war/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/steve-bannon-is-ready-for-war/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">656826</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Will the Biden family escape justice?</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/will-the-biden-family-escape-justice/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/will-the-biden-family-escape-justice/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Hunter-biden-laptop-v3.jpg?w=747</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>laptop from hell</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Miranda Devine]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/sohrab.ahmari_unherd.com_720.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p>Miranda Devine is a columnist for the <em>New York Post</em>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>mirandadevine</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[Miranda Devine is a columnist for the <em>New York Post</em>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 06 Feb 2025 00:01:57 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 17 Feb 2025 17:50:25 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Biden]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Big tech]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Censorship]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[CIA]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Deep State]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[fbi]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hunter Biden]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hunter Biden laptop]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[New York Post]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium Article]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=654238</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[A reckoning is coming to Washington]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Hunter Biden’s “laptop from hell” is at the center of the reckoning that Donald Trump is bringing to Washington. Almost the first action of the freshly sworn-in president was to sign an executive order stripping security clearances from the 51 former intelligence officials who, in October 2020, <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2020/10/19/hunter-biden-story-russian-disinfo-430276">signed a letter</a> claiming that emails from the laptop were a “Russian information operation”. Last week, he added a memorandum banning most of the former spooks from entering secure federal facilities. The Hunter Biden censors have, literally, left the building.</p>
<p>Uncritically reported by <em>Politico</em> at the time, their claims helped legitimate the Big Tech censorship of the <em>New York Post </em>— America’s oldest continuous daily newspaper, where I serve as a columnist — which broke the laptop story. The emails put the lie to Joe Biden’s claims that he knew “nothing” about his son Hunter’s overseas business dealings and apparent influence peddling, not least Hunter’s 2015 role in connecting his father, then Barack Obama’s vice president, with executives from Burisma, a Ukrainian energy firm on whose board Hunter served.</p>
<p>Thanks to the combined efforts of Twitter (now X), Facebook, the mainstream media, and the Deep State, all this was buried, and Biden eked out a win.<br />
<a id="continuereading" name="continuereading"></a></p>
<p>Four years later, a resurrected Trump piled on the punishments for the “spies who lied”, as the <em>Post</em> <a href="https://nypost.com/2024/06/25/us-news/cia-admits-some-spies-who-lie-were-active-contractors-as-records-show-internal-fear-of-long-run-harm-of-letter/">dubbed the 51 officials</a>. “The signatories willfully weaponized the gravitas of the Intelligence Community to manipulate the political process and undermine our democratic institutions”, he wrote in his Day One executive order, followed by last week’s memorandum banning them from secure buildings.</p>
<p>Trump believes that the actions of the ex-spooks was a major reason why he lost the blisteringly close election of 2020, in which fewer than 45,000 votes in five states made the difference. Yet with Biden out of office, it’s all too easy to lose sight of the magnitude of the crisis that goes beyond a single election: the corruption of both America’s security apparatus and its establishment political class as embodied by the Biden family.</p>
<p>In hindsight, the letter signed by the 51 spies should be seen as a domestic CIA election-interference operation in cahoots with the Biden campaign. It was part of a coordinated Deep State effort to ensure that Donald Trump wouldn’t win a second term and that the sins of Joe Biden remained hidden from the American people.</p>
<p>Five former CIA directors or acting directors signed the letter: Mike Hayden, Leon Panetta, John Brennan, John McLaughlin, and Mike Morell. That last was the principal author, who hoped he would lead the CIA if Biden won the election. In all, 41 of the 51 signatures came from the CIA.</p>
<p>Morell told congressional investigators from the House Judiciary Committee in 2023 that the letter had been solicited by the Biden campaign adviser and future secretary of State, Antony Blinken, in a call to Morell, who quarterbacked it through the CIA classification review process in record time.</p>
<p>We now know, thanks to <a href="https://intelligence.house.gov/uploadedfiles/the_intelligence_community_51-_how_cia_contractors_colluded_with_the_biden_campaign_to_mislead_american_voters.pdf">Andrew Makridis</a>, then the CIA’s chief operating officer, testifying before the Judiciary committee last year, that the letter was cleared for publication by then-CIA director Gina Haspel, a protégé of Brennan’s, who also had her fingerprints on Operation Crossfire Hurricane. The operation was the foundation of Russiagate, which framed the 2016 Trump campaign for “collusion” with the Kremlin, when she was CIA station chief in London in 2016.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/hunter-biden-and-the-curse-of-the-failson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/hunter-biden-and-the-curse-of-the-failson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/GettyImages-1297458688-copy-scaled-e1675784078283.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/hunter-biden-and-the-curse-of-the-failson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested article</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/hunter-biden-and-the-curse-of-the-failson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Hunter Biden and the curse of the failson</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/hunter-biden-and-the-curse-of-the-failson/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Michael Cuenco</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Morell told colleagues <a href="https://www.foxnews.com/media/sean-hannity-intel-officials-worked-behalf-biden-campaign-spread-disinformation">in an email</a> that the letter was timed to appear on the eve of the final presidential debate to give Biden a “talking point to push back on Trump on this issue”. It worked like a charm, allowing Biden to deflect the bombshell revelations about his family’s international influence peddling.</p>
<p>“Look, there are 50 former national intelligence folks who said that what he’s accusing me of is a Russian plant”, Biden coolly told the debate moderators. “Four, five former heads of the CIA, both parties, say what he’s saying is a bunch of garbage”.</p>
<p>Trump kept harping on the laptop, with all its evidence of diamonds and millions of dollars that Hunter was paid by Chinese energy company CEFC, whose executives Biden had met in Washington. But Joe Biden denied it all: “My son has not made money in terms of this thing about — what are you talking about? — China”. He concluded his performance by looking down the barrel of the camera and addressing American voters at home: “You know his character. You know my character. You know my reputation is for honor and telling the truth. The character of the country is on the ballot.”</p>
<p>Yes, it was.</p>
<p>Getting Biden to his false vindication during the debate took a months-long team effort. In one of the regular meetings the FBI conducted with social-media companies to sound the alarm about supposed disinformation in the weeks leading up to the 2020 election, somebody warned of a “hack-and-leak operations” by “state actors” involving Hunter Biden and “likely” to take place in October, according to a sworn declaration by Yoel Roth, who headed Twitter’s trust and safety department at the relevant time. The warnings were so specific that when the <em>Post</em>’s scoop first appeared, Facebook and Twitter recognized it and immediately throttled its reach.</p>
<p>Twitter claimed the story violated its “hacked-materials” policy. Officials with the company claimed that they couldn’t permit the release of journalistic material not authorized by the subject — a stance that would have rendered impossible the Pentagon Papers, the Abu Ghraib disclosures, and every other legendary scoop celebrated in journalism seminars across the land.</p>
<p>In the event, the laptop hadn’t been hacked. Rather, Hunter Biden had abandoned the waterlogged device in April 2019 at a Delaware repair shop without paying for services, granting the owner what lawyers call “constructive ownership.” Moreover, Twitter executives knew even at the time that their hacked-materials excuse was so much bosh, as we now know thanks to Elon Musk’s disclosure of the #TwitterFiles. But that didn’t stop them from locking the <em>Post</em>’s account for two weeks, silencing the newspaper founded by Alexander Hamilton.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“The FBI &#8230; knew the Post story was not Russian disinformation.”</div>
<p>Something similar unfolded at Facebook. “Right on schedule,” a Facebook employee said of the timing of the laptop story in an internal chat obtained by the House Judiciary Committee’s subcommittee on the weaponization of government. “FBI tipped us all off last week that this Burisma story was likely to emerge,” an unidentified Microsoft employee wrote in another internal message.</p>
<p>The FBI, too, knew the <em>Post</em> story was not Russian disinformation. The agency had had possession of the laptop for 10 months, as <span style="color: #000000;">prosecutors would tell a Delaware court during Hunter’s 2024 gun trial. </span>The FBI’s forensic analysis, moreover, had concluded that the device belonged to Hunter, had not been tampered with, and was fit for use as evidence in court. CBS News reached the same conclusion after commissioning its own <a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hunter-biden-laptop-data-analysis/">independent analysis of the laptop</a> in 2022.</p>
<p>How did the FBI have possession of the laptop so much earlier? The Delaware store owner, John Paul Mac Isaac, became alarmed by content he found on the computer that he feared was a national-security risk. He handed the laptop to the FBI in December 2019. Nine months later, Mac Isaac handed Trump’s personal lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, a copy of the hard drive, believing a batch of Ukrainian invoices would exonerate Trump during his first impeachment.</p>
<p>At the time, the Internal Revenue Service was investigating Hunter for tax violations related to his international dealings. But every time investigators Gary Shapley and Joe Ziegler tried to follow a trail of evidence that led to Joe, they were obstructed by prosecutors in the office of the US attorney for Delaware, David Weiss, as Shapley and Ziegler would later tell Congress.</p>
<p>After they blew the whistle, Shapley and Ziegler were dismissed from their jobs. Still, their testimony derailed the suspicious sweetheart plea deal that the Biden Department of Justice had stitched up with Hunter’s lawyers, which would have amounted to probation on a couple of tax misdemeanors and immunity from future prosecution over other crimes.</p>
<p>The FBI knew something else, too. It had been spying on Giuliani in 2020 using a covert surveillance warrant on his iCloud. Agents thus had access to an email from Mac Isaac to Giuliani, from August 2020, disclosing information from the laptop that would damage Biden’s campaign. The FBI also would have had access to messages between me and Giuliani two months later, indicating that the <em>New York Post</em> was interested in the story.</p>
<p>To sum up all this in other words: The American security apparatus knew that the laptop was authentic; and that buried in the laptop’s treasury of bank statements, corporate documents, and homemade porn were emails that made the Democratic nominee for president look pretty bad. Nevertheless, intelligence officials at the highest levels pretended that the laptop was “disinformation” and prevailed upon Big Tech to censor the <em>Post</em>, with the mainstream media dutifully justifying the censorship in the name of protecting democracy.</p>
<p>Which brings us to Joe Biden’s grift. Depicted through the adventures of Hunter and his fast-talking uncle, Joe’s brother Jim Biden, the scale of the family’s corruption has slowly dripped into the public consciousness over the last four years. This is mainly thanks to congressional committees with subpoena power that sprang into action once Republicans retook control of the House in 2022.</p>
<p>But back in October 2020, the <em>Post</em> was on its own. In its first story, the paper revealed a 2015 email from an executive of Burisma, the Ukrainian energy firm, which was then paying Biden’s son $83,333 a month to serve on its board (his pay was cut in half after his father left the vice presidency). Vadym Pozharskyi, the executive, thanked Hunter for “the opportunity to meet your father” the previous evening in Washington.</p>
<p>That meeting, we later discovered, was a dinner organized by Hunter in a private room at Café Milano in Washington on 16 April, 2015, at which his powerful father met some of his colleagues from Ukraine, Russia, and Kazakhstan. Upon the story’s publication, Biden campaign spokesman Andrew Bates told the media: “They never had a meeting”. Months after the election, the White House admitted that Joe Biden <em>did</em> attend the Café Milano dinner.</p>
<p>It was just one of the dozens of meetings he had during his vice presidency with his son’s foreign partners, after which millions of dollars would flow into the family coffers. Hunter would also call his father and put him on speaker phone when he wanted to impress a prospective client or partner, according to Devon Archer, Hunter’s former business partner. Another email published by the <em>Post</em> described a plan to allocate 10 percent of a lucrative Chinese venture to “The Big Guy” — the code name Hunter’s partners used to refer to Joe Biden.</p>
<p>It would take another three years for James Comer, chairman of the Republican-controlled House Oversight Committee, to identify 20 shell companies created by Hunter and his partners, into which more than $30 million flowed from Chinese and other foreign entities after Joe Biden became Obama’s vice president. Incremental payments were made from those companies to at least 10 Biden family members, including Joe Biden himself.</p>
<p>Comer released bank records revealing that “Joe Biden received $40,000 in laundered China money from the account of his brother, James [Jim] Biden, and his sister-in-law, Sara Biden, in the form of a personal check”. He uncovered another $200,000 check to Joe from Jim. Both checks were labeled “loan repayment,” and the White House maintained that Joe had kindly helped his brother when he was in need; Comer could find no proof to suggest otherwise.</p>
<p>Even so, evidence from the laptop suggests that Hunter had paid for upkeep and maintenance of Joe Biden’s Delaware estate, as well as the monthly bill for his father’s private cellphone. Hunter footed the bill for a lot of family expenses through the years and often griped in family discussions that he never got sufficient credit. In one message on the laptop, he complains that he has had to “pay for everything for this entire family for 30 years”.</p>
<p>For months after Joe was sworn in as president, Democrats and their media allies ignored the laptop. Some were still in denial right up until the moment last December, when Joe Biden broke his promise not to pardon Hunter.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“Joe Biden effectively pardoned Joe Biden.”</div>
<p>Days before Hunter was to be sentenced over a felony gun conviction in Delaware and felony tax fraud in California, Joe Biden gave his son an unprecedented “full and unconditional pardon” for any crime he might have committed stretching back 11 years to January 2014, the year of Ukraine’s Maidan Revolution, which brought the country under the influence of the vice president from Delaware and opened the door to Biden-family self-dealing.</p>
<p>The pardon timeline covered all the Ukraine grift, and most of the China grift, everything that would implicate Joe Biden in Hunter’s influence-peddling. That’s another way of saying that Joe Biden effectively pardoned Joe Biden.</p>
<p>Then, on 27 December, new photographs emerged from an activist lawsuit against the National Archives showing then-Vice President Biden introducing Hunter to Chinese President Xi Jinping and other Chinese Communist Party dignitaries in Beijing a decade earlier. To Chinese eyes, it was clear when Hunter followed his father off Air Force Two that this was American power come to do private business. A few days later, Hunter would receive a 10 percent stake in the Chinese equity firm BHR. Hunter’s business partner in the venture, Jonathan Li, is pictured in several Beijing photographs gladhanding Joe Biden.</p>
<p>But the scope of Biden’s pardons went far beyond Hunter. Preemptive unconditional pardons were also granted to his brothers Jim and Frank and their wives, and his sister Val and her husband. Jim, who was deeply involved Hunter’s China dealings and had been under investigation by the Department of Justice over various deals invoking Joe’s name. Frank, the youngest, spent years avoiding paying a court-ordered $1 million to the children of a Florida man killed in a high-speed hit-and-run. A few years later, at age 49, he was arrested for shoplifting in a Florida Blockbuster when he allegedly stuffed two DVDs down his pants.</p>
<p>As with Hunter, Joe pardoned his siblings for all nonviolent crimes they may have committed going back to January 2014, in what seems to many like an implicit admission of guilt for the period when Joe’s power and influence in the world garnered a fortune for his family.</p>
<p>For many Democrats on the day of the pardon, disappointment with Joe turned to bitter rancor. Big Tech, the Deep State, and the corporate media conspired to suppress evidence of Joe Biden’s corruption, and then he made fools of them all. He refused to give up power when he should have, and when they discarded him too late, he snookered them with an unelectable nominee, Kamala Harris, whom he had selected as his veep to fulfill a pledge to hire a woman of color.</p>
<p>“No one fucks with a Biden,” he is reportedly fond of saying. You could see in the old man’s sly, lopsided grin as he turned away from the camera one last time after his party’s election drubbing, that the muscle memory of a machine politician was in full working order. In his one last act of political bastardy, Joe Biden blew up the Democratic Party. Now, as Donald Trump lays waste to all their works in Washington, they only have themselves to blame.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/will-the-biden-family-escape-justice/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/will-the-biden-family-escape-justice/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/02/will-the-biden-family-escape-justice/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">654238</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Who verifies BBC Verify?</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/who-verifies-bbc-verify/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/who-verifies-bbc-verify/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/bbc_verify_graphic_3_2.jpg?w=622</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Investigation </unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[David Rose]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Blue-thumbnail-archie.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Why does Verify need to employ over 60 members of staff?]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>David Rose </strong>is <i>UnHerd</i>&#8216;s Investigations Editor.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>DavidRoseUK</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an <strong>Editorial Assistant</strong> at <strong>UnHerd.</strong>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 04 Nov 2024 00:03:12 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 11 Nov 2024 12:46:07 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[BBC]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[bbc verify]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[disinformation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium Article]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=633868</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The disinformation unit has a record of failure]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><strong>BBC Verify, the new fact-checking service inside the BBC, was launched last year with much fanfare and at great expense. Its verdicts are pushed across all the corporation&#8217;s channels. So why is it getting so many things wrong? And where is the accountability for these arbiters of truth? UnHerd Investigations Editor, David Rose, subjects Verify to some fact-checking of his own…</strong></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">On 6 August, at the height of the riots that swept Britain after the Southport murders, </span><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20240806050446/https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cj622z0w7n0o" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">BBC Verify</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> revealed “one of the most shocking” outbreaks of violence: a racist attack on Humberside. According to Verify, “an angry mob of white men surrounded and attacked a car with men of Asian heritage inside.” Some of the attackers “threw bricks and shouted racist slurs. One performed the Nazi salute.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Verify team deployed its OSINT (open source intelligence) skills and facial recognition software to compare images from the scene with social media profiles. Soon enough, they’d identified and named two of the alleged attackers. Yet despite having no less than four writers on the story </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">— just one of many Verify articles to boast multiple bylines — this gaggle of reporters initially failed to spot the most important fact of all. </span><br />
<a id="continuereading"></a></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">That only became clear later, in a note added at the bottom of the BBC website once the story had been published. “An earlier version of this article identified the men in the car as of Asian heritage,” it said. “Humberside Police has since told the BBC they are Eastern European.” To put it differently, the victims on Humberside were as white as their attackers. Whatever else the incident was, then, it certainly wasn’t a straightforward case of white racism against non-white targets. Later, the BBC also changed the headline.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">If journalism is the first draft of history, often produced at speed, it’s inevitable that reporters sometimes get things wrong. But just as the 6 August story suffered from a glaring and arguably story-ending error, BBC Verify seems to suffer more mistakes than most. Having examined more than 200 stories listed on BBC Verify’s website, and produced between its launch in May 2023 and 5 October this year, we found 12 that were later corrected, clarified or withdrawn. That’s about one in 20.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">For an outfit like BBC Verify,</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> an expensive new unit established to combat disinformation, that’s awkward enough. That’s doubly true when journalists elsewhere in the corporation face redundancy, </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">with £24 million annual cuts to the BBC News budget forcing executives to axe well-regarded programmes and shed 130 staff. Yet beyond these individual embarrassments, or the strange focus on Verify to the detriment of other reporting, the real story here is what BBC Verify says about the contemporary BBC’s approach to journalism </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">— and how it often seems to put shallow, memeable newsgathering ahead of the facts. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">BBC Verify was born in an age of disinformation, in which “fake news” spread by platforms such as TikTok has eroded trust in “legacy media” — and diminished its audience. A high-level BBC insider says that from the moment Deborah Turness was appointed chief executive of BBC News in 2022, she tried to persuade her senior colleagues that the way to restore both was to set up a unit to challenge the spread of disinformation and report the facts. She got her way, and BBC Verify was the result. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Despite being founded around 18 months ago, Verify has quickly come to dominate BBC News output. Boasting over 60 dedicated journalists, it enjoys a special corner of the BBC website, with each story it publishes highlighted by a BBC Verify logo. Covering everything from war (“What satellite images reveal about Israel&#8217;s strikes on Iran”) to climate change (“No, Hurricane Milton was not &#8216;engineered’”), online content is dovetailed by Verified Live, which airs weekdays on BBC News. No less striking, Verify has also made stars of several BBC journalists. One example is </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">Ros Atkins, the BBC’s analysis editor. Another is Marianna Spring, a disinformation correspondent who’s appeared everywhere from Breakfast to Radio 4, and so become one of the corporation’s most recognisable faces.</span></p>
<p><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="alignnone wp-image-634395 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg" alt="" width="1920" height="1311" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg 1920w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=300,205 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=768,524 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=1024,699 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=1536,1049 1536w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=267,182 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=253,173 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=250,171 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=660,451 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/BBCVerify-1.jpg?resize=480,328 480w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1920px) 100vw, 1920px" /></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Given all this coverage, at any rate, it’s unsurprising that Verify should also enjoy praise from executives. “BBC Verify is transparency in action </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">—</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> fact-checking, verifying video, countering disinformation, analysing data and explaining complex stories in the pursuit of truth,” is how Turness put it. As Verify’s creator has added, its staff aren’t just ordinary journalists. Rather, they’re “a highly specialised team with a range of forensic and OSINT capabilities that enable them to go beyond conventional newsroom techniques”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Last month Turness sent a message to every BBC journalist making further grandiose claims. In the note, seen by </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">UnHerd</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, she said Verify was “on the front line” of the corporation’s “fight for truth”, and its “forensic teams” were “setting the standard for transparent journalism”. Such enthusiasm is clearly echoed in the accounting department too: the BBC has said the salary bill for Verify’s 63 staff is £3.2 million a year.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Yet amid the plaudits and the paychecks, just how accurate is Verify’s reporting? </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Certainly, that the unit has had to correct, clarify or withdraw about one in 20 stories isn’t a good start. “The BBC claims that BBC Verify is on the frontline of the ‘fight for truth’ </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">—</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> but the fact it has been forced to correct 5% of its stories suggests otherwise,” explains Danny Cohen, the former director of BBC Television. “That is a very high number for any news organisation, and the BBC should be upholding the highest of standards.” </span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;The BBC claims that BBC Verify is on the frontline of the ‘fight for truth’ — but the fact it has been forced to correct 5% of its stories suggests otherwise&#8221;</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Nor do things look much better once you dig a little deeper. Like the Humberside story, after all, some mistakes involve that most sensitive of subjects: race. On 25 February, for instance, BBC Verify published a troubling </span><a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/business-68349396" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">exposé</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;">. Its author, Maryam Ahmed, had used advanced statistical techniques to compare thousands of car insurance quotes, finding that drivers in racially diverse areas were having to pay much higher premiums </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">—</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> an average of 33% more than people from places that were mainly white.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">It seemed the motor insurance industry was racist, for behind the disparity lay what the BBC called an “ethnicity penalty”. Even if differing levels of accidents, crime and economic prosperity were taken into account, “areas with a high number of people from ethnic minorities saw higher prices”, the article said. It went on to quote a demand from Citizens Advice that the Financial Conduct Authority “get off the sidelines and investigate why people of colour are being charged so much more”.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Seven months later, the BBC quietly replaced the article with an embarrassing </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-68349396" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">statement</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;">. It now transpired there was no “ethnicity penalty” after all. The BBC “had not established why premiums were higher”, because it had failed to see “the limitations of the data we used”. The story “did not meet our normal editorial standards” and was therefore being deleted.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">And if that’s echoed by errors in other domestic stories — among other things, that includes a </span><a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/y1i9tmgibi5atej/Screenshot%202024-11-01%20at%2012.00.29.png?dl=0" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">muddle</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> over high speed railways — the unit has arguably faced its biggest problems very far from Britain. </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">Since the Hamas attack of October 2023, indeed, the Middle East has proved something of a theme for the unit: our analysis shows that in the year since the attack, about a fifth of the stories listed on its website have focused on the region. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">And if Cohen says this suggests an “unhealthy obsession” with events in Israel, some of Verify’s claims on this most controversial of conflicts don’t stand up.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Early in the war, on 17 October last year, an explosion at the Al Ahli hospital in Gaza triggered furious controversy, after the BBC correspondent Jon Donnison said on air that it was “hard to see” what could have caused it other than an Israeli airstrike. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Israel insisted that the blast was caused by a Palestinian rocket, but according to Donnison, these might kill “half a dozen </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">—</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> maybe a few more”, and “when we’ve seen rockets being fired out of Gaza, we never see explosions of this scale”. In its reports that evening, the BBC echoed a claim by Hamas that it had killed 500 people. In fact, the hospital itself had not been hit: the blast was in the car park outside, and the death toll, according to both Western governments and Human Rights Watch, was far lower than 500.  </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">BBC Verify published three successive items on the event, culminating in a lengthy article on 26 October that carried the bylines of no fewer than 12 of its staff. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">By this time, the Biden administration and numerous independent experts had concluded that the explosion was caused by a misfired rocket, launched from inside Gaza. Rishi Sunak, the then-prime minister, had told Parliament this was likely true, based on the “deep knowledge and analysis of our intelligence and weapons experts&#8221;. Yet BBC Verify continued to maintain the cause of the blast was still “</span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-67216929" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">contested</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;">” </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">—</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> and that, as Hamas still claims, it might have been an Israeli strike. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Verify’s assertion relied on analysis by an organisation called Forensic Architecture, which the BBC somewhat obliquely described as a “UK-based organisation which investigates human rights abuses”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">What it failed to mention was that Forensic Architecture’s advisory board </span><a href="https://forensic-architecture.org/about/advisory-board" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">includes</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> Ryvka Barnard, the deputy director of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign; and that it has a long record of issuing reports critical of Israel. At the same time, Forensic Architecture has often worked with Al Haq, a Palestinian group designated a </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-62593244" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">terrorist organisation</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> by Israel. After the October 7 attacks, meanwhile, Al Haq staff issued numerous </span><a href="https://ngo-monitor.org/reports/al-haqs-extremist-demonization-of-israel/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">statements</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> describing them as legitimate acts of resistance. One of its leaders urged his social media followers to support the “jihad”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Despite all this, Verify’s initial story is still online </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">— complete with the claim that the origin of the hospital blast remains “contested”. That’s even as the story now includes a clarification at the bottom conceding that Forensic Architecture itself now admits “they had been wrong” about the specifics of the attack.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Nor is this Verify’s only Gaza story to be based on dubious sources. On 1 March, it published a report into the deaths of 112 </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">Gazans, who’d died the previous day while food was being distributed from a convoy of aid trucks. Hamas claimed most of the dead had been shot by the IDF; Israel that they’d been crushed in a stampede.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The six named Verify staff accredited in its report analysed satellite photos, videos and drone footage. It seems OSINT wasn’t much help, as they still weren’t able to draw any definitive conclusions. In the end, Verify relied on an old-fashioned human source. A Palestinian named Mahmoud Awadeyah told the reporters he’d seen what happened: a deliberate attack on desperate civilians by Israeli soldiers.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Beyond Awadeyah’s testimony, Verify’s story contained no other evidence this was true. More to the point, </span><a href="https://david-collier.com/bbc-news-unaccountable/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">other</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> research suggests that he may not be a reliable source for such serious allegations. For one thing, he has worked for Tasnim, a news agency controlled by Iran’s Revolutionary Guards. On the same day as the murder of seven Jews outside a Jerusalem synagogue, meanwhile, Awadeyah tweeted about &#8220;A state of rejoicing, exuberance, and mosques confirmed with exuberance.&#8221; The same message included an emoji of a contented-looking face with a halo. He&#8217;s also posted photos of himself with Khalil Al Bahtini, a leader of the military wing of Palestinian Islamic Jihad, and mourned his “sincerity and loyalty” when the latter was killed in an Israeli airstrike.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Twelve days after the Verify piece was published, the BBC appended yet another “clarification” </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">— noting that “this piece has been amended to make clear Mahmoud Awadeyah’s current employment” for a Lebanese news station called Al Mayadeen. For its part, Verify also noted Al Mayadeen’s sympathies to groups fighting Israel. But even that’s not the full story: Al Mayadeen openly supports Iran, Hezbollah and the murderous </span><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20151231113422/https://english.aawsat.com/2012/06/article55241706/al-mayadeen-the-last-attempt-to-revive-pro-assad-media" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">Assad regime</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> in Syria. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/britain-needs-to-deploy-warhammer/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/britain-needs-to-deploy-warhammer/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/image-29.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/britain-needs-to-deploy-warhammer/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/britain-needs-to-deploy-warhammer/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How to weaponise the BBC</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/britain-needs-to-deploy-warhammer/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Aris Roussinos</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Cohen, for his part, is amazed that the BBC didn’t feel the need to explain that an eyewitness source was employed by a pro-Iranian outlet. “This is a good example of bias by omission,” he says. “Without all the facts and context clearly presented, the BBC is misleading audiences.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">And if Verify has been caught out by its sources in other areas too — an expert quoted in support of a </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/videos/c0ww32ne04yo" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">wealth tax</span></a> <span style="font-weight: 400;">has campaigned for just such a policy, even as his background wasn’t made clear — reporting on riots or war at least feels worthy in principle. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Elsewhere, though, the unit seems content paddling in distinctly shallow waters. </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">On 7 May, for instance, Spring </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-68973448" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">presented</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> a filmed segment describing a fake picture on Instagram. This was significant, she said, because AI-generated forgeries often involved politicians, and so could potentially influence elections. In the event, though, the picture she highlighted wasn’t of Donald Trump or Joe Biden </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">— but rather of the singer Katy Perry, doing nothing more than standing in a floral dress she hadn’t actually worn. Undaunted, Spring justified her prime time report by saying it was “a reminder to put our social media sleuthing to the test”.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Nor is this the only story that feels like it could have been left to the tabloids. On 17 October, BBC Verify </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cn5zn1l6g5yo" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">published</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> a story about a supposed “wave of cases” involving an alleged drug called Devil’s Breath. The article explained that it was apparently a travel sickness remedy, which could “be administered to victims in the street, without them realising they have been drugged”. Perhaps it can. Yet Verify admitted there was “no evidence” it had been administered in the cases it examined, though it “has been used in robberies in Ecuador, France and Vietnam”. Even if it had been used in Britain, meanwhile, this would have been “difficult to establish”.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Sometimes, Verify even “proves” things that no one seriously disputes. One example came on 7 September, when it published images showing Israel had been building a new road along the border between Gaza and Egypt. Three weeks later, it analysed videos of the airstrike that killed Hassan Nasrallah in Beirut. The fact that solar panels were seen facing away from the bombed building suggested that the attack had come from the south:</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> in other words from Israel. Who knew?