<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	xmlns:unherd="https://www.unherd.com"
	>

	<channel>
		<title>The Transgender Issue - UnHerd</title>
		<atom:link href="https://stage.unherd.com/tag/the-transgender-issue/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
		<link>https://stage.unherd.com/tag/the-transgender-issue/</link>
		<description>think again</description>
		<lastBuildDate>Tue, 10 Jun 2025 08:42:56 +0000</lastBuildDate>
		<language>en-US</language>
		<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
		<sy:updateFrequency>12</sy:updateFrequency>
		<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4</generator>

 
<site xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">241382538</site>				<item>
					<title>The troubling trends in gender surgery</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/the-troubling-trends-in-gender-surgery/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/the-troubling-trends-in-gender-surgery/?edition=us#respond</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/GettyImages-1052957408-e1749402448544.jpg?w=580</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>American medicine</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Karla Solheim]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Blue-16-2.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['The trans patients who came to me had more and more mental health complications.' Drew Angerer/Getty Images.]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Karla Solheim</strong> is an Ob/Gyn living in a small city in Iowa.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle></unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an Ob/Gyn living in a small city in Iowa.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 08 Jun 2025 23:00:10 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 10 Jun 2025 08:42:56 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[detransition]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[LGBT]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Tavistock Clinic]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The Transgender Issue]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://stage.unherd.com/?p=682818</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[I’ve seen a change in my patients]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>I performed my first gender-affirming hysterectomy with pride. It was 2019, and I was delighted to be my local LGBT clinic’s official gynecologist. There is, after all, no greater joy in medicine than providing great care to a vulnerable, under-served community in Iowa. This was, I felt, how the world should be.</p>
<p>Six years later, I’m not so sure.</p>
<p>The hysterectomies went well. They were uncomplicated, and no one told me they regretted their surgery. But even though we were earnest, well-meaning clinicians, were we doing the right thing?</p>
<p>In 2019, I took a job as an Obs and Gyn doctor at a nonprofit in Iowa, after my private practice went out of business. I had a wife, twins in preschool, and a toddler. And, after working for a Catholic organization previously, I loved the progressive policies of my new employer. They provided medical transition services for transgender patients and even sponsored an out-of-hours LGBT clinic for patients who might not have felt comfortable in a mainstream doctor’s office. I was at the clinic, enthusiastically, once a month to provide my expertise.</p>
<p>I was quite surprised, though, that the clinic seemed almost exclusively T, without much LGB. Call me naive, but for the past decade, I had my head down: training, getting married, having kids and starting my practice. And by the time I looked up, the LGBT world was very different from the last time I had really been around other gay people.</p>
<p>I also had some uncomfortable questions: hadn’t we learned in medical school that most pediatric gender dysphoria resolves by adulthood? If so, did it make sense for young adolescents to transition to the opposite sex? Was it really plausible that transgender female athletes didn’t have a biological advantage over natal females? The accepted answers seemed counterintuitive to me. Nonetheless, I was on board, assuming that the experts who crafted medical society guidelines around gender medicine had followed the usual process, carefully weighing the evidence, and had reached a scientifically based consensus before making their recommendations regarding gender medicine.</p>
<p>And so, for a few years, I became the go-to gynecologist for gender-affirming hysterectomy referrals and other gynecology care for transgender patients. Although this was a very small part of my practice as a full-scope Ob/Gyn in a rural underserved area, I loved it. I enjoyed taking care of my patients. Some would drive hundreds of miles from their homes elsewhere in rural Iowa to receive their care with us. I was, I felt, providing a much-needed service. The patients came in knowing exactly what they wanted: a hysterectomy. Unlike hysterectomies for abnormal bleeding or pelvic pain which require full diagnostic tests, there was no need to document prior attempts at treatment, failures, and impact on the patient’s life. “Gender dysphoria” always got approved (with the requisite two letters, one from a mental health professional and one from a PCP). Unless they had a major contraindication, such as uncontrolled diabetes, we could just book them in.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-gender-vibe-shift-and-its-discontents/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-gender-vibe-shift-and-its-discontents/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Screenshot-2025-03-05-at-3.34.27 PM.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-gender-vibe-shift-and-its-discontents/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-gender-vibe-shift-and-its-discontents/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The gender vibe shift and its discontents</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/03/the-gender-vibe-shift-and-its-discontents/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Valerie Stivers</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Of course, I counseled my patients. Would they like their ovaries conserved or removed? I was adept at discussing the risks and benefits of both approaches. I offered referrals for egg freezing if they desired oophorectomy. I discussed surgical risks and expected recovery. But these surgeries were still, I would joke to my assistant, “my easiest consult of the day”.</p>
<p>But as the years went by, I couldn’t help but notice some troubling trends. The trans patients who came to me had more and more mental health complications. I also started seeing a fair percentage of them who were really quite feminine — not very different in their gender presentation from my biologically female patients.</p>
<p>Then came the see patients who truly stymied me. One who particularly struck me was just 21 years old, born a female but who now identified as nonbinary. They requested a hysterectomy to conform to what they saw as their gender identity, but otherwise did not desire transmasculine medicalization such as testosterone or mastectomy, and had classically feminine mannerisms and dress.</p>
<p>I began to feel more uneasy that hysterectomy — surgery that carries numerous surgical risks, and results in irrevocable lifelong infertility — was necessarily the right thing for this new group of trans patients. But if they didn’t have any contraindications per se, I couldn’t really say no. After all, <a href="https://www.acog.org/clinical/clinical-guidance/committee-opinion/articles/2021/03/health-care-for-transgender-and-gender-diverse-individuals" target="_blank" rel="noopener">according</a> to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, a hysterectomy is “medically necessary for patients with gender dysphoria who desire this procedure”.</p>
<p>I thought the World Professional Association for Transgender Health <a href="https://wpath.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">(WPATH)</a> guidelines might help my dilemma. But as I puzzled over the “nonbinary” section, I found no clarity. The guidelines said that “motivations for accessing (or not accessing) gender-affirming medical interventions, including hormone treatment, surgeries, or both are heterogeneous and potentially complex and should be explored collaboratively before making decisions about physical interventions”. Though that seemed like solid advice, I did not feel particularly well equipped to do so as a surgeon, rather than a mental health professional.</p>
