X Close

Forget San Francisco — Britain has a shoplifting epidemic too

7 Sep 2023 - 8:00am

San Francisco’s shoplifting epidemic is shocking to behold. But we shouldn’t imagine that the same couldn’t happen here. In fact, we’re well on our way. According to the British Retail Consortium, theft from stores across 10 UK cities is up by 26%. More, “incidents of violence and abuse against retail employees have almost doubled on pre-pandemic levels.”

On Tuesday, Asda Chairman Stuart Rose told LBC that “theft is a big issue. It has become decriminalised. It has become minimised. It’s actually just not seen as a crime anymore.”

In the absence of an adequate response from the authorities, retailers are beginning to take defensive measures. For instance, home furnishings company Dunelm is now locking up duvets and pillow cases in cabinets; Waitrose is offering free coffees to police officers to increase their visibility; and Tesco plans to equip staff with body cameras. 

The “progressive” response to this phenomenon isn’t quite as deranged as it is in in the US. Nevertheless, British liberals have responded as expected. A piece in the Observer is typical. You’ll never guess, but apparently it’s all the Tories’ fault: “Starving your population and then ‘cracking down’ on it for nicking baby formula or a can of soup can start to make a government look rather unreasonable.”

But as the writer ought to know, the issue here isn’t the desperate young mum hiding a few groceries in the pram. Nor is it the schoolboy pilfering the occasional bag of sweets. Rather, the real problem is blatant, organised and sometimes violent theft of higher value items. Criminals who never previously thought they could get away with it increasingly now do — thus presenting a material threat to retail as we know it. 

But instead of addressing the issue head-on, the writer blames the victim: “Once goods were kept behind counters, but since the birth of large supermarkets they have been laid out near the door, ready for the taking.” How terribly irresponsible of them! On the other hand, perhaps the open display of goods isn’t just a convenience for customers, but instead the hallmark of a high trust society. 

In fact, modern shops are a minor miracle of civilisation: public spaces, stacked high with products from all over the world, that passing strangers may freely inspect and handle, but which aren’t looted by anyone who feels like it.

Surely, that’s something worth defending. But if you’d prefer to abandon retailers to their fate, then don’t moan when they do what it takes to survive. Some will close, of course, and others will move their operations online. Those who stay open will guard themselves and their stock behind plexiglass and electronic tags. And then there’s the hi-tech solution: the fully automated and completely cashless store, in which customers have to be authenticated to even get in. 

Remember that retail facilities like this already exist. One day, when they become the norm, we’ll remember what shops used to be like. Then, we’ll ask why no one stood up for them.


Peter Franklin is Associate Editor of UnHerd. He was previously a policy advisor and speechwriter on environmental and social issues.

peterfranklin_

An early election could unite the Right

The next Baldwin. Credit: Getty

The next Baldwin. Credit: Getty

30 Oct 2026 - 7:00am

Despite another denial from Downing Street, speculation that a snap election is imminent isn’t going away. It’s no wonder. This week’s Budget is a policy vacuum that begs to be filled — by, say, a manifesto. Also, take a look at the Office for Budget Responsibility’s predictions for the economy. The decline of housebuilding, for instance, or the spending cuts implied by the Government’s borrowing plans. Does 2029 seem an auspicious time for a general election? No.

Then there’s Andy Burnham’s loose talk about rejoining the European Union in some way. But he can’t sit on the issue for too long, because his colleagues are already causing problems by floating their own ideas. And yet the Prime Minister won’t regain control of the debate he started unless he departs from Keir Starmer’s status quo. By Burnham’s own admission, however, that can’t happen in this parliament.

Of course, calling an early election would mean facing a new parliament. And yet that tactic doesn’t always work. In 2019, Boris Johnson gambled and won. In 2017, Theresa May gambled and lost. In 2007, Gordon Brown almost went for it then lost his nerve. Three precedents, three different outcomes.

But for the most relevant precedent, we need to look back more than a hundred years. In 1923, the prime minister was Stanley Baldwin. He was a Tory, but like Burnham he was sitting on a Commons majority and had plenty of time before he had to call an election. So what possessed him to go to the country so soon?

Crucially, Baldwin — like Burnham — was a replacement prime minister (his predecessor, Andrew Bonar Law, had stepped down due to ill health). That meant the Tory majority wasn’t Baldwin’s majority, which mattered because he wanted to make major changes to Government policy. Specifically, his plan was to tackle rising unemployment by raising trade barriers. However, this would have gone against a promise by the Conservatives at the 1922 general election — hence the need for a fresh mandate.

Burnham finds himself in a remarkably similar position. Though he’d argue that he wants to liberalise trade, rejoining the single market and/or customs union would subject the UK to the EU’s common external trade barriers with the rest of the world. And in any case, Starmer fought the 2024 general election on an explicit commitment — the “red lines” — not to do either of those things.

If that parallel isn’t close enough, consider the fact that Baldwin was emboldened by a seemingly divided opposition. In the early Twenties, the Labour Party was on the rise and the Liberal Party was split between the Asquith and Lloyd George factions. Today, the great schism is between the Conservatives and Reform UK, which will encourage Burnham to fight an election.

But here comes the twist. By fighting the 1923 election on a protectionist platform, Baldwin’s strategy backfired, inspiring the Liberals to reunite around the cause of free trade. The Tories lost 86 seats and their majority. The Liberals did well enough to enable Ramsay MacDonald to form a Labour minority government.

And so the question for Burnham is this: can he be sure that fighting a snap election on a promise to drag Britain back into Europe won’t rally and reunite the Right-of-centre opposition? After his spectacular miscalculation, Baldwin was allowed to remain as Tory leader. Burnham may not be so readily forgiven.


Peter Franklin is Associate Editor of UnHerd. He was previously a policy advisor and speechwriter on environmental and social issues.

peterfranklin_