</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Combined with those monumental bylines </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">— even a straightforward </span><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-66799518" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">story</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> about flooding in Libya involved a dozen staff — and that </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">£3.2 million wage bill begins to feel oddly high. Indeed, Verify might cost the BBC even more than that. Notwithstanding the unit’s focus on transparency, when we asked the corporation about the rest of its budget, for costs such as travel and OSINT software, a spokeswoman said they weren’t available because they’re “accounted for as part of the overall BBC News budget”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Such munificence might matter less if the BBC was rolling in money. As it is, the corporation is seriously cash-strapped, a situation that’s obliged managers to cancel some of its most respected shows. </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Newsnight</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, for one, is now a shadow of its former self, shorn of filmed reports and investigations. </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">HARDtalk</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, an in-depth interview programme, is vanishing too, despite first going on air back in 1997. Together with those 130 redundancies, and the high-level BBC insider is unsurprisingly upset about the corporation’s apparent focus on BBC Verify, especially when they suspect it’s indulged as</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> Deborah Turness’s baby. &#8220;Because she is the head of news, it can only ever be declared a success,” he explains. “Its triumph is pre-ordained.” It hardly helps, the insider adds, that other sections of BBC News actually have to correct stories far less often than Verify </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">— even as they </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">“they don’t presume to be more truthful than anyone else”. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Nor do things seem likely to change going forward. In late October, mere days after BBC director-general Tim Davie made a speech about the growing threat of “misinformation” from foreign powers</span><span style="font-weight: 400;">, </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">the corporation had ordered four of its most seasoned foreign correspondents back to Britain to save money. All had years of experience, backed by foreign language skills, of reporting on authoritarian regimes including China, Russia and North Korea. Now, though, they’d been told to cover news in Britain.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Within the BBC, the news was received with dismay. </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Times</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> quoted a staffer saying they had been “told to return at a time when the amount of propaganda we are up against is astounding. None of them costs very much money and strategically, it doesn’t make sense when you look at the big, looming stories.” But in the new BBC, it seems that on-the-ground reporting, battling to get at the truth, is destined to be replaced by analysis of videos shot by amateurs on mobile phones </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">— all </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">carried out by BBC Verify in London.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Certainly, the corporation clearly remains optimistic about the unit. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Milibands.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The Miliband files</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> David Rose</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">We asked the BBC to comment on everything in this article. Its spokeswoman told us: “By their very nature, BBC Verify stories are heavy in facts and detail on contentious topics which can sometimes require clarifications and updates, and occasionally corrections, which we do in an openly transparent way. Often pieces are updated to show our workings to audiences — showing them how stories develop as new information comes to light. We do not recognise the flawed calculations that attempt to describe updated pieces with transparent workings as corrected articles.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“We are proud of the vital work that BBC Verify is doing, and our audience research shows that people value this offering and are actively seeking out BBC Verify stories to help them understand events.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Regarding the false claim that the victims of the attack on the car during the riots were of Asian heritage, the spokesperson said: “The story used a range of technology, on the ground reports and social media to piece together how the violence escalated in Humberside that day. When we became aware of the new information we amended the story swiftly and transparently. We stand by the story as an accurate account of what happened.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">As for the now-deleted article about “racist” car insurance, the spokeswoman said that “we have been transparent in saying this story did not meet our normal editorial guidelines and why we withdrew the article”. She also defended the report claiming Israel had massacred Gazans when they tried to get food, despite relying on a single source who’d worked for a pro-Iran TV channel. “The fact,” she said, “that someone has expressed an opinion on social media doesn’t automatically disqualify them from giving eye-witness testimony.” </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Not everyone at the corporation is so bullish. Our BBC insider was unimpressed by these comments, saying he was dismayed that even when Verify had admitted that fundamental elements of major stories were wrong, they’d nonetheless stayed online. As he puts it: “This is misleading and dishonest.” </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Beyond the finances, questions about the unit surely remain. Scanning our analysis of the stories on BBC Verify’s website, it’s hard to avoid the impression that it’s selective with its targets: evidence, perhaps, of a certain Left-leaning bias. It doesn’t, for instance, examine claims made by Hamas with anything like the frequency and rigour it applies to Israel. During the UK election, meanwhile, it dismissed Reform UK’s manifesto by saying its promises had been described as impossible by “experts”, “economists” and “analysts” — without naming or quoting any of them. As was </span><a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/10/30/will-bbc-verify-call-labour-out-for-their-lies/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><span style="font-weight: 400;">noted</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> last week, meanwhile, it failed to measure the Budget, and the tax increases it contained, against Labour’s pledges during the election. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Especially when the corporation is tightening its belt elsewhere, it’s little wonder Cohen remains sceptical. “At a time when the BBC is having to cut jobs and save a lot of money,” he concludes, “the track record of BBC Verify seems very hard to justify.”</span></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/who-verifies-bbc-verify/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/who-verifies-bbc-verify/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/who-verifies-bbc-verify/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">633868</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Kemi Badenoch&#8217;s New Toryism</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/kemi-badenochs-new-toryism/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/kemi-badenochs-new-toryism/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/GettyImages-2175362256.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Interview </unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Tom McTague]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Tom-McTague-Website.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[‘Call it Badenochism — an immigrant’s vision of Roger Scruton’s England.’ Christopher Furlong/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Tom McTague</strong> is UnHerd&#8217;s <strong>Political Editor.</strong> He is the author of <em>Between the Waves: The Hidden History of a Very British Revolution 1945-2016,</em> due to be published in September 2025</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>TomMcTague</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is UnHerd's <strong>Political Editor.</strong> He is the author of <em>Between the Waves: The Hidden History of a Very British Revolution 1945-2016,</em> due to be published in September 2025]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sat, 02 Nov 2024 11:13:54 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Sat, 02 Nov 2024 11:41:04 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium Article]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Roger Scruton]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=634188</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[She is fighting to save a lost Britain



]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>There is something strikingly different about Kemi Badenoch, the newly anointed Conservative Party leader. For a while I thought it might be that she is peculiarly old fashioned — a throwback to an age before the end of history and the professionalism of the Nineties. She speaks in a way that seems somehow more liberated and less calculating than her rivals, and more ideological. To her supporters, of course, this is the point — she is a new incarnation of the lady who will not turn. Though it could also make her the new Michael Foot.</p>
<p>Yet the more I think about it, the more obvious it becomes that while there is something of the lost Britain about Badenoch — I can’t think of another politician who has spoken to me of <em>Some Mothers Do ‘Ave Em</em> and <em>Mind Your Language</em> — what she really represents is a distinctive modern Britain that is not so much pre-Blair as post-Blair. She is the embodiment of the modern migration nation that is Britain in 2024.<br />
<a id="continuereading"></a></p>
<p>The most interesting thing about Badenoch, then, is not that she is the Conservative Party’s first black leader, but that she is its first immigrant leader. While Rishi Sunak was the first ethnic minority prime minister, he was not an immigrant. Another way to tell the Sunak story is that of the Winchester boy who went to the City via Oxford — living proof of George Orwell’s observation in <em>The Lion and the Unicorn</em> that England is “an aristocracy constantly recruited from parvenus”. Our aristocrats might appear more diverse today, but the basic settlement has not changed.</p>
<p>Badenoch, though, is different. She is the first Conservative Party leader to be raised in an entirely different country: Nigeria. And this is not because she was an expat or the child of diplomats, but because she was Nigerian. Though Britain was the land of her birth, it was principally the land that Badenoch chose to escape to as a teenager when her home country descended into chaos in 1996.</p>
<p>She thus represents something unique: a leader raised in post-colonial West Africa but who came of age in anti-colonial modern Britain. The result is a strikingly contemporary form of modern conservatism: a New Toryism, perhaps — a global Little Englandism. Badenoch’s politics are those of a middle-class Nigerian anglophile refracted through a world of alien English progressivism.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;The result is a strikingly contemporary form of modern conservatism: a New Toryism, perhaps — a global Little Englandism.&#8221;</div>
<p>Speaking to her, it’s hard to avoid the sense that Roger Scruton was on to something when he came up with his theory about expats. The expat is destined to hold a candle for an idea of home that has, without him realising it, vanished long ago. Only upon returning to the motherland does the fantasy reveal itself, leaving the old expat homeless and yearning to resurrect the lost land of his imagination. Though Badenoch is not an expat, she seems to have carried with her an illusion of Britain that must have shattered quite quickly upon her arrival at the fag end of John Major’s government at the age of 16.</p>
<p>The legacy of Empire is “complicated” for Badenoch — not a source of humiliation for her, it seems, but a distant world whose shadow gently fell over her life. Her family, the Adegokes, were upper-class Nigerians doing just fine in post-colonial Africa, with a comfortable home in a well-to-do suburb of Lagos. That Kemi was even born in Britain is testament to this: her parents chose to have her in the safety of a private London hospital after a referral in Nigeria. Her childhood is not the story of struggle. And yet the reality of post-imperial Nigeria remained one of political and economic instability.</p>
<p>The Britain Badenoch arrived in in 1996 was not one of easy prosperity and wealth, even if it offered the kind of stability Nigeria lacked. On her arrival, Badenoch worked in McDonald’s, stayed with family friends and went to Sussex University. Her British story begins just as Tony Blair is about to become prime minister, riding on a wave of optimism about a new, outward-looking Britain, not only open to Europe but the entire world. She arrived during the first great wave of migration, between 1994 and 2004, mostly from outside Europe. The second wave, from 2004, would be indelibly linked to Europe. It was around this time, in 2005, that Badenoch joined the Tories.</p>
<p>“My personal experience has shaped me as a politician, because I grew up somewhere that was very different, and I left just as childhood was coming to an end, becoming an adult when I came here,” Badenoch tells me in an interview earlier this week. “I am very much shaped by what I saw growing up in Nigeria and by my experiences in those formative years, 16 to 21, and the profound observation that I have is that people in the UK take so much for granted and assume that, because things have been good, they&#8217;re always going to be good.”</p>
<p>Her politics, in other words, are founded on a sense of fragility born in Africa that she feels is too often missing in the minds of comfortable Europeans. Another instinct from her experience growing up outside the progressive West is a deep scepticism about the emphasis on racism and imperial guilt — and the lack of focus on what she sees as gentle English orderliness and meritocracy.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/labours-blueprint-for-decline/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/labours-blueprint-for-decline/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/GettyImages-2181233010.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/labours-blueprint-for-decline/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/labours-blueprint-for-decline/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Labour&#039;s blueprint for decline</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/labours-blueprint-for-decline/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Aris Roussinos</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>“When people say that the police treat you differently because of the colour of your skin and so on, I&#8217;m sure that there will be cases where that has happened, but I grew up in a place where the police looked exactly like me and they were not nice.” The contrast with Nigerian policing, not the racism, is what struck Badenoch the most about British policing, and with it the fear that what is good about British policing could be lost. “The concept of policing by consent is so special. The concept of being innocent until you&#8217;re proven guilty is actually very rare. We are losing this.” This is the instinct at the core of conservatism, which is concerned less by perfecting what exists than conserving what might be lost. The same is true of her politics more broadly.</p>
<p>When Badenoch looks at Britain, she does not see a cesspit of racism, inequality and backwardness — a benighted Brexit Isle cut off from the world — but a place with relatively mild faults that needs protecting, perhaps even from itself, before it loses what it has.</p>
<div><div style="left: 0; width: 100%; height: 0; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.25%;"><iframe src="//cdn.iframe.ly/api/iframe?url=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2Fov739t36Mpg&amp;key=357d953055da7177194e1a84a2d8a5a3&amp;playerjs=1" style="border: 0; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;" allowfullscreen scrolling="no" allow="encrypted-media; accelerometer; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; autoplay"></iframe></div></div>
&nbsp;
<p>Badenoch’s muses provide further evidence of her unique post-colonial conservatism. In recent weeks, I have asked various Conservative MPs and leadership contenders to name their intellectual inspirations, and I’ve been struck by how quickly they have reached back to Margaret Thatcher and her milieu as if lost for contemporary ideas. Badenoch, by contrast, offers four influences, all of whom are concerned with loss. At least three of them are notable for their prominence in today’s America rather than Britain: Thomas Sowell, the voice of black conservatism in the United States; Jonathan Haidt, the American social psychologist; and <em>Why Nations Fail</em> by the Nobel prize-winning economists Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson. Her fourth muse is the English conservative Roger Scruton.</p>
<p>Her analysis of modern Britain is a combination of these influences. The thesis of <em>Why Nations Fail</em>, in Badenoch’s telling, is that the countries that succeed are built on trust — a trust that is being broken in Britain, as both Scruton and Bedenoch would have it, because the political class has, for too long failed to stand up for the nation and to affirm what its members see as their inherited rights.</p>
<p>She offers two examples of why trust in Britain is breaking down, both of which are distinctly modern and distinctly conservative. First: immigration; second: social media. “If you bring people to a country en masse with very different attitudes, and you don&#8217;t have a muscular emphasis on what is special about this country, what is different, why that&#8217;s important, it will erode,” she tells me. “You can&#8217;t just take it for granted. You can&#8217;t just assume that everybody understands these things.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/in-defence-of-the-little-englander/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/in-defence-of-the-little-englander/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/GettyImages-1445509934.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/in-defence-of-the-little-englander/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/in-defence-of-the-little-englander/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>In defence of the Little Englander</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/in-defence-of-the-little-englander/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom McTague</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Badenoch is the immigrant who believes she can see more clearly than the home-born English the real dangers of immigration. This is not, in her view, racism in a multiracial Britain, but the loss of a unifying sense of nation. When it comes to diagnosing Britain’s problems, the fact that she is an immigrant can be an advantage. “It means that I am very, very crystal clear on what things can look like if they go wrong,” she tells me.</p>
<p>The language she uses to speak about nationalism is more strident than any other politician I have interviewed. When I ask her if she agrees with Scruton that the disquiet over immigration, as he put it, was the result not of racism, but “the disruption of an old experience of home”, she says she agrees “very much so — and I can say that because I also know how people react in other countries when things don&#8217;t look familiar”. She argues in this regard that nostalgia is not simply a negative emotion, but provides an “anchor on what used to be helps people stay rooted in a community”.</p>
<p>This runs into a central theme of her leadership pitch: the duty of patriotism. “Citizenship is not about having a passport,” she tells me. “Citizenship, to me, means being rooted in a place, wanting it to succeed. It&#8217;s not about what you look like… you don&#8217;t just want yourself to succeed. You want your neighbourhood to do well. You want your neighbours to do well. You want the success of your country for the next generation, and you&#8217;re not obsessed about what&#8217;s happening thousands of miles away, either out of, you know, prurient interest, or because of some ancestral history that you might have.”</p>
<p>She is dismissive of citizenship tests, believing instead that patriotism must be promoted organically by everyone in society. Above all, it has to be felt. “[Britain] is not a dormitory. It is not a hotel, for people who are just passing by who want to make some money — and yes, there is a place for that, but we should want people who want the success of the UK.” For a Tory free marketeer, it is striking that she feels able to attack the global super-rich for using Britain as a “hotel” just as much as she attacks some of the poorer arrivals who she claims see the country as a dormitory.</p>
<p>She goes as far as to say she is “horrified” by the videos on TikTok of people saying they wouldn&#8217;t fight for the country, believing it’s “cool” to say they’re not from Britain. “All this nonsense we get every St George&#8217;s Day of, oh, well, St George wasn&#8217;t English. He was Turkish and so on. And there&#8217;s no such thing as English culture. This is nonsense, trying to pretend that culture is always something that comes from elsewhere, and what we have here is not real. I think that these are actually very destructive ideas that undermine a lot of the fabric of society that binds people together. And I&#8217;m not afraid to say that.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/rachel-reeves-has-no-vision/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/rachel-reeves-has-no-vision/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/GettyImages-2173183895.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/rachel-reeves-has-no-vision/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/rachel-reeves-has-no-vision/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Rachel Reeves has no vision</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/10/rachel-reeves-has-no-vision/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Despotic Inroad</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>That she is not afraid to say things is a core part of both Badenoch’s appeal — and her unpopularity. To some, she is crass, reactionary and even rude — all of which was said of Thatcher. She is certainly strident. Badenoch tells me she backed Brexit in part because of Angela Merkel’s decision to open Germany’s borders to help cope with the flow of migration in the early 2010s — “a fundamental violation of my view of citizenship”, as she puts it. “She created… lots of EU citizens without anybody else&#8217;s consent. I thought that was wrong.”</p>
<p>Speaking to some of her critics within the Tory party, there are hints — usually whispered — that Badenoch’s immigrant background does not mean she has a deeper understanding of England, but a shallower one ultimately influenced by the usual American obsessions. In this, her love of Sowell and Haidt is just a mirror of the Left’s obsession with critical race theory and decolonisation. We are all just poor reflections of an American political divide. Perhaps, but there is more than a whiff of xenophobia in such analysis. If Badenoch is not British enough for some, it is hard to see how any immigrant could ever be.</p>
<p>As Badenoch herself puts it, her background confers both advantages and disadvantages. It allows her, for example, to voice an opinion that I think is the closest to Enoch Powell’s analysis of the Commonwealth that I have heard, criticising the preferential treatment given to those migrants from former colonies compared to European citizens. Powell was the original Commonwealth sceptic in British politics, dismissing it as a charade to pretend Britain still had an empire. There will be some deep ironies at play if it falls to an immigrant — who Powell would not have welcomed — to finally sever the final connections with the Commonwealth based on a similar instinct.</p>
<p>“There is a whole new set of issues that our generation has to deal with,” Badenoch tells me. For her, these are migration, the rise of the authoritarian powers “hacking industrialisation”, the progressives “hacking” liberalism, all aided and the rise of social media. “Knowing who we can trust now is getting harder and harder, not just because we are becoming more diverse and that creates, you know, some complexity, but also because of social media and the removal of supposedly trusted voices who everyone would listen to and say, well, yes, they are the authorities, and if they said it, it must be true — now everyone has equivalence.”</p>
<p>For Badenoch, of course, there is no equivalence in life — that is the point. Not everyone’s opinions are equally valid, just as not every culture is equally valid. And as she says, she is not afraid to say it — a phrase I suspect we are going to grow tired of hearing. Badenoch has opinions on everything and we will hear them.</p>
<p>To protect Britain from the forces of modernity, Badenoch suggests what she calls “muscular liberalism” both at home and abroad. This is the Badenoch promise: unrepentant and even, at times, abrasive conservative-liberalism. Call it Badenochism — an immigrant’s vision of Roger Scruton’s England.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/kemi-badenochs-new-toryism/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/kemi-badenochs-new-toryism/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/11/kemi-badenochs-new-toryism/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">634188</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The Miliband files</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Milibands.jpg?w=534</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[David Rose]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/David-Rose-817-2.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Brothers in arms. (Credit: Paul Ellis/AFP/Getty)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>David Rose </strong>is <i>UnHerd</i>&#8216;s Investigations Editor.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>DavidRoseUK</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is <i>UnHerd</i>'s Investigations Editor.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 29 Sep 2024 23:03:09 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 30 Sep 2024 10:36:18 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Climate change]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Corruption]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ed Miliband]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Labour Party]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[sleaze]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=625620</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>As acts of political fratricide go, few were as public — or petulant — as Ed Miliband’s defenestration of his elder brother David. After Ed beat David to the Labour Party leadership in 2010, the pair attempted an awkward hug — but there was no disguising David’s bitterness. He refused to join Ed’s shadow cabinet and resigned as an MP three years later. After Labour lost the 2015 general election, he accused his brother of “taking the party backwards”.</p>
<p>How times change.</p>
<p>Speaking to Labour Conference last week, Ed Miliband — now the Secretary of State at the Department for Net Zero and Energy Security — pledged to construct an “armoury of clean power” for the United Kingdom, in order to make its electricity system “net zero” by 2030. What he didn’t mention, however, was that his brother is being paid by a venture capital outfit whose profits are likely to increase in the process.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>***</strong></p>
<p>When David Miliband stepped down from Parliament, his MP’s salary was a modest £66,000. But that was only a small portion of his income. In his final entry in the Commons interests register, he declared he was also being paid £100,000 a year as chairman of Sunderland Football Club, and £92,840 as an adviser to a green investment fund. To top up his account, he also accepted almost £65,000 for appearing at a London forum hosted by the foreign ministry of the United Arab Emirates.</p>
<p>Just over a decade later, David has refashioned himself as a man of virtue: he lives in New York, where he runs International Rescue Committee, a US-based charity that supports people in humanitarian crises. For his services, however, he receives a princely sum. In 2022, <a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8900805/Labour-Foreign-Secretary-David-rakes-1-million-year-mega-salary.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">he took home</a> a salary of $1,253,728, as well as a bonus of $150,000.</p>
<p>For such a level of remuneration, and with such a workload, one might expect David to be busy with the day job. Yet, for more than four years he has had an additional job: in <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2020/09/25/david-miliband-john-browne-join-giant-ventures-new-uk-venture/" target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2020/09/25/david-miliband-john-browne-join-giant-ventures-new-uk-venture/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1727525778847000&amp;usg=AOvVaw1RSpXW1EUGzN2NFJKlNSjx">September 2020</a>, five months after his brother became shadow energy secretary in Sir Keir Starmer’s new shadow cabinet, it was revealed that David had become a paid advisor to Giant Ventures, a London-based venture capital firm that has a particular focus on green technology and energy. Following a series of earlier investments, it recently launched a new “<a href="https://www.giant.vc/insights/giant-ventures-launches-new-funds-to-invest-250m-into-purpose-driven-technology-companies-in-europe-and-the-us" target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.giant.vc/insights/giant-ventures-launches-new-funds-to-invest-250m-into-purpose-driven-technology-companies-in-europe-and-the-us&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1727525778847000&amp;usg=AOvVaw3GGE1Edz_yP3ccSNINCjVC">climate focused growth fund</a>” and claims it wants to invest a further $1 billion in “sustainable technologies” by the end of the decade.</p>
<p>All of which may seem perfectly in fitting with David’s form when it comes to juggling multiple jobs. Except for one thing: at least two of the companies Giant Ventures has invested in are likely to prosper as a direct result of decisions made by the new government. In other words, David now works for a company that stands to profit from climate policies introduced by his brother Ed.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;In other words, David now works for a company that stands to profit from climate policies introduced by his brother Ed.&#8221;</div>
<p>Before and since the election, Ed Miliband has <a href="https://www.innovationnewsnetwork.com/ed-miliband-reveals-priorities-for-uk-energy-sector/49045/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">spoken</a> of the need to create a vast energy storage network connected to the national grid — to ensure that, in a renewable energy system, the lights don’t go out when the sun is not shining and there is no wind. Part of this, he has said, will be supplied by arrays of giant batteries. He mentioned them again in his <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8GxLZ46YAZs" target="_blank" rel="noopener">conference speech</a> last week, when he called for the “armoury of clean power”.</p>
<p style="font-weight: 400;">Enter Field, a battery power storage firm set up in 2021 by Amit Gudka, one of the co-founders of collapsed energy firm Bulb. Field, with five sites already finished or being built, claims to be ready to meet Miliband’s challenge. And Giant Ventures seems to agree: according to data gathered by finance research experts PitchBook, it <a href="https://www.solarpowerportal.co.uk/field_unveils_160mw_storage_pipeline_following_10m_fundraise/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">invested</a> in Field at its outset in 2021.</p>
<p>Now, it is possible that Ed Miliband was unaware that Field was partly financed by Giant Ventures, although this had already been <a href="https://sifted.eu/articles/energy-storage-field-200m-news" target="_blank" rel="noopener">reported.</a> It is also possible that didn’t know his brother was a member of the Giant Ventures advisory board, though that information was also <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2020/09/25/david-miliband-john-browne-join-giant-ventures-new-uk-venture/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">public</a>.</p>
<p>But that would be puzzling. According to Whitehall’s Ministerial Code, newly appointed ministers must formally declare “all interests that might be thought to give rise to a conflict” with their government post: not only their own, but those of their spouse and “close family members”. They must not only avoid any conflict, but also the “perception” that one might arise. It should have been obvious to Ed Miliband that he had a duty to check his brother’s interests.</p>
<p>This year’s declaration is yet to be published, but both Labour and Conservative former ministers told me that declarations of ministerial interests are usually made immediately after taking office, so that civil servants are aware from the start where conflicts might arise. I asked both the energy department and the Cabinet Office, which is responsible for the list, whether Ed had declared David’s role at Giant Ventures, but both refused to comment. Asked when the next list would be published, all they would say is that this would happen “in due course”.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-baroness-making-a-fortune-from-net-zero/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-baroness-making-a-fortune-from-net-zero/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/GettyImages-81060811.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-baroness-making-a-fortune-from-net-zero/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-baroness-making-a-fortune-from-net-zero/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The Baroness making a fortune from Net Zero</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-baroness-making-a-fortune-from-net-zero/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> David Rose</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Similarly reticent, Giant Ventures refuses to disclose how much it pays David Miliband, but it seems certain he does receive a stipend: one of his fellow advisory board members, Lord John Browne, the former chairman of BP, states in the Lords register of interests that the position constitutes “remunerated employment”. For Miliband in particular, this “employment” takes a number of forms: not only does he attend board meetings — he also appears at events and in the firm’s <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_0fq5wZsxZk" target="_blank" rel="noopener">videos</a> and <a href="https://www.giant.vc/insights/giant-ideas-the-podcast" target="_blank" rel="noopener">podcasts</a>.</p>
<p>As for the insight he provides to the fund, a spokesperson told me that, “like all venture capital firms that are not listed on public markets, we do not publish our investor reports to the general public”. However, PitchBook has identified two firms that look likely to profit from Ed Miliband’s “clean energy superpower” revolution. As well as Field, for instance, there is Beams, which helps homeowners make their properties more energy efficient — a service that should prosper following Miliband’s <a href="https://www.property118.com/ed-miliband-ready-to-challenge-landlords-over-epc-c-targets/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">pledge</a> to impose tough, green standards on both private and public rental homes.</p>
<p>Miliband has also made a specific ministerial decision that will benefit Field. Less than three weeks after the election, Field became the beneficiary of a technical change to the rules governing Britain’s electricity supply system that Miliband personally signed.</p>
<p>The document in question, the <a href="https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/669a2017ab418ab055592894/Capacity_Market__Amendment__Rules_2024.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Capacity Market (Amendment) Rules 2024</a>, is not an easy read. It relates to the curious way that the grid pays for energy storage: under the “capacity mechanism”, the Government concludes expensive contracts with companies such as Field, who in return guarantee that they will supply a stipulated amount of electricity at a moment’s notice for a given period of time. (In the case of batteries, the limitations of battery technology mean this will be no more than a few hours.) Under this system, the companies get paid whether or not they actually supply any energy.</p>
<p>The cost, which has been rising steadily, is met by adding a levy to customers’ electricity bills. Energy supply expert Gordon Hughes, emeritus professor of political economy at Edinburgh University, told me that by the beginning 2026, the annual cost is likely to be more than £2 billion, the equivalent of £70 per household, and by 2030, up to £5 billion.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/why-is-a-brit-running-a-chinese-weapons-conference/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/why-is-a-brit-running-a-chinese-weapons-conference/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/GettyImages-2094022713-e1724865011785.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/why-is-a-brit-running-a-chinese-weapons-conference/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/why-is-a-brit-running-a-chinese-weapons-conference/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why is a Brit running a Chinese weapons conference?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/08/why-is-a-brit-running-a-chinese-weapons-conference/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> David Rose</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Until Ed Miliband changed the rules, the problem for companies like Field was that when batteries are used and recharged repeatedly, their capacity deteriorates. This meant that battery firms had to pay to install more capacity than their contracts said they needed when their batteries were new, so that they would not be running the risk of breaching their contracts when their capacity declined. This was because the old rules said they were not allowed to add more capacity if and when it was required. “This change is clearly advantageous to them,” says Hughes, “because it allows them to reduce their upfront costs. It is also likely to increase their profits.”</p>
<p>This was not the only decision Miliband made on 18 July that may come to benefit Field. On the same day, he signed <a href="https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/669a5eeda3c2a28abb50d310/security-of-electricity-supply-capacity-market-auction-parameters-2024_.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a letter</a> to the national grid setting out details of the capacity mechanism’s future, which will create lucrative opportunities for firms like Field to build more batteries, enhancing their profits and the value of investments made by venture capital firms.</p>
<p>After the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero told me it could not comment as to whether Ed Miliband had declared his brother’s interest in Giant Ventures, I sent an email setting out details of how a conflict, or at least the appearance of one, might occur. But Its spokesperson refused to address this, saying only: “There is an established process in place for the declaration and management of interests held by ministers. This ensures that steps are taken to avoid or mitigate any potential or perceived conflicts of interest. The List of Ministers’ Interests will be published as part of this in due course.”</p>
<p>Giant Ventures said it did not wish to comment, while David Miliband failed to respond at all.</p>
<p>This is unsurprising. Since leaving Parliament, David Miliband has been reluctant to speak publicly about his relationship with Ed. But on one of the few occasions that he has, in 2015, he told <em>The Guardian</em>: “I’ve always said you remain brothers for life.”</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/09/the-miliband-files/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">625620</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>How Starmer slaughtered the Tories</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-starmer-slaughtered-the-tories/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-starmer-slaughtered-the-tories/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/ksnobloodnohandsred.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Election 2024</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Tom McTague]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Tom-McTague-Website.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Tom McTague</strong> is UnHerd&#8217;s <strong>Political Editor.</strong> He is the author of <em>Between the Waves: The Hidden History of a Very British Revolution 1945-2016,</em> due to be published in September 2025</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>TomMcTague</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is UnHerd's <strong>Political Editor.</strong> He is the author of <em>Between the Waves: The Hidden History of a Very British Revolution 1945-2016,</em> due to be published in September 2025]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Fri, 05 Jul 2024 07:23:04 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 09 Jul 2024 08:39:58 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[2024 General Election]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Future of the State Sector]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Keir Starmer]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Labour]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Morgan McSweeney]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Rishi Sunak]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=608910</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Inside Labour's march to victory]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>This was an election campaign like no other. Less a battle of personalities and visions than of competing strategies to attain power, commanded not by the uninspiring monarchs under whose banners the battle was fought but the generals quietly ordering the troop movements far from the front lines. The upshot is the revolution we have before us: a strange and bathetic upheaval in British politics that is no less transformative for the manner of its birth. Last night’s extraordinary result brings to an end a period in our national life forever stained by the Conservative Party’s chaotic ineptitude, captured in its pathetically inglorious departure. “Into the valley of Death, rode the six hundred.” Indeed. Only this time without any of the honour.</p>