<p>Still wondering how best to take care of my patients, I went on a private online forum for O&amp;G doctors to ask about how others addressed nonbinary individuals who requested gender affirming hysterectomy. I was told my question was “transphobic”. I was told that the surgery was “life saving” (presumably due to the suicidality brought on by the presence of one’s natal uterus).</p>
<p>This didn’t sit well with me. I wondered about one of my patients, who had detransitioned just a few years after her hysterectomy. Conventional wisdom said detransition almost never happened; that the rate was just 1%. Well, I certainly hadn’t done a hundred hysterectomies for gender affirmation. So what was going on here?</p>
<p>Curious as to whether detransitioning was more common than we thought, I found my way to Hannah Barnes’s excellent book, <em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_to_Think_(book)" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Time to Think</a></em>, which detailed the scandal at Britain’s national youth gender medicine clinic, the Tavistock Center. Barnes found that distressed adolescent girls with no longstanding history of gender dysphoria were requesting to become boys at skyrocketing rates and being prescribed puberty blockers and testosterone with very little medical or psychiatric evaluation, while any adults raising concerns were labelled “transphobic”.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Any adults raising concerns were labelled &#8216;transphobic'&#8221;</div>
<p>Similarly, through reading <a href="https://jessesingal.substack.com/p/maybe-its-a-bad-idea-to-give-a-bunch?utm_source=publication-search" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Jesse Singal’s work on the scientific basis of youth gender medicine</a>, I learned about the relatively flimsy evidence it is built on. Certainly, there have been studies that seem to show <a href="https://substack.com/home/post/p-157984072" target="_blank" rel="noopener">favorable short-term mental health outcomes for youth who access gender medicine</a>. But there have also been scandals about burying the outcomes of major studies at <a href="https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/06/27/research-into-trans-medicine-has-been-manipulated" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Johns Hopkins</a> and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/23/science/puberty-blockers-olson-kennedy.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Children’s Hospital of Los Angeles</a>. It seems nobody has published a long-term study on how these young people are doing. In fact, the Tavistock in London, which was forced to close, <a href="https://www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/no-one-kept-data-on-tavistock-children-its-a-monumental-scandal-z766jbmvm" target="_blank" rel="noopener">failed to retain or share data</a> on thousands of children. It seems that nobody knows the true rates of detransition for young people, but according to the most credible expert in the field, Dr Kinnon MacKinnon, who is himself an openly transgender man, “<a href="https://substack.com/home/post/p-161457143" target="_blank" rel="noopener">it is very unlikely to be only 1%</a>”.</p>
<p>I was surprised that in America there were no specific requirements for the psychological evaluation of young adolescents before it was agreed that they were ready to start transitioning. WPATH guidelines say that the young person should have demonstrated “a marked incongruence between one’s experienced/expressed gender and assigned gender, of at least six months’ duration”, but in practice, <a href="https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/12/06/americas-best-known-practitioner-of-youth-gender-medicine-is-being-sued" target="_blank" rel="noopener">even this minimum requirement has not consistently been followed</a>. Even the minimum standard of a basic mental health evaluation of the patient, as advised, is controversial. Dr Johanna Olson-Kennedy, president-elect of the US division of WPATH, has been an outspoken advocate of the “informed consent” model, <a href="https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/article-abstract/2504256?redirect=true" target="_blank" rel="noopener">deeming the requirement of any psychological evaluation prior to starting a medical transition to be excessive gatekeeping</a>.</p>
<p>And while things are changing in Britain, where puberty blockers are no longer allowed for under-18s, there are many youth gender clinics in America which routinely <a href="https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-transyouth-care/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">provide prescriptions for puberty blockers or hormones at patients’ first appointments</a>, even when a patient does not have a longstanding history of gender dysphoria since early childhood.</p>
<p>I also discovered an emerging population of detransitioners, individuals who took steps to medically transition and who have now reverted to their natal gender identity. Although some do not regret the changes they made to their bodies, others are profoundly distressed by them and have serious and credible critiques of the gender medicine system as it stands.</p>
<p>I had just assumed the experts crafting guidelines were ensuring that there was a body of evidence supporting the incontrovertible long-term benefits for these extraordinary treatments that were being performed on young people: puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and double mastectomy.</p>
<p>However, since there was no unbiased scientific organization of experts on transgender issues, American medical organizations relied on WPATH to guide them. Why wouldn’t they? As upstanding evidence-based scientific organizations, they generously assumed their counterparts were the same. But the holes in the evidence behind WPATH’s official standards of care become more obvious, suggesting that these organizations can rely only on themselves to evaluate the evidence. Interestingly enough, the American Society of Plastic Surgeons conducted its own review of the evidence, and, contrary to the interests of its own members, concluded that <a href="https://www.plasticsurgery.org/for-medical-professionals/publications/psn-extra/news/asps-statement-to-press-regarding-gender-surgery-for-adolescents" target="_blank" rel="noopener">gender affirming mastectomy for minors is not ready to be rolled out.</a></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/can-the-cass-report-really-be-enforced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/can-the-cass-report-really-be-enforced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/download-10.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/can-the-cass-report-really-be-enforced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/can-the-cass-report-really-be-enforced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Can the Cass Report really be enforced?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2024/04/can-the-cass-report-really-be-enforced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Dr Anna Hutchinson</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Let me be clear. I understand that the profound psychological pain of gender dysphoria is real. And many adults have found happiness after medical transition. But what isn’t clear is whether medical transition for adolescents still developing their identities is the solution that many hope it is. A 2024 study from Finland — a <a href="https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2024-03-20/why-finland-is-the-worlds-happiest-country" target="_blank" rel="noopener">progressive nation</a>, with a strong social safety net and a tradition of women’s rights — found that <a href="https://mentalhealth.bmj.com/content/27/1/e300940" target="_blank" rel="noopener">medical transition in gender dysphoric adolescents did not decrease the risk of suicide</a>.</p>