<p>In five years, the Tories have transferred their 80-seat majority to Keir Starmer’s Labour party and then let them double it. No government since the war has been rejected in such a manner. But even this doesn’t do justice to the upheaval. In 1997, the Tories seemed similarly broken, facing an opponent in Tony Blair far more adroit than Starmer. And yet, the party still emerged with 165 seats. In 2001, under the leadership of William Hague, it finished with 166. On both occasions the Tories retained swathes of England considered “safe” from which they could replenish their forces. Theresa May arrived in parliament in the landslide defeat of 1997. David Cameron, George Osborne and Boris Johnson all followed in 2001. Today, much of that old Tory England lies in ruins, captured by the enemy which is now the national party of Britain, stretched far and wide — if not particularly deeply.</p>
<p>Overnight, the Conservative Party didn’t just lose Penny Mordaunt’s seat in Portsmouth and Jacob Rees-Mogg’s in Somerset, they lost Welwyn Hatfield, Chichester, Cheltenham and worse still: David Cameron’s old seat of Witney, Boris Johnson’s Henley, Margaret Thatcher’s Finchley and, perhaps most symbolically of all, Liz Truss’s in Norfolk. Accepting defeat, Rishi Sunak admitted the British people had delivered “a sobering verdict”. Sobering for the Conservatives perhaps. And it was one delivered with cold, calculated fury too, not some wild act of drunken abandon. This was calculated to hurt.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;The past five years are almost certainly the worst period of government in modern British history.&#8221;</div>
<p>Meanwhile, a new band of cavaliers under the leadership of Nigel Farage has emerged on the scene, slicing through the grinding dullness of the campaign to claim a few small corners of England for itself — and a lot more votes — much as Ed Davey managed for the Liberal Democrats. Despite Davey’s startling success, at least in the number of seats he managed to win from an overall vote share of just 12%, Farage remains the personality who imposed his will on the race, a cavalry showman whose rearguard raids on the Tory backlines helped secure him the parliamentary breakthrough he has craved for so long — and just in time to lead the peasant’s revolt he has been building for decades. The reality this morning is that few people now doubt him when he warns that the result is “just the first step of something which is going to stun all of you”. As recently as 2017, Marine Le Pen’s National Front had just two MPs. Today, she stands on the brink of power, the Gaullist Republicans little more than a shell. For Keir Starmer, a warning — as Boris Johnson and Emmanuel Macron can attest: revolutions have a habit of eating their own.</p>
<p>This in many ways is the most curious of election results. Labour has won a landslide with 34% of the vote — this is less than Tony Blair in 1997, 2001 and 2005, David Cameron in 2010 and 2015, Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn in 2017, and Boris Johnson in 2019. Two factors of huge significance secured Labour its landslide. First, the collapse of the Tory vote to just 24% — far less than Jeremy Corbyn in the last election, Gordon Brown in 2010 and even Michael Foot in 1983; a historic rejection of the government. And second, the extraordinary performance of Reform, which won 14% of the vote, but only four MPs — more votes than the Lib Dems for far fewer MPs. Today, however, Farage’s massed forces lie in second places across swathes of England — the new natural opposition to Labour. As Farage was right to point out, this may well prove to be one of the dominating facts in British politics over the next five years. Can you really imagine Labour daring to get too close to the EU given this new vulnerability? Farage may only have three colleagues with him in parliament, but his influence in British politics is about to explode.</p>
<p>Dig a little deeper into the result and there were disconcerting signs for Labour: Jeremy Corbyn winning in Islington, the expelled Faiza Shaheen denying the party another seat in Chingford, Jonathan Ashworth losing in Leicester and Wes Streeting coming close to losing his in Ilford. Yet, overall, such footnotes are just that — footnotes. The victory is Labour’s.</p>
<p>Over the past six weeks, I have travelled across the country speaking to ministers, candidates, party insiders and the campaign generals on both sides to understand what was happening and why, peering deep inside the bellies of both party machines. During this time, I saw a contrast of startling intensity: between one party ruthlessly committed to victory and another which had long ago lost the discipline necessary to govern and therefore even to command the respect of the country.</p>
<p>For Labour, the machine was manned by those entirely focused on one thing: power. These were the men and women who began 2021 on the sodden, boggy land of unpopularity only to suddenly discover their route to higher ground had been cleared by the grotesque incompetence of a Tory party. In contrast, I saw a governing party bewildered by the predicament in which it had found itself, lost to the point that it was unaware of why it was losing so badly; a desperate party playing a desperate hand and failing with every gamble it made, led by a prime minister who managed to be even more arrogant about his political ability than his predecessors. For four general elections in a row, Britain had voted for the Tories to stop something else: Gordon Brown “bankrupting Britain”, Ed Miliband being in the pocket of Alex Salmond, Jeremy Corbyn blocking Brexit. As soon as the Tories stood no chance of defeating anyone or anything, voters deserted them in their droves, their raison d’être having disappeared.</p>
<p>The campaign we have just witnessed was ultimately a battle between a party that was willing to make the sacrifices necessary to attain power, and another which had long ago given up the organising discipline to retain it. It was a campaign launched out of desperation by a prime minister who seemed so disoriented by his own failures in government that he was unable to see the folly of his reckless gamble. Much of the result, then, has to be on Sunak, a man who proved incapable of the task in front of him. But not all of it. The truth is, Sunak inherited a Conservative Party that long ago lost the will for power, and has been shattered as a result.</p>
<p>The day after the election five years ago, Boris Johnson travelled to Sedgefield to declare himself the Lord Servant of the North. Rishi Sunak travels to Buckingham Palace today having lost not only the North, but most of the rest of the country with it. The Tories were once the national party: the party of England and the Union, town and shire. Today, they are a party of national rejection.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">***</p>
<p>The Tory calamity is epitomised in the manner of its departure. The Labour Party knew the campaign had begun six hours before Sunak called it at 6pm on 22 May. The previous day, McSweeney had received a text message from a friend who monitors the betting markets and had noticed a flurry of activity from people placing money on a 4 July election. By the time McSweeney arrived in Parliament the next day and bumped into Starmer preparing for Prime Minister’s Questions, speculation was rife that Sunak was about to make his move. But McSweeney felt the sheer volume of bets was enough evidence to begin preparation. When he got back to Labour HQ at around midday, he authorised Labour’s head of digital, Tom Lillywhite, to start buying digital advertising space on YouTube and elsewhere, while also giving the go-ahead to staff to order the party’s “Change” logo to go on the lectern Starmer would speak from later on. As one senior figure put it to me, it never occurred to them that they might try to make some money from the information they had. The Tory rot was already evident.</p>
<p>McSweeney and his closest team had planned the first day of the campaign repeatedly over the previous few months, acutely aware that the most value he could bring was at the beginning. This head start, then, was doubly significant. For Isaac Levido, the battle-hardened campaign veteran entrusted by Sunak with the Tory campaign, the opposite was true. Not only had he lost the element of surprise, he did not know that this was the case, his trust broken by those who had lost their heads. More importantly, Levido was also being asked to fight a campaign from a position he had advised against.</p>
<p>Levido, who had already played a prominent role in the previous three elections, knew that the main benefit of incumbency lies in the ability to call the election at a time of your choosing — and on your terms. Given this, Levido had advised the Prime Minister to wait until the Autumn, arguing that the party’s best — and perhaps only — chance lay in going long. As inflation fell, so the argument went, so too would interest rates, helping to create an environment in which people might, just might, start to feel better about the country’s prospects. In a game where vibes and emotion are as important as facts, waiting was simply the sensible thing to do.</p>
<p>Yet robbed of his strongest message, Sunak had to deliver a different one in the pouring rain outside No. 10. “It might still be hard when you look at your bank balance, but this hard-earned economic stability was only ever meant to be the beginning.” It is hardly the best pitch for re-election. No longer “the plan has worked, don’t risk it” but “the plan will work — trust me”.</p>
<p>Ever since Sunak became prime minister, Levido had been urging the party to stick to its core message to voters: that it had a plan and it was working. Sunak had launched it on 4 January, 2023, just a few months after taking office, setting out five pledges that could be repeated in 13 words: “Halve inflation; grow the economy; reduce debt; cut waiting lists; stop the boats.” Levido had worked with Lynton Crosby in January 2014, when David Cameron had similarly sought to frame the next election with more than a year to go, unveiling his “long-term economic plan”. But after the calamities of Johnson and Truss, voters would no longer accept another slogan, Levido argued. They needed commitments they could be held to. And so the five pledges were born.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/how-britain-abandoned-scotland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/how-britain-abandoned-scotland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/GettyImages-583668204-e1718988159867.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/how-britain-abandoned-scotland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/how-britain-abandoned-scotland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How Britain abandoned Scotland</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/how-britain-abandoned-scotland/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom McTague</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The problem for Sunak was twofold. The first was that the party was no longer disciplined enough to rally around this message — or even appeared capable of delivering it. At a Tory “away day” last year, MPs complained to Levido that they could not be expected to remember all the pledges. Levido was left exasperated.</p>
<p>The bigger problem, however, was that Sunak could not actually deliver on them, falling on all but the first two. And the longer he waited, the worse it got. Not only was he failing to get a grip on the NHS and the small boats crisis, but the country’s prisons were falling over, the flights to Rwanda were unlikely to go anywhere, the junior doctors continued striking and, most alarmingly, the Conservative parliamentary party could simply not be counted on to maintain its discipline over the summer. Sunak had lost faith in his ability to govern.</p>
<p>It was in the face of such failure — and his loss of faith that he could do anything about it — that Sunak faced a choice between a slow death or a suicidal charge. Ignoring Levido’s advice, he chose the latter.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">***</p>
<p>Ordered to lead the party into battle, Levido devised a strategy which would open with a blitz of campaign promises targeting potential Reform voters. This would force people to choose between Labour and the Conservatives in a straight fight. From here, Levido hoped the race would tighten and then the party would move to its central message: “Risk, risk, risk.” This, Levido believed, was the best the Tories had available. Denied the “stability” message that going long would have allowed, he was forced to pivot to a beware-Labour “security” message.</p>
<p>While Levido and his team expected a rocky first few days, as MPs raged against the Prime Minister’s recklessness, they did not expect to have to endure an succession of gaffes — Sunak asking a group of Welsh publicans whether they were looking forward to the European championships they had not qualified for; or appearing at the Titanic quarter in Belfast as his own campaign seemed to be sinking. Despite these, the plan showed some tentative signs of life. The announcements promising compulsory national service and a new “quadruple lock” for pensioners successfully differentiated the party from Labour. Tory internal polling showed the party’s favorability ratings starting to pick up. It helped that MPs were no longer at each other’s throats, while Labour was having to deal with a series of candidate selection headaches.</p>
<p>But, then, two catastrophes. First, Nigel Farage announced he was taking over as leader of Reform and contesting the seat in Clacton. And then Sunak went to Normandy and, inexplicably, left before the D-Day commemorations had finished. Back in London, the most senior campaign officials suddenly realised with horror that the leaders of France, Germany and the United States were all there on the beach together — alongside David Cameron, not Sunak. “What the fuck is this?” shouted one senior Tory, looking up at the TV screens. Levido advised the Prime Minister that the only option was to apologise, cauterise the wound and move on, but no-one was under any illusion about how bad it was for the campaign. Any hopes of an early poll tightening vanished.</p>
<p>McSweeney, however, believed Sunak’s campaign strategy was always doomed: he maintained it simply was not possible to appeal to Reform voters in this way without making the Tory campaign seem marginal to everyone else. Sunak’s cardinal sin, in McSweeney’s view, was his failure to deal with his Reform problem earlier: he could have tacked Right to crush the party; or he could have defined himself as a strong centrist by publicly taking on the recalcitrant MPs who had supported Liz Truss or were flirting with Farage. By doing neither, Sunak was fatally exposed.</p>
<p>Worse, his party looked out of touch. Why talk about national service to people who were drowning under the expense of their food, energy and childcare bills? They could only afford to make such specific pledges once they had established a strong campaign message, which they were unable to do. “They needed to get the plane off the ground first,” one senior Labour figure told me. But it wasn’t just a case of the policies being counterproductive; in McSweeney’s view, the very fact that Sunak suddenly tried to catch everyone off-guard with his election gamble also reinforced the narrative of Tory chaos.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;At a Tory away day last year, MPs complained to Levido that they could not be expected to remember all the pledges.&#8221;</div>
<p>Privately, I understand Levido is frustrated that his strategy for the start of the election was not successful. It failed, he believes, because, ultimately, voters had just stopped listening to the Tories. They were done. But starting 20 points behind in the polls did demand a riskier strategy than the one available to Labour. Levido was right to believe that closing the polls was the only way he could change the campaign narrative. Indeed, the reality is that from the moment Sunak called the election, the Tory campaign was not about winning, but stemming the scale of the defeat. Still, by mid-June there was still hope within the party that the Conservatives could finish with more than 200 MPs. It finished today relieved that it was the main party of opposition. Unless it gets its house in order quickly it won’t be so lucky next time. Remarkably, this defeat is both a punishment and an act of clementia. There is now an executioner’s blade hanging over the Tory Party.</p>
<p>Where McSweeney and Levido ultimately agree is the fact that much of the Tory problem — and Labour’s success — is because of decisions taken long before the election was called. Today’s Tory failure was baked in long before Sunak stood in the rain outside Downing Street and sealed his fate.</p>
<p>Indeed, those who know both McSweeney and Levido are struck by how similar they are as operators — quiet, softly spoken and no-nonsense. Sunak and Starmer are also remarkably similar in the tasks presented to them as leaders. Both had come into parties which had shown themselves unfit to govern. And both tried, at first, to hold their parties together, rather than take on those who had brought the party to the brink of ruin.</p>
<p>At first, in truth, Starmer and McSweeney had been quite concerned about Sunak. He was young, energetic and seemingly capable in the Covid era. But, then, he showed his essential weakness. In McSweeney’s view, Johnson’s great success in 2019 was persuading voters he was serious about change by purging the MPs standing in his way — including his own brother. Sunak convinced himself he didn’t need to do this or perhaps that he couldn’t. For McSweeney this was his original sin. As one Labour official put it: “He had a tiger at his front door and he had to go out and either shoot it or try to bring it into the house to domesticate it. He did neither and ended up being chased out of his back door.” By 2022, the options for displaying strength were extreme: expel Truss; condemn Johnson; launch a war against Farage. As the unelected head of a divided party, such options were not available to him. Nor was the opposite: inviting Farage to become a Tory. The task of weighing up such options now falls to the next Tory leader whoever that may be.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-mcsweeney-project/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-mcsweeney-project/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/morgan-mcsweeney-2-864x576-1.jpeg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-mcsweeney-project/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-mcsweeney-project/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The McSweeney Project</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/05/the-mcsweeney-project/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom McTague</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Those who have worked with both Sunak and Johnson tell me that the fundamental difference between the pair was one of “animal instinct”. Sunak was serious, decent and good to work for, driven by an optimistic conviction that had stood him well throughout his life: because he is usually smarter than everybody else in the room, he only needed to work harder than everybody else to win. Johnson, meanwhile, appreciated that politics was far more mediaeval: a game of power and theatre in which displays of authority mattered. It was Starmer, though, who learned Johnson’s lesson, not Sunak. And he is unlikely to now repeat Johnson’s mistakes in government, though may quickly find he is just as unpopular for a host of other reasons.</p>
<p>If there were ever any tigers at Starmer’s door, few now doubt McSweeney would have shot them. He knew that the very fact Labour had put forward Jeremy Corbyn for leader risked disqualifying the entire party in the eyes of voters. Given Starmer had served under Corbyn for almost all of his time in government, this was potentially deadly in a campaign. Yet, McSweeney and Starmer moved to deal with this weakness by not only sidelining Corbyn but expelling him from the parliamentary party and stopping him from standing for Labour. McSweeney and those close to him maintain this was a prerequisite of today’s result. He also moved to exile Labour’s Corbynite leader in Scotland, Richard Leonard. Without this other act of ruthlessness, today’s crushing defeat of the SNP would have been impossible, McSweeney believes. The man from Cork who saved the Union — it is some story.</p>
<p>Even after the campaign began, Starmer’s top team showed a ruthlessness in their insistence that any Labour candidate who risked causing them trouble in the future would not be allowed to stand. This has cost them in Islington and Chingford, but it will be seen as a price worth paying. Starmer’s missteps on Gaza — principally <a href="https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/sir-keir-starmer-hamas-terrorism-israel-defend-itself/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">that LBC interview</a> — were just as costly. Where this Muslim rage at Labour now goes is another current in British politics which could yet build into something important. But it wasn’t only the decision to rid Labour of its troublesome priests of the Left which showed McSweeney’s ruthlessness. Before the campaign, both he and Starmer’s campaign coordinator Pat McFadden — now nailed on to be one of the very biggest beasts in the incoming government — had also moved to shut down every potential weakness imaginable, not only with Corbyn but on tax, spending, the green energy transition, Brexit, immigration and gender. The party war-gamed all the different campaigns the Tories might try to fight, including the one they eventually did: tax. None of the leading figures strayed from that message. Even the trade unions, unhappy with Labour’s general direction, played their part. Here was a movement determined to seize their moment, the lure of power proving as much of a disciplining force as the weariness of power has proved disabling for the Conservatives.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Johnson appreciated that politics was far more mediaeval: a game of power and theatre in which displays of authority mattered.&#8221;</div>
<p>Brexit will of course remain the defining legacy of the Conservative era. This was a government elected to Get Brexit Done and did so, no matter how dishonourably. Yet the Brexit they delivered is now deeply unpopular, neither close enough to the EU to have avoided the inevitable friction of withdrawal, nor distinctive enough to have proved to voters there was much good gained from all the pain. More importantly, it does not feel like it has worked for many voters whose grievances were not really about the EU so much as the powerlessness they felt over their own government. The twin issues of immigration and the European Court of Human Rights will now step into the hole once filled by the EU, the fuel which will turbocharge Farage’s new army. The irony now is that the challenge of Making Brexit Work now falls to Starmer, the man who tried to stop it. What he does with it is now up to him. The party of England has lost control of its own revolution. In Richard II, John of Gaunt lies dying, lamenting the rule of his King: “That England, that was wont to conquer others, Hath made a shameful conquest of itself.” We can say the same of the Conservative Party.</p>
<p>And as it dies, there is little to be gained for the Conservatives, nor the Liberal Democrats or Reform, in claiming Keir Starmer does not have a mandate for revolution because he only won 34% of the vote. They handed him the keys to No 10. In raw power terms, his achievement is more impressive than Clement Attlee’s, Harold Wilson’s or even Tony Blair’s, having required a swing of 1997 proportions simply to become the government. Instead, he turned the biggest Tory majority since 1987 into the biggest Labour majority since 2001. He is now our Puritanical Lord Protector, master of Parliament. With Sue Grey running Whitehall, Starmer controls Westminster in a way Boris Johnson never could. The machine is his.</p>
<p>As Labour leader, Starmer has shown two principal traits, discipline and ruthlessness, which has not been in evidence on the Conservative side since before the last election. Yes, Starmer is now bound by a manifesto of such rigid discipline it will make his life harder in government: he will be forced to manage the same creaking infrastructure, funded by the same creaking economy. But if he is anywhere near as ruthless in the application of power as he was in his pursuit of it, the manifesto won’t bind him for long.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-654564968-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The Machiavelli of Meta</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom McTague</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The scale of his victory is so unique that in some ways it is harder to predict where the challenges to his authority will emerge — from within his cabinet, perhaps? Or from Farage’s new band of Reformers? Maybe even, somehow, from the bloodied corpse of the Conservative Party. All we do know is that the challenges will come. McSweeney and others were sanguine about the danger posed by Reform during this election, correctly calculating that the party damaged the Tories far more than Labour, but they are already conscious of the danger Farage will soon pose in swathes of small-town England which voted Labour this year but left Reform in second place. It is also the case that while Labour has shown discipline on issues where it is not comfortable, it remains vulnerable to any serious political party on the politics of gender, immigration and culture issues in particular.</p>
<p>However disciplined the Labour party has been over the past few years, the moral of this story is ultimately one of crime and punishment; a governing party driven mad by its failures of character, like Raskolnikov, unable to control itself, unable to govern and ultimately, at the death, unable even to think straight and maintain its dignity. The party has been sent into exile, not quite dead, but broken. It will take a long time to live down the dishonour of its defeat. “Ah, would the scandal vanish with my life,” John of Gaunt declares, hopefully. No such luck for Sunak, Truss, Johnson and the Conservative Party.</p>
<p>For today is Keir Starmer’s day. And Morgan McSweeney’s. Politics is the pursuit of power and they pursued it better than anyone else. Now they must now wield it. Becoming King is no guarantee of safety after all. Just ask Richard II.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-starmer-slaughtered-the-tories/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-starmer-slaughtered-the-tories/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/07/how-starmer-slaughtered-the-tories/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">608910</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The trouble with political Christianity</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/the-trouble-with-political-christianity/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/the-trouble-with-political-christianity/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/DD-EVENT.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Faith</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Alex O'Connor]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Blue-thumbnail-2.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Richard Dawkins embrace after their debate (UnHerd)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Alex O&#8217;Connor </strong>is the host of the “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/@cosmicskeptic" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Within Reason</a>” YouTube show and podcast.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>CosmicSkeptic</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is the host of the “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/@cosmicskeptic" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Within Reason</a>” YouTube show and podcast.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 18 Jun 2024 23:02:39 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 29 Aug 2024 13:44:14 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Atheism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Christianity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Faith]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[God]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[none]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Richard Dawkins]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Science]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=606492</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Those celebrating faith's revival should be cautious]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>In the apocryphal Gospel of Thomas, Jesus condemns those who “(either) love the tree and hate its fruit (or) love the fruit and hate the tree”. A regular critique of the nominally religious is that they claim to believe in, say, Christianity, but fail to act in accordance with its demanding message of love and compassion. They love the tree, but can’t quite swallow the fruit. More recently, however, a strange reverse phenomenon is emerging: a class of thinkers who, unable to rationally assent to the <em>actual truth </em>of Christianity, and yet disillusioned with the politics of “new atheism”, and fearful of the various religious and pseudo-religious ideas that have filled the vacuum it created, find themselves in the tough spot of being hungry for the fruit but unable to believe in the existence of the tree.</p>
<p>These so-called “cultural Christians” are appearing in droves: Douglas Murray, Tom Holland (not that one), Konstantin Kisin, Jordan Peterson (depending on what you mean by “Christian” and “cultural” and “and”); even Richard Dawkins — the archetypal modern atheist who has done more to confront organised religion than perhaps any other identifiable person in a <em>generation </em>— happily adopts this paradoxical moniker for himself.</p>
<p>Paradoxical because, of course, Christianity is more than just an affinity for evensong, disappointment with secular architecture, and suspicion of Islam. St Paul wrote in no uncertain terms to the Corinthians that “if Christ has not been raised, our preaching is useless and so is your faith”, and the vague, <em>à </em><em>la carte</em> approach to the religion displayed by the “cultural Christian” which doesn’t seem to <em>care about</em>, much less <em>affirm</em>, the historicity of the extraordinary events of Easter Sunday is the kind of attitude that would see you condemned as heretical by the founders of the orthodox church.</p>
<p>Yet Christianity is experiencing a popular makeover, from an affirmative doctrine of truth-claims to a sort of protective garment to be worn as a practical measure against the equal and opposite destabilising forces of radical political religiosity and cynical nihilism which continue to claw away at the souls of those without a firm spiritual conviction.</p>

<p>This metamorphosis of the Christian religion in is many ways indebted to Tom Holland — not the actor, though perhaps <em>an </em>actor, in that he seems content to live <em>as if </em>Christianity were true — whose “Dominion” thesis has convinced a not insignificant number of intellectuals that the bulk of our celebrated Western ethics is ultimately the product of Christianity, an ideology which has so successfully embedded itself in our culture that we do not even notice it anymore.</p>
<p>This leads our cultural Christians, often those with a special interest in safeguarding Western civilisation, to cozy up to an ideology that they can’t quite adopt without qualification due to their rather inconvenient conviction that it isn’t true.</p>
<p>Enter Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Re-enter, I should say, as this brave apostate from Islam won successful prominence as an atheist writer and speaker for many years since the early 2000s, before recently <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/why-i-am-now-a-christian/">announcing</a> that she had embraced Christianity. Indeed, she had originally been scheduled to participate in that famed discussion in Washington D.C. in 2007 which gave birth to the “four horsemen” of new atheism — Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, Daniel Dennett, and Sam Harris. So news of the “almost fifth’s” conversion was met with widespread surprise, joy, and speculation.</p>
<p>Perhaps the most widely read response came from Dawkins, in an open letter whose first sentence contained a rather less than charitable: “Seriously, Ayaan? You, a Christian? You are no more Christian than I am.”</p>
<p>Why? Because Hirsi Ali’s article, while passionate and detailed, suffered from the exclusion of anything resembling an argument for the existence of God, or for the theological supremacy of the Christian religion over others (or even over atheism). Instead, it is a political treatise: it begins with her experiences as a Muslim, touching on 9/11, the Muslim Brotherhood, and antisemitism, before asking: “So, what changed? Why do I call myself a Christian now?”</p>
<p>She answers: “Part of the answer is global. Western civilisation is under threat from three different but related forces,” which she identifies as Russian/Chinese authoritarianism, Islamism, and wokeism. All of which are distinctly political considerations and so hardly serve as a theological defence of Christianity. Then, referring to Tom Holland, she tells us that the “story of the West” is a civilisation built on the “Judeo-Christian tradition”. That is to say, She is ticking all the boxes of a merely cultural Christian.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Strangely, then, they could find initial agreement on one point: their being just as Christian as each other.&#8221;</div>
<p>Yet she later writes, as if anticipating this objection, “I would not be truthful if I attributed my embrace of Christianity solely to the realisation that atheism is too weak and divisive a doctrine to fortify us against our menacing foes.” It’s a promising interjection, which seems to ready us for an apolitical testimony that might justify her exclusion of the “cultural” in labelling her new Christian identity.</p>
<p>Here, Hirsi Ali begins to describe her personal struggles as an atheist. “I have…  found life without any spiritual solace unendurable,” she writes, claiming that the “God hole” left behind after her deconversion was not filled with reason and intelligent humanism, as atheists like Betrand Russell had predicted, but instead left painfully vacant.</p>
<p>“In this nihilistic vacuum, the challenge before us becomes civilisational,” she continues. “We can’t withstand China, Russia and Iran if we can’t explain to our populations why it matters that we do.” In explaining, then, her reasons for becoming Christian <em>apart from </em>her desire to defeat her political foes, she tells us that she was struggling with a nihilistic vacuum that was… insufficient for defeating her political foes. Once again, the motivation seems political.</p>
<p>Thus Richard Dawkins and his assessment, “you are no more a Christian than I am”. The funny thing is, Ayaan Hirsi Ali endorses this sentiment. Dawkins has, of late, been airing his misgivings about gender theorists and Islamists, and constantly reaffirms his admiration for Christian art, architecture and music. These political and aesthetic preferences inspired her to refer to Dawkins at one point as one of “the most Christian” people that she knows. Strangely, then, they could find initial agreement on one point: their being just as Christian as each other.</p>
<p>This uneasy equilibrium provided the <em>mise en sc</em><em>è</em><em>ne</em> for an eagerly awaited conversation between the two, which took place in Brooklyn last month. Dawkins tells us at one point that he showed up fully prepared to explain to Hirsi Ali why she is not a Christian: “The idea,” he says, “that the Universe has lurking beneath it an intelligence a supernatural intelligence that invented the laws of physics it invented mathematics […] is a stupendous idea (if it&#8217;s true) and to me that simply dwarfs all talk of nobility and morality and comfort and that sort of thing.”</p>
<p>He was, therefore, taken quite unawares, as were many of us, when he asked (or rather <em>told</em>) her, “You don’t believe Jesus rose from the dead, surely?” and she confidently replied, “I choose to believe that Jesus rose from the dead. And that is a matter of choice.” This, for Dawkins (as for me), changes the game. While throughout the event she had no hesitation in repeating her political grievances, in New York, she finally addressed the <em>truth claims</em> of Christianity, and appeared to confess a belief in them. “I came here prepared to persuade you, Ayaan, you&#8217;re not a Christian,” Dawkins told her, before correcting himself: “I think you are a Christian,” and — being Richard Dawkins — he added, “and I think Christianity is nonsense.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/why-i-am-now-a-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/why-i-am-now-a-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/GettyImages-470426810-1-e1699621389222.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/why-i-am-now-a-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/why-i-am-now-a-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why I am now a Christian</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/11/why-i-am-now-a-christian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Ayaan Hirsi Ali</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>This extraordinary event began with Hirsi Ali recounting her conversion: “I lived for about a decade with intense depression and anxiety self-loathing. I hit rock bottom. I went to a place where I actually didn&#8217;t want to live anymore but wasn&#8217;t brave enough to take my own life.” Through prayer, she managed to escape that hole. “My zest for life is back,” she declared to a healthy applause, indicative of the one thing that everyone can agree on: it is wonderful to hear that Ayaan is happy again.</p>
<p>After finishing this personal narrative, she could only look at Dawkins and shrug slightly. The audience laughed, in anticipation of something of a shift in tone. I did think there <em>was </em>something comical about following such a moving story of escape from depression and anxiety with, “But do you really think Jesus was born of a virgin?” Dawkins’s decision to do so, however, can hardly be blamed: as touching as his former colleague’s story may be, if he is right that God’s existence is a scientific question, then we should remember that bringing personal narrative into the laboratory is as inappropriate an approach as bringing a microscope into a poetry seminar. It should be no more an insult to say that Hirsi Ali’s emotional struggles are irrelevant to the question of God’s existence than it would be to say to say that scientific observations are irrelevant to the study of Keats.</p>
<p>As Dawkins himself put it, responding to Hirsi Ali’s fear that an atheistic universe doesn’t offer us any way to connect with each other and the cosmos: “Suppose it were true that atheism doesn&#8217;t offer anything. So what? why should it offer anything?” Further applause.</p>
<p>“Faith offers you something, obviously. That&#8217;s very very very clear,” he says at one point. “But it doesn&#8217;t make it true. It doesn&#8217;t make the existence claims of Christianity true.” More clapping. Given that such a claim is hardly extraordinary or controversial, this reception seemed to be less in support of the point, and more of Dawkins’s willingness to make it plain.</p>
<p>Yet it is worth remembering that believing something for non-rational reasons is not unusual. Our beliefs are quite often formed by our surrounding environment, rather than some kind of perfect logic and analysis of abstract syllogisms. Most people know this. Hirsi Ali is happy to admit it. You may think it imperfect, but it is not unique to her.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;The kind of Christianity adopted by Hirsi Ali goes further in asserting its truth, but not very much further in its justification.&#8221;</div>
<p>This means that any surge in Christian interest we may notice among our public intellectuals is unlikely to be due to a renewed interest in Biblical scholarship or the figure of the crucified Nazarene. It is instead likely a product of their environment. Cultural Christianity, then, is in many ways a political movement disguised as a religious one, reacting not to arguments for God’s existence, but concerns about the practical shortcomings of atheism and alternative religions. The kind of Christianity adopted by Hirsi Ali goes further in asserting its truth, but not very much further in its justification.</p>
<p>Therefore, those celebrating some alleged resurgence of Christianity ought be cautious: it would certainly be a happy day for them if their favourite intellectuals began discovering a relationship with Jesus, but if they begin converting to Christianity principally as an ideological bulwark, we may witness the return not of a meek and mild community of believers, but of a more strong-armed, aggressive Christianity that has historically been a touch more controversial.</p>
<p>But Ayaan does seem genuinely transformed by her new faith: she looks happy, speaks humbly, and seems genuinely uninterested in point-scoring or winning any arguments. It troubles me not at all to admit that I found myself applauding her more than Richard Dawkins. It transpired in Brooklyn that her conversion, which at first appeared mostly political, was more a result of her personal battle with nihilism. This is hardly going to convince anybody else to become Christian, but such personal experience isn’t ever supposed to.</p>
<p>Atheists are often told that they are plagued with a “God-shaped hole”. Hirsi Ali appears to have developed for herself a hole-shaped God. But despite the probability of at least an element of motivated reasoning in this conversion, I’m genuinely happy for her. We should keep in mind, too, as her story evolves, that our ideas are the most unclear to us when they are new, and Ayaan is a new Christian. While we are all trying to work out what she <em>really</em> believes, she is probably trying to work out the same thing. She, however, has the unusual courage to do it out loud.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/the-trouble-with-political-christianity/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/the-trouble-with-political-christianity/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/06/the-trouble-with-political-christianity/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">606492</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The Machiavelli of Meta</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-654564968-1.jpg?w=526</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Special investigation</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Tom McTague]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Tom-McTague-Website.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Tom McTague</strong> is UnHerd&#8217;s <strong>Political Editor.</strong> He is the author of <em>Between the Waves: The Hidden History of a Very British Revolution 1945-2016,</em> due to be published in September 2025</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>TomMcTague</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is UnHerd's <strong>Political Editor.</strong> He is the author of <em>Between the Waves: The Hidden History of a Very British Revolution 1945-2016,</em> due to be published in September 2025]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 26 Feb 2024 00:10:29 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 22 May 2024 12:40:56 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Facebook]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Meta]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Nick Clegg]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[none]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=491146</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Inside Nick Clegg's lobbying operation]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>In six years, Nick Clegg has gone from political has-been to one of the most powerful executives at one of the world’s biggest tech firms: President of Global Affairs at Meta. As one of Mark Zuckerberg’s most trusted consiglieri, Clegg reportedly earns over $15 million a year and is tasked with dealing with the politics of its extraordinary global power and wealth. But is “the Foreign Secretary of Facebook” a constraining force on the media behemoth, or an enabling one?<br />
<a id="continuereading"></a><br />
Tom McTague, UnHerd&#8217;s Political Editor, has spent months investigating the darker side of Facebook. He has spoken to people in government, finance, tech and the police force, as well as friends of the former deputy prime minister to find out: is Nick Clegg whitewashing Facebook?</p>
<p><a href="#reincarnation"><strong>1. The reincarnation of Nick Clegg </strong></a><br />
<a href="#escape"><strong>2. The escape from California </strong></a><br />
<a href="#battles"><strong>3. Clegg battles Britain </strong></a><br />
<a href="#fraud"><strong>4. The rise of Facebook fraud </strong></a><br />
<a href="#superpower"><strong>5. How Clegg wields his superpower </strong></a></p>
<div><div style="left: 0; width: 100%; height: 0; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.25%;"><iframe src="//cdn.iframe.ly/api/iframe?url=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2F9Qa5l9YTxeI&amp;key=357d953055da7177194e1a84a2d8a5a3&amp;playerjs=1" style="border: 0; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;" allowfullscreen scrolling="no" allow="encrypted-media; accelerometer; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; autoplay"></iframe></div></div>
&nbsp;
<p><a name="reincarnation"></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>1. The reincarnation of Nick Clegg </strong></p>
<p>In July 2018, former deputy prime minister Nick Clegg was a mid-tier guest speaker at Anders Fogh Rasmussen’s inaugural “Democracy Summit” in Copenhagen. No longer an MP after being unceremoniously dumped from parliament in 2017 by a bar manager now in jail for fraud, Clegg was one of a number of former politicians who, having lost power, believed democracy was in trouble. Also appearing with the former Lib Dem leader were the two headliners that day: Joe Biden and Tony Blair.</p>
<p>The themes of that summit reflected the zeitgeist of the moment: the dangers of fake news and technology, particularly on social media platforms. For much of that year, Facebook had been under intense public scrutiny following revelations that people’s private data had been secretly collected and sold to Donald Trump’s presidential campaign. The “Cambridge Analytica scandal” had seen Facebook’s owner, Mark Zuckerberg, dragged before Congress where he had given a hesitant and unconvincing performance in front of the world’s media, becoming a lightning rod for all the anxieties of the moment.</p>
<p>Rasmussen’s Democracy Summit was, then, another potential PR problem for Facebook. Yet, as one of the key sponsors, it also offered an opportunity to show how seriously it was now taking its responsibilities. Facebook’s Vice President of Global Policy Solutions at the time, Richard Allan, headed up the company’s delegation. Allan was the former Liberal Democrat MP for Sheffield Hallam who gave up his seat for Clegg in 2005, acted as his campaign manager, and was then granted a peerage by the Coalition in 2010. Also in attendance was Facebook’s former vice president, Joanna Shields, who had also been given a peerage under the Coalition, becoming a minister under David Cameron and then Theresa May’s “special representative on internet crime and harms”.</p>
<p>So, while Clegg was a rather bruised former politician, he remained a very well-connected one. When the conference ended, he did not even have to sort his own travel home: Blair offered him a lift back to London in his private jet. Here was a taste of the gilded life he might aspire to in his political retirement, the life of a former politician no longer constrained by democracy.</p>
<p>But Clegg, thanks to that summit, has taken quite a different path from almost any previous British politician. He had never been that interested in technology, according to those who know him. But as Allan told me recently: “The event was one of those moments which helped Nick understand how politically significant all this was.” Within a few months, Clegg had joined Facebook, and relocated to the US. He has since risen to become one of the most senior executives at its parent group, Meta — no longer merely deputy prime minister of the UK, but, according to those I spoke to in Whitehall, effectively “Foreign Secretary of Facebook”.</p>
<p>Clegg’s importance at Meta was revealed last year when he negotiated both his return to London and promotion to “President of Global Affairs”; a position which reportedly earns him upwards of $15 million a year. Six years after his career low-point, Clegg is now Zuckerberg’s trusted consigliere, the political representative for a $1 trillion corporate behemoth. He is the man paid to ensure Zuckerberg is not exposed to the sort of political scandal that dragged his name through the mud in 2018.</p>
<p>In short, Clegg has it all: not only the kind of power, wealth and settled family life back in London that few former politicians could ever dream of, but also his reputation repaired and even enhanced. No longer a humiliated political loser, he is now the man tasked with making the world’s most important media company more socially responsible and saving democracy from the populists in the process.</p>
<p>While Clegg remains relatively guarded about this new life — he would not agree to be interviewed for this piece — his wife Miriam González Durántez’s Instagram page is like a show reel for what it all looks like. There he is with his wife one moment, hiking in Africa, smiling for the camera, soaked in the mists of Victoria Falls; then in the United States; and then back in England walking in the countryside. “Happy birthday Nick Clegg!” Miriam writes below one image of the pair of them. “Life with you is an incredible journey.”</p>
<p>“Y’all shooting Clarkson’s farm?” one of Miriam’s friends jokes in reply to her birthday post, the rolling English countryside clearly visible behind them. “I’ve watched two episodes and I’m hooked!” Miriam replies. “At least it’s anti-Brexit!!” For Miriam the nature of her husband’s departure from politics — and what came soon after — remains a source of bitterness. Under a news story that she posted on her Instagram feed about David Cameron returning to frontline politics as foreign secretary, she remarks, “Clearly getting bored at home,” before adding, acidly: “And yet home is where he truly belongs.” When a friend replies, “I thought it was George O you really hated”, Miriam posts a laughing emoji. When another adds, “what a joke of a man”, Miriam responds with a heart.</p>
<p>But is her husband really so different from Cameron? “The only difference,” one senior government minister said to me, “is that David is back in government trying to launder his reputation — whereas Nick is selling his to launder somebody else’s.”</p>
<p>This is central to any consideration of Clegg’s new life: is he really the liberal constraining influence on Meta that his defenders claim, the man making Facebook that little bit more responsible for the good of us all? Or is he, actually, an enabling force, giving a veneer of respectability to a company that is so big it has moved beyond the control of mere national governments and remains just as socially irresponsible as ever? For, according to those I have spoken to in the British Government and law enforcement over the past few months, Meta’s influence is not becoming more benign under Clegg — quite the opposite.</p>
<p>I was told by a senior minister that, in the UK today, 10% of all crime happens on a Meta platform. “That’s not online crime,” he said, “but all crime.” And it is getting worse. Not only has online fraud exploded on Facebook marketplace, but child exploitation is being made easier by Meta’s decision to ignore pleas from law enforcement agencies and government ministers not to roll out “end-to-end encryption” across its platforms, in effect making it much easier for paedophiles to groom and abuse children without anyone knowing. “They are responsible for an awful lot of harm in this country,” another minister told me.<br />
<a name="escape"></a><br />
And yet what is being done about it? According to those I spoke to in government, Britain has become a global soft touch for online criminals, attracted to the country by the ease of operating in English, our economic openness, speed of online payments — and, crucially, the utter inability of the state to do anything about it.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>2. The escape from California </strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_491196" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-491196" style="width: 2560px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-491196 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg" alt="" width="2560" height="1708" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg 2560w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=300,200 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=768,512 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=1024,683 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=1536,1025 1536w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=2048,1366 2048w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=267,178 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=253,169 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=250,167 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=660,440 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1245435791-scaled.jpg?resize=480,320 480w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 2560px) 100vw, 2560px" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-491196" class="wp-caption-text">&#8216;Is Nick Clegg whitewashing Facebook?&#8217; (Kenzo Tribouillard/AFP/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>Clegg’s time in California was important, say those who know him, because it allowed him to get close to Facebook’s “C-suite” executives — in particular, Zuckerberg himself. For much of this time, his boss was Sheryl Sandberg, the company’s all-powerful number two. When she stepped down in the summer of 2022, Zuckerberg relied instead on a team of lieutenants, one of whom was Clegg. With this direct relationship established, Clegg felt secure enough to move back to Britain.</p>
<p>According to Meta, he only occasionally interacts directly with the British Government — his job is now too important for that. “He spends most of his life on a plane,” I was told. In January, he was in Switzerland for meetings about AI; in December, in Brussels to talk to the EU; in October, Greece for another summit about democracy; and over the summer, India, where he was greeted like a visiting head of state.</p>
<p>Clegg’s job at Meta is to set overall strategy for dealing with the world’s most powerful regulators, oversee Meta’s own governance strategy and manage the politics that inevitably come with its extraordinary global influence and wealth. In total, there are now 3 billion “monthly active users” on Facebook, 2 billion on WhatsApp and 1 billion on Instagram. If Meta is now the size of a country, Clegg is both its cabinet secretary and its chief diplomat.</p>
<p>As such, Meta is not just another social media company, but a monster of global proportions: an international news platform, publisher, marketplace and advertising giant all rolled into one, used not just by ordinary people, but also by criminal gangs, sexual predators, authoritarian governments and terrorists. Indeed, one of Meta’s own lines of defence is that its very size is the reason why so much crime happens on its platforms.</p>
<p>Clegg’s defenders argue that, since joining Meta in 2018, he has moved the company away from its more libertarian instincts towards a more “mature, sensible place”, where it apparently acts more proactively in addressing public concerns about its role in things such as deep fakes, sexual exploitation and fraud. He has, they say, been instrumental in making Meta less hostile to regulation while creating new layers of governance for the platforms. He created the independent “Oversight Board” which now makes decisions on free speech and content on Facebook and Instagram, and which has been filled with unimpeachably liberal bigwigs such as the former Danish prime minister, Helle Thorning-Schmidt, who lives in London, and the former editor of <em>The Guardian</em>, Alan Rusbridger. These are Clegg’s people.</p>
<p>The Oversight Board has certainly helped to reduce the kind of political controversy over Facebook censorship which dogged the company during Clegg’s early years, when Donald Trump was removed from the site. Yet this innovation also points to the question about Clegg’s influence. “I mean, come on,” said one of the senior UK government figures I spoke to. “Does anyone really believe the ethics board is anything more than a rubber stamp for the same old West Coast liberal politics the company has always had?” To Clegg’s critics, in other words, it’s all just window dressing for the same corporate interest.</p>
<p>Over the past months, I have spoken to more than a dozen figures in government, finance, tech and police, as well as those who know Clegg personally, to try to understand how much he has really managed to achieve at Meta. Those who have come across him at work describe the same figure who burst into the public consciousness in 2010: fluent, charming, persuasive, normal.</p>
<p>One British minister who had dealt with Clegg in government told me he was the same as ever, only now with the air of corporate power behind him. Another MP said he was “charming but defensive” when representing Meta. Another who met him in California told me that while he was thriving professionally in the US, he was clearly out of place in Silicon Valley’s deracinated suburbia, too far removed from the Victorian warmth of south-west London where the family had made their home and to which they have now returned — albeit to a new £8 million home in Chiswick.</p>
<p>Clegg and his wife disliked the scale of urban poverty in California that sat alongside the kind of extraordinary tech wealth that they were benefiting from. Both felt that their time in the US had confirmed how European they were and, while they might hate Brexit and the Conservative Government, London was nevertheless home. While they were there, Miriam lectured on international trade policy at Stanford University, but she has her own political ambitions in Europe. Since returning, she has created a new political movement — or “nascent political party” as one friend described it — called España Mejor, or “Better Spain”.<br />
<a name="battles"></a><br />
It was always the pair’s Europeanness that made Clegg such an attractive prospect for Zuckerberg. He is, explains one friend, fluent in European in a way Zuckerberg is not.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>3. Clegg battles Britain </strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_491323" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-491323" style="width: 2560px" class="wp-caption alignnone"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-491323" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg" alt="" width="2560" height="1707" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg 2560w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=300,200 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=768,512 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=1024,683 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=1536,1024 1536w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=2048,1366 2048w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=566,376 566w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=267,178 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=253,169 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=250,167 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=660,440 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1142545311-scaled-1.jpg?resize=480,320 480w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 2560px) 100vw, 2560px" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-491323" class="wp-caption-text">&#8216;The Foreign Secretary of Facebook.&#8217; (Yoan Valat/AFP/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>“The tech industry needs to work together to fight predatory adults online,” Clegg tweeted in November. “That’s why Meta is a founding member of the Tech Coalition’s new <a href="https://about.fb.com/news/2023/11/lantern-program-protecting-children-online/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Lantern programme</a>, which will allow companies to share signals about predatory behaviour &amp; take action on their respective platforms.”</p>
<p>A month later, Meta announced that it was rolling out end-to-end encryption for all personal chats and calls on Messenger and Facebook, meaning, as it boasted at the time, “the content of your messages and calls with friends and family are protected from the moment they leave your device to the moment they reach the receiver’s device”. As a result, “nobody, including Meta, can see what’s sent or said”.</p>
<p>For years the British Government had been lobbying Meta not to go through with this plan. Today, Britain receives around 800 referrals every month from the US-based National Centre for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC), an organisation which trawls the internet looking for evidence of child exploitation. When NCMEC finds evidence of wrongdoing it passes it on to national crime agencies around the world who then go to arrest the abusers operating in their country. As a result of these 800 referrals, around 1,200 children are protected from predatory adults every month. By rolling out end-to-end encryption, the UK Government believes this number will collapse overnight.</p>
<p>In 2022, there were around 32 million reports of online child sexual exploitation made to NCMEC — 21 million of which came from Meta. When I put this to Meta, they pointed to comments by the NCMEC executive John Shehan, who recently praised the company for going “above and beyond” in their search for online child sexual exploitation while other companies did not, and there seems to be some truth in this. While Facebook referred 21 million reports to NCMEC in 2022, Google reported 2.2 million, TikTok 290,000 and X just under 100,000. Apple reported just 234. And yet, by rolling out end-to-end encryption, Meta has, in effect, wilfully blinded itself to at least some of what is happening on its platforms, even if it insists there is still much they can do to combat child sexual exploitation.</p>
<p>A Meta spokesman told me: “We don’t think people want us reading their private messages so have spent the last five years developing robust safety measures to prevent and combat abuse while maintaining online security.” Here is classic Cleggite third-wayism. Meta points to things such as enforcing age limits, using technology to scour for suspicious behaviour and stopping adults contacting children they don’t know. The company says, for instance, that it can block anyone over 19 from starting a direct conversation on Instagram with children they don’t follow. Meta also says it has developed technology to identify “suspicious adults” — for example, if they’ve recently been reported or blocked by a teen — which would prevent them from finding, following and interacting with teen accounts. But if adults are this suspect why aren’t they just thrown off Facebook altogether?</p>
<p>Another safety feature Meta boasts about are the “safety notices” it sends to teenagers if they are talking to suspicious adults. In just one month last year, 85 million users apparently saw such safety notices. And yet, as a parent, it is hard to feel reassured by such statistics rather than simply terrified at the scale of potential abuse. Other defenders of Meta argue that end-to-end encryption does not disempower the police. Encrypting messages does not stop undercover police entering WhatsApp groups or seizing mobile phones. Meta insists that overall, even with end-to-end encryption, it expects to continue providing more reports of potential child sexual exploitation than other social media companies. We shall see.</p>
<p>The British Government, at least, is far from convinced. In the autumn of 2022, the then home secretary, Suella Braverman, held a video call with Clegg about the issue. In this meeting, Clegg claimed Meta was being unfairly targeted because it was making the majority of referrals to NCMEC. From the British Government’s perspective, though, this was exactly the point — it is making so many referrals because there is so much abuse happening, which will now be harder to do anything about. The discussion ultimately ended without agreement: the UK Government insisted that it was possible to protect privacy and child safety by developing new technology to sit alongside end-to-end encryption. Clegg insisted that it was not.</p>
<p>It looks, to those in government, like Clegg has absorbed the prevailing libertarian orthodoxy of California: an orthodoxy which places privacy above all else. In Silicon Valley, there is an arms race to offer customers total privacy in their private communications, no matter the cost. For the British Government, the cost of such unbreakable privacy is simply too high. Instead, it believes technological solutions are possible that allow social media companies to scan for illegal material on encrypted platforms, while also maintaining privacy. “We know it’s possible, because GCHQ says it is,” one government figure told me. The British state, in other words, had developed the technology itself. Meta says most experts disagree.</p>
<p>After Braverman and Clegg’s discussion in 2022, the pair did not meet until 2023. In the meantime Braverman ordered the Home Office to produce a public campaign directed against Meta’s planned roll out of end-to-end encryption which would target Zuckerberg directly, pleading with him “as a father” to change course. The plan, in effect, was to launch a coordinated government attack on the Facebook founder to shame him into action by turning public opinion against him. But, then, Rishi Sunak ordered Braverman to pull the campaign.</p>
<p>Why would he do this? On this point there remains a fierce dispute between ministers. Some see something nefarious — Sunak eyeing a future career like Clegg’s — others the power of the Treasury, others mere political tactics or Sunak’s weakness. What is certainly true is that there was a campaign and then there was not.</p>
<p>It was also at this time that the Government began trying to reassure Meta about the measures contained within its then-controversial Online Safety Bill, which was making its way through parliament. Under the Bill’s provisions, social media companies such as Meta would be responsible for the content on their platforms and would have a new duty to “identify, mitigate and manage the risks of harm” from illegal content and “activity that is harmful to children”. The legislation also gave the powers to enforce this to Ofcom, the media regulator. Ofcom, the act states, could order Meta to use “accredited technology” to look for and take down child sexual abuse material on its platforms, and also to levy fines up to 10% of a company’s global annual revenue.</p>
<p>Facing this threat, in March 2023, Meta warned it would pull WhatsApp from the UK if the proposed measures in the Bill were not removed. But, then, in September — just as the row between Braverman and Clegg was reaching its climax — the Government moved to reassure Meta and the other social media companies that Ofcom would only be able to force them to scan WhatsApp, Messenger and Facebook for illegal content if that was “technically feasible”, which Meta insists it is not. In the end, the Bill received royal assent in October without the changes once demanded by Meta, but with responsibility for dealing with the problem kicked over to Ofcom.<br />
<a name="fraud"></a><br />
No one knows how Ofcom will use its new powers — or how powerful the new law will actually be. One thing we do know is that since the passage of the Online Safety Act in September, Meta has not only not pulled WhatsApp from the UK but has felt free to push ahead with the roll out of end-to-end encryption across its other services. “The truth is we’re too scared and timid,” said one government figure involved at the time. “As ever.”</p>
<p>When I opened my phone this weekend, I noticed a little message on WhatsApp. “We’re updating our Terms of Service and making relevant changes to our Privacy Policies for UK users, effective 11 April 2024,” the note read. The changes are necessary, it went on, “to reflect that the minimum age to use WhatsApp in the UK will be changed from 16 to 13&#8243;.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>4. The rise of Facebook fraud </strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_491200" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-491200" style="width: 2560px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-491200 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg" alt="" width="2560" height="1707" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg 2560w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=300,200 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=768,512 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=1024,683 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=1536,1024 1536w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=2048,1366 2048w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=566,376 566w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=267,178 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=253,169 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=250,167 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=660,440 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-1236309511-scaled.jpg?resize=480,320 480w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 2560px) 100vw, 2560px" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-491200" class="wp-caption-text">Clegg has recruited straight from Whitehall. (Hugo Amaral/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>Alongside the Online Safety Act, the principal challenge for Meta over the past year has been the growing anger over the explosion of fraud on its platforms, particularly Facebook. According to the <a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/online-fraud-charter-2023/online-fraud-charter-2023-accessible#opening-statement" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Government</a>, fraud now accounts for 40% of all crime in England and Wales, 70% of which comes from abroad with as much as 80%  happening online — the vast majority on social media. In recent evidence to the Home Affairs Select Committee, the TSB’s Financial Crime Prevention Director, Paul Davis, said 80% of the fraud they saw originated on social media, before adding: “Let’s not walk past the fact that when I say ‘social media’, the majority of them start from the channels owned by one company in particular, which is Meta.” Baroness Nicky Morgan, chair of the House of Lords Fraud Act Committee, told Meta that she had received written evidence from high-street banks that in one three month period alone, 70% of all cases of investment fraud started on Facebook or Instagram, either through adverts or victims being directly messaged.</p>
<p>The police are <a href="https://data.actionfraud.police.uk/cms/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/2020-21-Annual-Assessment-Fraud-Crime-Trends.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">seeing</a> the use of social media and “encrypted messaging services” like WhatsApp by criminals “increasing throughout all aspects of fraud”.</p>
<p>While Clegg sets Meta’s overall political strategy, he tends to defer the job of defending Meta’s interests in the UK to the team he has assembled in London, most of whom also used to work in Whitehall.</p>
<p>Meta’s director of public policy in London is Chris Yiu, a former No. 10 adviser and Treasury official who went on to become one of the most influential figures at the Tony Blair Institute (TBI). Yiu is credited within the TBI as being the man who convinced Blair of the revolutionary potential of technology, setting him off on his journey towards Oracle’s Larry Ellison, who now funds most of his work calling for much greater use of technology by government. Yiu remains close to Blair, becoming one of the TBI’s board members in 2022, a position he still holds, alongside his job at Meta.</p>
<p>Alongside Yiu, there’s Rebecca Stimson, who was in the Cabinet Office during the Coalition as a senior EU policy advisor to Cameron. Then there’s Richard Earley, Meta’s “Head of UK Content Regulation Policy”, who also worked in the Cabinet Office with Clegg during the Coalition, and Philip Milton, who does much of the direct interaction with the Government on the issue of online fraud. Before joining Meta, Milton previously worked at the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, “with responsibility for e-Privacy, Data Protection and Net Neutrality policy”, and before that at the Serious Fraud Office. For Meta, Whitehall is less a revolving door than a one-stop shop from which to poach its lobbyists.</p>
<p>When Milton appeared before the House of Lords in 2022, he claimed that dealing with online fraud was Meta’s “number one priority”. “Without our users, our platforms cease to exist, it is as simple as that,” he said. “Even if they do not necessarily fall victim to fraud, the very presence of it degrades users’ experience, and it makes it an unattractive place for advertisers to use as well.”</p>
<p>Yet, according to those I spoke to within the British Government, Facebook has been the slowest and least effective of all the Big Tech companies in reducing fraud on its platforms. When Google changed its algorithm so that it would only take adverts from investment products regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, the amount of online fraud coming from the site collapsed to almost zero. Meta, in contrast, dragged its feet and is only now doing something similar.</p>
<p>Far from being motivated to act, one senior government insider told me, Meta’s business model and sheer size meant it was, in fact, incentivised to move much more slowly than other companies. “If you are eBay or Gumtree, then fraud on your marketplace is a real problem because it’s your bread and butter,” they explained. “For Meta, they are ultimately an advertising company, so eyeballs on site is what they need, so the incentives are completely different.”</p>
<p>Meta’s principle strategy was to avoid any new legal obligations imposed upon it to deal with the fraud — or, more specifically, any new legal liabilities to recompense those who had been defrauded through its sites.</p>
<p>Today, pressure for the Government to do something is not just coming from consumers who have been ripped off online, but from Britain’s powerful banking sector, which has become incensed at the amount of money it is having to pay out in compensation to those defrauded on social media. The issue has become more acute because of a new regulatory regime coming into force in October this year, which will mean almost everyone who is defrauded online will be entitled to a full reimbursement. At the moment, most banks voluntarily reimburse their customers, covering around two-thirds of all fraud cases. Under the Government’s new rules, however, almost all claims up to £415,000 will be covered — some 99% of all cases — with the cost of the compensation split 50/50 between the bank of the fraud victim and the bank of the fraud thief. The social media platform on which the fraud took place will not have to pay a penny.</p>
<p>To deal with this discrepancy, there has been a growing push inside the Government for tighter rules on tech companies — Meta in particular — to force them to clamp down on the fraud on their sites. The Government has had two “anti-fraud champions” over the past year or so — Anthony Browne and then Simon Fell. Both have publicly backed calls for the burden of compensation to be shared between the banks and social media companies. For Meta, this is not just a financial irritation but also a potential legal principle that could become a new gold standard across the world.</p>
<p>Before the party conference season last year, formal proposals went into No. 10 that included a recommendation that the Government look again at “burden-sharing” as part of a new Online Fraud Charter. According to one minister, two of the Prime Minister’s closest advisers — James Nation, deputy head of the policy unit, and Will Tanner, deputy chief of staff — were demanding the Government “push hard in this space”.</p>
<p>And yet, when the Charter was eventually published in November, there was no mention of it. Instead, the Charter was a kind of voluntary compact between the Government and tech firms to do more to deal with fraud, with a review to take place in six months to see how they are getting on. The tech companies — and Meta — had dodged a bullet. “The lack of anything in the Fraud Strategy caused quite a stir from the financial services sector,” the minister told me.</p>
<p>Even getting Meta to accept some responsibility for the content on its platforms took an enormous effort and the direct lobbying of Clegg to get it over the line. “It is the first time they have ever accepted responsibility for what is on their platforms,” one insider said, “so it’s a big mental boundary that they’ve crossed, which we shouldn’t overlook.”</p>
<p>In the run-up to this turning point last year, Clegg spoke to Bob Wigley, Chair of UK Finance, after which he ordered a number of his juniors to engage directly with Anthony Browne, the Government’s then anti-fraud champion. Following one such meeting, Browne wrote to Clegg directly to say he was “very pleased with the new identification measures that Meta is taking to combat fraud on your platforms” and that he was “confident they will have a real impact, and benefit millions of your users in the UK”. He concluded: “Thank you for your constructive approach and taking the issue with the seriousness it deserves.”</p>
<p>Meta says that while the Government has not made it financially liable for site fraud, the Online Safety Act does list fraud among the harms social media companies have a duty to combat — with fines of up to 10% of its global turnover if it does not. Meta also insists that the commitments it has made in the Online Fraud Charter are significant. For instance, it will soon be rolling out “increased verification” on Facebook Marketplace, introducing warning messages to encourage users never to pay for an item without seeing it first. But why has it taken so long to get here? And if it takes the threat of government action to do it, why aren’t we demanding more laws with more bite all over again?</p>
<p>According to a number of insiders involved in the process, the real brake on imposing burden sharing was the Treasury and Jeremy Hunt in particular. “It was a combination of the two of them,” said one government figure. The Treasury does not want to impose financial burdens that make Britain less attractive for inward investment, particularly from tech companies. A second figure confirmed that the reason the social companies had escaped without any new liabilities for the fraud was because of “competitiveness issues”. A third said: “As ever, the Treasury is reluctant to choke off any potential UK investors with what they see as punitive measures.”</p>
<p>For Hunt, personally, one of his central objectives as Chancellor is to make London and “the triangle” with Oxford and Cambridge “the Silicon Valley of Europe”. In his Autumn Statement, he boasted that Britain already had the “third largest technology sector in the world, double the size of Germany and three times the size of France”, but wanted to go further. Meta has already invested heavily in London, with a big new campus at King’s Cross, one on Rathbone Place and another on Warren Street. It is from Warren Street in particular that Clegg is able to “hot desk” whenever he goes into the office. Hunt’s vision has also been embraced by Sunak, the tech bro with a place and a former career in California.<br />
<a name="superpower"></a><br />
And so, what is the result? Next month the UK Government is hosting the first ever Global Fraud Summit in London, attended by interior ministers and figures from Interpol, the EU Commission and the UN. And who has been asked to give a presentation on how to share intelligence? Meta.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>5. How Clegg wields his superpower </strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_491194" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-491194" style="width: 2560px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-491194 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg" alt="" width="2560" height="1606" srcset="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg 2560w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=300,188 300w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=768,482 768w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=1024,642 1024w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=1536,964 1536w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=2048,1285 2048w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=267,168 267w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=253,159 253w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=250,157 250w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=660,414 660w, https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GettyImages-470507168-scaled.jpg?resize=480,301 480w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 2560px) 100vw, 2560px" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-491194" class="wp-caption-text">His ordinariness is his secret weapon. Matt Cardy/Getty Images</figcaption></figure>
<p>If Nick Clegg has a superpower, it is surely the illusion of normality. He is the public schoolboy in an M&amp;S pullover helping to run one of the world’s great hegemons. It was this ordinariness that once made him politically popular, but which also contributed to the ferocity of the backlash when it came. The country had briefly fallen in love with this new Blair, only for him to let them down, just like the old one.</p>
<p>His skill as a politician was to always adopt the demeanour of the most sensible person in the room, neither irresponsibly libertarian nor hysterically conservative. It is the same trick he plays today. When Clegg bemoans those fixated on “speculative future risks about AI models that currently do not exist”, this may sound like third-way centrism, but it is also no coincidence that this reflects Meta’s corporate interest in maintaining a light-touch regulatory system for as long as possible.</p>
<p>Again and again, Clegg has adopted the same strategy: shepherding Meta into a place where it can say it is already regulating itself — and so does not need sweeping new regulations imposed upon it. But all the while, things are getting worse online, not better, and Clegg is the man ultimately responsible for Meta’s overall political strategy — a strategy which, I was told by four separate figures from within the UK Government, was self-interested, slow and resistant to any real democratic challenge, reticent to do anything which affects its corporate bottom line or sets damaging regulatory precedents which could be adopted elsewhere.</p>
<p>“There’s no question in my mind that he is an enabler,” one former colleague at Meta told me. “The only question is whether he realises it or not.”</p>
<p>Far from a burnt-out politician, Clegg is now a private citizen with extraordinary power and responsibility, paid a fortune to promote the interests of a company whose policies affect the lives of billions. If the US Congress can hold Zuckerberg to account, why isn’t the British Parliament doing the same to Clegg?</p>
<p>But it is also true that when trying to piece together his influence, the British Government has also shown itself to be as full of contradictions as Meta. During my conversations I heard how unimportant Clegg was to Zuckerberg, a figure to be held in contempt for selling his reputation for money. But I was also told how instrumental he was in dragging Meta over the line to sign the Online Fraud Charter. Meanwhile, some ministers boasted about how the Government had refused to give in to threats from Meta, while others lamented how ineffective they had been. Some blamed the Treasury, others No. 10 and others still a general mindset of British state weakness, made worse by splits within the Cabinet between security-conscious departments such as the Home Office and rivals such as the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology.</p>