<p>After all, is it really credible that gender dysphoric adolescents, who we know have existed across societies for millennia, have recently become distraught to the point of widespread suicide because they could not access puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, or mastectomies — none of which was available anywhere in the world until the first youth gender medicine clinic opened in the Netherlands in the Nineties? This is a serious claim. If it were true, of course, medical and surgical transition should be available to any gender dysphoric adolescent who desired it. But the evidence that medical transition itself — rather than the compassion and acceptance the patients find in a youth gender clinic — prevents suicide, is truly scanty.</p>
<p>In medicine, sometimes we get ahead of ourselves. New treatments which seem so promising at first don’t always work. The widespread prescription of oxycodone as a panacea for chronic pain in the 2000s is a good example. The doctors who prescribed it wanted to help their patients, but just didn’t realize the real harms caused by oxycodone until they became common enough to see.</p>
<p>I’d like to believe that we are people of science who realize when it is time to course correct. On gender medicine, the time is now.</p>
<p>It is time for experts in our professional organizations need to make evidence-based recommendations for standards of care. We need to seriously ask ourselves what the safest, least harmful interventions are in youth gender medicine, and hold these interventions to rigorous, data-driven standards. It may be reasonable at this juncture to halt new medical and surgical treatments for minors (puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and mastectomies and other surgeries) outside of well-designed, lengthy clinical trials. It is time to provide resources within the institutions of mainstream medicine for people who seek detransition care.</p>
<p>And to question whether “gender dysphoria” as an indication in and of itself for hysterectomy, without abnormal bleeding, pain, or any other diagnosis, should continue to bypass all of the checks and balances in our healthcare system for major surgery. My fellow gynecologists, if we are people of science who know right from wrong and care about our patients, we can surely find the courage to do this.</p>
<p><em>This is an edited version of a piece first published on <a class="pencraft pc-reset color-secondary-ls1g8s line-height-20-t4M0El font-meta-MWBumP size-11-NuY2Zx weight-medium-fw81nC transform-uppercase-yKDgcq decoration-hover-underline-ClDVRM reset-IxiVJZ meta-EgzBVA" href="https://karlasolheim.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">The Ob/Gyn Power Project</a>.</em></p>
<div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-flexDirection-column pc-gap-8 pc-alignItems-flex-start pc-reset"></div>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/the-troubling-trends-in-gender-surgery/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/the-troubling-trends-in-gender-surgery/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2025/06/the-troubling-trends-in-gender-surgery/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">682818</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Why I stopped being a good girl</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Doc-20-Feb-2022-10.19.jpg?w=622</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Hadley Freeman]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Hadley-blue.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[  ]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Hadley Freeman </strong>is a staff writer at <em>The Sunday Times</em>. Her latest book, <em>Good Girls: A Story and Study of Anorexia</em>, was published in 2023.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>HadleyFreeman</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is a staff writer at <em>The Sunday Times</em>. Her latest book, <em>Good Girls: A Story and Study of Anorexia</em>, was published in 2023.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 22 Feb 2022 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 14 Dec 2022 18:30:24 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Dawn Butler]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Don't miss]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Gender ideology]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[JK Rowling]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Kathleen Stock]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Keir Starmer]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Maria Miller]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Mumsnet]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The Transgender Issue]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[TikTok]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=360543</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Women can no longer afford to sit out the gender wars]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>I was always a good girl, by which I mean a people pleaser, because that is what being a good girl is. I enjoyed the benefits that such a personality brings (straight As at school, a close relationship with my parents, a decent job) and endured the usual downsides (teenage anorexia, frequent bouts of insomnia, lifelong anxiety). I had what a therapist later described as “total conflict avoidance”, which is a therapy way of saying I would rather eat my hair than argue with someone.</p>
<p>For example, when I was 10, I wore a Santa jumper to school. “You can’t wear Santa, you’re Jewish! Do you believe Jesus was born on Christmas?” a girl in my class said to me. I didn’t really know what she was talking about, but I knew what she wanted me to say, so I said it: “Yes, Jesus was born on Christmas.” She walked away, satisfied, and I felt a little like I’d given something away, but I was mainly relieved I’d avoided an argument.</p>
<p>And that’s how things continued for me, until 2014, when everything changed.</p>
<div class="ad-insert"></div>
<p>I was reading the <em>New Yorker</em> one evening and came across an article with the headline “<a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/08/04/woman-2" target="_blank" rel="noopener">What is a Woman?</a>”. It was, according to the standfirst, about “the dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism”, a subject about which I knew nothing. I read it, vaguely interested in the social shift that meant being “transgender” no longer refers to someone who has undergone a sex change operation, but is now “how someone sees themselves”, as the writer Michelle Goldberg put it. This meant, Goldberg continued, that women-only spaces were increasingly changing to women-and-transwomen spaces, even if those transwomen still had male bodies — and to query this risked accusations of bigotry.</p>
<p>What really interested me was how quickly institutions were falling into line with this new ideology: venues cancelled talks if a radical feminist was on the bill; all-female bands pulled out of women-only festivals for fear of looking transphobic. How strange, I thought, that those with authority capitulate to the obviously misogynistic demands of a few extreme voices. Oh well, that’s just America — obviously it will never happen in the UK.</p>
<p>Oh, the innocence of eight years ago! Today, gender ideology — the belief that who a person feels they are is more important than the material reality of their body — is firmly in the ascendent. Activists like to claim that the only people who have a problem with this are “Right-wing bigots”, because it keeps things simple to suggest that this is a good (gender ideology) versus bad (Right-wing bigots) issue.</p>
<p>Yet I know a lot of non-Right-wing, non-bigots who are extremely angry at how things have shifted. My friendship group consists mainly of thirty-something to fifty-something progressive women, all, like me, lifelong Labour, or Liberal Democrat, or Green voters, all teachers, or civil servants, or writers, or lawyers. Most are not on Twitter, or TikTok, or any Mumsnet message boards. But when we meet up these days, they talk about Lia Thomas, the Ivy League swimmer who recently transitioned and is allowed to compete against female swimmers and is duly smashing women’s swimming records.</p>
<p>They talk about JK Rowling, vilified for saying that women — not people — menstruate and calling for single-sex spaces to be preserved. They talk about Kathleen Stock, a philosophy professor, who had to leave her job at Sussex University due to ongoing harassment from gender activists. They talk about political parties which explicitly describe women’s sex-based rights as transphobic, including the Green Party and the SNP. They talk about politicians who say things so stupid about gender it’s impossible to believe that they truly believe what they are saying, from Dawn Butler’s claim that “a child is born without a sex”, to Layla Moran’s insistence that she doesn’t care about a person’s sex because she can see “their soul”, to Keir Starmer’s stammering insistence that it’s wrong to say “only women have a cervix”.</p>