<p>For all this pointless squabbling, a simple reality remains: Clegg might be an influential figure in a giant corporation, but the British Government is responsible for the laws which apply in Britain. If Britain is a soft touch, that is the Government’s fault. The question of whether he is a restrainer or an enabler is, then, moot: he is, inevitably, both. The real question is one of power. Clegg and the British Government have it. And we should be angrier with both for how they use it.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/the-machiavelli-of-meta/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">491146</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Will Britain lose World War Three?</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/will-britain-lose-world-war-three/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/will-britain-lose-world-war-three/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/UpdatedFeaturedImg.jpg?w=669</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme> </unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Aris Roussinos]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/aris.jpeg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Aris Roussinos</strong> is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and a former war reporter.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>arisroussinos</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an <em>UnHerd</em> columnist and a former war reporter.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Fri, 02 Feb 2024 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 22 May 2024 14:11:59 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[British Army]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[China]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Don't miss]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Military]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Nato]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Russia]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Taiwan]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[War]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=497735</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[To defeat Russia, we must pivot to air and sea]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><strong>Will 2024 be the year of a Third World War? As Russia&#8217;s war in Ukraine grinds on, the Middle East threatens to erupt, and China intensifies its military pressure on Taiwan, a global conflict seems all but inevitable.</strong></p>
<p><strong>How strange, then, that Britain’s Armed Forces are unprepared to defend their country. Over the past month, an increasing number of military insiders have been sounding the alarm, warning that, if we are to survive, we may have no choice but to enlist a “citizen army”. </strong></p>
<p><strong>The truth, however, is even more concerning. </strong></p>
<p><strong>As Aris Roussinos reveals in this Special Report, it may be too late to guarantee Britain’s survival. Decades of political indifference and dismal procurement strategies have left our Armed Forces outgunned and obsolescent. And with military insiders increasingly expecting a land conflict with Russia, Britain now faces an uncomfortable question: is the coming war already lost?</strong></p>
<h5><strong style="margin-bottom: 0;">Read on to learn about:</strong></h5>
<ul>
<li><a href="#one"><strong>Russia’s ability to expose Britain’s weakness</strong></a></li>
<li><a href="#two"><strong>The dismal state of Britain’s Armed Forces</strong></a></li>
<li><a href="#three"><strong>A catalogue of procurement fiascos</strong></a></li>
<li><a href="#four"><strong>How we were crippled by support for Ukraine</strong></a></li>
<li><a href="#five"><strong>Can Britain build a new army?</strong></a></li>
<li><a href="#six"><strong>Why we must pivot towards the air and sea</strong></a></li>
</ul>
<div><div style="left: 0; width: 100%; height: 0; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.25%;"><iframe src="//cdn.iframe.ly/api/iframe?url=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2Fj0ZvGwzo3GQ&amp;key=357d953055da7177194e1a84a2d8a5a3&amp;playerjs=1" style="border: 0; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;" allowfullscreen scrolling="no" allow="encrypted-media; accelerometer; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; autoplay"></iframe></div></div>
&nbsp;
<hr style="margin-bottom: 2.2rem;" />
<p>How close is Britain to all-out war? It would be comforting to assume that all the recent warnings from defence officials are mere hyperbole. But quite the opposite is true: as it stands, there is a very real risk that the British Army will be politically committed to fighting <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/29/us/politics/europe-nato-russia-trump.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a land war against Russia in eastern Europe</a> within the next five years. Without American support, we are <a href="https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/british-army-too-weak-to-fight-in-european-war-mrm2sk839" target="_blank" rel="noopener">on course to lose</a>.<br />
<a name="continuereading"></a><br />
When the Chief of General Staff, General Sir Patrick Sanders, claimed last week that “we need an army designed to… equip the citizen army that must follow”, the debate it produced centred on whether Britain is now too woke <a href="https://thecritic.co.uk/talk-of-conscription-is-pure-fantasy-politics/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">or too ethnically diverse</a> to sustain mass conscription, while also considering <a href="https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/would-i-die-for-britain-no-thanks/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">whether the Britain of 2024 is even worth fighting for</a>. While these are valid questions, the broader context — the idea of a land war against Russia — was left largely unexamined.</p>
<p>Yet Sanders’s warning was not without precedent. In 2022, he <a href="https://www.army.mod.uk/news-and-events/news/2022/06/rusi-land-warfare-conference-cgs-speech/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">declared</a> that this is “our 1937 moment”, in which the British state had a few short years to mobilise industry and modernise the Army on a war footing, with the aim to avert a war if possible, or at least not lose if one began. But if 2022 was 1937, by Sanders’s reckoning, 2024 is 1939 — and this work has not been done.<br />
<a name="one"></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>Russia will expose Britain’s weakness</strong></p>
<p>In 2022, even as Russian troops found themselves bogged down and on the back foot in Ukraine, Sanders presciently cautioned observers that “historically, Russia often starts wars badly”. Thanks to “its depth and resilience”, however, it “can suffer any number of campaigns, battles and engagements lost, regenerate and still ultimately prevail”. While Russia’s slow progress initially birthed <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/nato-underestimated-russia-ability-to-resupply-army-troops-ammo-general-2024-1?r=US&amp;IR=T" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a crowing sense of overconfidence</a> among British commentators and Ukraine’s online cheerleaders, Sanders warned: “Putin’s declared intent recently to restore the lands of ‘historic Russia’ makes any respite temporary and the threat will become even more acute. We don’t yet know how the war in Ukraine will end, but in most scenarios, Russia will be an even greater threat to European security after Ukraine than it was before.”</p>
<figure id="attachment_497813" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-497813" style="width: 1920px" class="wp-caption alignnone"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-497813 size-full" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Patrick-Sanders_1.jpg" alt="" width="1920" height="1080" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-497813" class="wp-caption-text">General Sir Patrick Sanders, Chief of the General Staff since June 2022.</figcaption></figure>
<p>A year and a half later, Ukraine is <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/01/peace-in-ukraine-has-never-seemed-further-away/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">firmly on the back foot</a>, and while Russia’s gains on the ground are slow and costly, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/09/business/economy/russia-economy-ukraine-war.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Putin’s mobilisation</a> of his vastly larger economy and population towards the war effort mean that, over the course of the next few years, Russia’s prospects of victory will become more likely, while Ukraine’s will dwindle. To defeat Russia, <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/12/27/biden-endgame-ukraine-00133211" target="_blank" rel="noopener">in the current reality</a>, means not recapturing lost territory but blunting the Russian advance at such cost to Putin that negotiations to freeze the conflict become a more attractive prospect than total military victory. In pursuit of this goal, Ukraine has been dependent on a constant flow of war materiel from the United States which has now ceased, and on a rapid scaling up of Europe’s military-industrial capacity that has not manifested. Just to stay in the fight, Ukraine will be forced to <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/3ce63abc-9a71-427b-8e11-ab5309288845" target="_blank" rel="noopener">conscript half a million men</a> from a civilian population <a href="https://www.thedailybeast.com/the-real-reason-thousands-are-fleeing-conscription-in-ukraine" target="_blank" rel="noopener">increasingly unwilling</a> to fight in a war that has caused the country, <a href="https://committees.parliament.uk/oralevidence/13758/pdf/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">according to Sanders</a>, “hundreds of thousands” of casualties.</p>
<p>Indeed, the unspoken assumption in military circles is <a href="https://x.com/nicholadrummond/status/1750512367417413741?s=20" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a scenario</a> in which Ukraine loses the war against Russia, perhaps next year or the year after. And if this happens, Putin will <a href="https://www.politico.eu/article/nato-chief-sees-real-risk-of-putin-attacking-other-countries-after-ukraine/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">then turn his gaze</a> to eliminating Nato as a threat to Russia by <a href="https://kyivindependent.com/polands-national-security-chief-russia-could-attack-nato-within-3-years/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">launching a war on the alliance’s eastern frontier</a>. The United States will be too preoccupied with <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/06/09/america-weapons-china-00100373" target="_blank" rel="noopener">its confrontation with China</a> to take part, and European armies, including Britain, are too under-equipped to win. As Sanders warned two years ago: “Given the commitments of the US in Asia during the Twenties and Thirties, I believe that the burden for conventional deterrence in Europe will fall increasingly to European members of Nato and the JEF [Joint Expeditionary Force].”</p>
<p>Giving evidence last summer to the Commons Defence Select Committee, the RUSI analyst <a href="https://committees.parliament.uk/oralevidence/13249/pdf/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Justin Bronk suggested</a> that Britain’s “window of vulnerability is probably late 2026 to about the end of 2028”. That is, he cautioned, “<a href="https://media.defense.gov/2023/Apr/24/2003205865/-1/-1/1/07-AMONSON%20&amp;%20EGLI_FEATURE%20IWD.PDF" target="_blank" rel="noopener">the maximum window of vulnerability</a> for a Chinese-American clash in the Pacific”, as, <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2023/12/02/draft-pentagon-strategy-china-00129764" target="_blank" rel="noopener">due to Pentagon procurement errors</a>, this is the period in which <a href="https://news.usni.org/2022/11/29/pentagon-chinese-navy-to-expand-to-400-ships-by-2025-growth-focused-on-surface-combatants" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Chinese naval power in the Pacific</a> will overmatch the American forces they are rapidly preparing to confront.</p>
<p><a href="https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/europe-must-urgently-prepare-deter-russia-without-large-scale-us-support" target="_blank" rel="noopener">As Bronk has warned</a> elsewhere, “in the event of such a military confrontation with China in the mid-to-late 2020s, Russia will have a strong incentive to take a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to break Nato while the US cannot reinforce Europe effectively. By 2026-2028, Russia’s industry will have been at full-scale military production for years, allowing it to rebuild its increasingly battle-hardened forces.” It is because of <a href="https://nypost.com/2024/01/23/news/norway-military-chief-warns-europe-has-two-maybe-3-years-to-prepare-for-war-with-russia/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">this likely scenario</a> that prominent US strategic thinkers such as Elbridge Colby, who would be expected to play a major role in a future Trump administration, <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/02/11/america-wont-defend-europe-britain-has/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">have warned</a> that “America must first and foremost ensure that it can defeat China in a conflict, and Washington no longer has a military capable of fighting two concurrent wars”.</p>
<figure id="attachment_497811" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-497811" style="width: 1920px" class="wp-caption alignleft"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-497811" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Elbridge-Colby.jpg" alt="" width="1920" height="1080" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-497811" class="wp-caption-text">Elbridge A. Colby, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy and Force Development during the Trump administration.</figcaption></figure>
<p>With a laser focus on America winning a war against China, Colby makes clear that “European Nato needs leadership” — and Britain should fulfil that role. <a href="https://committees.parliament.uk/oralevidence/13249/pdf/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Bronk</a> implicitly acknowledges this, warning that: “We must plan on the danger that, if the Americans are more than occupied, they will not just be unable to reinforce Europe; they will be pulling things out… in all domains, because the threat is really huge in the Indo-Pacific. I would ask people in the country as well: how secure would you feel against Russia in Europe, given it will continue to mobilise long after Ukraine fighting stops, if the United States is not coming to save us?”</p>
<p>The only answer is: <em>Not very.</em> According to one recent study, based on the volume of artillery fire in the Ukraine war, the British Army would run out of munitions <a href="https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/british-armys-ammunition-would-last-for-only-a-week-of-war-says-royal-united-services-institute-fd2hm0gh7" target="_blank" rel="noopener">after eight days</a>.<br />
<a name="two"></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>The dismal state of Britain’s Armed Forces</strong></p>
<p>If <a href="https://www.economist.com/leaders/2023/11/30/putin-seems-to-be-winning-the-war-in-ukraine-for-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Russia defeats Ukraine</a>, and then launches an incursion against Nato in Eastern Europe while the US fights <a href="https://www.foreignaffairs.com/china/united-states-big-one-krepinevich" target="_blank" rel="noopener">the greatest war in its history</a> in the Pacific, then Britain is committed to fighting Russia on land in Europe without significant American help. This is not a scenario for which British defence planning has geared the Army to undertake, and is not a war the Army is currently capable of fighting.</p>
<p>Everyone is aware that the British Army is too small for its stated task. From 109,600 troops in 2000, the Army <a href="https://x.com/gregbagwell/status/1751200677873787278?s=20" target="_blank" rel="noopener">had shrunk</a> to a mere 80,500 in 2022. As Sanders warned: “If this battle came, we would likely be outnumbered at the point of attack and fighting like hell.” And yet, in the year and a half since, the Army has shrunk to 76,950, and is on course to shrink further to 73,000. <a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12248783/Head-British-Army-quits-boss-claimed-naval-officer-job.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Sanders has resigned in protest</a>. To put these numbers in context, Russia has currently deployed 40,000 troops in its current operation to seize the small Ukrainian town of Avdiivka, just one front in a series of Russian offensives taking shape over the coming year. Yet it is perhaps under-appreciated that not only is the Army too small for its purpose, it is vastly under-equipped for the coming task.</p>
<p>The most sobering evidence of Britain’s shoddy preparation for our increasingly dangerous strategic environment can be found in the testimony of Armed Forces chiefs and military experts to the <a href="https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/24/defence-committee/publications" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Commons Defence Select Committee</a>. Its 2021 report on the state of Britain’s armoured capability put its conclusions in its title: <a href="https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm5801/cmselect/cmdfence/659/65902.htm" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“Obsolescent and outgunned.”</a></p>
<p>As it warns: “Were the British Army to have to fight a peer adversary — a euphemism for Russia — in Eastern Europe in the next few years, whilst our soldiers would undoubtedly remain amongst the finest in the world, they would, disgracefully, be forced to go into battle in a combination of obsolescent or even obsolete armoured vehicles, most of them at least 30 years old or more, with poor mechanical reliability, very heavily outgunned by more modern missile and artillery systems and chronically lacking in adequate air defence. They would have only a handful of long-delayed, new generation vehicles, gradually trickling into the inventory, to replace them.” Due to “bureaucratic procrastination, military indecision, financial mismanagement and general ineptitude”, for which the Army’s leadership is, if anything, more responsible than the Government, “we are still some four years away from even being able to field a ‘warfighting division’, which, itself, would now be hopelessly under-equipped and denuded of even a third combat brigade”.</p>
<p>As Brigadier (Retd.) Ben Barry, Senior Fellow for Land Warfare at the International Institute for Strategic Studies, warned the enquiry: “The reduced UK division”, which would be Britain’s initial land contribution to a war against Russia, “has half the anti-armour capability, only 30% of the tanks of a Russian tank division, two-thirds of the armoured infantry fighting vehicles, 20% of the anti-tank guided weapons and 15% of the self-propelled artillery. It would be very difficult for that reduced division to stop a Russian tank division. A Russian tank division would seriously overmatch the reduced Third Division. ‘Overmatched’ is a very polite, clinical way of saying ‘could be defeated’.”</p>
<p>As another expert witness, the <a href="https://uklandpower.com/about/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">defence consultant Nicholas Drummond</a>, observed, Russia outguns the British Army in a number of areas: “The first is artillery. It needs to do a wholesale renewal of its artillery systems.” The second is the British Army’s “ability to fire anti-tank missiles from under armour. It does not have that ability. It urgently needs that. The third missing capability is air defence. We are woefully short, and we would get absolutely spanked if we went to war without investing there.”<br />
<a name="three"></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>A catalogue of procurement fiascos</strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_497784" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-497784" style="width: 1024px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-497784" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/GettyImages-1238355140.jpg" alt="" width="1024" height="715" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-497784" class="wp-caption-text">One fiasco among many (Daniel Leal &#8211; Pool/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>Since 2021, even those timelines have slipped, and capability has worsened since then. Britain’s armoured fleet consists of Challenger 2 Main Battle Tanks, CVR(T) reconnaissance vehicles, Warrior Infantry Fighting Vehicles and FV432 Armoured Personnel Carriers. By the middle of this decade both the FV432 and CVR(T) will be approaching 70 years in service: indeed, CVR(T) was partly designed to fit between the trees in Malayan rubber plantations. Warrior and Challenger 2 entered service in the Eighties and Nineties and are also reaching the end of their working life. Yet the <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/ddfdfb87-b651-4eb4-92b3-1fa3e88f420d" target="_blank" rel="noopener">joint MoD and Army “fiasco”</a> of procuring their replacements has left the Army waiting for new armour that will not enter service until the end of the decade at the earliest.</p>
<p><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="alignnone wp-image-497846" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Aris-graphic-3_top-trumps-5-300x155.jpg" alt="" width="914" height="472" /></p>
<p>The <a href="https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/armys-new-ajax-tanks-make-crew-ill-and-cant-fire-shells-on-the-move-pn3wlh77v" target="_blank" rel="noopener">long-delayed Ajax Armoured Fighting vehicle</a>, whose vibrations <a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9990089/Troops-injured-Armys-3-5b-Ajax-tanks-claim-hundreds-thousands-pounds-lawyers-say.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">cause the troops inside debilitating injuries,</a> may <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/06/03/sort-ajax-tanks-shambles-scrap-whole-scheme-mod-told/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">enter service in 2030</a>: the Army is “cautiously optimistic” on this point. <a href="https://committees.parliament.uk/oralevidence/12532/pdf/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">According to Select Committee evidence</a>, the upgraded Challenger 3 is expected to enter service in tiny numbers — 18 — by November 2027, and its full complement of 148 by December 2030. The wheeled Boxer family of armoured vehicles will see 27 enter service in 2027, not reaching its full complement of 623 units until 2032. As the Committee Chair Tobias Ellwood remarked: “The full complement will not come into service here until the 2030s, when we can start doing our all-arms combat. Until then, we have a mix and match of old and obsolete kit, with the stuff that is coming online.”</p>
<p>If Britain goes to war in the mid-2030s, it will do so with a small but modern armoured force. Unfortunately, as we have seen, the war may already be over by then. As Bronk warned the committee, if the MoD was tasked with providing “a backbone of European deterrence against Russia, with credible warfighting capabilities in Europe in the next three to five years”, and resourced to do so, it will still take “five to 10 years to build that force”.<br />
<a name="four"></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>Crippled by support for Ukraine</strong></p>
<p>If Britain goes to war with Russia within the timeframe our military leadership fears, it will do so with the Army we have, or can quickly build in the next few years. And as the RUSI analyst Jack Watling <a href="https://static.rusi.org/by_parity_and_presence_final_web_version.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">warned in 2020</a>, the Army we have is not equipped for the task: “The UK lacks ground-based air defences and deployable long-range precision fires… Its heavy armour is under-gunned, its protected mobility is worn out, its artillery is outranged, its logistics are under-resourced, its deployment is too slow, and its ammunition stockpiles too small to deliver the effect for which it is designed.”</p>
<p>Due to well-meaning political decisions, which have not been matched by a sense of urgency in rebuilding the Army, the situation has deteriorated further. The <a href="https://www.thedefensepost.com/2023/02/23/uk-ukraine-challenger-tanks/?expand_article=1" target="_blank" rel="noopener">donation of 14 Challenger 2 tanks to Ukraine</a>, along with <a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11703401/British-army-runs-heavy-guns-pledging-30-AS90s-Ukraine-stave-Russia.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">AS90 self-propelled artillery systems,</a> <a href="https://mil.in.ua/en/news/ukrainian-military-mastering-m270-mlrs-and-105-mm-l118-howitzers-in-great-britain/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">M270 rocket launchers and L118 Light Guns,</a> <a href="https://mil.in.ua/en/news/fv432-bulldog-apc-heading-to-ukraine/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">FV432s</a> and significant quantities of anti-armour munitions and artillery shells “will leave us temporarily weaker as an Army, there is no denying it”,<a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11642011/Army-chief-writes-letter-warning-helping-Ukraine-make-troops-vulnerable.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> Sanders warned a year ago</a>. “There is no doubt our choice will impact on our ability to mobilise the Army against the acute and enduring threat Russia presents and meet our Nato obligations.”</p>
<p>As Watling <a href="https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/rearming-british-army" target="_blank" rel="noopener">cautioned in 2022</a>, “UK anti-tank guided missile (ATGM) stockpiles have now been significantly depleted — having been gifted to Ukraine — leaving British units toothless. With the <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-61701055" target="_blank" rel="noopener">announcement</a> that the UK’s MLRS are also going to be sent to Ukraine, the punch that was supposed to buy out the UK’s lethality in the close fight is about to be stripped from the order of battle. The already woefully inadequate stockpiles of rockets for these systems are now to be expended.” As one senior defence source <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2023/10/02/britain-run-out-of-arms-send-to-ukraine-says-military-chief" target="_blank" rel="noopener">told the press</a>: “We’ve given away pretty much everything we can afford to give…” As another<a href="https://news.sky.com/story/us-general-warns-british-army-no-longer-top-level-fighting-force-defence-sources-reveal-12798365" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> warned</a>: &#8220;The PM&#8217;s wartime approach is currently to cut the Army, hollow it out further by gifting [equipment to Ukraine] and with no plans to replace [the weapons] for five to seven years.&#8221;</p>
<p>Britain’s Nato commitment to the ground defence of Eastern Europe is <a href="https://www.iiss.org/online-analysis/military-balance/2021/01/british-army-heavy-division" target="_blank" rel="noopener">an armoured division by 2025.</a> Unfortunately, this division does not exist. As RUSI observed in 2022, the “current force comprises two armoured regiments of obsolete tanks, while one brigade has been converted to a medium-weight Strike Brigade. This forms the core of the UK’s current land contribution to Nato’s conventional ‘hard power’ in Europe to deter Russia.”</p>
<p>Moreover, as <a href="https://committees.parliament.uk/oralevidence/13249/pdf/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Ellwood notes</a> of those two tank brigades: “We have just one brigade deployed in the Baltic right now and it is going to take days, if not weeks, to bring that up to divisional strength. Bear in mind that if the Russians cross the border into the Baltic, that second brigade is going to be under attack all the way from the UK into the Baltic area. Our lines of communication are certainly going to be hit, and hit very hard.” In fact, it is doubtful that even the single existing brigade is currently fit for its commitment, <a href="https://x.com/FTusa284/status/1747194651335909655?s=20" target="_blank" rel="noopener">according to the defence analyst Francis Tusa</a>.</p>
<p>In the air, too, Britain will be heavily outgunned, outranged and outnumbered by its opponent. Because Nato’s SEAD capability — the ability to search and destroy enemy Surface-to-Air Missiles — <a href="https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/rusi-defence-systems/getting-serious-about-sead-european-air-forces-must-learn-failure-russian-air-force-over-ukraine" target="_blank" rel="noopener">is dependent on the US</a>, for the first time since midway through the Second World War, Britain cannot expect air superiority and must work on the assumption that any build-up of forces will be both visible and vulnerable far behind the front line. Under-equipped on almost every front, Britain is heading towards military defeat.<br />
<a name="five"></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>Can Britain build a new army?</strong></p>
<p>The question is what to do now. As long as Ukraine stays in the fight, Russia will not be able to expand the war, providing Britain and the rest of Europe with breathing space to rebuild military capacity. But enabling Ukraine to do so requires <a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/seven-countries-order-ammunition-under-eu-scheme-aid-ukraine-2023-09-29/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a vast, Europe-wide effort</a> to produce munitions in the quantity sufficient for full-scale war. And in the two years since the war began, <a href="https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2023/11/14/eu-countries-failing-to-meet-ammunition-production-demands-for-ukraine" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Europe has not achieved production</a> sufficient for Ukraine’s own needs, let alone rebuilding Nato stockpiles. <a href="https://www.euractiv.com/section/defence-and-security/news/breton-eu-countries-must-pressure-defence-industry-to-ramp-up-production-for-ukraine/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Unless this work is done now</a>, the looming war will be lost almost before it has begun.</p>
<p>Even if this level of production is reached, a question mark hangs over Ukraine’s ability to conscript the manpower necessary to survive the coming war: Europe’s year or two of breathing space will be very costly in human lives for Ukraine, without even guaranteeing the country victory at the end of it. In that short space of time, Britain will need to marshal its existing resources — which means shifting its focus to training Ukrainian troops rather than gifting Ukraine our dwindling stockpiles of equipment — while converting what remains of British industry to a war economy.</p>
<p>Yet a country that cannot produce its own steel, and is dependent on nations that will be either open rivals or detached observers for much of its imports of raw materials, is hardly geared towards a wartime-level of production. In the short term, Britain could engage in a frantic spending spree, buying off-the-shelf armour from European allies, <a href="https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/british-army-should-seek-retain-armoured-capability" target="_blank" rel="noopener">as it should have done years ago</a>. But even here, whether Britain could outcompete equally panicked European allies for limited production is questionable. The <a href="https://www.janes.com/defence-news/news-detail/british-army-to-receive-archer-sphs-as-interim-capability" target="_blank" rel="noopener">recent acquisition of 14 ARCHER artillery systems</a> to replace equipment donated to Ukraine shows that, while far short of the investment needed, a rapid procurement programme could swiftly bring results.</p>
<p>Ultimately, Britain needs to rapidly pool resources and production with European allies, based around a standardised, interchangeable suite of capabilities. <a href="https://x.com/nicholadrummond/status/1747227972161937838?s=20" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Drummond suggests</a> a five-year spending drive to buy Boxer armoured vehicles, anti-tank munitions, drones and long-range artillery, while increasing the Army to a size of 90,000 formed in eight brigades — all at a cost of an extra £10 billion defence spending a year, solely focused on the Army. This is a useful baseline level of thinking, but whether the political will exists is doubtful: the two controversially expensive aircraft carriers came to around £8 billion in total, while <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/jan/25/the-guardian-view-on-a-uk-citizen-army-unpopular-and-unaffordable" target="_blank" rel="noopener">the <em>Guardian</em>’s lofty declaration</a> that defence spending “should take a place in the queue” behind council funding and fighting climate change suggests that the British political class has no understanding of what the country is very shortly going to be tasked to do, the amount of effort and pain it will take, and the level of spending it will require.<br />
<a name="six"></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>A pivot towards the air and sea</strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_497790" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-497790" style="width: 1024px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-497790" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/GettyImages-88184864-1.jpg" alt="" width="1024" height="672" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-497790" class="wp-caption-text">An RAF Tornado GR4 fighter bomber (Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>Any future war would not be easy for Russia: the war in Ukraine has re-emphasised that, in modern warfare, the defending side <a href="https://www.foreignaffairs.com/ukraine/how-russia-stopped-ukraines-momentum" target="_blank" rel="noopener">holds a strong advantage</a>. Britain would not fight alone: it would fight alongside the small but capable Baltic armies, currently building <a href="https://www.euronews.com/2024/01/19/baltic-states-to-build-new-defences-to-bolster-natos-eastern-border" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a joint defensive line</a> along the Russian border, the currently more effective French Army, <a href="https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-nato-leaked-memo-defense-budget-boris-pistorius/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">the German Bundeswehr</a> and the <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/02/22/poland-us-weapons-ukraine-russia/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">rapidly expanding Polish army</a> (whose defence procurement and recruiting effort, at much less cost, should shame Britain), as well as Sweden, Finland and other nations. Britain’s land contribution has been so woefully managed that we should expect to play a supporting role, perhaps under European command.</p>
<p>But perhaps we should rethink the question from first principles: the Army is the weakest link in the Armed Forces, and as it stands threatens to be the weak link in Nato’s ground campaign, which itself means it will be disproportionately targeted by Russian fire. Given how things stand, should Britain be frank with the rest of Nato about the state of our Army, and shift our contribution to our better-resourced Air Force and Navy?</p>
<p>As Watling <a href="https://static.rusi.org/by_parity_and_presence_final_web_version.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">warned in 2022</a>: “if the UK feels it can no longer resource a war-fighting capability then this must be the starting point from which UK strategy develops, and extensive and difficult conversations with allies must be initiated.” Perhaps the time has come to warn Nato that we’re going to be late handing in our homework.</p>
<div><div style="left: 0; width: 100%; height: 0; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.25%;"><iframe src="//cdn.iframe.ly/api/iframe?url=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2Fj0ZvGwzo3GQ&amp;key=357d953055da7177194e1a84a2d8a5a3&amp;playerjs=1" style="border: 0; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;" allowfullscreen scrolling="no" allow="encrypted-media; accelerometer; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; autoplay"></iframe></div></div>
&nbsp;
<p>At some time in the 2030s — all things being well — Britain will possess a functioning Army, but until then it does not. A weak and underpowered British land commitment in Europe threatens to become a drag on Nato’s capacity, a burden rather than a gift. Should a war break out this decade, Britain has three choices: to go to war with the Army we have, and lose; to spend the next few years rapidly building up the Army, at vast cost; or to admit in good time that the Army will not be functional this decade, and shift Britain’s contribution to a European war to the air and sea. These are fundamentally political decisions, each of which will be controversial, and which require a degree of political leadership and popular legitimacy the current government, in its waning days, does not possess.</p>
<p>As the historian Robert Lyman <a href="https://x.com/robert_lyman/status/1744021201717010522?s=20" target="_blank" rel="noopener">observes</a>: “We have opened ourselves up to a shock of very significant proportions.” This is the insufficiently-understood context in which the current conscription discourse, essentially a debate on how to quickly replace our currently-existing Army, which has been set up for defeat, exists. But unlike 1914 or 1940, there is no strategic hinterland of booming factories and willing volunteers to fall back on. There is no Empire to come to Britain’s aid, Russia’s resources will be pitted against us, and the United States will be hard-pressed with its own war against <a href="https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/china-worlds-sole-manufacturing-superpower-line-sketch-rise" target="_blank" rel="noopener">the world’s greatest industrial power.</a></p>
<p>As Watling warned two years ago: “The old British tradition of losing the early battles but winning the war does not work when it takes years to build sophisticated modern military equipment. In short, if deterrence fails, and the Army is not appropriately provisioned, there will be no comeback. There will simply be defeat.&#8221;</p>
<style>.article-body li { margin-bottom:0; }.article-body ul { margin-bottom: 2.2rem; }</style>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/will-britain-lose-world-war-three/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/will-britain-lose-world-war-three/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2024/02/will-britain-lose-world-war-three/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">489246</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Inside Britain&#8217;s new trans clinics</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/inside-britains-new-trans-clinics/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/inside-britains-new-trans-clinics/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/belgh-1.png?w=747</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Investigation</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Kathleen Stock]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Blue-37.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<div><strong>Kathleen Stock</strong> is contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</div>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>kathleen_stock1</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</div>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Fri, 20 Oct 2023 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 22 May 2024 13:54:34 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Don't miss]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Feminism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Gender]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[GIDS]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[NHS]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Sex]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Tavistock Clinic]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Transgender]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=488544</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[They said they were closing the Tavistock's gender services — but what happened next?]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p style="font-weight: 400;"><strong>Since its closure was announced last July, Gids — the Gender Identity Development Service at the world-renowned Tavistock and Portman Trust — has become synonymous with mismanagement and medical scandal.</strong></p>
<p style="font-weight: 400;"><strong>It was supposed to be a haven for young people experiencing gender-related distress. Instead, following a string of complaints by whistle-blowers, an “inadequate” rating by the Care Quality Commission, a high-profile judicial review and, finally, a damning independent review, it was deemed unsafe.</strong></p>
<p style="font-weight: 400;"><strong>In its place, two new regional hubs were set to open, with several more centres to follow. For Gids&#8217;s long-standing critics, concerned about the distress its tumult was having on children, this came as a huge relief.</strong></p>
<p style="font-weight: 400;"><strong>The story, however, does not end here.</strong></p>
<p style="font-weight: 400;"><strong>Kathleen Stock has spent the past month speaking to a range of clinicians, NHS professionals and parents of dysphoric children — to find out whether Gids’s new service will be an improvement.</strong></p>
<p style="font-weight: 400;"><strong>The portrait she paints is stark: her findings suggest that the NHS gender services are yet to become a clinically safe space for children and teens, with senior figures still pushing an activist ideology.</strong><strong> Only last week, NHS bosses internally announced that they are significantly delaying the launch of one of the hubs. And as she reveals in the below investigation, it is unlikely to be the final twist in Gids’s new chapter…</strong></p>
<p><strong>Read on to learn about:</strong></p>
<p><strong>What happened to Gids?</strong><br />
<strong>The ideology in the new hubs</strong><br />
<strong>A new Wild West for patients</strong></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>***</strong></p>
<p>In 2014, the head of the NHS Gender Identity Development Service, Dr Polly Carmichael, appeared on a BBC children’s television programme <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/proginfo/2014/46/my-life">billed as the story</a> of “an extraordinary boy… born with a girl’s body”. Soothingly addressing the tomboyish young protagonist sitting across from her, Carmichael was <a href="https://twitter.com/newsround_blog/status/1151821906707984385">filmed</a> saying that a “puberty blocker” — or to give it its proper name, a gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) analogue — “pauses the body and stops it from carrying on to grow up into a man or a woman”.</p>
<p>She continued: “The idea of the blocker is that if we can take away that worry about your body doing something that you don’t want it to, then it gives you and us more time and space to be really thinking about what’s going to be best for you now, but also in the future.” As she spoke, a cartoonish pause button symbol was projected onto the child sitting opposite her, whose moving image was then frozen to a still, to reinforce the point.</p>