<p>You can — and many do — dismiss these angry women as irrelevant middle-aged mums, or just a bunch of Karens, but they do not fit into the “Right-wing bigot” pigeonhole, however much gender ideologues try to squash them in. As a result, many on the Left would prefer that this debate about gender, with older feminists on one side and gender ideologues on the other, was not happening at all, because it doesn’t fit into the good versus bad dichotomy with which the Left frames the world. So they tell themselves that this is a “niche” issue and “normal women” (ie, women not on Twitter or Mumsnet) don’t know or care about it.</p>
<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us?=refinnar"><div class="ref-ar"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Doc-20-Feb-2022-10.19.jpg?w=300" /><div class="content"><span class="meta">Suggested watching</span><h5>Why I stopped being a good girl</h5><p class="author"><span>By</span> Sally Chatterton</p></div></div></a>
<p>Let me disabuse them of both of those notions: they do and they do. The threats, the abuse, the no-platforming of gender-critical feminists: despite the activists’ best efforts to make all of this vanish, none of it has worked. This is the issue that readers and friends want most to talk to me about, albeit only, they say, with no small amount of frustration, in private.</p>
<p>It did not – and I cannot stress this enough – have to be this way. In 2016, Maria Miller, then the chair of the women and equalities committee, produced a report that suggested switching gender should just be a matter of “self-identification”. This statutory declaration would replace the previous gender recognition process, which involved living in one’s chosen gender for two years, being diagnosed with gender dysphoria and being questioned by a panel.</p>
<p>Yet it is a pretty basic fact that male bodies are bigger and stronger than female ones, which is why sex-based rights exist in the first place. So how, I wondered, would self-ID work in practice? Would a person born male now be able to compete against women in sport, or be incarcerated with female prisoners? I assumed the government had thought about this. I assumed wrongly.</p>
<p>In a 2017 interview with <em><a href="https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/how-do-you-solve-a-problem-like-men-in-women-s-changing-rooms-maria-v3hhxmk3p">The Times</a></em>, Miller was unable to answer the most basic questions about how her proposals would affect women, which seemed weird to me, because surely you’d think about women when massively overhauling women’s rights? If Miller had given this even a moment’s thought, and acknowledged that women and transgender people’s rights needed to be balanced, rather than selling out the former to appease gender ideologues, it seems highly likely to me that the debate would never have become as fraught as it is. Anyway, after four years of anguished discussions, Miller’s reforms got kicked into the long grass in 2020, although they are still scheduled to go forward in Scotland, backed by the SNP and Greens.</p>
<p>Many transgender people have said how much they have hated being the subjects of political and online debate over the past five or so years, and who can blame them? Yet this issue is not just about them. Debates about gender rights are also debates about women’s rights, because activists are asking, essentially, for the abolition of women’s sex-based rights. This made and makes no sense to me, not because I think that trans women are terrible people, but because women’s sex-based rights exist for a reason.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/raquel-rosario-sanchez-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/raquel-rosario-sanchez-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/rrs.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/raquel-rosario-sanchez-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/raquel-rosario-sanchez-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Raquel Rosario Sánchez won&#039;t be silenced</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/raquel-rosario-sanchez-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Joan Smith</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>I started having tentative discussions about this with other progressive journalists, but I was invariably the only one at the table who believed (or was willing to say out loud) that there is a clear clash between gender-based rights and women’s rights. When I said to one journalist that women need women-only spaces, he replied, “So you’re defending segregation?” Another time, when I said it was ridiculous to make prisons mixed-sex, someone I consider a friend said, “You sound like a homophobe in the Eighties saying you wouldn’t let your kids have a gay teacher.” Someone else told me I sounded like a “bigoted radical feminist” and I thought, “I used to be a deputy fashion editor, so if I’m now radical then the Left really is in trouble.” Another one said that by arguing for women’s sex-based rights I was beating down on “the most oppressed minority in Britain”, i.e., transgender people.</p>
<p>I have no doubt that transgender people suffer horrific bigotry in this country and everywhere. But when I found the <a href="https://www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-how-many-trans-people-murdered-uk">statistics</a> showed one trans person is tragically, killed a year in the UK, but two women are killed a week in England and Wales, I was accused of engaging in “the victim Olympics”. People who claimed to care ever so deeply about women’s physical safety during the MeToo movement now sneered at any woman who expressed doubt about sharing private spaces with male-bodied people. The most obvious example here was JK Rowling, who wrote about how her experiences with domestic violence informed her views, an inconvenient truth her critics conveniently ignored. Women are raised to fear male strength, and with very good reason. And now we’re called bigots for doing so.</p>
<p>For the first time in my 20-plus years of being a liberal journalist, I felt completely isolated. I knew I could make my life easier if I just reverted to being the good girl and shut up. “Be kind,” women were told by gender ideologues: be good girls, don’t ask questions, just nod and say what we tell you to say. You don’t want to be mean, do you? But how can you be a writer and not write your doubts about something so important? How can you be a journalist and not ask questions? Occasionally a professional peer would send a text saying that they agreed with me, but they couldn’t say so publicly because their editor wouldn’t like it, or their teenage kids would shout at them, or it was just too stressful.</p>
<p>So I questioned myself. Of course I did. Would my children be ashamed of me in twenty, ten, five years time? “Am I the baddie here?” I asked myself. But I just couldn’t make it square up: how can feelings (gender identity) always take precedence over material reality (biological sex)? Trying to convince myself that I was wrong and the gender ideologues were right was like trying to convince myself that one plus one equals a unicorn. How can you shut your eyes to your own experience and say something that makes no sense? Apparently some people can, but I could not.</p>
<p>I understand why some people see parallels between the modern transgender movement and the gay rights struggle. Like many gay people, trans people experience terrible marginalisation and discrimination, and some are rejected by their families, and that is tragic. Like gay people, they have been cruelly vilified in the Right-wing press (which is partly why the Left-wing media is then so loathe to raise any questions about the transgender movement. They don’t want to look like the evil Tories, right?). But there are other ways to see this situation, too.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/the-truth-about-trans-murders/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/the-truth-about-trans-murders/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/2GettyImages-457771598-scaled-e1641816256877.gif?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/the-truth-about-trans-murders/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/the-truth-about-trans-murders/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The truth about trans murders</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/01/the-truth-about-trans-murders/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tish Still</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>It felt at times like men’s rights activism as a religion. Whenever I or a female colleague dared to voice our doubts about gender ideology, we were pilloried; whenever a male colleague did, he was given a free pass. It was, in the vast, vast main, women who were condemned as bigots, all because they didn’t believe the right things, because they were trying to defend their legal rights. Left-wing men — both in person and online — told me that unless I repeated the mantra “trans women are women”, I was a bigot. It reminded me of that time in school when I was questioned about Jesus to prove my worthiness to wear a jumper.</p>
<p>At the same time as all this was going on, Labour’s seemingly never-ending anti-Semitism scandals were unfolding. Everyone was being urged to listen to those with “lived experience”, and yet non-Jewish people on the Left were telling British Jews that they knew better than them what anti-Semitism was. Now many of those same men were telling me that they knew better than me what a woman was. So this time I didn’t give up a part of myself. Instead, I felt real anger, and I wrote an <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2018/mar/31/man-explains-what-means-be-woman">article</a> in which I told them to get lost. This provoked a huge backlash on Twitter, and no, it wasn’t pleasant. But it was definitely preferable to staying silent just because I was scared.</p>
<p>Other people, however, did not react like that. It was astonishing to me how quickly universities, publishing houses, NHS services, political parties, newspapers and TV networks capitulated to the gender ideologues, who were often not even trans themselves. Mainstream newspapers were suddenly using ideological terms like “cis”, a term which endorses the highly dubious belief that we all have an innate gender identity, and “top surgery”, a tidy euphemism for an elective double mastectomy. NHS services would talk about “cervix havers”, “chest feeding” and “pregnant people” (although prostate-havers were, notably, still men). ITV made a much-publicised drama, Butterfly, about a little boy who decides he’s a girl because he likes to wear make-up and jewellery, because clearly a boy playing with make up needs some kind of medical intervention — and what else is a girl but jewellery and lipstick?</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/kathleen-stock-i-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/kathleen-stock-i-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Kathleen-4-e1636027060258.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/kathleen-stock-i-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/kathleen-stock-i-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Kathleen Stock: I won&#039;t be silenced</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/11/kathleen-stock-i-wont-be-silenced/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Julie Bindel</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Many of the people demanding these institutional shifts were and are not transgender themselves. They are bullies who set themselves up as moral arbiters, using self-righteous hysteria and factually questionable claims to demand censorship, instilling fear that anyone caught engaging in wrongspeak or even wrongthink will be publicly shamed and professionally destroyed. Bullies who insist they need to reshape women’s rights entirely, and then accuse any woman who even wants to discuss this of being hateful, stupid and dangerous. I have seen some people refer to gender-critical feminists as bullies, but I have never seen a gender-critical feminist call for writers to be no-platformed, words to be banned, books to be pulped, or articles to be deleted from the web. Gender activists do all of that as a matter of routine.</p>
<p>Contrary to what these bullies have claimed, gender-critical feminists do not hate trans people. I certainly feel no anger or animosity towards trans people. The only feeling I have towards them is compassion. Not to the point where I’m willing to give up all of women’s sex-based rights, no. But I do know I can only imagine the trauma and pain they have endured in their lives. I also know that so many of the arguments that are happening in their name are not ones that they wish for at all; they are conducted largely by provocateurs who are just burnishing their online brands.</p>
<p>No, my anger is directed at the cowardly institutions that have allowed themselves to be bullied by a tiny misogynistic online minority instead of maintaining even a shadow of a backbone and doing what they know is right. Bristol University, for one, which is currently being sued by a young Dominican woman, Raquel Rosario-Sanchez, on the grounds of sex discrimination and negligence. Rosario-Sanchez came to Bristol to do a PhD on the male exploitation of prostitutes, but because she chaired an event with the feminist group, Woman’s Place UK, trans activists bullied and intimidated her.</p>
<p>She follows in the now extremely established lineage of women like Kathleen Stock, Maya Forstater, Allison Bailey, Rosie Kay — all women who have suffered huge professional setbacks and personal upheaval simply for believing that biological sex is the defining factor in women’s oppression. Do their employers think they’re wrong? Do they really think that something called gender identity, which I’m guessing most of them had never even heard of until six years ago, is the most important quality to a person, and any woman who doubts this must be shunned from society? Or do they just wish to be on The Right Side of History?</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/12/for-me-self-identification-was-a-con/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/12/for-me-self-identification-was-a-con/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/pxSquare2DENH9R-e1607450440361.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/12/for-me-self-identification-was-a-con/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/12/for-me-self-identification-was-a-con/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>For me, self-identification was a con</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/12/for-me-self-identification-was-a-con/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Mary Harrington</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>That’s a phrase I’ve heard often over the past few years. An editor said it to a friend of mine when she wanted to look at the effect of puberty blockers on gender dysphoric children (“I know, I know, but we want to be on the right side of history…”), and a US magazine editor said it to me when I asked if I could interview Martina Navratilova about her views on trans athletes: “I know what you’re saying, and I’m on your side, really I am. But you have to wonder what the right side of history is,” he said. It’s a concern that’s entirely based on vanity, because it’s about wanting to look good, to be seen as the good guy, polishing one’s future legacy. It’s also a way of abdicating responsibility for one’s choices: I’m not making this decision because it’s what I think – it’s what the future thinks!</p>
<p>And then there’s Twitter. When I wanted to write for a magazine about the vilification of JK Rowling, I was told no, because it would cause “too much of a Twitter storm”. A friend wanted to put together a book of collected gender-critical essays, but an editor told her “the Twitter kickback would be too strong, and it wouldn’t get past the sensitivity readers anyway”. It amazes me how much power some people give to Twitter, because as someone who has been the object of several Twitter storms in my time, I’ll let you in on a little secret: Twitter means nothing, unless you give it the power to mean something. People should really stop giving Twitter so much power, because it’s making them bad at their jobs.</p>