<p>Back in 2014, Carmichael’s service — known as Gids, and based at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust in London, with a satellite clinic in Leeds — was still riding relatively high in public opinion. The clinical psychologist was often in the media, describing the challenges of treating a highly mysterious new being — the “transgender child” — to fascinated and relatively uncritical audiences. Indeed, the children’s television programme in question,<em> My Life: I Am Leo</em>, went on to win a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gEVXpObdi-U">Bafta</a>.<br />
<a name="continuereading"></a><br />
But times change. These days — thanks to a string of <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/may/02/tavistock-trust-whistleblower-david-bell-transgender-children-gids">whistleblowers</a>, a high-profile <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-57573428">judicial review</a> involving a former patient, a <a href="https://www.cqc.org.uk/news/releases/care-quality-commission-demands-improved-waiting-times-tavistock-portman-nhs">rating of “inadequate”</a> by the Care Quality Commission (CQC), and a cumulatively devastating <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/books/what-to-read/time-think-review-book-tells-full-story-tavistocks-trans-scandal/">book</a> by investigative journalist Hannah Barnes — the name of Carmichael’s service is now synonymous with mismanagement and medical scandal. The closure of Gids was announced by NHS England in July last year, and an independent review is now well under way, also known as <a href="https://cass.independent-review.uk/">“the Cass Review”</a> after its chair, the distinguished paediatrician Dr Hilary Cass.</p>
<p>Following Cass’s interim recommendations, published in February last year, two new regional services are being formed to treat “gender incongruence and gender-related distress” in children under 17, with several more centres planned for launch afterwards. Slated to open next month, the “Southern hub” involves teams from Great Ormond Street Hospital, the Evelina Children’s Hospital, and the South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust. The “Northern hub” partners Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust with the Royal Manchester Children’s Hospital.</p>
<p>Many long-standing critics of Gids have been reassured by these developments, and by the principled and cautious approach apparently taken by Cass so far. It seems she aims to examine trans-identification in children and adolescents systemically, applying what is known about wider paediatric health rather than sacralising her patients as exotic anomalies. One parent of a Gids patient, seeking anonymity for the sake of protecting the privacy of his child, as so many parents of trans-identified children do, told me with enthusiasm: “Gender has been exceptionalised as a clinical speciality, but Cass wants to weave it back into paediatric practice.”</p>
<p>But the story does not end there. Over the past month, I have spoken to a range of clinicians, other NHS professionals, and parents of dysphoric young people to understand how Cass’s guidance is being enacted on the ground. I have discovered that there are deep ideological tensions and conflicts within the very institutions — clinics, hospitals, trusts, commissioning boards, adjacent adult services — whose responsibility it is to implement Cass’s new vision. Moreover, it seems NHS systems are still influenced by activist thinking; in particular, by the idea that a sex-incongruent gender identity is something to be “affirmed”, either as a matter of social justice or as personal liberation.</p>
<p>Considered together, my findings suggest that the NHS gender services are yet to become a clinically safe space for children and teens. Last week, NHS bosses suddenly internally announced that they are significantly delaying the launch of the Southern hub — after months of preparing training materials for clinicians recruited into the new service, and only a few days before the materials were due to be used for the first time. In line with <em>I Am Leo</em>’s original metaphor, it seems that senior managers too are pressing the pause button, in order to have more time and space to think. In the meantime, thousands of distressed children and their worried parents wait anxiously for a resolution.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>***</strong></p>
<p><strong>What happened to Gids?</strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_488568" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-488568" style="width: 1232px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-488568" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/euowfgh.jpg" alt="" width="1232" height="752" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-488568" class="wp-caption-text">Polly Carmichael outside the Tavistock</figcaption></figure>
<p>Despite the common belief that Gids closed following the announcement last year, it is still open, providing what it describes as “continuity of care” for around 1,000 existing young patients, including some on puberty blockers. (Cass recommended that in this interim period, any referrals to endocrine services by Gids staff should be reviewed by a multidisciplinary external panel).</p>
<p>It is unclear to outsiders exactly how patient care is now being managed at Gids, but what does seem true is that attempts have been made to improve existing processes since at least 2021. Published in <a href="https://medium.com/@GidsStaffGroup/an-open-letter-to-nhs-england-from-concerned-gids-staff-4e075dd574d2" target="_blank" rel="noopener">February</a>, an open letter from Gids staff concerned about Cass’s plans for the new services reveals that, after the CQC rating of “inadequate”, something called the “Gids Transformation Programme” was developed — separately from the Cass review, according to them — in order to make “wide-reaching changes to the running of the service”. The letter claims that external consultants were paid over £1.5 million to advise on the Transformation Programme, with some changes yet to be implemented.</p>
<p>At the heart of the controversy about the original service was its increasingly positive attitude to “gender affirmation”: roughly, the idea that a clinician should “believe” a girl who declares she is a boy (or vice versa), and so accede to her way of describing herself in clinical encounters. Though advocates deny it, critics insist that this practice precludes genuinely critical exploration of what may well be a passing phase. Without the capacity to gently challenge such a child in a therapeutic setting, an outcome involving lifelong medication is thought to become much more likely.</p>
<p>Even under the most scrupulous of arrangements, treating psychological distress in a physically healthy child or teen by administering experimental, powerful hormone-blockers carries risk. At Gids, that risk was increased severalfold by the organisational chaos of the service. During Keira Bell’s judicial review in 2020, High Court judges expressed surprise that clinicians did not seem to know how many young people had been referred there for blockers since 2011, nor of what age distribution. Only in 2022 — when Gids clinicians got round to publishing an analysis of outcomes for medicalised patients for the first time — was it <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35851291/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">announced</a> that 1,151 children had been referred to the endocrine clinics in London and Leeds for puberty blockers and/or cross-sex hormones between 2008-21. According to Barnes, what proportion of them received puberty blockers still remains unknown.</p>
<div><div style="left: 0; width: 100%; height: 0; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.25%;"><iframe src="//cdn.iframe.ly/api/iframe?url=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2FQboHWVDCyDQ&amp;key=357d953055da7177194e1a84a2d8a5a3&amp;playerjs=1" style="border: 0; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;" allowfullscreen scrolling="no" allow="encrypted-media; accelerometer; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; autoplay"></iframe></div></div>
&nbsp;
<p>There were other failures too, made clear in the course of Keira Bell’s judicial review and appeal, and in Barnes’s book. They include a startling absence of curiosity about certain recurring characteristics of patients — for instance, why so many of them were female, same-sex-attracted, and/or autistic. And there was also the close working relationship with the transactivist lobby groups Mermaids and Gendered Intelligence; inadequate preliminary assessments, both in quantity and quality; and a shocking lack of post-discharge follow ups.</p>
<p>In the past year or so, this impression of institutional disarray has been reinforced by Cass. In her <a href="https://cass.independent-review.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Cass-Review-Interim-Report-Final-Web-Accessible.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">interim report</a>, she criticised management for having no standardised approach to patient assessment; no routine contact between psychologist and endocrinologist; no consistent safeguarding processes; poor record-keeping; and too-infrequent monitoring of medicated patients. She also seemed critical of affirmative approaches, noting with apparent disapproval: “From the point of entry to Gids there appears to be predominantly an affirmative, non-exploratory approach, often driven by child and parent expectations.”</p>
<p>In June, guided by Cass’s analysis, the NHS <a href="https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Interim-service-specification-for-Specialist-Gender-Incongruence-Services-for-Children-and-Young-People.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">published an</a> “Interim specialist service specification for children and young people with gender incongruence”, laying out the broad features of a new clinical pathway for this cohort — including standardised, genuinely exploratory assessment by multidisciplinary teams. Separate service specifications for puberty blockers and hormones are to follow. Cass has also insisted that, in future, puberty blockers should be administered in the NHS only as part of a properly managed clinical trial.</p>
<p>Despite the many criticisms of her management career to date, Carmichael remains in post as director of Gids. One of the main whistleblowers at the Tavistock, former staff governor <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/may/02/tavistock-trust-whistleblower-david-bell-transgender-children-gids" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Dr David Bell</a>, told me: “Gids was found in the judicial review to be profoundly deficient in terms of clinical governance and record keeping. It is thus extraordinary that Polly Carmichael has been allowed to remain in position as director.” He described this as “a shocking message to parents and families who have been so damaged by this level of neglect”.</p>
<p>It is hard to find out which other clinicians still work at Gids, but many are assumed to be affirmative in their approach. In a second <a href="https://medium.com/@genderopenletter/open-letter-to-the-acp-uk-e668378d95f4" target="_blank" rel="noopener">open letter</a> from late last year — written from an affirmative perspective, in order to criticise the relatively positive response from the Association of Clinical Psychologists to the Cass Review — 13 signatories named their current workplace as Gids, including Carmichael herself.</p>
<p>One of the Gids-affiliated signatories was non-binary author and therapist Dr Jos Twist. Twist has edited an anthology, <a href="https://uk.jkp.com/products/nonbinary-lives" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Non-Binary Lives: An Anthology of Intersecting Identities</em></a>, which includes “stories of… how it feels to be non-binary and neurodiverse, the challenges of being a non-binary pregnant person, what it means to be non-binary within the Quaker community, the joy of reaching gender euphoria”. Another Gids signatory was clinical psychologist Dr Lorna Hobbs, who told <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/19/a-contentious-place-the-inside-story-of-tavistocks-nhs-gender-identity-clinic" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Guardian</em></a> in January that, “for me, affirmative is starting from a stance that says gender diversity isn’t a disorder but has existed across cultures through history. It is saying ‘I believe you’ when you tell me about your experience.” Along with Twist, two other signatories who also claim to work at Gids — Dr Claudia Zitz and Dr Josh Goulding-Talbot — are now also listed as working at <a href="https://www.genderplus.com/team?gclid=Cj0KCQjwpompBhDZARIsAFD_Fp_z7i23RsoR-7NN0EMZGI3BaSO1KwDm0LcNLKl201M61isnV3CqiBYaAmlgEALw_wcB" target="_blank" rel="noopener">GenderPlus</a>, a recently registered private provider with ambitions to prescribe hormones to teens (more on this below).</p>
<p>Such evidence suggests that the remaining patient cohort at Gids are not receiving the sort of care of which Hilary Cass would thoroughly approve. However, when it comes to the new services being built at the moment, it is not entirely clear that things will be much better…</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>***</strong></p>
<p><strong>The ideology in the new hubs:</strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_488574" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-488574" style="width: 1024px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-488574" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/GettyImages-1154084108-1.jpg" alt="" width="1024" height="683" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-488574" class="wp-caption-text">(NIKLAS HALLE&#8217;N/AFP via Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>Certainly, the presence of Professor Gary Butler in the new Southern hub does not instil great confidence that things have changed. For much of the service’s history, Butler was the endocrinology lead for Gids. In 2017, apparently with all the zeal of a true believer, he told <a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4743036/800-children-young-10-puberty-blockers.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Daily Mail</em></a> that, under his supervision, his clinic at University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust “routinely” prescribed puberty blockers to children with “life-long” gender dysphoria: “When the team feels the young person is genuinely transgender they welcome [the use of] puberty-blocking drugs right from the early stages.”</p>
<p>Butler has also co-authored articles with Carmichael and others at the clinic. In one from 2018, he observes that “around 35% of referred young people [to the clinic] present with moderate to severe autistic traits” — apparently untroubled by the thought that he might be contributing to the premature sterilisation of autistic youth. For it is now recognised that, when combined with cross-sex hormones later, giving blockers to dysphoric young patients early on in puberty can inhibit the development of adult sexual function permanently — a fact occasionally <a href="https://www.instagram.com/reel/ClTW3N8jpCp/">openly mentioned</a> by clinicians supportive of medical intervention but most of the time glossed over.</p>
<p>Yet Butler has now been <a href="https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/senior-doctor-questions-need-for-reforms-at-tavistock-trans-clinic-tavistock-zjd22zn5h#:~:text=As%20a%20consultant%20paediatric%20endocrinologist,and%20Portman%20NHS%20Foundation%20Trust." target="_blank" rel="noopener">recruited</a> onto the team based at Great Ormond Street Hospital (GOSH) charged with developing training materials for clinicians in the new hubs. (Insiders I have spoken to believe that Polly Carmichael was initially on the recruitment panel, though the BBC reported that the decision to have her there was later <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65245498" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“reversed&#8221;</a><u>.</u>)</p>
<p>Butler advertised his new role at a conference for gender medics in April, during a speech in which he also accused Cass of “nepotism” and said that the hospitals he was working with had no relevant experience with gender incongruence. He said he had “fought back” to “continue to be able to provide endocrine services for trans young people”. He has since <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65687697" target="_blank" rel="noopener">rowed back</a> on his comments and expressed support for Cass. But for David Bell, Butler’s presence in the new service still rings alarm bells: “Butler was responsible for being part of a service penetrated by trans ideology and neglecting the safeguarding of children; he is part of the Gids debacle and shouldn’t be involved in the new service.”</p>
<p>And Butler is not the only Gids clinician involved in the new hubs. I’m told that Dr Lorna Hobbs — the Gids psychologist who extolled the virtues of “believing” a trans-identified child to <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/19/a-contentious-place-the-inside-story-of-tavistocks-nhs-gender-identity-clinic" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Guardian</em></a> in January — has advertised online that she is involved in the new service. Hobbs often reposts material from trans activist lobby groups on her public LinkedIn profile, and declares, on the website of a private therapy provider she also works for, that she applies a “social justice and equalities framework” to all the work she does.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/has-gids-learned-from-its-failure/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/has-gids-learned-from-its-failure/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/GettyImages-1144752383-1-1-scaled-2.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/has-gids-learned-from-its-failure/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/has-gids-learned-from-its-failure/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Online Right and Ben Shapiro battle over the true meaning of Barbie</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/07/has-gids-learned-from-its-failure/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Sallie Baxendale</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>One person working in the Southern hub told me that some clinicians recruited into the service “only believe in an innate notion of identity rather than one developing over time”. They added that involving such different voices on a single team was causing dysfunction. “The official position is that diversity of opinion in a team is a good thing, in order to mirror the fact that people don’t all agree in real life. But it doesn’t work. You can’t say yes and no at the same time.”</p>
<p>In the Northern hub, meanwhile, there is also a risk of repeating old mistakes. Buried within the July 2023 meeting minutes of the Alder Hey Board of Directors is the news that Leeds Children’s Hospital has now entered into the Northern hub partnership “as the existing providers of endocrinology services for children and young people under the care of the current Gender Identity Development Service”. In other words, endocrinology appointments for patients in the new service will apparently be managed by the very same hospital department involved with Gids Leeds, the satellite clinic of the Tavistock. On the current <a href="https://www.leedsth.nhs.uk/a-z-of-services/gids/meet-the-team/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">website</a> for the hospital team, staff all list their pronouns.</p>
<p>Why were affirmative clinicians who were already tarnished by an association with Gids recruited into the new hubs, even after Cass’s recommendations? According to NHS sources close to both hubs, the most common explanation is cock-up rather than conspiracy. Managers at the relevant trusts don’t know much about the area, I was told, and when recruiting and setting up new structures, were likely to be impressed by a lot of mentions of “gender” on a CV. From this uninformed perspective, having already worked at the main NHS gender identity service for children presumably looks like an unimpeachable background.</p>
<p>Whatever the explanation, what does seem clear is that transactivist lobby groups and networks are strongly vocal in all of the trusts involved in the new hubs. Across the NHS, activist clinicians and support staff are pushing the idea that gender identity affirmation is a minority rights issue, and a way of furthering Equality, Diversity and Inclusion (EDI) goals. With “inclusive” policies about pronouns, changing rooms, and hospital wards already in place in a trust, the job of any clinician who wishes to resist affirmative narratives for dysphoric young people becomes that much harder. For fellow staff naively unaware of the potential clinical repercussions, it can easily seem that “respecting identities” is a simple matter of courtesy.</p>
<p>So, for instance, GOSH’s existing <a href="https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/789473/response/1890894/attach/7/FOIRQ6493%20Privacy%20and%20Dignity%20Policy.pdf?cookie_passthrough=1" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“Privacy and Dignity policy”</a> instructs clinicians that “Trans and gender variant young people should be addressed and accommodated according to their self-defined gender or presentation e.g. the way they dress, and the name and pronouns that they currently use”. Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust’s <a href="https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/789475/response/1995227/attach/3/supporting%20trans%20staff%20and%20patients%202020.pdf?cookie_passthrough=1" target="_blank" rel="noopener">trans policy</a> says: “Asking and correctly using someone’s pronouns is one of the most basic ways to show your respect for their gender identity.” In other words — wider hospital policy in both trusts instructs clinicians and support staff to “affirm” any non-standard gender identity automatically, wherever it is encountered. It is unclear how such policies could possibly be maintained in the sort of genuinely exploratory clinical setting Cass apparently envisages.</p>
<p>Over at South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust, meanwhile, all job adverts have Stonewall Diversity Champion branding. Freedom of Information requests also reveal that <a href="https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/982747/response/2337099/attach/2/Response%20Letter%20A%20Pearce%20230615.pdf?cookie_passthrough=1" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Mermaids provided EDI training</a> to Childhood and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) staff at the Maudsley Hospital last year. (The training this year was cancelled after <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/01/16/nhs-trust-reviews-training-trans-charity-mermaids-telegraph/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">adverse press attention</a><u>.)</u> Moreover, the hospital also has a vocal LGBTQ+ Staff Network, which seems to have some influence with management. I’ve been shown a copy of an email written by their leadership team in September this year, warning members of a visit to the Women’s Staff Network from <a href="https://lesbianlabour.com/on-being-a-lesbian/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Lynn Alderson</a>, a lesbian feminist speaker with gender-critical and sex-realist views. After complaining that the speaker’s views were “divisive and hurtful, and in contradiction of our network’s gender identity statement”, the authors continue: “We have been assured that strict protocols have been put in place to prevent the speaker stating her views on gender, and that she will be ejected from the meeting if she does so.”</p>
<p>South London and Maudsley Trust also participates in the NHS Rainbow Badge scheme, <a href="https://lgbt.foundation/howwecanhelp/nhs-rainbow-badge" target="_blank" rel="noopener">described as</a> “an assessment and accreditation model for NHS Trusts” and a “partnership between the LGBT Foundation, Stonewall, LGBT Consortium, Brighton &amp; Hove LGBT Switchboard and GLADD”. (The Rainbow Badge scheme was actually founded by a medic working at the Evelina Children’s Hospital — the third hospital involved in the Southern hub partnership.) In a <a href="https://slam.nhs.uk/download.cfm?doc=docm93jijm4n2496.pdf&amp;ver=3623" target="_blank" rel="noopener">recent assessment</a>, the Trust was given a Bronze Award, with particular commendation for its trans policies and for having “awareness posters across the site that reference microaggressions relating to homophobia, biphobia and transphobia” — though it was also marked down for a maternity policy that “uses gendered language throughout”.</p>
<p>A similarly ideological picture emerges in the North. Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust — which includes the Royal Manchester Children’s Hospital, one of the two children’s hospitals in the hub — also advertises its membership of the <a href="https://mft.nhs.uk/2019/11/05/staff-at-mft-wear-their-rainbow-badges-with-pride/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">NHS Rainbow Badge Scheme</a>, and in the recent past has used <a href="https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/627090/response/1504949/attach/4/FOI%20893%2019%20Worley%20LGBT%20training.pdf?cookie_passthrough=1" target="_blank" rel="noopener">another scheme</a> from the explicitly transactivist charity LGBT Foundation for training. The other one, Alder Hey Children’s Hospital Trust, is a member of the “<a href="https://merseysideintrust.org/navajo-information/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Navajo Charter Mark&#8221; scheme</a> — the North West’s equivalent of the Stonewall scheme, founded in 2010 to assess organisations in terms of “LGBTIQA+ friendliness” with a remit that includes “practices and policies” and “training”. Alder Hey was <a href="https://www.sefton.gov.uk/mysefton-news/latest-news/sefton-council-s-commitment-to-lgbtplus-issues-once-again-recognised-with-navajo-charter-mark/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">reportedly</a> accredited by Navajo this month.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-gender-wars-are-not-a-gift-to-the-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-gender-wars-are-not-a-gift-to-the-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/GettyImages-632150998-1-scaled-e1686073232358.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-gender-wars-are-not-a-gift-to-the-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-gender-wars-are-not-a-gift-to-the-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The gender wars are not a gift to the Right</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/06/the-gender-wars-are-not-a-gift-to-the-right/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The content of Navajo training for organisations is unavailable to outsiders, but a 2019 <a href="https://qpconline.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/SPRING-2019-LD1.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Navajo newsletter</a> perhaps gives us a sense of the organisation’s sympathies. It carries posts about banner-making workshops for Trans Pride, and regurgitates the <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8888486/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">persistent</a> falsehood that “Almost half the trans kids of school age in the UK have attempted suicide”.</p>
<p>When it comes to implementing the recommendations of Cass, then, it is not inconceivable that local LGBT+ networks and transactivist groups within hospitals and trusts will put up resistance, whether active or passive. In April 2023, a NHS-sponsored <a href="https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Public-consultation-analysis-and-summary-on-the-interim-service-specification-for-Specialist-Gender-Incongruen.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">analysis</a> of responses to the public consultation on Cass’s interim service specification was published. Of the 411 clinicians who responded, 49% of them (the largest group) fell into “Group A”, described as “largely opposed to the proposals outlined in the interim service specification”, for reasons that included the perceived “transphobia” of some clinicians and the equation of “mental health treatments” for trans-identified youth with “conversion therapy”. Though obviously there was self-selection bias here, nonetheless the findings suggest there is a problem.</p>
<p>This sense is reinforced by the contents of a series of <a href="https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/gender_identity_training_camhs_14#incoming-2353250" target="_blank" rel="noopener">FOI requests</a> made earlier this year to every NHS Trust in England and Wales that provides CAMHS, asking: “What if any training in gender, gender identity and equality your Clinical staff and practitioners have received in the last 4 years?” Some trusts replied that they paid explicitly trans activist organisations such as Mermaids and Gendered Intelligence to give them training; but even where trusts used less obviously partisan sources, it was clear from responses that the majority of them are employing a minority rights and inequality lens to look at gender identity, and not a psychological one.</p>
<p>And there is also evidence of at least partial capture in other powerful NHS bodies. NHS England was <a href="https://www.stonewall.org.uk/top-100-employers/full-list" target="_blank" rel="noopener">placed 68th</a> in the Stonewall Top 100 Employers this year — an intensely fought competition with hundreds of entrants, in which a high placing indicates close policy compliance with Stonewall’s transactivist goals. The Care Quality Commission, in charge of regulation, proudly advertises <a href="https://www.cqc.org.uk/about-us/jobs/working-cqc-our-commitment-equality" target="_blank" rel="noopener">on its website</a> that it is a Stonewall Diversity Champion — as <a href="https://www.nice.org.uk/about/who-we-are/policies-and-procedures/nice-equality-scheme">does the</a> National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice), <a href="https://www.hee.nhs.uk/our-work/diversity-inclusion/stonewall-diversity-champions-programme" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Health Education England</a>, and the <a href="https://www.nhsconfed.org/be-yourself-whoever-you-are">NHS Confederation</a>.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/GettyImages-1245528886-1-e1681805956225.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The media is spreading bad trans science</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-media-is-spreading-bad-trans-science/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Jesse Singal</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Elsewhere, the British Medical Association has come out in favour of affirmation, and published a response to Cass that <a href="https://www.bma.org.uk/media/6721/bma-response-to-nhse-interim-service-specification-december-2022.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">criticises</a> the new service specification for failing “to recognise the highly individual nature of children and young people’s experiences or their own developing autonomy in relation to exploring their identity”. The Chair of the Sexualities Section at the British Psychological Society, Dr Rob Agnew, frequently writes or endorses transactivist content on his public LinkedIn profile, including <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/drrobagnew_transgender-care-for-kids-whats-wrong-activity-7114833518064455682-nAQO" target="_blank" rel="noopener">one post</a> claiming that “[k]ids receive cis gender ‘grooming’ from the moment they are born” and that “[s]upposedly ‘experimental’ blockers are fully approved by the medical establishment and readily prescribed to cis kids for a variety of reasons”.</p>
<p>But this is not so. Some analyses suggest that blockers can negatively affect the <a href="https://news.ki.se/systematic-review-on-outcomes-of-hormonal-treatment-in-youths-with-gender-dysphoria" target="_blank" rel="noopener">bone density levels</a> of young patients, and perhaps their <a href="https://www.thelancet.com/journals/landia/article/PIIS2213-8587(17)30099-2/fulltext" target="_blank" rel="noopener">renal and cognitive</a> functions too. ​​A 2020 <a href="https://cass.independent-review.uk/nice-evidence-reviews/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Nice evidence review</a> — later <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/drrobagnew_yo-getting-some-heat-for-what-i-said-about-activity-7105447119024463872-BKwT?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop" target="_blank" rel="noopener">acknowledged by Agnew</a> after pushback — has concluded that the quality of evidence for the positive impact of blockers on “gender dysphoria, mental health and quality of life” is of “very low certainty”. There is also <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66842352" target="_blank" rel="noopener">increasing doubt</a> about whether blockers are beneficial or even just neutral for mental health.</p>
<p>Indeed, one NHS research trial manager I talked to expressed strong scepticism that a properly described clinical trial for puberty blockers — as mandated by Cass — could ever meet statutory regulations for what is known as “Good Clinical Practice”. She told me: “The Tavistock’s original application for their Early Intervention Study wasn’t regulated as a Clinical Trial of an Investigative Medical Product (CTIMP) but this one would have to be.” She added: “Children get classed as a vulnerable group. They need to have very special protections, and the rationale is just not there. The possible impacts [of blockers] on a child are so high that the moment that this was recognised, the study would be shut down. If you had a healthy child, and you recognised that medication could confirm sterility issues, or fertility issues, or bone density issues, the trial would be stopped at that point.” It would be “completely insane” to run such a trial, she concluded.</p>
<p>Meanwhile, even within the <a href="https://www.england.nhs.uk/commissioning/spec-services/npc-crg/gender-dysphoria-clinical-programme/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">National Programme Board for Gender Services</a>, the body ultimately in charge of service specifications for both adults and children with gender dysphoria, there are worrying signs for those seeking a clinical approach that situates dysphoria in the realm of paediatrics and psychology.</p>
<p>The Chair of the Board is Dr James Palmer, Medical Director for Specialised Services, a consultant neurosurgeon who has overseen all gender services in England and Wales in the past decade, both for children and adults. In 2018, he <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/06/04/nearly-two-million-britons-expected-question-gender-health-boss/?utm_campaign=Echobox&amp;utm_medium=Social&amp;utm_source=Facebook&amp;fbclid=IwAR3TAXva-R-_GJsOk1lObWQ63tkp07cCz7Ht_vmU_9NlpJvpJj89YNHF-Qs#link_time=1528147018" target="_blank" rel="noopener">told a conference</a> that the NHS needed to design “a healthcare service that will allow somewhere around 1-3% of the population at some point in their lives to have a discussion about their gender”. Talking about the drop in average age of Gids patients, he added: “It&#8217;s got to be a good thing that there are people out there that want to explore their gender. The fact that it&#8217;s in the younger age group has got to be a good thing. For a young adult, to be able to come forward, to seek that expertise, earlier [rather] than much much later in life, that&#8217;s got to be a good thing.” The lack of curiosity about <em>why</em> so many younger people were suddenly arriving in his services is marked. And in fact, there is <a href="https://segm.org/early-social-gender-transition-persistence" target="_blank" rel="noopener">evidence</a> that early social and medical transition for a child experiencing gender dysphoria — carried out, of course, by adults — tends to solidify a sex-incongruent gender identity in the child that otherwise might well have passed.</p>
<p>Meanwhile, on the Clinical Reference Group for Adult Gender Dysphoria Services, described as providing “independent expert advice to the National Programme Board for Gender Dysphoria Services on the various aspects of the Board’s work”, two out of five of the members are openly affirmatory of children. Dr Laura Charlton, a clinical psychologist, works at Gids Leeds and was the first author of the open letter signed by Carmichael last year, defending affirmation. At one point, the letter complains of the use of “male” and “female” for trans-identified children because it “undermines the lived experiences of the people being referenced”.</p>
<p>The second affirming clinician on the board, Dr Christine Mimnagh, is clinical lead at the Merseyside adult gender service CMAGIC, and also a GP and private practitioner. In <a href="https://fabnhsstuff.net/fab-stuff/fabtalks-in-conversation-with-dr-christine-mimnagh" target="_blank" rel="noopener">an interview last year</a>, worth quoting at length, Mimnagh said about trans-identified children: “The first thing you get taught in safeguarding for children is, if a child comes up to you and says, you know&#8230; ‘I don’t like the way they touch me’, or whatever, what you do is go ‘OK, yeah, tell me more, I’m listening’&#8230; what you don’t do, is say, ‘Oh no they didn’t, that’s Mr Jones the gamesmaster, he would never do that!’ There’s a difference between affirmation and dismissal and with everyone whose trans, affirmation is kind of the name of the game; you can’t deny people’s reality just because their reality is different from yours.”</p>
<p>In other words: just as we should believe a child who says she or he is being sexually abused, we should also believe a female child who says she is a boy.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>***</strong></p>
<p><strong>A new Wild West:</strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_488575" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-488575" style="width: 1500px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-488575" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/methode_times_prod_web_bin_5c499186-4c1a-11ee-98c9-759fff07db04.jpeg" alt="" width="1500" height="843" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-488575" class="wp-caption-text">Dr Aiden Kelly has set up a new practice</figcaption></figure>
<p>It appears, then, that despite the apparent good sense of Cass’s interventions so far, contemporary gender medicine in England and Wales remains somewhat chaotic. Within relevant services and wider NHS institutions, there are clinicians with directly clashing views about what sex-incongruent gender identity is, what it means, and what clinical decisions should be made as a result. And it seems that the cracks are starting to show.</p>
<p>I have seen evidence that, only last week, clinicians in the Southern hub — getting ready to launch in a month’s time, and to trial the new training materials with clinicians that very week — received a wholly unexpected internal announcement: the November launch had been postponed. Rising clinical, legal, and communication costs were cited, as was the insufficient time for senior clinicians to sign off the training materials in line with the proposed delivery schedule. I’m told that a manager of the team in charge of producing training materials resigned. Though teams within the Southern hub continue to be employed, their work is now paused, with no revised schedule yet in place.</p>
<p>What will this delay mean? With Gids closed to new referrals and the hubs not yet established, waiting lists will inevitably grow longer by the day. Now taken out of Gids’s hands and managed separately by a NHS Commissioning Support Unit, as of July 2023 <a href="https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/gender_dysphoria_services_waitin#incoming-2389236" target="_blank" rel="noopener">7,902 children and young people</a> were on the national waiting list. It is widely acknowledged that any child who is 16 is unlikely to be seen by a children’s service before she turns 17 (the cut-off point for care under childhood and adolescent services).</p>
<p>In desperation, some parents with enough means are turning to private providers to buy puberty blockers and hormones for their child. <a href="https://www.gendergp.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">GenderGP</a> is the most well-known of these, notorious for its close links with Mermaids — even to the extent of <a href="https://www.gendergp.com/susie-green-joins-the-gendergp-team/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">employing</a> former CEO Susie Green for a few months this year — and for its historical <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-65136838" target="_blank" rel="noopener">run-ins</a> with the General Medical Council.</p>
<p>But there are others who also see waiting lists as a business opportunity. The “Yorkshire Gender Endocrinology Services clinic” offers blockers <a href="https://www.yorkshiregenderendocrinology.co.uk/about-our-services">on its website</a>, though it’s unclear whether its clinicians would dispense these to under-17s. And last month, a new private clinic — GenderPlus — arrived on the scene, overseen by former Gids clinician Dr Aidan Kelly, with <a href="https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/trans-gender-teenagers-transition-future-tavistock-clinic-2023-5d6m608lf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">stated ambitions</a> to start prescribing hormones to teens in the next couple of months. Several other former and current Gids clinicians are involved in this venture, most notably Paul Carruthers — lead nurse at the NHS Gids clinic still based at Leeds Children Hospital, and described as the person who will be “leading the hormone clinic” at GenderPlus.</p>
<p>For some parents, this is an attractive option. One told me: “I know there are parents who want to do it by the book and feel that GenderGP is not doing it properly. They want to go to a Harley Street clinic, get a diagnosis, and feel reassured by having a clinician registered with the NHS.”</p>
<p>Yet while GenderPlus is presented by Kelly as a new project, focused on hormones not blockers, it seems he might already have experience in prescribing blockers to children under the auspices of another of his businesses, <a href="https://www.kellypsychology.co.uk/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Kelly Psychology</a>. As an anonymous <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/comments/v9vnqh/puberty_blockers_for_my_13yearold_son/ic0c7ha/?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=web3x&amp;utm_name=web3xcss&amp;utm_term=1&amp;utm_content=share_button" target="_blank" rel="noopener">comment</a> on the TransgenderUK Reddit put it a year or so ago: “There is another provider to GenderGP but it’s probably more expensive. I use Kelly Psychology and have a private endocrinologist who prescribes puberty blockers to my 13-year-old child. The process is the same as Gids but private.” (Kelly Psychology did not respond to a request for comment.)</p>