<p>I’m lucky — I haven’t lost my job because I believe something that everyone believed up to five years ago, and most people still believe now. (Gender activists love to produce sweeping surveys which they insist prove most people support trans rights. When people are questioned about the rights of trans people who have not had gender reassignment surgery, or dig into the specifics of sport and prisons, <a href="https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2020/07/16/where-does-british-public-stand-transgender-rights">public opinion</a>, unsurprisingly, changes.) I did, however, stop writing my column. I was tired of being seen as the Phyllis Schlafly of <em>The Guardian</em>.</p>
<p>I’m currently writing a book about anorexia. Multiple doctors have confirmed to me what I already suspected, which is that there are obvious parallels between what gender dysphoric teenage girls say today — about their hatred of their body, their fear of sexualisation, their assumptions about what being a woman means — and what I said while in hospital as a teenager.</p>
<p>This is a fact, and an important one about adolescent mental health, and yet when other people have tried to make similar points in print, they have come up against enormous barriers. Abigail Shrier’s book, <em>Irreversible Damage</em>, which looked at the disproportionate rise in numbers of teenage girls seeking gender transition, was ignored by progressive newspapers and magazines, even though it sold well. A US supermarket stopped stocking it after protests by activists. The deputy director for transgender justice at the ACLU, which still claims to be a free speech organisation, said that suppressing Shrier’s book was “100% a hill I would die on”.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/11/why-i-had-to-leave-the-guardian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/11/why-i-had-to-leave-the-guardian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/SM8-scaled-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/11/why-i-had-to-leave-the-guardian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/11/why-i-had-to-leave-the-guardian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why I had to leave The Guardian</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2020/11/why-i-had-to-leave-the-guardian/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Suzanne Moore</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Repeatedly, women who write about this tell me they are subjected to impossible edits: pleas for balance, softened language, a more neutral tone, dissenting voices, more equivocation so as to render their original argument into meaningless slurry — everything editors do to a piece when, really, they would rather spike it and save themselves the bother. It doesn’t matter how many facts you have, what matters are the feelings.</p>
<p>I don’t discount feelings. Feelings are important. But it’s interesting whose feelings matter. Andrea Long Chu, a trans woman, wrote in her 2017 memoir that the “barest essentials” of “femaleness” is “an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eye”. How did that get past the now ubiquitous sensitivity readers? It certainly didn’t hurt the writer’s career, who continues to get very high-profile commissions, whereas I personally know women who have lost their jobs for saying that the barest essentials of their femaleness was their biology. Or how about this line from a recently published memoir by Grace Lavery: when describing how hormone treatment has affected her body, she writes that her penis felt “as though I were laying my own miscarried foetus across my hand”.</p>
<p>I had a miscarriage. Two, actually. And so has almost every woman I know who has been pregnant. I wonder if anyone at that publishing company thought how we might feel, seeing our failed pregnancies compared to a flaccid penis? I’m guessing none, and fair enough, because I actually don’t think fear of offence is a reasonable excuse not to publish something. The double standards are ludicrous: you can now say any old garbage about women, but anything that even questions gender ideology will be anxiously second-guessed and overly edited into oblivion, no matter how many facts and even genuine feelings are behind it.</p>
<p>Someone described this to me recently as “a period of over-correction”, and I get that. For so long, transgender people were underrepresented, mocked and harassed, and now it’s their moment to have their say, and fair enough. But this should not be an either/or situation: both women and trans people should be able to speak out equally and honestly in progressive spheres. Instead, I see Left-wing feminist writers being funnelled towards Right-wing publications, simply because Left-wing ones are too anxious to stay on The Right Side of History to publish them. This makes it easier for the Left-wing bullies to discredit them, but it does not make what they’re saying any less true.</p>
<p>Recently, Mumsnet hosted a live discussion with Stella Creasy and Caroline Nokes about women and mothers in politics. When the majority of the questions were about gender and what Creasy and Nokes think a woman is, the journalist Marie Le Conte called the Mumsnetters “obsessive” and “radicalised”. There were many problems facing women today, <a href="https://www.newstatesman.com/comment/2022/02/feminism-has-been-reduced-to-the-transgender-debate">she wrote</a>, but instead of working together on low rape convictions and workplace discrimination, feminists were arguing over this one issue.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/my-body-will-never-be-erased/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/my-body-will-never-be-erased/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/ROSIE-IN-STUDIO-Tim-Cross.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/my-body-will-never-be-erased/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/my-body-will-never-be-erased/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>My body will never be erased</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/12/my-body-will-never-be-erased/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Rosie Kay</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Le Conte is right, of course: these are things women should be focusing on, because they affect women. But how can women focus on them if politicians won’t even say what a woman is anymore? If sex and gender are being blurred together, how can we discuss who’s being discriminated against and why? In the workplace, a woman might be sacked because, say, she got pregnant, which is sex discrimination. A trans woman might be sacked because of transphobia. These are very different issues, and while inclusion is a laudable aim, it can’t come at the cost of clarity and efficacy.</p>
<p>It is not bigoted to say these things. And yet, there was a period, about three years ago, when I honestly thought about quitting my job. I felt so hated for saying things — things that are scientifically, biologically and factually true — and so unsupported by people who I know secretly agree with me but are too scared to say so out loud that I nearly left journalism. Well, I didn’t. Instead, I decided to stop being so frustrated by it all, and to stop taking what is going on in the progressive media circles and institutions so personally. For so long, I defined myself as a Left-wing journalist, but political categories are watery these days, and I’m OK with feeling out of step from so many people I once thought of as my side. I know they see things differently from me and I fully support their right to express their views; that feeling, I know all too well, is not mutual.</p>
<p>I don’t feel like I’ve become radicalised, because I don’t think anything I didn’t already think six years ago. I do, however, feel much better about myself for not just thinking it but saying it. I have learned that there is something worse than people telling me I’m a bad person, and that is allowing bullies to reframe the world, to dictate what we can all think and to define my reality. They might have triumphed over some institutions, but they haven’t triumphed over me. It turns out life is much better when you’re no longer the good girl.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>***</strong></p>
<p><em>Order your copy of <a href="https://stage.unherd.com/edition-zero/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">UnHerd’s first print edition here</a>. </em></p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2022/02/why-i-stopped-being-a-good-girl/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">360543</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Trans activism has mummy issues</title>