<p>Whatever the truth here, it is clear that Kelly is aiming GenderPlus at the parents of dysphoric children and adolescents, and that he anticipates big business. The company already lists 17 staff members on its website, including a research manager.</p>
<p>Given the acknowledged lack of a solid evidence base, to prescribe such poorly-understood drugs privately could be seen to be incautious. Cass’s new interim service specification is very explicit, with added red lettering for extra emphasis: “Children, young people and their families are strongly discouraged from sourcing puberty suppressing or gender affirming hormones from unregulated sources or from on-line providers that are not regulated by UK regulatory bodies.” Though GenderPlus <a href="https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/ex-tavistock-staff-to-run-new-gender-clinic-dlvwxzb83">has told</a> <em>The</em> <em>Times</em> it is seeking registration with the Care Quality Commission regulator, its website currently says that it has “clarified” with the CQC that its service “does not fall under their remit and as such is not eligible for CQC registration. If in the future we do provide services which will require CQC registration then we will seek registration.”</p>
<p>Another major worry for many parents of children currently on the national children’s waiting list is the increasing proximity to adult services as their child gets older. In August this year, <a href="https://www.transgendertrend.com/17-yr-olds-fast-tracked-adult-gender-services-nhs/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">letters were sent</a> directly to all 17-year-olds on the list, encouraging them to opt for referral onto the adult list instead. They were told that the original date on which they were placed on the children’s list could be transferred to the adult one, so that they could be seen more quickly. The letters were signed by James Palmer.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-problem-with-trans-women-are-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-problem-with-trans-women-are-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/GettyImages-1246299778-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-problem-with-trans-women-are-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-problem-with-trans-women-are-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The problem with &#039;trans women are women&#039;</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/02/the-problem-with-trans-women-are-women/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Kathleen Stock</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Since adult services tend to be uncritically affirmative, the letters have profoundly alarmed some parents desperately holding out for a non-medicalised resolution to their child’s dysphoria. In practice, it seems that a 17-year-old might self-refer to an adult clinic and be put on hormones on the day of her second appointment, without any psychological intervention; indeed, one clinic <a href="https://www.merseycare.nhs.uk/our-services/liverpool/sexual-health/cmagic-cheshire-and-merseyside-adult-gender-identity-collaborative/cmagic-frequently-asked-questions-faqs" target="_blank" rel="noopener">proudly advertises</a> the possibility of prescription at this speed.</p>
<p>What makes this possible is the existing NHS adult service <a href="https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/service-specification-gender-dysphoria-services-non-surgical-oct-2022.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">specification</a>, written in 2019. It is a document that governs standards of care in all adult services, and is a world away from Cass’s careful formulations. Gender dysphoria, it states, is “not, in itself, a mental health condition” — making it somewhat obscure why the NHS should pay for treatment. Equally, “psychological interventions will not be offered routinely or considered mandatory”; and “the majority of individuals will have two core assessment consultations” (and no more). Individuals can also self-refer to a clinic without any intermediate referral from a GP. For breast removal, a patient will need the sign-off of one clinician within the service. For genital surgery, she will need two.</p>
<p>There are eight NHS gender clinics for adults in England and Wales, plus four new “pilot” services, brought in more recently to bring down adult waiting lists in local areas (one of these was mentioned earlier: C-Magic in Liverpool, run by Dr Christine Mimnagh — the clinician who made an equation between believing a child’s disclosure about sexual abuse, and affirming a child’s incongruent gender identity). The new pilot services tend to be embedded within sexual health services, are run by predominantly LGBTQ+ clinicians, and appear to be even more affirming than the already fairly ideological norm.</p>
<p>For instance, the website of <a href="https://indigogenderservice.uk/about-us" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Indigo</a>, the pilot service in Manchester, says: “We know that trans and non-binary people are the experts of their own experience&#8230; Our services are trans and non-binary-led, with trans and non-binary people guiding and feeding into them at all levels.” An NHS <a href="https://democracy.brighton-hove.gov.uk/documents/s188435/Trans%20Health%20Care%20Specialist%20Services%20APX.%20n%201.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">commissioning document</a> for the pilots says that Indigo is “testing the role of Care Navigators, a non-clinical role typically staffed by individuals with lived experience, to support patients before their first appointment with the specialist team”. Somewhat unusually for a primary care provider, Indigo also has a “Leave this site quickly” button on its website, taking browsers to Google if necessary.</p>
<p>I talked to Anna, the mother of a trans-identified daughter currently on the Gids waiting list who is nearly 17 and is seeking medical transition. Her daughter formerly identified as a lesbian. Over lockdown, she began to identify as a boy, having discovered transactivist websites. The teenager, who also has ADHD, is now living with an affirming father who supports her transition.</p>
<p>Anna told me: “I’m frightened that without any evidence of benefits, and with a high rate of neuroconditions and traits — bearing in mind that girls will be more undiagnosed than boys — without consideration for all of that, and with only one pathway in the adult services, our kids have no hope. I don’t want to say mutilated but that’s what is happening. There is so much regret, I don’t want our kids to have regret. They are only on one path, without any mental health considerations. I don’t understand how they can do it.” Along with another mother in a similar position, she is now seeking permission to pursue a <a href="https://democracythree.org/help-us-hold-the-nhs-to-account" target="_blank" rel="noopener">judicial review</a> against the NHS, “for providing unsafe treatment advice for young people from 17 years old and vulnerable adults”.</p>
<p>For David Bell, what is happening to dysphoric 17-year-olds is the “biggest area of concern”. He told me that, in light of their incomplete cognitive and emotional development, there is plenty of precedent already for 17-25 year olds to be treated separately from adults in mental health services; pointing me to guidelines from the <a href="https://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/improving-care/nccmh/service-design-and-development/meeting-the-needs-of-young-adults-mental-health-care" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Royal College of Psychiatrists</a> and <a href="https://www.northumbria.nhs.uk/about-us/quality-and-safety/research-and-clinical-trials/developmentally-appropriate-healthcare-toolkit#8a02bf79" target="_blank" rel="noopener">elsewhere in the NHS</a> that have established this. He described the failure of adult gender services to recognise this as the “trans-exceptionalism” already familiar from elsewhere in the NHS. Indeed, with what another former Tavistock clinician described to me as a “beautiful irony”, the Tavistock and Portman Trust itself has an <a href="https://tavistockandportman.nhs.uk/care-and-treatment/our-clinical-services/adolescent-and-young-adult-service-ayas/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">adolescent and young adult service</a> in general mental health that covers 14-25 year olds — just not in Gids.</p>
<p>Cass’s interim service specification states that, when a child is moved to an adult service, “a co-ordinated transfer to appropriate local adult services will be needed where complex presentations continue”. It seems that, at the moment, such a rational arrangement is some distance away. In effect — thanks to the collapse of the old service and to delays within the new ones — a void has opened up in the systems supposed to care for gender dysphoric young people. And until it is filled, a cohort of highly distressed children and their desperate parents will continue to pay the price.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>***</strong></p>
<p>A spokesperson for the NHS Children’s and Young People’s Gender Service (London) said:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;"> “The NHS Children’s and Young People’s Gender Service for London — a partnership between Evelina London Children’s Hospital (part of Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust), Great Ormond Street Hospital and the South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust — is working towards full mobilisation of the new service by the beginning of April 2024</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px;">“The set-up of this completely new service is complex. In advance of full mobilisation, we will be working with colleagues on the safe handover of current patients. We are also focused on recruitment, training and ensuring good data collection which supports the developing research, and progress made in these areas will determine how quickly it will be possible to start seeing new patients off the waiting list.”</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/inside-britains-new-trans-clinics/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/inside-britains-new-trans-clinics/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/inside-britains-new-trans-clinics/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">481745</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>We need to talk about ZOE</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/we-need-to-talk-about-zoe/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/we-need-to-talk-about-zoe/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/2023-10-10-unherd-zoe-patch-pub.jpg?w=747</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme> </unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Deborah Cohen]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/blued-margaret-300x300-1.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Deborah Cohen</strong> is an award-winning, medically qualified TV, print and radio reporter.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>deb_cohen</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a GP and broadcaster.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Wed, 11 Oct 2023 23:03:08 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 22 May 2024 13:53:49 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Diabetes]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Health]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Influencers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[none]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Science]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Technology]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Tim Spector]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ZOE]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=487752</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[How scientific is the must-have health app?]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><b>Professor Tim Spector was one of the &#8220;winners&#8221; of the Covid era: his ZOE symptom tracker app accrued millions of users during the pandemic. </b></p>
<p><b>Now he has pivoted back to his true passion, gut health, and taken many of his followers with him. Endorsed by celebrities such as Davina McCall and Carrie Johnson, the new version of the ZOE app promises a personalised nutrition plan and comes with a glucose blood monitor usually used by diabetics. It is proving hugely popular, with over 100,000 subscribers paying up to £600 in their first year — and a further 300,000 on the waiting list. </b><br />
<a name="continuereading"></a><br />
<b>It boasts all the hallmarks of a scientific endeavour, with endorsements by world-leading experts and numerous studies. But how convincing are its claims?</b></p>
<p><b>Deborah Cohen, a medically qualified TV, print and radio reporter</b><b>, and Margaret McCartney, a GP, undertook a forensic investigation for <em>UnHerd</em> and found that ZOE’s scientific foundations aren’t as strong as they would have you think…</b></p>
<p><b>Read on to learn about:</b></p>
<p><a href="#influencers"><strong>1. ZOE and the influencers</strong></a><br />
<a href="#spector"><strong>2. Why Tim Spector created</strong><strong> ZOE</strong></a><br />
<a href="#healthy"><strong>3. Does ZOE think you are healthy?</strong></a><br />
<a href="#data"><strong>4. Why ZOE wants your data</strong></a><br />
<a href="#gut"><strong>5. What does your gut tell ZOE? </strong></a><br />
<a href="#scientific"><strong>6. How scientific is ZOE? </strong></a></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>***</strong></p>
<p><a name="influencers"></a><br />
<strong>1. ZOE and the influencers</strong></p>
<div class="row">
<div class="col-sm-10 offset-sm-1">
<blockquote class="instagram-media" style="background: #FFF; border: 0; border-radius: 3px; box-shadow: 0 0 1px 0 rgba(0,0,0,0.5),0 1px 10px 0 rgba(0,0,0,0.15); margin: 1px; max-width: 658px; min-width: 326px; padding: 0; width: calc(100% - 2px);" data-instgrm-permalink="https://www.instagram.com/p/CwAbROionx0/?utm_source=ig_embed&amp;utm_campaign=loading" data-instgrm-version="14">
<div style="padding: 16px;">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div style="display: flex; flex-direction: row; align-items: center;">
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; border-radius: 50%; flex-grow: 0; height: 40px; margin-right: 14px; width: 40px;"></div>
<div style="display: flex; flex-direction: column; flex-grow: 1; justify-content: center;">
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; border-radius: 4px; flex-grow: 0; height: 14px; margin-bottom: 6px; width: 100px;"></div>
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; border-radius: 4px; flex-grow: 0; height: 14px; width: 60px;"></div>
</div>
</div>
<div style="padding: 19% 0;"></div>
<div style="display: block; height: 50px; margin: 0 auto 12px; width: 50px;"></div>
<div style="padding-top: 8px;">
<div style="color: #3897f0; font-family: Arial,sans-serif; font-size: 14px; font-style: normal; font-weight: 550; line-height: 18px;">View this post on Instagram</div>
</div>
<div style="padding: 12.5% 0;"></div>
<div style="display: flex; flex-direction: row; margin-bottom: 14px; align-items: center;">
<div>
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; border-radius: 50%; height: 12.5px; width: 12.5px; transform: translateX(0px) translateY(7px);"></div>
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; height: 12.5px; transform: rotate(-45deg) translateX(3px) translateY(1px); width: 12.5px; flex-grow: 0; margin-right: 14px; margin-left: 2px;"></div>
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; border-radius: 50%; height: 12.5px; width: 12.5px; transform: translateX(9px) translateY(-18px);"></div>
</div>
<div style="margin-left: 8px;">
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; border-radius: 50%; flex-grow: 0; height: 20px; width: 20px;"></div>
<div style="width: 0; height: 0; border-top: 2px solid transparent; border-left: 6px solid #f4f4f4; border-bottom: 2px solid transparent; transform: translateX(16px) translateY(-4px) rotate(30deg);"></div>
</div>
<div style="margin-left: auto;">
<div style="width: 0px; border-top: 8px solid #F4F4F4; border-right: 8px solid transparent; transform: translateY(16px);"></div>
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; flex-grow: 0; height: 12px; width: 16px; transform: translateY(-4px);"></div>
<div style="width: 0; height: 0; border-top: 8px solid #F4F4F4; border-left: 8px solid transparent; transform: translateY(-4px) translateX(8px);"></div>
</div>
</div>
<div style="display: flex; flex-direction: column; flex-grow: 1; justify-content: center; margin-bottom: 24px;">
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; border-radius: 4px; flex-grow: 0; height: 14px; margin-bottom: 6px; width: 224px;"></div>
<div style="background-color: #f4f4f4; border-radius: 4px; flex-grow: 0; height: 14px; width: 144px;"></div>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p style="color: #c9c8cd; font-family: Arial,sans-serif; font-size: 14px; line-height: 17px; margin-bottom: 0; margin-top: 8px; overflow: hidden; padding: 8px 0 7px; text-align: center; text-overflow: ellipsis; white-space: nowrap;"><a style="color: #c9c8cd; font-family: Arial,sans-serif; font-size: 14px; font-style: normal; font-weight: normal; line-height: 17px; text-decoration: none;" href="https://www.instagram.com/p/CwAbROionx0/?utm_source=ig_embed&amp;utm_campaign=loading" target="_blank" rel="noopener">A post shared by Tim Spector MD FRCP OBE (@tim.spector)</a></p>
</div>
</blockquote>
<p><script src="https://www.instagram.com/embed.js" async=""></script></p>
</div>
</div>
<p>“I gave up after a month.” Gail, 49, is talking about her experience of using the ZOE app — the heavily promoted personalised nutrition plan that, we’re told, will help us understand our bodies and make us more healthy. “It certainly didn’t change my food compulsion — if anything, it made me feel worse.”</p>
<p>Take a look at ZOE’s lavish series of adverts, or the rapturous response to the app on social media, and you would be forgiven for thinking that Gail is an anomaly. TikTok, Facebook and Instagram are filled with celebrities, ZOE “members” and influencers sharing their positive experiences and inviting you to join the club.<br />
<a name="continuereading"></a><br />
One is Carrie Johnson, who recently shared her welcome email on Instagram, another is Davina McCall, one of the faces of ZOE’s marketing campaign. She claims she is now “living her best life”, telling prospective consumers (and her 1.7 million Instagram followers) that the knowledge provided by the technology is the “greatest gift ever”. A vocal menopause-awareness campaigner, McCall claims the gut microbiome is “completely different” in pre- and post-menopausal women.</p>
<p>But women only make up part of the market. Steven Bartlett, of <em>Diary of a CEO</em> podcast, is also an ambassador: “There’s an incredible correlation between what I’ve eaten, my blood glucose levels, and how I’m feeling,” he claims.</p>
<p>These three are among the 117,000 people who ZOE claims are now “members”. Another 300,000 are on the waiting list. This, despite the fact that ZOE isn’t cheap: it costs £24.99 per month (roughly £300 per year) and £299.99 for the intro kit which includes the instantly recognisable bright yellow blood glucose monitor that users display proudly.<br />
<a id="“continuereading”"></a><br />
These monitors are all part of a “personalised nutrition” plan that also measures your gut “microbiome”: the collection of “good” and potentially “bad” microorganisms in your intestines. This is assessed via stool samples which you collect in a “hammock” over the loo bowl and then post to the “lab” for testing.</p>
<p>After a fortnight of continuous blood sugar monitoring, combined with your gut bug measurement, you are provided with a nutritional programme — basically foods you should eat and those you should avoid. ZOE suggests that this sort of personalised approach can help with energy levels, reduce hunger, help you reach a healthy weight, feel less bloated, sleep better, and avoid chronic health issues.</p>
<p>But is ZOE the solution? Certainly, its stratospheric rise is a marketing triumph. But beneath the sheen of its glossy adverts and its wealth of medical testimonies, ZOE’s scientific foundations seem far from healthy…</p>
<div><div style="left: 0; width: 100%; height: 0; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.25%;"><iframe src="//cdn.iframe.ly/api/iframe?url=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2F_lmFI-2c2c4&amp;key=357d953055da7177194e1a84a2d8a5a3&amp;playerjs=1" style="border: 0; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;" allowfullscreen scrolling="no" allow="encrypted-media; accelerometer; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; autoplay"></iframe></div></div>
&nbsp;
<p><a name="spector"></a><br />
<strong>2. Why Tim Spector created</strong><strong> ZOE</strong></p>
<figure id="attachment_487806" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-487806" style="width: 716px" class="wp-caption alignnone"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class=" wp-image-487806" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/G65TE6-300x200.jpg" alt="" width="716" height="477" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-487806" class="wp-caption-text">Tim Spector, centre. (Anthony Devlin/Alamy Stock Photo)</figcaption></figure>
<p>From its inception in 2018, ZOE has relied heavily on the profile and academic credentials of co-founder Tim Spector, professor of genetic epidemiology at King’s College London. Already a familiar name in nutrition circles, he rose to prominence during the pandemic with his ZOE Covid symptom tracker app, described by <em>The</em> <em>Financial Times</em> as “arguably the world’s largest ever citizen science experiment”. With millions logging on to share their test results and symptoms, Spector’s app, boosted by £5 million of government funding, was credited with first highlighting that loss of taste and smell accompany Covid infection.</p>
<p>A self-described “measured risk-taker”, Spector told <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/b1b60f54-5d32-4644-a5f9-27af3c1704c7"><em>The FT</em></a> that he moves from subject to subject “if I’m not very interested in the next step or the next stage any more”. He started out as a rheumatologist, treating joint and muscle disorders, before turning to epigenetics, the study of how behaviours and environment can affect the way your genes work. Then, he set up the UK Twins Registry, one of the richest collections of data about identical and non-identical twins in the world.</p>
<p>It was this work, in particular, that led to his current interest: the interplay between diet and gut health. When he was studying the genetics of obesity in twins, he noticed that their weight sometimes greatly varied — which he attributed to the fact that <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5082693/">their gut microbes were different</a>.</p>
<p>After this Eureka moment, he decided to focus his efforts on nutrition, writing several books, the most recent being <em>Food for Life: The New Science of Eating Well </em>(2022). And he takes his own advice seriously — eating plenty of “fermented food” such as kombucha, kefir and kimchi to help his microbiome. He also microdoses on a diabetes drug which, he claims, could have anti-ageing benefits.</p>
<p>According to Spector’s website, it was during one of his presentations on his microbiome research that he met his ZOE co-founders, the now-CEO Jonathan Wolf and president George Hadjigeorgiou, both of whom have backgrounds in machine learning and business. They “shared his vision of helping individuals understand their unique biology to improve their own wellbeing in an accessible way”.</p>
<p>After opening offices in Boston and London, they rapidly attracted $27 million in initial funding to commercialise Spector’s work. (He remains a part-time ZOE employee and company shareholder.) And in 2019, they paid for a study that seemed to confirm the key concept for ZOE’s entry point into a crowded consumer market of products that offer advice on the healthiest foods to eat.</p>
<p>The PREDICT1 study suggested individuals’ metabolic responses to the same foods vary remarkably, with genes only playing a small part. (More on what you can infer from it later.) At a conference in the US, Spector revealed that they had found “really surprising” variation between certain biomarker responses — including some of those used by ZOE — to standardised meals.</p>
<p>It was what other investors needed to hear. The combination of a personalised nutrition app coupled with machine-learning and big data proved to be alluring buzzwords for the wellness-obsessed digital world. Steven Bartlett invested more than £2 million earlier this year. ZOE, he says, is a company that represents “the future”. It is “health science, driven by big data” that doesn’t just extend “our lifespan, but more importantly our health span”. Venture capitalists and those involved in a crowdfunding exercise thought similarly. Last year, one of the CEOs <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2022/12/01/zoe-which-went-viral-with-its-covid-tracking-app-raises-30m-at-a-303m-valuation-to-track-nutrition/">valued</a> the company at over £209 million.</p>
<p>Yet some are sceptical. They suggest this is just the latest iteration of Big Diet — or Big Nutrition. “This is a classic playbook. X doesn’t work; the experts are wrong; read my book and find out the truth. Then buy my product which FINALLY fixes everything,” says one critic, who did not want to be named. Interestingly, Spector himself used to be of these sceptical voices, writing cautiously in <a href="https://www.bmj.com/content/361/bmj.k2179#:~:text=In%20humans%2C%20observational%20studies%20can,in%20particular%2C%20randomised%20controlled%20trials."><em>The British Medical Journal</em></a> in 2018 that observational studies — such as those since published by ZOE —  are limited by the inability to measure causal relations between microbes and health traits. They can only show associations.</p>
<p>“The strongest level of evidence is obtained from interventional clinical studies — in particular, randomised controlled trials,” he wrote. (ZOE is yet to publish controlled trial data.) In 2019, he again suggested evidence was limited. In the same year he promoted ZOE study findings at that US nutrition conference, <span style="font-weight: 400;">Spector </span><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6950569/"><span style="font-weight: 400;">wrote</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">in a medical journal</span><span style="font-weight: 400;">, that “there is a lack of long term human studies, or indeed follow-ups of short-term dietary interventions” to understand whether “diet-induced modulation of the gut microbiota endures”. Could this barrier be overcome?</span></p>
<p><a name="healthy"></a><br />
<strong>3. Does Zoe think you are healthy?</strong></p>
<p><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="alignnone wp-image-487805" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/ZoeApp.jpg" alt="" width="722" height="481" /></p>
<p>On social media, it doesn’t take long to find people posting about the thrill of receiving their ZOE test results. As one user, Joel, 28, said to us: “It gives you another thing to share on Facebook or Twitter.” But how much can we actually infer about what’s going on inside our bodies?</p>
<p>There has long been a temptation in medical circles to assume that the more biological parameters we measure, the better. The truth, however, is that not all test results are useful. Just because something is measurable in your body, doesn’t necessarily mean that the result will yield useful information.</p>
<p>Dr Guess claims the app might be doing little more than recommending more fruit and veg to everyone. “They have no published data showing all this info results in personalised dietary advice,” she says. “They need to show that the dietary recommendations made by their algorithm can be replicated by other scientists. In other words, does the test give the same dietary recommendations on Wednesday as it did on Monday? This is one of the hallmarks of good science. Even more important, they need to show what they’re doing actually improves a user’s short and long-term health.”</p>
<p>This isn’t to say that continuous glucose monitoring isn’t useful. It is offered in the NHS, but for specific reasons — for people with diabetes. Readings can help to adjust insulin doses and improve control of potentially harmful spikes and troughs. Many people say that it has revolutionised their care. In people without diabetes, however, blood glucose is under continuous physiological control — with the pancreas regulating the release and storage of sugar in the body to keep it within normal parameters. This is the market ZOE is aiming for.</p>
<p>They’re not the only company making continuous glucose monitors aimed at people without diabetes. Even those in the clinical medicine arena are pivoting into this space. Indeed, The Global Wellness Institute estimates the global market segment for “healthy eating, nutrition and weight loss” is worth $946 billion a year.</p>
<p>The only problem is we don’t really have any evidence that these monitors do keep non-diabetic people healthy.</p>
<p>Dr Shivani Misra, a consultant in metabolic medicine at Imperial College London who researches continuous glucose monitoring, cautions that we don’t totally understand how to interpret measurements in healthy people. “We have no robust evidence base to suggest that those rises and falls are signalling anything untoward in the present or that they have negative consequences in the future,” she says. In fact, different devices might have different readings in response to eating the same meal.</p>
<p>Dr Kevin Hall investigates the regulation of body weight and metabolism for the publicly funded US National Institutes of Health, which has a programme in precision nutrition. His team has studied the use of continuous glucose monitoring in highly controlled environments — when people actually live at the lab for a month and undergo very specific diets and exercise regimens. They measured the glucose levels of one person wearing two devices. They found that sometimes one of the devices would give a very high glucose reading after a meal, and the other would give a low reading. They also analysed readings on the same device. They changed the regimens week to week — and concluded that the response to the same meal might vary as much as it did to eating a different meal in different weeks.</p>
<p>“Even in these very highly regimented kinds of controlled feeding studies, they don&#8217;t give rise to reproducible measures,” Dr Hall says. “It&#8217;s very likely that if that person ate a banana the next week, even if they had exactly the same previous food and did the same exercise that day, they might get a very different response.”</p>
<p>Unsurprisingly, the results are causing confusion. For instance, Gail says her glucose levels went up when she was exercising and her friend, who has diabetes and is used to monitoring their glucose, looked at her graph and thought it looked high. “I felt I didn’t get enough explanation about what this means or what might happen to my glucose,” Gail says. On TikTok, users also warn against the unwanted “spike”, saying they need to get a flatter line and describing their worries about their glucose dipping at night.</p>
<p>But this is not necessarily something to worry about: glucose going up and down is a normal bodily response. “Any time they see a slight rise or spike, people panic and it’s creating unnecessary anxiety,” Dr Misra says. “Then they think it&#8217;s wrong to eat carbohydrates — which release glucose into the blood — and there is no evidence that this is necessary or beneficial. Some tell me it’s taken over their life.”</p>
<p><a name="data"></a><br />
<strong>4. Why ZOE wants your data</strong></p>
<p>But what about those who do feel their energy levels drop and notice a lethargic “crash”? Joel, for example, frequently wakes up at 3am to find his glucose dipping. He was even told he was waking up because of this dip. But he’s not entirely sure what to do about it.</p>
<p>This isn’t entirely surprising. While symptoms and how we feel are real, it can be hard to attribute cause and effect. In her clinic, Dr Misra sees people with and without diabetes who tell her they’re getting symptoms of low blood sugar, but when they’ve actually measured it, it’s within normal range. “There’s a risk everything becomes glucose-related,&#8221; Dr Misra says. “It’s human nature when you&#8217;re monitoring something you become hypervigilant about that.” This is something Dr Hall and his team also found in their studies. “I think the fascinating thing is that when people are provided with more and more information, they tend to make these correlations,” he says.</p>
<p>The risk is that we are creating problems for people rather than solving them, and turning healthy people into patients.</p>
<p>Ironically, perhaps mitigating this is the relationship between social class and health: in other words, the people most likely to be able to afford ZOE may be among the least likely to benefit from it. Because of this, Amitava Banerjee, professor of clinical data science at University College London and consultant cardiologist, says that ZOE plays into what is called the “digital divide”.</p>
<p>“Even when digital interventions are useful, the people who need them least are usually accessing them most, especially given the cost,” he says. “Those who are at the highest risk of health problems are often in more deprived and ethnically diverse areas, with neither the money nor the resources to use ZOE.&#8221; And even though it’s been largely tested on young healthy people of European ancestry — as the ZOE team has written in medical journals — the marketing goes beyond this cohort of people. “The results they get from studies might not be applicable to people outside that group,” Professor Bannerjee cautions.</p>
<p>Elsewhere, some doctors have turned to social media to complain about the increased workload the app is creating for them among a cohort known as the “worried well”. GPs have described to us how they’ve been contacted by patients concerned they have diabetes, as they think that is what their continuous glucose monitors are showing. While ZOE is just one of dozens of private companies and influencers who generate blood results capable of causing alarm and sending patients to NHS GPs, they all add pressure on appointments — especially if people didn’t get good enough information about what the test results actually mean.</p>
<p><a name="gut"></a><br />
<strong>5. What does your gut tell ZOE? </strong></p>
<p><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-487849" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Dr-Tariq-Iqbal.jpg" alt="" width="1920" height="1080" /></p>
<p>Blood sugar is only a part of what ZOE tests. Other indicators as to the function of our metabolism and how we respond to food is determined by our gut microbiome. Zoe wants to harness the “potential power” of this to affect your long-term health and certain symptoms, and so takes a reading on how good your “gut bugs” are with the help of your stool sample. A diet plan to improve that is then constructed.</p>
<p>But not everyone is convinced there is sufficient scientific evidence to justify this approach. Dr Hall says research suggests you can change the microbiome in pretty consistent ways across individuals by changing their diet. “The complexity of the microbiome kind of belies a single readout of good versus bad. How you even come up with a single good, bad kind of criteria is mystifying to me,” he says.</p>
<p>Professor Tariq Iqbal, a gastroenterology consultant who runs trials into faecal microbiota transplantation in people who have bowel disorders, says that we’re only just beginning to understand to what degree levels of microbes naturally fluctuate in the gut in a healthy person over time. &#8220;At the moment, there is no reason to get your microbiome generally tested,” he says. “We don&#8217;t have good evidence about what a “normal” microbiome looks like. It&#8217;s more complicated than simply saying there are ‘bad’ and ‘good’ bacteria in the gut.”</p>
<p>Current research suggests that there is no “standard” microbiome composition that can be used as a baseline for health. There may also be problems with reading too much from a single sample. According to Guts UK, a digestive disease charity that works closely with the Gut Microbiome for Health Group of the British Society of Gastroenterology, the bacteria found in your stool does not necessarily tell you what microbes are in your gut. Meanwhile, the British Dietetic Association warns: “Commercial gut microbiota testing and lifestyle change programmes based on the test results cannot be advised currently as the science is not at a stage that can support testing and treatments programmes.”</p>
<p>Nor, Dr Guess adds, is there any robust evidence to support the claim that personalising a diet based on the gut microbiome is more effective than generic healthy eating advice for any of the claims being made. In fact, Professor Iqbal says that patients might be unnecessarily worried by what microbiome testing shows. “At the moment, we just do not have enough knowledge to safely and accurately recommend any specific interventions (such as particular changes in diet, and/or particular probiotics) to cause beneficial long-term changes to the composition of the bacteria in the gut,” Guts UK said.</p>
<p>ZOE, however, told us that their data showed members “who follow ZOE advice, including gut booster foods, see an improvement in their gut microbiome score” — the mix of “good” and “bad” microbes. This conclusion is drawn from a ZOE internal survey of 450 members who followed their advice for more than 12 weeks, which also showed 70% have more energy, 85% improved their gut health and others saw improvements in their menopause symptoms. This is all heavily promoted across their website.</p>
<p>These results haven’t been published and they declined to share it with us when we asked, so we are unable to assess what was asked or how the sample was selected. Moreover, as Dr Guess points out, “the data has not been validated or peer-reviewed”. <span style="font-weight: 400;">Neither was there a control group, which would be needed to know whether it was ZOEs’ specific advice, or simply better healthy eating, that was making a difference. </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">When we relayed this to ZOE, they </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">agreed this meant that we could not be sure these were “clinically meaningful results” and told us they were going to be publishing a randomised controlled trial in the future.</span></p>
<p><a name="scientific"></a><br />
<strong>6. How scientific is ZOE?</strong></p>
<p><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-487850" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Dr-Shivani-Misra.jpg" alt="" width="1920" height="1080" /></p>
<p>It is hard not to be blown away by the dizzying array of high-profile journals that feature on ZOE’s website: <em>Nature Medicine</em>, <em>The BMJ</em>, <em>The Lancet</em>, among others. It links to abstracts of papers published in peer-reviewed journals, which on the surface seem to provide proof of the science. At a closer look, however, not all is as it seems.</p>
<p>ZOE places the weight of their programmes&#8217; claims on three main studies with the acronym PREDICT (Personalised Responses to Dietary Composition Trial). They were carried out with scientists from prestigious universities, including Stanford, Harvard and Kings’ College, London. They have not yet all been published.</p>
<p>The studies analyse the results of people making multiple readings about their body and food intake. This has produced a huge dataset: more than 4 million glucose readings so far, for example. These findings are then used to develop models to predict the impact of particular foods on our bodies — all valid areas of study. The researchers have searched for associations between different measurements, such as hunger and types of food eaten.</p>
<p>All of which sounds impressive. Until you realise that these were observational studies, which can only show <em>associations</em> between various data collected, and not causations, as Tim Spector himself has previously noted. For while measuring lots of variables to find patterns can be a useful research technique, it also means you increase the chances of finding coincidences — which puts you at risk of misinterpreting random variation as a meaningful difference. Poor practice in this type of study is known as “data dredging”.</p>
<p>Nor do they answer the key question: is there evidence that the individualised advice generated by the ZOE tests, which is the key market differentiator, does what it claims?</p>
<p>The answer: we don’t know. There have been no trials published exploring whether the “personalised” advice given by ZOE can result in better health outcomes compared with standard diet and lifestyle advice.</p>
<p>And the same holds for menopausal women, the key ZOE demographic targeted by Davina McCall. The first PREDICT study in 2022 compared data in pre, peri and postmenopausal women. According to ZOE: “Women who have been through menopause had, on average, higher blood pressure and blood sugar, a greater risk of developing cardiovascular disease in the next 10 years, worse sleep, and more body fat. Crucially, the team’s analysis found that diet and the bacterial species that were present in women’s guts were at least partially responsible for the changes.”</p>
<p>However, Dr David Nunan, Senior Research Fellow at the Centre for Evidence Based Medicine at the University of Oxford, is sceptical. &#8220;It&#8217;s a cross sectional [observational] study&#8221; he says, &#8220;which means that no claims of causation can be made.&#8221;</p>
<p>The design of the study, in other words, simply isn&#8217;t capable of telling whether any changes in the microbiome are a result of menopausal change. In fact, Dr Nunan says, “when the data for all microbiome species are compared, there is no statistical difference in pre and postmenopausal women. It’s only when you examine a subgroup of species that 8 out of 2,452 show a statistically significant difference.” Moreover, even when this happens, the study has not indicated what this means in real life. In other words, we do not know what impact this has for the ways that women metabolise food.</p>
<p>Yet despite these gaps, ZOE told us that they are “proud” to have recently completed their own randomised controlled trial “with a non-personalised control group versus the ZOE programme”. The full manuscript, they say, is “under preparation”.</p>