					<link>https://stage.unherd.com/2021/09/the-trans-war-on-motherhood/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://stage.unherd.com/2021/09/the-trans-war-on-motherhood/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/GettyImages-1234176617-1024x683-1.jpg?w=622</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Mary Harrington]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/mary.jpeg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Trans rights campaigners at Reclaim Pride. Credit: Mark Kerrison/In Pictures/ Getty]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Mary Harrington</strong> is a contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>moveincircles</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 02 Sep 2021 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Sat, 04 Sep 2021 00:07:29 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Don't miss]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[gender identity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Helen Joyce]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Motherhood]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Mumsnet]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Shon Faye]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The Transgender Issue]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[trans]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Transgender]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[transgender politics]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=202108</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[A new primer on gender identity draws on second-wave feminism]]>
							</description>
																		
																			<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Though I’m a middle-aged mother myself now, I’ve had my share of tear-streaked, bitter arguments with my own mum. By turns loving and murderous, swinging wildly between enmeshed empathy and parental authority, mother/daughter relationships can trigger uniquely painful rows.</p>
<p>But it&#8217;s not just individual mothers and daughters who do this. It is also reproduced in the women’s movement. In <a href="https://susanfaludi.com/americanelectra.pdf">American Electra</a>, the feminist writer Susan Faludi argues that it is a central feature: matricide is a core dynamic in feminism from the Twenties onward.</p>
<p>“The mother stands for the victim in ourselves, the unfree woman, the martyr”, wrote Adrienne Rich in <a href="https://literariness.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Adrienne-Rich-Of-Woman-Born_-Motherhood-as-Experience-and-Institution-1995-W.-W.-Norton-Company.pdf"><em>Of Woman Born</em></a> (1976). Faludi quotes Betty Friedan, perhaps the quintessential rejecter of bourgeois domesticity as a desirable role for women, who said: “I didn’t want to be like my mother”.</p>
<p>And this dynamic, Faludi argues, has translated into “a persistent barrenness” within feminism: that is, a rejection not just of individual mothers but of the movement’s ability to create a heritage over time. Instead, each generation rejects the one that went before, endlessly reproducing this second-wave feminist scorn for endlessly victimised, unfree, martyred and unsatisfied mothers – both literal and also political. It’s a push-me-pull-you dynamic that both rejects whatever came before in the women’s movement, while also longing for an ongoing, motherly warmth and acceptance.</p>
<div class="ad-insert"></div>
<p>Nowhere is this battle over the nature (or, perhaps, the possibility) of a feminist legacy more evident than in contemporary arguments around trans identity. Shon Faye’s new book on “transgender liberation”, <em>The Transgender Issue</em>, argues this inheritance with energy and clarity. Meanwhile, in what it leaves half-said or unsaid, it also demonstrates it.</p>
<p>In general terms, the book delivers what you’d expect, given gushing blurbs written by Judith Butler, Ash Sarkar and Owen Jones: a bog-standard “intersectional” treatise. It abounds in the expected namechecks of standard “marginalised” groups, gestures in familiar ways at the evils of “capitalism” and evinces standard woke opinions on prostitution, prisons and immigration.</p>
<p><a href="https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/315/315349/the-transgender-issue/9780241423141.html"><em>The Transgender Issue: an argument for justice</em></a> is written with an op-ed journalist’s persuasive energy, in a style that (for anyone familiar with the so-called “Terf wars”) at times egregiously begs often hotly-contested questions. For example, proposed legislation that would replace biological sex in law with self-identified “gender identity”, a change with far-reaching conceptual and political implications, is breezily characterised as “a more humane process for gender recognition”.</p>
<p>But Faye writes well. Anyone seeking a primer on “trans-inclusive” and “gender critical” arguments could do worse than read this book alongside Helen Joyce’s <a href="https://www.waterstones.com/book/trans/helen-joyce/9780861540495"><em>Trans</em></a>. The book’s interest lies in its ambivalent relation to an older generation of feminism.</p>
<p>Faye draws on second-wave writers and radical feminist history, to argue that far from representing a repudiation of the second-wave legacy, trans-activism is its inheritrix. To this end, <em>The Transgender Issue </em>quotes Andrea Dworkin’s approving 1974 description, in <em>Woman Hating</em>, of how new research and fertility technology “challenges the notion that there are two discrete biological sexes” and “threatens to transform the traditional biology of sex difference into the radical biology of sex similarity”. Elsewhere, Faye correctly points out that disagreements over the place of trans women in feminist groups go all the way back to the Seventies.</p>
<figure id="attachment_202203" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-202203" style="width: 502px" class="wp-caption alignnone"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-202203" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/image-300x150.png" alt="" width="502" height="251" /><figcaption id="caption-attachment-202203" class="wp-caption-text">Shon Faye&#8217;s new book embraces Andrea Dworkin&#8217;s “matricidal” dynamic</figcaption></figure>
<p>And, indeed, this matriarchal lineage is difficult to dispute, when it was this generation of feminists who first argued that “sex” and “gender” are separable. Andrea Dworkin stated in <em>Woman Hating </em>that “man” and “woman” are […] cultural constructs […] reductive, totalitarian, inappropriate to human becoming”. What Dworkin outlines here is, today, settled opinion among pronouns-in-bio online leftists.</p>
<p>Against what Dworkin called the “totalitarian” idea of “man” and “woman”, other second-wave radical feminists imagined all of us liberated from the givens of biology. Shulamith Firestone’s <em>The Dialectic of </em>Sex (1970), for example, dreamed of a future in which women had been wholly liberated from reproduction by a mix of extra-uterine gestation and collectivised childcare.</p>
<p>From this perspective, if we admit of any relationship whatsoever between biology and wider social norms or structures, women are at risk of being subordinated again: relegated once more to (as Rich puts it) “the victim in ourselves, the unfree woman, the martyr”. And if there’s no relationship between biology and identity, why shouldn’t a trans woman be — as Faye argues — also “female”?</p>
<p>Like the secondwavers, Faye rejects the “conservative” idea that women are “vessels for reproduction”. <em>The Transgender Issue </em>situates trans liberation as a logical extension of feminist call for bodily autonomy and particularly for safe and legal abortion. In Faye’s view, both abortion and gender medicine are forms of resistance to “[c]onservative ideological positions about gender roles and the degree to which an individual is entitled to autonomy over their body”.</p>
<p>Faye’s argument for “transfeminism” as a daughter of the second wave, then, has merit. It continues this matrilineal dynamic in one further way: by embracing the “matricidal” dynamic described by Susan Faludi.</p>
<p>Mothers have only the most tenuous presence in <em>The Transgender Issue</em>. Only two get more than passing, warm mention: Faye’s own mother (in the dedication), and the supportive mother of a transgender-identified child.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/08/what-moden-feminism-is-hiding/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/08/what-moden-feminism-is-hiding/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/CCk-BCJW0AAHncR-e1629900780311.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/08/what-moden-feminism-is-hiding/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/08/what-moden-feminism-is-hiding/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>What modern feminism is hiding</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/08/what-moden-feminism-is-hiding/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Mary Harrington</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Mothers as a political group are (in Faye’s characteristically tendentious style) airbrushed out. Reflecting on why British feminism in particular is resistant to the inclusion of trans women, Faye blames this on all manner of things, from a hostile press, to (somehow) the British Empire, while leaving out perhaps the most central rallying-point for “gender critical” activism: Mumsnet, or as it’s sometimes dubbed by those infuriated by its members’ stubborn wrongthink, “<a href="https://twitter.com/llewcid/status/1276772028402544641?s=21">Prosecco 4chan</a>”.</p>
<p>Mumsnet’s feminism pages have played a central role in gender critical activism politics for over a decade, a fact not unconnected to Mumsnetters’ (usually) shared experience of maternity. It is, after all, more difficult to take seriously the idea that “woman” is an identity, when you’ve experienced pregnancy, childbirth and the shift in outlook and social role that comes with motherhood. But for Faye, the possibility that mothers might have experiences in common, and views of their own, doesn’t merit airtime.</p>
<p>In <em>The Transgender Issue</em>, mothers appear as bit-part players. Some are kind blunderers who don’t understand their children’s identity needs; others are violently transphobic. Inasmuch we appear as a class at all in connection with the female reproductive role, we’re either gender-diverse &#8220;people with uteruses&#8221; (ie not mothers), or else women in need of abortion services so they can avoid becoming mothers.</p>
<p>Again, in keeping with second-wave feminism, Faye is keen to sever any connection between women and gestation. In one footnote, the notion that pregnancy is a women’s issue is dismissed as “conservative and regressive”. With that, a key locus of specifically female political interest is reframed as a set of fertility services, that can and should be detached from “woman” as a concept, and whose “postcode lottery” availability represents yet another injustice to the trans community.</p>
<p>Shon Faye’s “transgender liberation”, then, sits in intimately ambivalent mother/daughter relationship with the feminism that birthed it. It embraces the conceptual legacy of second-wave feminism; then, in accordance with that heritage, also rejects motherhood and maternity. And, at the same time rejecting its own second-wave heritage, which (we gather) wasn’t nearly radical enough but instead merely accepted a set of minor improvements to the conditions for bourgeois women under capitalism.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/03/were-living-in-a-pornstars-world/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/03/were-living-in-a-pornstars-world/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://stage.unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/GettyImages-1230885340-scaled-e1616673243147.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/03/were-living-in-a-pornstars-world/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/03/were-living-in-a-pornstars-world/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>We&#039;re living in a pornstar&#039;s world</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/03/were-living-in-a-pornstars-world/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Mary Harrington</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Nor is it enough, in Faye’s view, to replicate such marginal gains for well-off, white, transgender people. Such activism (which the book exemplifies in Stonewall’s corporate “diversity” activism) affords at best superficial improvements without addressing The System that claims the right to determine who is or isn’t “acceptably trans under capitalism”.</p>
<p>For Faye, the real prize is smashing this underlying system, which the book identifies with “patriarchy”. Achieving this seems to mean abolition of all boundaries or limits, a vision that includes ending “rigid” ideas of biological sex, dissolving hierarchical relations such as “the state’s monopoly on legal force through policing, prisons and migrant detention centres” and ending any political structure — such as national borders — that imposes harsh divisions of any kind.</p>
<p>To replace this “patriarchal” regime, Faye envisages one of pure nurture. This order, we gather, would be unstintingly welcoming to the vulnerable, impoverished, addicted or mentally unwell. It would be endlessly adaptive to individuals’ specific, contextual, identity-driven needs. And it would be boundlessly giving with medical, housing and therapeutic resources – up to and including laser hair removal and gamete-freezing, resources certainly not universally available to other groups on the NHS.</p>
<p>It ought, Faye declares, “to be the state’s obligation to support trans people, not the other way around”. Even as it rhetorically sidesteps literal mothers, then, true liberation, is a political regime that sets out liberate women from the need to be mothers, by itself embodying the once-archetypal maternal qualities of empathy, nurture and support.</p>
<p>Faye characterises as “frankly unhinged” Germaine Greer’s argument <em>in The Whole Woman</em> that transgender women are engaged in a form of symbolic matricide. But perhaps it’s more accurate to say Greer didn’t go far enough. That is, it’s not just transfeminism that’s engaged in symbolic matricide, it’s pretty much all of it, from the second wave onwards.</p>
<p>Other strands have, of course, emerged over many decades of sometimes rancorous feminist debate. But Shon Faye makes a convincing case for transgender activism as the matricidal inheritrix of a profoundly matricidal strand in that debate.</p>
<p>And perhaps the regime of therapeutic totalitarianism <em>The Transgender Issue </em>proposes, to replace our current social order, is the true inheritance of this matricidal liberation. For since the likes of Dworkin and Firestone were writing, those women who didn’t want to be like their martyred mothers have increasingly swapped caring for toddlers favour of entry into public and working life.</p>
<p>In tandem, the care of even very young children has since been increasingly outsourced to institutional providers. Many of these young people are now adults: generations for whom, increasingly commonly, the earliest infant experiences of nurture are fused with a more impersonal, institutional authority.</p>
<p>Perhaps it’s natural that such adults would dream of a political regime on the same template of nurturing authoritarianism. And perhaps, too, Shon Faye’s vision of a politics so motherly no one need ever want, compete or quarrel again is the true contemporary legacy of the second wave’s mummy issues.</p>
<style>
				a.appcomments {
					background: #FFF;
					border: 1px solid #446c76 !important;
					font-family: benton-sans,sans-serif;
					font-weight: 600;
					font-style: normal;
					font-size: 12px;
					color: #446c76 !important;
					padding: 12px 50px;
					text-transform: uppercase;
					letter-spacing: 1.5px;
					text-decoration: none;
					width: 100%;
					display: block;
					text-align: center !important;
				 }
			</style>
			<a href="https://stage.unherd.com/2021/09/the-trans-war-on-motherhood/?edition=us?appcomments" class="appcomments">view comments</a>]]>
							</content:encoded>
																<unherd:comments_embed_url>https://stage.unherd.com/2021/09/the-trans-war-on-motherhood/?edition=us?appcommentsnew</unherd:comments_embed_url>
											<wfw:commentRss>https://stage.unherd.com/2021/09/the-trans-war-on-motherhood/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">202108</post-id>				</item>
						</channel>
</rss>