<p>According to its critics in the science community, however, even this trial has its design flaws. One group receives the whole ZOE package, the other receives a leaflet with US health advice. But the way it is set up, people will know exactly which group they are in, thereby rendering results less reliable. <span style="font-weight: 400;">A fairer test to assess is its ZOE’s personalised a</span><span style="font-weight: 400;">lgorithm</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> that makes the difference would be for both groups to receive blood monitoring </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">and </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">stool analysis, and </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">what they thought was personalised advice. The only difference should be that one group receives advice based on ZOE’s tests and algorithms, while the other receives</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">advice</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> that looks like it might be &#8220;personalised&#8221; but isn’t</span><span style="font-weight: 400;">.</span></p>
<p>“You have to bear in mind when looking at these studies that they aren’t fully independent,” Professor Banerjee says. “They are marking their own homework. You need external validation and testing to reproduce the results.”</p>
<p>None of this is to say that paying close attention to nutrition is not important. ZOE is only one of hundreds of apps that measure our biometrics in this age of the quantified self. But while keeping abreast of our data might be interesting, are these promises of personalised advice based on sound medicine? And are they, as the website promises, scientifically proven to lead to real-world improvements?</p>
<p>Without this evidence, Zoe is simply collecting our data and then selling it back to us. And not only does this come at a financial cost — it could be making us less healthy.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/we-need-to-talk-about-zoe/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/we-need-to-talk-about-zoe/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/10/we-need-to-talk-about-zoe/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">481727</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Inside Tony Blair Inc.</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/inside-tony-blair-inc/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/inside-tony-blair-inc/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/2023-08-03-unherd-blair-4b.jpg?w=747</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Premium</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Tom McTague]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Tom-McTague-Website.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Blair has created a world in which he remains powerful (Aïda Amer) ]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Tom McTague</strong> is UnHerd&#8217;s <strong>Political Editor.</strong> He is the author of <em>Between the Waves: The Hidden History of a Very British Revolution 1945-2016,</em> due to be published in September 2025</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>TomMcTague</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is UnHerd's <strong>Political Editor.</strong> He is the author of <em>Between the Waves: The Hidden History of a Very British Revolution 1945-2016,</em> due to be published in September 2025]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 06 Aug 2023 23:07:06 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 22 May 2024 13:48:53 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Africa]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[empire]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[interview]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Keir Starmer]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Labour Party]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ldtv]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Premium]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Tony Blair]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[UK]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=481715</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The former PM's new empire is growing]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>I</strong></p>
<p>At the end of every week, Tony Blair receives his “box” to review over the weekend. It is no longer the tatty, old red briefcase of a Prime Minister, but a virtual one accessible from his laptop wherever he is in the world. Yet, the process remains much the same as when he was in Downing Street. Those who work for him must submit their papers before the box is closed for the weekend. Blair will then review the documents and add comments before meeting his team the following week. Only those really close to the former PM can email him papers directly.</p>
<p>Such is the life of Blair in “retirement”. Aged 70, he works with the zeal of a man with something still to prove; something to build; something perhaps to redeem. Constantly travelling, Blair spends as much as 70% of his time abroad: raising funds, attending conferences, giving speeches and networking with world leaders, plutocrats, corporate executives and “thought leaders”. He flies on private jets and is escorted in armed cars with security always close by. This is Blair today: no longer Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, but Prime Minister of Tony Blair Inc.</p>
<p>Formally, he is “executive chairman” of the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change, known to all as the TBI. The institute was born in 2017 and now employs more than 800 people worldwide, some with salaries as high as $504,000 (though Blair does not take one). He has offices in London, New York, San Francisco, Abu Dhabi, Singapore and Accra, and enough money to stage the slickest political conference in Britain. He has a media team to manage his media “grid”, a policy team to shape national debate, and a delivery team to project-manage his priorities across the world.</p>
<p>Working directly for him, Blair has a chief executive who used to work in No. 10, Catherine Rimmer, a global managing director who once worked for Justin Trudeau, Michael McNair, and an executive vice president who sits on the board of Oracle, one of the world’s biggest tech companies, Awo Ablo. His policy unit, meanwhile, is the only think tank in Britain with American levels of funding and a direct line into both the Government and Opposition, not to mention the Commissioners in Brussels and tech titans in San Francisco.</p>
<p>It is this arm of the TBI which has produced policy papers on everything from Brexit to <a href="https://www.institute.global/insights/politics-and-governance/new-national-purpose-ai-promises-world-leading-future-of-britain" target="_blank" rel="noopener">AI</a> to <a href="https://www.institute.global/insights/public-services/pass-time-quantifying-public-health-benefits-covid-pass" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Covid</a>. Its influence is such that cabinet ministers and even prime ministers — including Boris Johnson and Liz Truss — are regularly in touch. Starmer’s agenda as Labour leader now so closely resembles the policy prescriptions put forward by the TBI, whether on the need for a closer relationship with Europe or a new planning regime, that there is talk throughout Westminster of a Blairite <em>reconquista</em>. He has <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07/27/tony-blair-preparing-to-rule-britain-again-starmer-let-him/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">openly</a> offered his institute to help Starmer if he becomes prime minister.</p>
<p>And yet, it is not the policy unit that is the TBI’s driving force, but its consultancy operation. Today, the “government advisory work&#8221; is responsible for almost all of its revenue, bringing in $79.4 million of its $81 million turnover in 2021, according to the latest accounts. In a recent round of internal restructuring, this side of the organisation was prioritised, resulting in a number of policy specialists leaving, including the policy unit’s leading man, Ian Mulheirn. (When we approached the TBI a spokesman insisted policy making had not been “de-prioritised” and remained one of the three pillars of the institute’s work, alongside “strategy and delivery”.)</p>
<div><div style="left: 0; width: 100%; height: 0; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.25%;"><iframe src="//cdn.iframe.ly/api/iframe?url=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2FHX7TlBRvg9I&amp;key=357d953055da7177194e1a84a2d8a5a3&amp;playerjs=1" style="border: 0; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;" allowfullscreen scrolling="no" allow="encrypted-media; accelerometer; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; autoplay"></iframe></div></div>
&nbsp;
<p>The consultancy arm, meanwhile, is expanding rapidly, offering advice to governments around the world on the art of “delivery”. Look at the <a href="https://www.institute.global/who-we-are/careers" target="_blank" rel="noopener">TBI’s recruitment page</a> and there is an extraordinary array of jobs available: four in Abu Dhabi, three in Eastern Europe, two in each of the Philippines, Rwanda, Athens and Côte d’Ivoire, and one each in Israel, Indonesia, Kenya, New York, Nigeria, Senegal, Ghana and Miami. Meanwhile, its offices in London, Singapore and Delhi are all expanding.</p>
<p>The TBI has become, in the words of one figure who knows the institute well, a “McKinsey for world leaders” — a global consultancy business which advises governments on how to govern, while also acting as a middle man between the world’s political and business elites. Astride it all, of course, is Blair himself, the man who decides what the organisation should focus on, who it should help and where it should expand. Like a senior partner in a law firm, Blair brings in the clients, using his connections with the rich and powerful.</p>
<p>It is important to stop for a moment to appreciate just how mould-breaking Blair’s post-premiership life really is for a British politician. When Margaret Thatcher resigned as prime minister, she joined the House of Lords. When John Major left office, he became chairman of a cricket club. Gordon Brown became a UN special envoy, David Cameron took on various chairmanship roles, Theresa May and Liz Truss remained in parliament and Boris Johnson returned to his old life writing newspaper columns. None of them tried to build anything on the scale of Blair’s globe-spanning TBI, a British “Clinton Foundation&#8221; combining philanthropy, business and political influence. Blair has assembled something so big, in fact, that according to one figure close to another former prime minister, he has approached at least one of those who succeeded him in No. 10 to see if they might be interested in working with him.</p>
<p>But the question I keep coming back to is: why?</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>II</strong></p>
<p>At Blair’s Future of Britain conference in July, I watched as he weaved through a packed drinks reception, glass of water in hand, posing for selfies, imparting his wisdom. I hoped to grab a word. But such was the scrum of acolytes and security, I could not get close.</p>
<p>As Blair worked the room, hugging old friends and granting quick audiences to starstruck Labour MPs, it felt like being back in the early 2000s. For many of my generation, Blair will always be a defining politician. For me this is doubly so; I grew up in Sedgefield, his constituency, and knew him, tangentially, through my parents who were both Labour activists. I knew all those who worked for him and, indeed, spent time in his constituency office myself as a wide-eyed work experience kid. Back then, Blair seemed almost the <em>ur-</em>politician, the archetype others copied to win power. To this day, seeing him still feels a little bit like journeying back in time.</p>
<figure id="attachment_481743" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-481743" style="width: 2500px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-481743" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/GettyImages-74117787-1-e1691167095292.jpg" alt="" width="2500" height="1537" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-481743" class="wp-caption-text">Blair leaves Trimdon Labour Club after handing in his resignation as the MP for Sedgfield (Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>I am not the only one who thinks this. One person who worked at TBI, and has since left, compared life inside the institute to the movie <em>Goodbye Lenin</em>  — in which a woman who fell into a coma before the fall of the Berlin Wall is shielded from the truth by her protective son. Blair’s new life, according to some former colleagues, feels like one long prime ministerial cosplay in which everybody must play their part. There is the media grid, the box, the police protection officers, armoured cars, private jets and constant meetings with world leaders and VIPs. Spend a day in the TBI offices in central London and you might see anyone popping in: a leading Indian politician one day, Bill Clinton greeting his old friend with a bear hug the next.</p>
<p>Yet there are plenty of giveaways that time has not stood still: the grey hair; the suede Chelsea boots which are a shade too informal for frontline politics; the Apple Watch poking out from under his jacket. The truth is that Blair is only just emerging from a period of his life when public animosity meant that he rarely ventured out in London and, indeed, felt more comfortable not just out of the city but out of the country itself. Looking back, it is astonishing how quickly his reputation fell after leaving office.</p>
<p>Blair resigned as prime minister in 2007 with high hopes for his new life. He was given a standing ovation as he left the House of Commons for the last time and was immediately confirmed as the new &#8220;Middle East envoy” representing the UN, EU, US and Russia. There was hope he could do for Israel-Palestine what he had done for Northern Ireland. The tides of history, however, were no longer with him. By the time he left the envoy job in 2015, peace in the Middle East was further away than ever.</p>
<p>During this period, the world Blair had tried to build as prime minister seemed to collapse all around him. Soon after the financial crisis, which immediately followed his resignation, Blair lost his bid to become the first permanent president of the European Council, the stain from Iraq just too great. And then his old rival Gordon Brown ordered an independent inquiry into the Iraq War — a trial Blair could neither win nor escape.</p>
<p>This was when he set up the basic structure of his life today, creating a number of charities in the areas of policy he was most interested in: the Tony Blair Sports Foundation in the North East of England; the Tony Blair Faith Foundation which worked across the world; the Tony Blair Africa Governance Initiative focused on development. He also set up &#8220;Tony Blair Associates”, his consultancy business. To begin with, each of these organisations were nominally separate, which meant most of the attention went on the business wing, leaving the impression that he was simply hawking his services among a range of unsavoury governments — from the Kuwaitis to the Kazakhs —  to the highest bidder, his post-premiership life one primarily driven by money-making.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-political-power-of-deano/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-political-power-of-deano/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/GettyImages-1344508003ghj-3-scaled-e1682035503714.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-political-power-of-deano/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-political-power-of-deano/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The political power of Deano</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/04/the-political-power-of-deano/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom McTague</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Fair or not, the fact that Blair was evidently making a lot of money did not sit well with a public who had been thrust into a world of austerity immediately after he left office. He had swiftly taken a well-paid seat on the board of JPMorgan Chase and joined the lucrative speaking circuit. This work brought in enough money to allow him to swap his old constituency home Sedgefield for two multi-million pound properties: one in London and another in the Home Counties. It did not go unnoticed that he seemed to be recreating the life he had in No. 10, only now freed from having to care about public opinion. His Georgian townhouse in London looked just like Downing Street and his country retreat was not only near Chequers, but had the same air of Chilterns grandeur.</p>
<p>Taken together, the money-making nature of his post-Downing Street life almost destroyed Blair’s public image. Even his decision to give away the entire £4.6 million advance for his memoir<em>, A Journey, </em>was dismissed as a publicity stunt.</p>
<p>But then came Jeremy Corbyn, Brexit and Donald Trump — the populist revolt. This was the moment his resurrection really began. Brexit, in particular, replaced Iraq in the public consciousness as <em>the </em>defining political event, with a new set of political villains whom the public could boo and whistle.</p>
<p>This period of political turmoil, according to many I spoke to, shocked Blair into becoming more involved in politics again. Blair took an important step towards rebuilding his public image by merging all his business and charitable interests into one organisation — the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change. From this point on, instead of having a consultancy business and several charities, Blair presided over one giant not-for-profit organisation<em>.</em></p>
<p>In 2017, he set up a unit called “renewing the centre”, recruiting a team of smart, young Anglo-Americans to come up with ideas to save the liberal order, as they saw it. From the beginning, though, there were tensions in the team. Some believed that given Blair’s background as Labour leader, “renewing the centre” meant, in effect, renewing the centre-left, finding new policies that would rebuild the coalition of progressives he had once so successfully amassed. Others, though, saw it differently. For them, “renewing the centre” meant renewing both the centre-left <em>and </em>the centre-right, and even forming an alliance where necessary to defeat their existential enemy: the “populists” who must never be appeased. I was told Blair was firmly in the latter camp.</p>
<p>For some, he was drawing exactly the wrong conclusion, confirming the populist narrative that there was no difference between the traditional parties, and that neither of which would allow any real change to the system. Over the years that followed, some of Blair’s more Left-leaning recruits departed in frustration, believing, as one person put it, that Blair was not really any different from George Osborne when it came to austerity. Others said the tensions in the project ran even deeper.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/why-starmer-should-copy-the-tories/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/why-starmer-should-copy-the-tories/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/GettyImages-1479315085-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/why-starmer-should-copy-the-tories/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/why-starmer-should-copy-the-tories/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Keir Starmer the Conservative</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/05/why-starmer-should-copy-the-tories/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom McTague</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>“It was really fraught,” said one. “We were trying to save democracy — but from Mayfair.” Could the TBI really learn lessons this way? Another simply said: “It was a failure.” At this time, Blair was devoting much of his energy to campaigning for a second referendum — a fight he would eventually lose in December 2019, when Boris Johnson comfortably defeated Corbyn’s Labour with the promise to “Get Brexit Done”. The centre was collapsing.</p>
<p>And yet, from this point of political impotence, Blair’s reputation and influence has recovered. As the pandemic began to spread across Europe the following year, Blair put his policy unit to work. As cases escalated, the TBI released paper after paper on everything from face masks to mass testing and even international vaccine passports, always seemingly one step ahead of the Government. When the country was desperate to be vaccinated, Blair released a paper calling for a delay between the first and second doses to improve efficiency. The Government quickly announced the same plan.</p>
<p>Finally, Blair seemed to be back in touch with the <em>zeitgeist</em>. The pandemic was an ultimate test in apolitical “delivery” — that what matters is what works. He was back. His institute was flying and donations were beginning to pour in from around the world. But under the surface, all was not well.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>III</strong></p>
<p>In his memoir, <em>A Journey, </em>published in 2010, Blair describes how he helps developing countries. First, he hires teams of “highly qualified young people” from “Governments, the World Bank, McKinsey or private banks”. Then, after hiring these bright young things, he sends them out into the world to “build capacity, so that in time the locals can do it”.</p>
<p>Over the past few years, Blair has rapidly expanded his team of consultants. In Africa alone, the TBI is active in Rwanda, Senegal, Nigeria, Mozambique, Togo, Ivory Coast, Malawi, Burkina Faso, Sierra Leone and the Democratic Republic of Congo. Teams of TBI experts sit at the heart of foreign governments, advising on everything from how to improve crop yields to the creation of “presidential delivery units”.</p>
<figure id="attachment_481860" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-481860" style="width: 2278px" class="wp-caption alignnone"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-481860" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/MAP-w-PINS-no-vignette.jpg" alt="" width="2278" height="1281" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-481860" class="wp-caption-text">A map showing where TBI is known to have operated.</figcaption></figure>
<p>A quick look at the description for its &#8220;Country Director Eastern Europe” job gives an indication of the kind of work the institute does. “The Country Director will lead a TBI team embedded in country at the highest level of Government,” the advert reads. One of its key responsibilities is to “build and maintain a relationship of trust with your counterpart (typically President or Prime Minister level)”. In doing so, the candidate must be able to “suggest and convince your counterpart on key development priorities that TBI could be supporting”. What would be the reaction if this was the other way round: if, say, the Clinton Foundation, advertised for a team of people to be embedded in the British government or simply to “suggest and convince” the British prime minister to follow their advice?</p>
<p>Yet the TBI is proud of what its teams have been able to achieve . “In Nigeria, our energy advisor worked on the design and implementation of a mass solar-connection programme called Solar Power Naija that aims to provide electricity access to 25 million Nigerians,” the report states. In another example, the TBI said it “supported the government of Burkina Faso to improve the country’s agriculture and agri-business outcomes”. In doing so, the TBI claims, they helped increase the country’s “fertiliser-blending capacity”.</p>
<p>To the TBI’s critics, this is just the gloss of “<a href="https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v38/n07/david-runciman/deliverology" target="_blank" rel="noopener">deliverology</a>”, the belief that what is really holding a country back is not so much deep structural challenges such as corruption, economic exploitation or colonialism — but bad governance. And this can be fixed. The problem, in other words, is largely technocratic, not political.</p>
<p>Another criticism levelled at Blair is that what he is really doing is advising on how to build a version of the Downing Street he created 20 years ago — right at the very moment the British state has shown itself to be so woefully dysfunctional (something, ironically, Blair also believes).</p>
<p>But it&#8217;s not just cynical Brits who are questioning the effectiveness of the TBI. There are also plenty of raised eyebrows in Africa. In June, Nigeria’s <em>Guardian </em>newspaper published an <a href="https://guardian.ng/opinion/president-tinubu-must-be-wary-of-foreign-do-gooders/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">op-ed</a> by an academic which dismissed Blair as a “self-serving lobbyist… projecting dubious altruistic inclinations”. Nigeria, it said, must not “willingly [offer] itself as a cheap financial rehabilitation home for retired British Prime Ministers”.</p>
<p>In Malawi, there is similar public disquiet. The TBI first arrived in the country in 2012 soon after the former president Joyce Banda came to power. However, after Banda’s government was overwhelmed by an extraordinary corruption scandal known as “Cashgate” — in which it emerged that as much as $250 million had been looted from public funds after a junior civil servant was found with $300,000 in cash in the boot of his car — the TBI left.</p>
<figure id="attachment_481740" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-481740" style="width: 2560px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-481740" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/GettyImages-151010297-scaled.jpg" alt="" width="2560" height="1707" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-481740" class="wp-caption-text">Blair with Joyce Banda, Malawi&#8217;s President, in 2012 (Amos Gumulira/AFP/GettyImages)</figcaption></figure>
<p>It returned to the country, though, in 2020, after Lazarus Chakwera, its new president, took over and asked for help to “strengthen its delivery and implementation mechanisms”. Not everyone in Malawi was happy about it. Charles Kajoloweka, executive director of the human rights and governance watchdog <a href="https://www.yasmw.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Youth and Society</a>, said it was almost impossible to to find out exactly what TBI was doing. William Kambwandira, executive director at the Centre for Social Accountability and Transparency in Malawi, agreed. “Our greatest concern is that government dealings with the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change have been kept under wraps.” In a statement, the TBI said the “sole purpose” of its work was “to ensure the government is delivering on its commitments to improve the public services it provides to its people.”</p>
<p>Such criticisms get to the heart of why some are sceptical about the TBI’s <em>modus operandi</em>. The TBI offers technocratic support based on a technocratic assessment of development, but it does so to <em>political </em>leaders often based on personal relationships with Blair himself.</p>
<p>The former Malawian president Banda explained how her relationship with Blair worked. “When I ascended to power, he and his wife Cherie flew over to Malawi within one week of my presidency,” she told <em>UnHerd</em>. “When he came over, during a state banquet hosted in his honour, I had a conversation with him where I personally requested [support] and he offered to send over three of his staffers to help me, due to the fact that I had assumed the presidency abruptly. I remember that is when he told me about his global programme and offered to lend me a hand. I remember what he said: ‘I have several people working in the region and I will shift them around.’” As Banda put it: “There was no formal agreement or big ceremony because he was just helping a friend.”</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>IV</strong></p>
<p>In April 2022, Blair needed someone to manage the TBI’s vast, global consultancy. He hired Mike McNair from McKinsey, a Canadian who had worked for years as Justin Trudeau’s policy chief in Ottawa. Since arriving, McNair has overseen a rapid expansion of the organisation.</p>
<p>The nature of this expansion, however, raises questions about the TBI’s future and how it is funded. There has been a push from the TBI to access philanthropic donations and to create partnerships with business. One relationship in particular jumps out from the TBI accounts: that with the tech billionaire, Larry Ellison, and his company Oracle.</p>
<figure id="attachment_481742" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-481742" style="width: 1718px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-481742" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/G6D8DM.jpg" alt="" width="1718" height="1207" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-481742" class="wp-caption-text">Blair entertains Larry Ellison at Downing Street in 2003 (Alamy)</figcaption></figure>
<p>Ellison, 78, is currently thought to be the world’s fourth richest man, with an estimated fortune of $140 billion. Like many tech billionaires, he has cultivated a reputation as something of an iconoclastic sage, a workaholic visionary who can see the future more clearly than others — and, importantly, deliver it. Like his friend Elon Musk, Ellison is known for his almost impish impatience, his mind moving from one <em>grand projet </em>to the next, often making grand claims about their revolutionary potential only to move on to something else soon after. “I am a sprinter,” Ellison once remarked. “I rest, I sprint, I rest, I sprint again.”</p>
<p>It should not have been a great surprise, then, when in 2020 Ellison announced that he was suddenly <a href="https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/9/2/21409530/larry-ellison-foundation-disband-london-philanthropy-coronavirus" target="_blank" rel="noopener">disbanding his entire team</a> at the Larry Ellison Foundation in London. The unit was led by Matthew Symonds, the former <em>Economist</em> journalist (and father of Carrie Johnson) who wrote an “intimate” authorised biography of Ellison, published in 2003. When I rang Symonds, he immediately hung up.</p>
<p>Ellison’s decision to close his London operation came at the height of the pandemic, announcing that he wanted to focus all his charitable energies on “medical philanthropy”. In many ways, this made perfect sense. Ellison bankrolls the Ellison Institute for Transformative Medicine, focused on trying to find cures for cancer.</p>
<p>At around the same time, Ellison began deepening his relationship with Blair. In partnership with the TBI, Ellison’s Institute for Transformative Medicine created a “Global Health Security Consortium” with scientists at Oxford University to provide “support for leaders around the world to help them prepare for the health-security challenges of tomorrow”. Ellison also began giving more and more money to the TBI. In 2019, the Larry Ellison Foundation gave the TBI $10 million with a further $20 million committed. By 2021, this had risen to $33 million, with plans for future donations of a further $49 million.</p>
<p>At some point, Blair was evidently able to convince Ellison that the TBI’s methods were a more effective way to make the world a better place than his previous efforts. And the partnership between the two does have a certain logic. Blair believes that &#8220;the power of technology” must be harnessed by bringing together politicians and &#8220;innovators”. This, then, is one of the central purposes of the TBI as Blair sees it: to act as a matchmaker for plutocrats such as Ellison and political figures such as himself. But it is an approach that raises awkward questions about power and transparency.</p>
<p>Alongside the Global Health Security Consortium, the two of them have also created a “Tech for Development” programme. The idea is to help developing countries build “comprehensive digital infrastructure”. Together, Blair and Ellison have rolled this out in Ghana, Rwanda and Senegal for free, with a view to building electronic health records so that governments know who is vaccinated and who isn’t.</p>
<p>Not everyone, however, looks so kindly upon the partnership. Ellison, after all, is a divisive figure. To some, he is an intense visionary in the same mould as Musk, with the same intense desire to conquer all in business. As Symonds writes in his biography, Ellison has an “unquenchable optimism and almost messianic self belief”. And he is not shy about it. During the pandemic, Ellison offered his medical research facilities to President Trump free of charge. He has bought an island in Hawaii which he uses as both an ultra-exclusive resort for the rich <em>and </em>a living agricultural experiment, part of his grand plan to secure global food supplies. Even as he approaches his 80th birthday, he is still dreaming of his next great breakthrough as well as his legacy. Perhaps that’s why, last year, he made one of the biggest gambles of his career.</p>
<div class="ad-insert-events"></div>
<p>In June 2022, Ellison bought the electronic health record company Cerner for almost $30 billion. It was the largest buy-out of his life. Almost immediately after the purchase, Ellison announced that it would help him realise his <a href="https://diginomica.com/doctor-doctor-larry-ellisons-prescription-oracle-led-healthcare-revolution-0" target="_blank" rel="noopener">aim</a> of building a single <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-06-09/oracle-s-ellison-pitches-national-health-database-on-cerner-deal?in_source=embedded-checkout-banner" target="_blank" rel="noopener">national database for health records</a>. The plan was <a href="https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/health-tech/oracle-cerner-plan-build-national-medical-records-database-ellison-pitches-bold-vision" target="_blank" rel="noopener">endorsed by Blair</a>. His hope is that, using Oracle technology, every American will be able to store their medical data online. It is a visionary move, which, if it pays off, would make Oracle the Amazon of health records. To some, the partnership with the TBI makes good philanthropic <em>and</em> commercial sense: if Oracle can show that digital health records work in Africa, why not elsewhere? And by partnering with the TBI, Oracle gains access to parts of the world it might not have been able to reach before.</p>
<p>The problem is that such a scheme to create a single national health record database is not only incredibly complex and hard to deliver, but extremely contentious. In fact, the main objection is not technocratic, but political — even moral. Do we want every health record to be stored on a cloud run by one corporation? Oracle is already facing a <a href="https://techmonitor.ai/policy/privacy-and-data-protection/oracle-privacy-lawsuit-court-case" target="_blank" rel="noopener">lawsuit</a> in the US over claims it has unlawfully collected information on 5 billion people.</p>
<figure id="attachment_481834" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-481834" style="width: 2500px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-481834" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/GettyImages-456303498-1.jpg" alt="" width="2500" height="1541" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-481834" class="wp-caption-text">Larry Ellison at the 2014 Oracle Open World Conference in San Francisco (Kimberly White/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>Whether you see the partnership between Blair and Ellison charitably or otherwise, it reveals an important reality about today’s world and the way power works in practice. Blair and Ellison operate in a sphere of hyper-connected individuals (one board member, for instance, is Baroness Rona Fairhead, Boris Johnson’s former minister for trade and export promotion). They talk and meet each other regularly, making important decisions that affect the lives of many people, in ways which are far harder to scrutinise than those taken by governments and political leaders.</p>
<p>Others I spoke to said it is not possible to judge Blair’s enthusiasm for this technology without acknowledging the fact that his institute is partially dependent on donations from a tech billionaire. Some of those who have previously worked closely with Blair went further, arguing that the conflicts of interests within Blair’s new life go even deeper, extending into the heart of the organisation itself. One arm of the TBI might be writing papers on how to protect the international liberal order, for instance, while the consulting arm is embedded with illiberal governments who pose a challenge to that very same order.</p>
<p>Rather than hide this, the TBI actively advertises its partnerships with business, arguing that the “partnerships” it has built up, alongside the donations it receives, allow it to do “the great bulk” of its consultancy work at no cost to governments. When it comes to tricky questions such as patient privacy, Blair is adamant that they do not undermine the transformative potential of technology. In Malawi, for example, the TBI boasts of its partnership with Musk’s “<a href="https://twitter.com/InstituteGC/status/1661035507705581569" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Starlink</a>” internet service, which helped hundreds of thousands of people left homeless by a cyclone. Blair’s entire vision today is for governments to become more effective by linking the kind of strategy, delivery and policy units he had in No. 10 with the kind of technology that was not available to him. Just as he wanted to introduce ID cards back then, he now supports <em>digital</em> ID cards today, as well as vaccine passports and vast new health databases to tackle the spread of disease. As Blair sees it, his partnership with Oracle is just pragmatic policymaking.</p>
<p>But like Ellison, Blair is something of a utopian futurist. He believes, almost as a faith, in the power of technology. Blair is a good boss, according to many I spoke to, because he is always so upbeat and energetic, but when it comes to technology he is a little too “naive” about its possibilities. Another former employee suggests he is “fatalist” about technology in the same way he was fatalist about globalisation — not thinking critically enough about its risks and political consequences. The greatest irony, though, is that such wide-eyed belief in technology now feels almost old-fashioned. To a younger generation who grew up in a world dominated by Big Tech and Big Pharma, the dominance of giant corporations run by tech plutocrats feels less utopian than <em>dystopian</em>.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>V</strong></p>
<p>When Blair left office, he consoled himself with the thought that his life was not over. As he wrote in <em>A Journey, </em>he’d always had a bigger passion than politics: religion. Religion gave him purpose. “There is so much frailty still to overcome,” he concluded in his memoir. “But in overcoming it lies the meaning of life.”</p>
<p>But what are these frailties Blair must overcome? According to Catholic teaching, &#8220;sins of frailty&#8221; are minor acts committed through “indecision, weakness, lack of vigilance or courage”. Those who have previously worked closely with him see a bit of all these in Blair. Some believe he too often shies away from conflict, even today. In No. 10, he outsourced being the bad guy to Alastair Campbell and did not confront and demote Gordon Brown soon enough, which undermined his premiership. Some believe Blair is now shying away from confronting Starmer, a man he believes will become prime minister, but, according to a number of people I spoke to, not a sufficiently reforming one. Even as Blair battled to save centrism, he was careful not to burn bridges with the Trump or Johnson governments, or indeed any of the illiberal governments he works with.</p>
<figure id="attachment_481833" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-481833" style="width: 2500px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="size-full wp-image-481833" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/GettyImages-682198802-1.jpg" alt="" width="2500" height="1567" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-481833" class="wp-caption-text">&#8216;There is so much frailty still to overcome.&#8217; (Charles McQuillan/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure>
<p>Is this is a sign of indecisiveness? It is striking that even those who most like and respect him are unclear what exactly he wants from the TBI. Does he really want it to be the McKinsey for world leaders? Or a think tank? And for what purpose exactly? To Blair, this type of thinking is overly reductive. To have a political impact you must have policies <em>and </em>the ability to implement them. But it is also for this reason that there is what one former employee described as a certain whimsy to the TBI — an organisation less committed to the service of an abstract goal than to the aspirations of Blair himself. If Tony wants something, it happens; if he wants to help someone he helps them.</p>
<p>The more I studied him, the more I wondered whether his biggest frailty of all is simply the desire to remain relevant, the frailty that J.D. Salinger once described as, “not having the courage to be an absolute nobody”. Blair was a somebody once and it is very difficult to give that up. He had power to do things and he still wants to do things — and so he needs power. But to get power you need money and connections and ideas and people. And he now has all those things in droves.</p>
<p>This is the reason he continues to work as hard as he does, taking his box home at weekends, raising money, flying around the world, attending conferences. Maintaining the network becomes an intrinsic goal in itself. This helps explain why Blair takes meetings with world leaders and works for countries many would avoid. He has what one person described as a deep, primal need to be “connected”.</p>
<p>Today, Blair lives the life of a prime minister, but with the freedom to shake off the petty realities of government, working on campaigns to help American governors one moment, flying in to help embattled African leaders the next; all while working on grand plans to change the world with exciting, utopian tech bros in California.</p>
<p>But how much of this is actually real? “Do governments really want his strategic advice,” one person who knows Blair put it to me, “or his phone number?” Do those companies he has partnered with really have only altruistic intentions? And do political leaders really only work with him to make their governments more effective? The truth, I suspect, lies somewhere in the ambiguous soup of human motivation; in the flawed, frail characters of ordinary human beings with conflicting aspirations, trying to do good in the world <em>and</em> for themselves.</p>
<p>​​Blair today is more influential than any other former prime minister: he has built an empire that connects business to power and himself to everyone. In the 15 years since he left office, Blair has created a world in which he might not be prime minister but he remains powerful. And that is the point. The power is the point.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><em>Additional reporting: Jack McBrams</em></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/inside-tony-blair-inc/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/inside-tony-blair-inc/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2023/08/inside-tony-blair-inc/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">481586</post-id>				</item>
						</channel>
</rss>
